Tear Down This Myth

by: Will Bunch, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

Tear Down This Myth
President Ronald Reagan. (Photo: Jeff Taylor / AP)

    Last week didn't only mark the inauguration of Barack Obama. January 20, 2009, was also a less noticed anniversary - marking 20 years to the day that the 40th president, Ronald Reagan, said his final goodbye to the Oval Office. During those two decades since, the world evolved, and the man who some called a Great Communicator and others called a "Teflon president" passed away - yet, watching last year's presidential race unfold, you might have been excused if you'd thought Reagan was somehow on the ballot. In debates and in countless TV ads - mainly but not exclusively on the GOP side - a return to Reagan-era orthodoxy in tax cuts or building up the military remained on the front burner of US politics. This, even as the American economy was collapsing from the weight of rising debt, unfettered greed on Wall Street and shortsighted energy policies - all of which trace back to the 1980s and Reagan's toxic legacy.

    The fact that the myth of Ronald Reagan - promoted and perverted by a modern generation of neoconservatives - persists even with the start of the Obama administration, makes it clear that this warped legend won't die - unless we work to combat it, That's why I wrote "Tear Down This Myth: How the Reagan Legacy Has Distorted Our Politics and Haunts Our Future." The book has just been released by Free Press and one can receive news by joining the official Facebook group here.

    Here's an excerpt from chapter one of the book:

It was Ronald Reagan himself who, as the spotlight faded on his presidency in 1988, tried to highlight his eight-year record by reviving a quote from John Adams, that "facts are stubborn things." The moment became quite famous because the then-77-year-old president had botched it, and said that "facts are stupid things." The tragedy of American politics was that just two decades later, facts were neither stubborn nor even stupid - but largely irrelevant.

Any information about Iran-Contra or how the 1979-81 hostages were released (Rudy Giuliani had falsely claimed during the 2008 race they were freed when "the Gipper" looked Iranian leaders in the eye) that didn't fit the new official story line was being metaphorically clipped out of the newspaper and tossed down "memory hole" - the fate of any information that would have undercut Reagan's image as an all-benevolent Big Brother still guiding the conservative movement from above.

A more factual synopsis of the Reagan presidency might read like this: That Reagan was a transformative figure in American history, but his real revolution was one of public-relations-meets-politics and not one of policy. He combined his small-town heartland upbringing with a skill for story-telling that was honed on the back lots of Hollywood into a personal narrative that resonated with a majority of voters, but only after it tapped into something darker, which was white middle class resentment of 1960s unrest.

His story arc did become more optimistic and peaked at just the right moment, when Americans were tired of the "malaise" of the Jimmy Carter years and wanted someone who promised to make the nation feel good about itself again. But his positive legacy as president today hangs on events that most historians say were to some great measure out of his control: An economic recovery that was inevitable, especially when world oil prices returned to normal levels, and an end to the Cold War that was more driven by internal events in the Soviet Union and in Eastern Europe than Americans want to acknowledge.

His 1981 tax cut was followed quickly by tax hikes that you rarely hear about, and Reagan's real lasting achievement on that front was slashing marginal rates for the wealthy - even as rising payroll taxes socked the working class. His promise to shrink government was uttered so many time that many acolytes believe it really happened, but in fact Reagan expanded the federal payroll, added a new cabinet post, and created a huge debt that ultimately tripped up his handpicked successor, George H.W. Bush. What he did shrink was government regulation and oversight - linked to a series of unfortunate events from the savings-and-loan crisis of the late 1980s to the sub-prime mortgage crisis of the late 2000s.

The fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 papered over some less noble moments in foreign policy, from trading arms for Middle East hostages to an embarrassing retreat from his muddled engagement in Lebanon to unpopular adventurism in Central America. The Iran-Contra scandal that stemmed from those policies not only weakened Reagan's presidency when it happened, but it arguably undermined the respect of future presidents for the Constitution - because he essentially got away with it. Over the course of eight years, the president that some want to enshrine on Mount Rushmore rated just barely above average for modern presidents in public popularity. He left on a high note - but only after two years of shifting his policy back to the center, seeking peace with the Soviets than confrontation, reaching a balanced new tax deal with Democrats and naming a moderate justice to the Supreme Court. It was not the Reaganism invoked by today's conservatives.

There has always been a place for mythology in American democracy - the hulking granite edifices of the Capitol Mall in Washington are a powerful testament to that - but this nation has arguably never seen the kind of bold, crudely calculated and ideologically driven legend-manufacturing as has taken place with Ronald Reagan. It is a myth machine that has been spectacularly successful, launched in the mid-1990s when the conservative brand was at low ebb.

The docudrama version of the Gipper's life story, successfully sold to the American public, helped to keep united and refuel a right-wing movement that consolidated power while citing Reaganism - as separate and apart from the flesh-and-blood Reagan - for misguided policies from lowering taxes in the time of war in Iraq to maintaining that unpopular conflict in a time of increasing bloodshed and questionable gains.

    Just a quick footnote: In the early days of the Obama administration, the Reagan myth looms larger than ever. Although the new Democratic regime seems likely to reverse course in some areas like global warming, in other areas they are continuing to fight the Reagan legend, not just from GOP members of Congress, but also from the Beltway punditocracy. This is especially true in the areas of taxes, where conservatives want to weigh any economic stimulus plan more heavily to tax cuts - despite a golden opportunity to create "green jobs" and undo the neglect of key infrastructure projects like mass transit, neglect that began in the 1980s. In the end, the path to America's future still requires clearing away some of the brush from the past.

    --------

    Will Bunch is author of the new book "Tear Down This Myth: How the Reagan Legacy Has Distorted Our Politics and Haunts Our Future," published by Simon & Schuster's Free Press. He is the senior writer for the Philadelphia Daily News and author of its popular blog Attytood; his articles have appeared in The New York Times Magazine, Mother Jones, The American Prospect, American Journalism Review, and elsewhere.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



The fact is Ronald Reagan

The fact is Ronald Reagan was a political hack who favored the rich and destroyed our sense of decency. He began the spending spree that still haunts us today. He was no different than Bush.


I grew up and live in

I grew up and live in California, and the ghost of Ronald Reagan lives on today: Proposition 13, which allows business property that has been in the hands of its owners for many decades, to be taxed at extremely low rates compared to highly taxed homeowner property that exchanged hands several times over since 1978. Though he was already out of office when Prop.13 passed, its passage would not have happened if not for his anti-tax, anti-government services stance as governor. Proposition 13 has been a disaster for Califonira in that many corporate businesses have been let off the hook for not paying what should have been their fair share of property taxes, dumping the tax burden on average home owners instead! Reagan didn't mind telling the middle and poor classes that taxes should hurt, while making sure that those at the top of the wealth heap paid as little as possible. Let's remember that in 1980, the year he ran for president, Reagan did not pay one cent of Federal Income Tax, as he used loopholes and deductions to pay NADA. That's got to be quite a feat for someone who was a multi-millionaire with an income consisting of royalties from film and TV, real estate holdings, and a pension from the State of California.


reminds of the expression

reminds of the expression 'more royalist than the king'.Fact is Republican/Conservatism is certainly a movement to catch the attention by phrases 'sound great'--who would say no to lesser/lower taxes? No One. Problem is this is not a carried-through effective system of governance, not addressing the needs of the country's people, in ignoring the fact that government is 'we the people..' and they are ONE. Inseparable. And cannot be disassociated: trying to separate people from government is as removing the body form the spirit. With the same results. Not that easy. Ronald Reagan's intellect is certainly not remembered or prized.


I never thought Reagan was a

I never thought Reagan was a great communicator at all. That was a PR ploy for a man who actually had quite a bit of trouble getting people to understand him. Friends I knew then who proudly announced themselves as "Reagan Democrats", cringe at his name today.


The fact is that Ronald

The fact is that Ronald Reagan was a lying, swindling crook whose name should be removed from any public building, bridge, airport, and pay toilet.


One of the causes of the

One of the causes of the income disparity we face today was the agreement in 1983 by Reagan and Greenspan to raise the employment tax. For 26 years, the average worker has been overtaxed for Social Security, and a huge portion of those taxes have been used in lieu of income taxes on the wealthy. All that money should be repaid by a tax surcharge on high income individuals and dividends and capital gains - incomes that never paid Social Security taxes, yet took advantage of the extra taxes paid by ordinary workers. Unfortunately, we will probably get a combination of even higher taxes on workers and benefit cuts for the Baby Boomers who have, in effect, already prepaid for their own retirement.


Read Gorbachev's memoirs

Read Gorbachev's memoirs [900 pages of fascinating history] for an incredible shift of perspective about the end of the Cold War, which was decades in coming. Reagan had pretty much nothing to do with it.


It has been said that a

It has been said that a squirrel is just a rat with great public relations. George W. Bush's policies and practices were virtually identical to those of Ronald Reagan. The only difference is that Reagan came off as someone we'd like to have in our yard while Bush had most people poring through the Yellow Pages looking for an exterminator.


Reagan was a CROOK who sold

Reagan was a CROOK who sold us a CROCK. 'Nuff said.


Under Reagan, a new social

Under Reagan, a new social underclass was created: the homeless. Science was effectively stopped. Our space program was starved to the point of dangerousness (e.g.,Challenger). We had one recession (2 recessions if you count Bush's daddy) and 3 recessionary quarters. He created borrow and spend Republicanism. The Iran Contra scandal that provided arms to a known enemy (aka: treason). Destruction of the educational system creating a generation hampered by an impoverished education. And he left the largest deficit known up to that point. And this is "great"? OTOH during the Kennedy-Johnson era, education was enriched, we had NO deflationary quarters-- a first!, we went to the moon within a decade. Science progressed incredibly, and the generation who would build silicon valley into a science/tech empire was educated. And this is "evil bad liberalism"??? The only value add I can see to America is that we are not only crazy, but we have added stupid too! Good luck Obama.


To Granny: Really? You

To Granny: Really? You think his name should be removed from public pay toilets?! I can think of no more fitting use for his name. Of course the toilet I would have in mind would not only charge for its services but also would not work. Anyway, one point I think we can be at least a little bit optimistic about is that (in my opinion) bush was really no worse than either reagan or nixon. He just did brazenly the same things they did under the table. In fact, he's really just the definitive embodiment of everything the republican party stands for. Yet his lack of popularity is astounding. Then again, reagan was definitely never as popular during his actual time in office as he's been touted for having been ever since. His approval ratings were surpassed by President Clinton's although I don't think the msm is likely to mention that. It seems that republicans in office or otherwise have a big picture strategy and agenda that transcends elections. It would be nice if Democrats had that same kind of focus. I read that one of mccain's weaknesses was that he thought in sentence fragments, whearas Obama thought in paragraphs. Maybe that is the strength AND the weekness of lefties. Look at me. Who am I to preach about "staying on message" huh? Anyway, reagan bad. There, now I can communicate again.


When America drank Reagan's

When America drank Reagan's "trickle down" "deregulate" "government is the enemy" koolaide - with cross party glee - the dice were cast. Electing the stupidest man in the world - TWICE - IS the CONSEQUENCE of thinking GOVERNMENT IS THE ENEMY. This is why Sweden, Canada, Britain and the REST OF THE CIVILIZED WORLD have - among MANY, benefits - Universal Health Care and the US of A has elected the "stoopidest" man in the world - TWICE. Bush was a symptom - AMERICA was the IDIOT!!!!!!


Well, I see most of you are

Well, I see most of you are unaware of the upcoming financial forecast. Through Reagan's "trickle-down economics" of giving tax breaks to the wealthy, the rest of us are about to be rich. Since that "rain" still hasn't arrived over the past 27 years, if the Republican congressional representatives get this next tax cut for the wealthy, it's about to start pouring money! Rep John Boehner (Ohio) will probably be telling the poor and middle class Americans to yank out their fishing nets because Reagan's sound economic policy that has been recycled by both Bush's is finally about to kick in.


About time. Someone, pass

About time. Someone, pass me a sledgehammer. Please.


Reagan was an actor, who

Reagan was an actor, who "stared" in many a B movie. He was used to being told what to say. A public relations coup for his handlers. no more, no less.


In all honesty, or maybe

In all honesty, or maybe just my experience, the USA has lost all it's beauty, majesty, and mystique it ever had for me ever since that very day Reagan was sworn in. I was 19 then; now I'm 47. That whole period, including the Clinton era was a huge waste of time for the world, and has put me in mistrust of politicians, for perhaps my entire life. And, the consequences are still looming on the horizon.


I will never forgot our

I will never forgot our beloved leader.He gave me a payrase of 4% then prorated it for a quarter (um would that not be 3%?)then in turn took SSI from my pay so for the year i took home less than the prevois year .what a commander in chief, so proud to serve my country.


I lived in CA while Mr.

I lived in CA while Mr. Reagan was governor. What a travesty he left that state in, too! Thank goodness you have written a book debunking this 'saint.' The sad fact that both Mr. Reagan and G.W. Bush might be 'funny and nice' men you might want to have a beer with is so unworthy of someone running for president. Makes me ill how the American public is so manipulated by the NeoComs and media and .... Wake up, world!


Reagan is given credit for

Reagan is given credit for the Soviet Union's collapse, but that process had been in motion for decades and was capped by their misadventure in Afghanistan. In fact, it was the Carter administration (rightly or wrongly) that began supplying the Mujahideen there with money and weapons, sapping the Soviet's coffers. What really tickles me about the Reagan mythology is how it conveniently overlooks the corruption and wrongdoing in that administration. There were 32 convictions during the Reagan administration. Sleazy Reagan luminaries included James Watt (indicted on 25 counts of felony perjury and obstruction of justice), Michael Deaver (convicted of perjury) and EPA Director Anne Burford (forced to resign in a "contempt of Congress" vote). Reagan Attorney General Edwin Meese was Alberto Gonzales' role model in "litmus test" hiring. I remember a Time magazine cover of that era entitled "The Sleaze Factor" which had portraits of several Reagan officials indicted and convicted on various charges. Also, who can forget Nancy Reagan's astrologer dictating good dates for meetings and travel? All these things (and many more) are conveniently forgotten by the Reagan sycophants.


I still remember the quote

I still remember the quote by N.Y. Governor, Mario Cuomo, when pundits burbled about Reagan, saying 'he moved the people'. Cuomo said: 'He made the denial of compassion respectable'.


Ronald Reagan was a

Ronald Reagan was a spiritless weakling, under the thumb of an immoral, vicious woman, Nancy Reagan. She wielded much too much power while he was on his climb to the presidency and during his terms of office. The fact that he called her "Mommie" tells us something! His presidency brought shame to this country.


THIS COMPASSIONATE FELLOW

THIS COMPASSIONATE FELLOW WAS THE ONE WHO DECIDED KETCHUP WAS A 'VEGETABLE', (good enough for kids (not his or his friends') in rundown schools .....) And Nancy, after a photo op with a black kid on her lap, immediately pushed her off her lap saying, 'get this thing off me.' The true face of Repugnican hypocrisy.....


Reagan's greatest "crime"

Reagan's greatest "crime" was to destroy the PATCO Union of striking air traffic controllers, as this shattered the sensible accomodation Labor and Management had forced since the end of WWll, and set unions on the downward slope that has cost the working-class almost everything, set us up for this recession, and mortally wounded the American Dream. Wiser old heads in labor-management relations urged him to let them return without loss of face in 3 days after the strike's start, but he chose instead a Jihadist approach, and we have been bleeding as a nation ever since.No president before or since has made so great a domestic policy mistake.