Bernie Madoff

by: Michael Moore  |  Time Magazine

Bernie Madoff
Bernard Madoff walks to federal court in mid-March. (Photo: AM New York)

    Elie Wiesel called him a "God." His investors called him a "genius." But, proving correct that old adage from the country and western song, you never really know what goes on behind closed doors.

    Bernie Madoff, for at least 20 years, ran a Ponzi scheme on thousands of clients, among them the people you and I would consider the best and brightest. Business leaders, celebrities, charities, even some of his own relatives and his defense attorney were taken for a ride (this has to be the first time a lawyer was hosed by the client).

    We're clearly in one of those historic, game changing years: up is down, red is blue and black is president. Aside from Obama himself, no person will provide a more iconic face of this end-of-capitalism-as-we-know-it year than Bernard Lawrence Madoff.

    Which is too bad. Yes, he stole $65 billion from some already quite-wealthy people. I know that's upsetting to them because rich guys like Bernie are not supposed to be stealing from their own kind. Crime, thievery, looting - that's what happens on the other side of town. The rules of the money game on Park Avenue and Wall Street are comprised of things like charging the public 29% credit card interest, tricking people into taking out a second mortgage they can't afford, and concocting a student loan system that has graduates in hock for the next 20 years. Now that's smart business! And it's legal. That's where Bernie went wrong - his scheming, his trickery was an outrage both because it was illegal and because he preyed on his side of the tracks.

    Had Mr. Madoff just followed the example of his fellow top one-percenters, there were many ways he could have legally multiplied his wealth many times over. Here's how it's done. First, threaten your workers that you'll move their jobs offshore if they don't agree to reduce their pay and benefits. Then move those jobs offshore. Then place that income on the shores of the Cayman Islands and pay no taxes. Don't put the money back into your company. Put it into your pocket and the pockets of your shareholders. There! Done! Legal!

    But Bernie wanted to play X-games Capitalism, run by the mantra that's at the core of all capitalistic endeavors: Enough Is Never Enough. You have the right to make as much as you can, and if people are too stupid to read the fine print of their health insurance policy or their GM "100,000-mile warranty," well, tough luck, losers. Buyers beware!

    It would be too easy - and the wrong lesson learned - to put Bernie on TIME's list all by himself. If Ponzi schemes are such a bad thing, then why have we allowed all of our top banks to deal in credit default swaps and other make-believe rackets? Why did we allow those same banks to create the scam of a sub-prime mortgage? And instead of putting the people responsible in the cell block in Lower Manhattan, where Bernie now resides, why did we give them huge sums of our hard-earned tax dollars to bail them out of their self-inflicted troubles? Bernard Madoff is nothing more than the scab on the wound. He's also a most-needed and convenient distraction. Where's the photo on this list of the ex-chairmen of AIG, Merrill Lynch and Citigroup? Where's the mug shot of Phil Gramm, the senator who wrote the bill to strip the system of its regulations, or of the President who signed that bill? And how 'bout those who ran the fake numbers at the ratings agencies, the lobbyists who succeeded in making sleazy accounting a lawful practice, or the stock market itself - an institution that's treated like the Holy Sepulchre instead of the casino that it is (and, like all other casinos, the house eventually wins).

    And what of Madoff's clients themselves? What did they think was going on to guarantee them incredible returns on their investments every single year - when no one else on planet Earth was getting anything like that? Some have admitted they did have an inkling "something was up," but no one really wanted to ask what it was that was making their money grow on trees. They were afraid they might find out it had nothing to do with gardening. Many of Madoff's victims have told investigators that, over the years, they have made much more than the original investment they gave Bernie. If I buy a stolen car from the guy down the street, the police will take that car from me regardless of whether I knew it was stolen. If I knew it was stolen, then I go to jail for receiving stolen property. Will these "victims" give back their gains that were fraudulently obtained? Will the head of Goldman Sachs reveal what he was doing at the meetings with the Fed chairman and the Treasury secretary before the bailout? Will Bank of America please tell us what they've spent $45 billion of our TARP money on?

    That's probably going too far. Better that we just put Bernie on this list.

    -------

    Moore's new documentary on the wonders of capitalism will be in movie theaters this fall.

    This essay is an extended version of the one that appears in the print version of Time.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



The culture of reckless

The culture of reckless greed and corruption which has permeated American society since 1980 testifies to the fundamental evil of the reaganaut monstrosity engineered by murdoch, buckley, ailes, ginrich, perle, and the like. Enough!


We have not had a Free

We have not had a Free Market ever since the Dollar was handed over to the group of Pirates known as the Federal Reserve Bank in 1913. By manipulating the currency all of these years, they have manipulated the markets and milked US like a cow all these years. We lost the gold standard altogether in 1971 under Nixon - that was the beginning of the end - and we have seen what always, always has happened throughout history when people try to operate an economy without the discipline that physical gold and silver always impose. In the old days, people could actually save money and still have it be worth something when they entered old age. Listening to the convoluted mumbo jumbo justifications for fiat currency systems as promoted by the Kenesian economists who the bankers have cleverly 'benefacted' into all of our Universities, would be comical if it hadn't resulted in the impoverishment of every working man and woman in this country. God help us if we descend into 'capitalism doesn't work, let's try socialism' - anyone who has ever visited those countries can tell you how poorly they fare.


Dear Anonymous @ 21:55: The

Dear Anonymous @ 21:55: The "reckless greed and corruption that has permeated American society" has been around a lot longer than the last 29 years! It has an infamous history dating back at least to the 19th Century, if not to the days of the Revolution. That we, as a society, have tolerated it, and have not stamped it down to a mere occasional criminal "flare-up" is mute testimony to the moral and ethical bankruptcy of perhaps a large majority of the population. It is further evidence that gives lie to the blathering of far too many that ours is a "Christian" nation, or a nation that truly espouses ANY organized religion worthy of the name. The promise of America is a far cry from realization, and our professed "values" are all too frequently a sham. Greed, envy, hatred, prejudice, war-mongering, exploitation of anyone and everyone possible, lying, cheating, stealing, bullying...all are the REAL values by which many, if not most of our nation lives, never mind the "values" professed. Just look at the people we elevate to positions of esteem and "leadership" and those whose every move we give our rapt attention. I believe President Obama personifies the best of our professed values, but he's only one man. I'm sure there must be many others, but not so many in positions of power or public esteem. Michael Moore tells it like it is.


Dear Bob Walters, we as a

Dear Bob Walters, we as a nation are not morally bankrupt. We are, however ill informed, misinformed, and lied to by our "elected" officials and dizzy from sleazy media spin. Without good information (like the truth) can you really expect people to make good decisions about what to trash and what to let stand? Moreover, some things are just plain foisted on us, like the 16th amendment (unconstitutional income tax) which was never fully ratified. If you want to identify morally bankrupt, point your finger at most politicians, bankers, media, big corporate businesses, and the laws they have lobbied to enact to fleece the rest of us, not the rest of us who don't individually have the clout to force anything on anybody. thank god we have the internet to spread the truth around. And maybe, when we get to the truth, we will wake up and change things.


Now Michael, think EVEN

Now Michael, think EVEN BIGGER. You CAN NOT talk about financial fraud without talking about the technicolor, we're-not-in-Kansas-anymore means by which money is created and by the FED and other banks. In the fewest possible words: It’s FRAUD, on a scale so vast it makes Bernie M's transgressions look like mere purse-snatching. It is a scheme that’s been operating since 1913 when the Federal Reserve act gave the FED (a private, cartel-owned bank) a monopoly on the creation of money. Because money is created out of nothing with a few keystrokes when you, me, the gov't borrow money, banks collect vast sums of interest for, well, nothing and it's a permanent drain on the economy. How much money is that? Sound like fraud yet?

Fractional reserve banking, the voodoo by which banks lend out more money than they have, has been further perverted -- they count deposits (not cash) as the basis for making loans. In other words there is no limit to how much money they can issue and dump into the economy which devalues OUR money like nobody's business. Most things like groceries cost twice what they did a couple of years ago. In a couple of years bankers have ripped off HALF OF EVERYONE'S wealth. How much money is that? It defies comprehension. It's orders of magnitude more than Madoff made off with and the fraud is still on.

Feeling sick yet? I really hope, plead, beg you to put the truth about banking in your next movie so we can wake up and take the banking system to task. Or our collective goose is cooked.

google "Money As Debt", "the Money Masters" or go to www.webofdebt.com for more info on banking fraud.



Believe it or not, I gave up

Believe it or not, I gave up my wealth over twenty years ago. I couldn't stand the company. I burned my Mammon's uniform, otherwise known as a business suite. So now the cops who once respected me don't. I don't go around with poor mouth, but I have long hair. Funny, when I was 'better off' my long hair was a charm with the authorities. Now I'm just a 'hippy type'. but I really don't mind. When the law confronts me for waking down the street in the land of the free. I smile knowing who I really please. I wouldn't suggest this for anyone else, but I adamantly suggest people quit smiling at wealth mongers. I was once asked why I don't respect so called rich people. I tell them "how do I know they didn't get rich robbing my bank"? So Madoff is my hero, he exonerated me. 21:55 You tell it like it is too! Good writing my friend. Remember one thing: There is no such a thing as a Christian country. And since I gave up on wealth, I have never been richer.


When people are amazed at

When people are amazed at his lying skills, I think, how many women (and men) have had an unfaithful spouse? My former husband is appalled at Bernie M. I think, look in the mirror...


unfortunately nothing is

unfortunately nothing is going to change. in fact, it'll probably get a lot worse, seeing as the bankers are already finding ways of paying back the gov. loans so they can get their snouts in the trough again. the only way out is revolution, but when you can get a plasma tv wth nothing to pay for two years (here in australia), it's hard to tear yourself away from the all new, widescreen simpsons and actually take to the street. especially since those streets are already crammed full of gas guzzling suv's.... outraged, blandford


Plenty of blame to go around

Plenty of blame to go around here, Michael. You come down hard on the lenders who made sub-prime loans and the credit card companies who charge up to 29% interest. Fair enough. But what about the borrowers who took out home loans that they knew were beyond their means? They were speculating, just like speculators in any other commodity--hoping that the prices of real estate would go up quickly enough to enable them to make some money before the large payments came do. And the credit card users? They could hardly have been unaware that they were paying a usurious interest rate. The APR is highlighted on every statement. But they wanted what they wanted, and they wanted it NOW. Victims? Hardly. --David


As one who knows first-hand

As one who knows first-hand the who, why and how of this fiasco scenario, it is finally time to re-focus all attention on the "what". The "what" in the Madoff case and all other failures named in the article is the broken social system which rewards arrogance, greed and deceit. Everything anywhere based on falseness will eventually crumble under its own weight of false-no-substance. Falseness will never support itself. Falseness always fails. This is all a big game being played by each of us who blindly and unconsciously participates in such a broken system. Insiders know that the game has no rules that cannot be broken. Our universal unconscious need for control and comfort is a big problem that always creates more of its own. As social systems become more conscious of their fundamental needs to serve humanity, we will each experience the world very differently. This new day is coming. I hope we learn by fully recognizing and understanding what not to do. It starts with each person looking at themselves as more significant than the lies and deceit of false systems. I know we can do this.


Madoff is in jail because he

Madoff is in jail because he robbed rich people, people who must now live like the rest of us, without Bahama vacations and million-dollar homes and face lifts and fancy cars, etc. He is in jail after a pretty swift and efficient court process was pressed by people with connections who were mad because they lost privileges he ill-got for them. He is in jail because of their "keep-it-coming" attitude. Don't tell me they shouldn't have guessed that "too good to be true" WAS too good to be true and honest and fair. OMIGOSH, now they have to do their own house cleaning and lawn mowing, and sit in economy seats and wear off-the-rack clothes. OMIGOSH!!!


Re: the sense of a

Re: the sense of a "Christian" nation look to fundamental ideas going back to Medieval times and before, viz. that to envy the rich is a sin. Who thought that one up? OK, even granted that envy might be a miserable emotion to suffer, but "morally" it has been blown up into a generalization that to interfere with the making of money is a sin. Why do so many videos of so many mega-churches show so many congregations of pentacostals et al. of that ilk stand there, eyes closed, palms upward, intensely praying to be showered with gold from Heaven? Christianity is the biggest ally capitalism has, it almost always has been, even though Jesus said more than once that his "kingdom" was "not of this earth."


re: anion 15:05, & anon

re: anion 15:05, & anon 06:42. I don't think wealth envy has just blown up out of nowhere. It has blown up out of desperation, poverty and eroding social support. In the matter of earning and accumulating wealth, the playing field is not even remotely level and it's tilting ever more wildly in favor of the wealthy every day. If you don't have money it is pretty near impossible not to want some as our society runs on it. I could see not caring that much about money if I lived in Denmark, where they have health care, old age care and free college for you kids. What's left to worry about then?

I would probably qualify as middle class but fears about money is never far from my consciousness. Nor is the awareness that if I or my husband loses his job, we would lose pretty much everything. Can you really blame the have-nots for wanting to have some, for taking a chance on maybe getting out of the poverty hole and having something for a change? What have they got to lose? If it doesn't work out they will still be poor.



For those who blame greedy

For those who blame greedy homeowners for the burst bubble, hear this: My lawyer friend just went to a legal seminar on foreclosures. She phoned me at lunchtime in amazement over the fraud and collusion on the part of the bankers and mortgage companies. She said the various laws were crystal clear and the blame was squarely on the lenders, not the borrowers. But we have yet to see any of them prosecuted and that's the "social" problem this country faces.


Madoff is just a decoy, a

Madoff is just a decoy, a scapegoat. The real blame goes to all of us- every single one of us---- for our petty greed, narrow minded competitiveness, lack of vision, and selfishness. Until that ever goes away, things will always be the same- the only difference might be when it happens again- in 1920, 2008, 0r onwards Ponzi had to leave Italy in 1903, in order to pull his sceme in the US, because the more sociable Italians at the time would have nipped his scheme int he bud much earlier on. The only way a Ponzi scheme works is when the suckers' attention is kept focussed inwards at their own profit margin, taking their attention off the whole picture. And, as a people, Americans are suckers, because most of us only care for ourselves, and not in our relationship with others. We are the Sneetches. And, like Sylvester McMonkey McBean, Madoff, "made off" with our cash, because we were too focused on getting the better of our neighbors and friends to be paying much attention to what was really going on. I'm glad that Michael Moore still has faith inus as a people, and you are lucky that he does, because I don't.


Most of "us" would not be in

Most of "us" would not be in the investment market getting hosed regularly if we could survive layoffs and retirement by accumulating savings that pay some sort of interest. Wanting a decent return now for the years we'll be in economic free fall after we stop working isn't greed. "All of us" don't share the blame for the current situation. "We have not had a free" says socialist countries fare poorly... Denmark looks pretty good to me. I like the stats posted by countries with national health plans. And if we weren't pouring money down the health insurance rathole, retirement would be easier to manage with modest net worth.


I love you Michael Moore.

I love you Michael Moore. Why can't you do a prime-time talk show? I might break my 30 year boycott of TV and watch you! And by the way, when are you going to do history documentaries that are as insightful as your political commentary, too? Time to educate the morons who think OBAMA policies are things we need to tea party about....


If we are to give lenders

If we are to give lenders and those in power a pass, and naively suppose they don't have profound influence on laws that protect their interests much more than ours, and place some large portion of blame or responsiblity on individuals what about a decimated system of education that doesn't effectively teach us to read the fine print or to understand it, much less to understand we are being brainwashed to identifiy with what we consume. Check out Jean Baudrillard. Do you want the red pill or the blue pill?


We are in a period of time

We are in a period of time where the world appears to stink because the garbage can lid has been taken off. There will always be greed, love, kindness, hate, etc. Everyone simply needs to get focused on what YOU are adding to the world. You can't do a thing about anyone else. Do your part of adding what you want to add and let the rest have the life they want. I quit my job one year ago realizing what a mess was coming and let someone else worry about income/layoffs, etc. I have exactly what I want, freedom and lightness. What a joy!


BMoore: It's wonderful that

BMoore: It's wonderful that you can walk away from your job and experience joy and lightness from it. Most of us would experience desperation, hunger, and homelessness if we did that.


SharonsJ, well said. But

SharonsJ, well said. But consider that poverty is the product of wealth. Anything that separates the community is unhealthy. I have seen a number of cases where people who get a well paying job become 'above' they're neighbors, even they're families. Money changes the social dynamic. Have you ever shared your dinner with a homeless guest? Or do you shut your door against a lesser person who happens through your neighborhood? Leaving them cold and hungry? I lived through the 60's. Many of us blue collar types would leave our cars unlocked in the winter so that the homeless could have a warm spot to sleep. Police and insurance companies put a stop to it. As well a stop to hitchhiking. Or anything else that is supportive to the poor or just travelers. How sad.


There has to be some kind of

There has to be some kind of resolve for everyone in this country who cannot and will never be able to have some of the"stolen"monies the investors made through Madoff. By this I mean, we can all feel very good that people who invested with Madoff are just as foolish or even downright stupid to think they deserve any monies from the Madoff Ponzi scheme; one exception only would be the amount they initially invested with Madoff. The question then arises who should get the "stolen" monies? I would feel really good if the "stolen" monies were given back to the government so that the country's deficit would become less of a burden on the citizens of this country and the future generations that need to pay for it. On this last note, I think if this would play itself out then others like Madoff investors, Bank of America, AIG, Goldman Sachs would think "twice" before investing to gain high returns called "stolen" monies.


Investment banking has

Investment banking has always been a casino for the wealthy... And a laundromat for organized crime... The repeal of glass-steagal allowed the banksters to gamble with our money... The bailout charade is a matter of one casino taking over their competitors after bankrupting them by flooding them with counterfeit chips...


00:09 I have lived in "one

00:09 I have lived in "one of those countries" and believe that because there are so few poor people, and the richest CEOs make about 2-3 mil a year, a working wage, but not the 10's and 100's of millions US CEOs make, the nations of Europe house a more satisfied and reasonable populace. Crime is much lower, older people live with dignity, and I encounter very few if any unsatisfied or bitter people in the middle class group I frequent. What's your basis for such an unsupported opinion?


The Banking business, a

The Banking business, a casino for the wealthy and a laundromat for organized crime. It really began when former Sen Phil Gramm of the Enron Scam, teamed up with Senator Chris Dodd and Bubba Clinton to introduce a bill to deregulate the banking racket. The time has come to put the blame on Bubba, the racketeer president..The sellout of our industrial base to China began under Bubba, and we are in a major depression. Tent Cities are popping up all over the country..Wake up people!!!


Let's not forget president

Let's not forget president Clinton's role in this debacle. Michael Moore singles out Phil Graham but omits three other key individuals, then senator Hank Paulson and senator McCain who sponsored legislation to suspend Glass-Steagall and President Clinton who signed these bills into law along with ramming NAFTA through. Clinton has proven to be no friend of the people unless you mean the top 1% which is where is head and heart really lie.