War Is Sin

by: Chris Hedges  |  Truthdig

War Is Sin
An American flag stands in front of a gravestone at Arlington National Cemetery. (Photo: Getty Images)

    The crisis faced by combat veterans returning from war is not simply a profound struggle with trauma and alienation. It is often, for those who can slice through the suffering to self-awareness, an existential crisis. War exposes the lies we tell ourselves about ourselves. It rips open the hypocrisy of our religions and secular institutions. Those who return from war have learned something which is often incomprehensible to those who have stayed home. We are not a virtuous nation. God and fate have not blessed us above others. Victory is not assured. War is neither glorious nor noble. And we carry within us the capacity for evil we ascribe to those we fight.

    Those who return to speak this truth, such as members of Iraq Veterans Against the War, are our contemporary prophets. But like all prophets they are condemned and ignored for their courage. They struggle, in a culture awash in lies, to tell what few have the fortitude to digest. They know that what we are taught in school, in worship, by the press, through the entertainment industry and at home, that the melding of the state's rhetoric with the rhetoric of religion, is empty and false.

    The words these prophets speak are painful. We, as a nation, prefer to listen to those who speak from the patriotic script. We prefer to hear ourselves exalted. If veterans speak of terrible wounds visible and invisible, of lies told to make them kill, of evil committed in our name, we fill our ears with wax. Not our boys, we say, not them, bred in our homes, endowed with goodness and decency. For if it is easy for them to murder, what about us? And so it is simpler and more comfortable not to hear. We do not listen to the angry words that cascade forth from their lips, wishing only that they would calm down, be reasonable, get some help, and go away. We, the deformed, brand our prophets as madmen. We cast them into the desert. And this is why so many veterans are estranged and enraged. This is why so many succumb to suicide or addictions.

    War comes wrapped in patriotic slogans, calls for sacrifice, honor and heroism and promises of glory. It comes wrapped in the claims of divine providence. It is what a grateful nation asks of its children. It is what is right and just. It is waged to make the nation and the world a better place, to cleanse evil. War is touted as the ultimate test of manhood, where the young can find out what they are made of. War, from a distance, seems noble. It gives us comrades and power and a chance to play a small bit in the great drama of history. It promises to give us an identity as a warrior, a patriot, as long as we go along with the myth, the one the war-makers need to wage wars and the defense contractors need to increase their profits.

    But up close war is a soulless void. War is about barbarity, perversion and pain, an unchecked orgy of death. Human decency and tenderness are crushed. Those who make war work overtime to reduce love to smut, and all human beings become objects, pawns to use or kill. The noise, the stench, the fear, the scenes of eviscerated bodies and bloated corpses, the cries of the wounded, all combine to spin those in combat into another universe. In this moral void, naively blessed by secular and religious institutions at home, the hypocrisy of our social conventions, our strict adherence to moral precepts, come unglued. War, for all its horror, has the power to strip away the trivial and the banal, the empty chatter and foolish obsessions that fill our days. It lets us see, although the cost is tremendous.

    The Rev. William P. Mahedy, who was a Catholic chaplain in Vietnam, tells of a soldier, a former altar boy, in his book "Out of the Night: The Spiritual Journey of Vietnam Vets," who says to him: "Hey, Chaplain ... how come it's a sin to hop into bed with a mama-san but it's okay to blow away gooks out in the bush?"

    "Consider the question that he and I were forced to confront on that day in a jungle clearing," Mahedy writes. "How is it that a Christian can, with a clear conscience, spend a year in a war zone killing people and yet place his soul in jeopardy by spending a few minutes with a prostitute? If the New Testament prohibitions of sexual misconduct are to be stringently interpreted, why, then, are Jesus' injunctions against violence not binding in the same way? In other words, what does the commandment 'Thou shalt not kill' really mean?"

    Military chaplains, a majority of whom are evangelical Christians, defend the life of the unborn, tout America as a Christian nation and eagerly bless the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan as holy crusades. The hollowness of their morality, the staggering disconnect between the values they claim to promote, is ripped open in war.

    There is a difference between killing someone who is trying to kill you and taking the life of someone who does not have the power to harm you. The first is killing. The second is murder. But in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, where the enemy is elusive and rarely seen, murder occurs far more often than killing. Families are massacred in airstrikes. Children are gunned down in blistering suppressing fire laid down in neighborhoods after an improvised explosive device goes off near a convoy. Artillery shells obliterate homes. And no one stops to look. The dead and maimed are left behind.

    The utter failure of nearly all our religious institutions-whose texts are unequivocal about murder-to address the essence of war has rendered them useless. These institutions have little or nothing to say in wartime because the god they worship is a false god, one that promises victory to those who obey the law and believe in the manifest destiny of the nation.

    We all have the capacity to commit evil. It takes little to unleash it. For those of us who have been to war this is the awful knowledge that is hardest to digest, the knowledge that the line between the victims and the victimizers is razor-thin, that human beings find a perverse delight in destruction and death, and that few can resist the pull. At best, most of us become silent accomplices.

    Wars may have to be fought to ensure survival, but they are always tragic. They always bring to the surface the worst elements of any society, those who have a penchant for violence and a lust for absolute power. They turn the moral order upside down. It was the criminal class that first organized the defense of Sarajevo. When these goons were not manning roadblocks to hold off the besieging Bosnian Serb army they were looting, raping and killing the Serb residents in the city. And those politicians who speak of war as an instrument of power, those who wage war but do not know its reality, those powerful statesmen-the Henry Kissingers, Robert McNamaras, Donald Rumsfelds, the Dick Cheneys-those who treat war as part of the great game of nations, are as amoral as the religious stooges who assist them. And when the wars are over what they have to say to us in their thick memoirs about war is also hollow, vacant and useless.

    "In theological terms, war is sin," writes Mahedy. "This has nothing to do with whether a particular war is justified or whether isolated incidents in a soldier's war were right or wrong. The point is that war as a human enterprise is a matter of sin. It is a form of hatred for one's fellow human beings. It produces alienation from others and nihilism, and it ultimately represents a turning away from God."

    The young soldiers and Marines do not plan or organize the war. They do not seek to justify it or explain its causes. They are taught to believe. The symbols of the nation and religion are interwoven. The will of God becomes the will of the nation. This trust is forever shattered for many in war. Soldiers in combat see the myth used to send them to war implode. They see that war is not clean or neat or noble, but venal and frightening. They see into war's essence, which is death.

    War is always about betrayal. It is about betrayal of the young by the old, of cynics by idealists, and of soldiers and Marines by politicians. Society's institutions, including our religious institutions, which mold us into compliant citizens, are unmasked. This betrayal is so deep that many never find their way back to faith in the nation or in any god. They nurse a self-destructive anger and resentment, understandable and justified, but also crippling. Ask a combat veteran struggling to piece his or her life together about God and watch the raw vitriol and pain pour out. They have seen into the corrupt heart of America, into the emptiness of its most sacred institutions, into our staggering hypocrisy, and those of us who refuse to heed their words become complicit in the evil they denounce.

    --------

    Chris Hedges, who spent nearly two decades as a war correspondent for The New York Times and other newspapers, is the author of "Empire of Illusion: The End of Literacy and the Triumph of Spectacle," due out in July. His Truthdig column appears every Monday.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Finally, the Truth... It is

Finally, the Truth... It is heartening to see this article. It has long puzzled me how people can "support the troops" but oppose the war, when the troops are volunteers, not draftees, who choae to sin by choosing to join the US Imperial Military. Regardless of whatever ignorance, motivations, beliefs or other factors cause a person to join the US Military, the choice indicates that the person is morally blind and is insensitive to the fact that US wars since WW II are always wars of aggression that have nothing do with defending the USA and everything to do with hegemony and the massive welfare scheme known as the military-industrial complex. The law of Karma is always in effect. So when I see other articles lamenting how soldier and veterans are suffering because they chose to join the US Military, I feel sad. Because the fact is, if you did not chose to join the Imperial Army, you would not be suffering the effects of being in corrupt wars where you invade and kill and are yourself the target of hostility because you are part of an occupying army. This article should be required reading for all soldiers and wanna-be soldiers. As far as I am concerned, the only honorable soldiers are people like Officer Erin Watada, who risked his safety and freedom to say NO to war by refusing to deploy.


Thank you for speaking out

Thank you for speaking out about a part of the inner struggle in which my husband is now fully ensnared. People often thank him, noting his willingness to put his life on the line - but he would argue that police and firemen do that every day. But no one 'back home' is asked by the government to kill people -- that is the bigger sacrifice, a part of one's soul.


Ambush and Incrementalism

Ambush and Incrementalism orchestrated by the architects of war nudge and drag us into patriotic savagery. Ask a Nazi: “Naturally the common people don't want war; neither in Russia, nor in England, nor in America, nor in Germany. That is understood. But after all, it is the leaders of the country who determine policy, and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along, whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is to tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same in any country.” -- Hermann Goering


This article may as well

This article may as well have been written 3000 years ago, or at any time in human history. We, as the pestilence, will not learn. The majority are born into poverty. This poverty leads to being educated in a system of controlled behavior. Speaks for most, does it not? Does it take war for most to wake. This only proves my previous point. We are not born with morality. Morality is taught. My previous point bears this out. The control system teaches its' perverted version of morality. This will not change. This has never changed. We ARE on the road to annihilation. The controllers will see to that. In there zeal they will have also eliminated themselves.


Thank you, Mr. Hedges, for

Thank you, Mr. Hedges, for writing this brave article. I have wondered for years why, in this Super-In-God-We-Trust country it is always the Atheists and Agnostics who demonstrate morality, and the Christians who favor torture and murder and seem to have no concept of morality at all. I no longer wonder about this issue. I have become convinced that the evil we exhibit can be laid directly at the feet of the Christian philosophy itself. It is a philosophy that teaches absolutism and the absolute rightness of authority. It is the tool of Authority used at the cost of morality. You see the result. WE start wars with terrorist attacks openly labeled as such: "Shock and Awe." WE torture. WE steal resources. WE murder everyone who gets in our way. WE are the axis of evil.


Chris, Thank you for this

Chris, Thank you for this moving reality check and illuminating the rank hypocrisy of government and religious leaders about the "glory" of war. Instead of glory and patriotism, we should be ashamed by what we as a nation have wrought and our own passivity watching it happen. The America I grew up believing in is now militaristic with more than 780 foreign military bases and military guards in embassies all over the world. And, of course, Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo. Who the hell are we anymore?


Wow! This column is a very

Wow! This column is a very dangerous one in a country of evangelical Christians. I fear for Mr. Hedges safety. I agree with him completely, and have believed his points since 2000. The moment GWB was announced as having won (stolen) the election I got a cold, ominous feeling. A close friend has since said "You were right that day". There would be war, absolutely no question, with this man. It would be war waged under a righteous banner (easy to sell). I somehow knew that my son, who was in the National Guard, would be involved even though that is unusual. I was so terrified of his possible death in the war that I didn't consider that he might be gravely wounded. He was a medic, completely against the war from the start, but felt in all honor that he had to go fight terrorism. Now blinded due to a serious and untreated closed-head TBI, Ken and our family bitterly regret the wars waged for oil & greed. We abhor that war causes such devastation for our troops and that most fundamentals prefer to gloss over the atrocities to civilians. I urge Americans to volunteer at a VA hospital (very Christian) where they will witness the results of the horrors for themselves. These soldiers need them so! Many are completely alone, yet should be cared for and honored by those who believe war is just. My family was devout Mormon before this war; our amazement that organized religion would perpetrate and callously support outright murder burst that bubble. True Christians should be the dissenters! What would Christ do? Do I need to add that my family no longer attends religious services and never will again?


THANK YOU.Military should be

THANK YOU.Military should be a defensive force only.The real misfits are those who initiate, escalate & profit from war.Local b/sticker 'g** bless ALL nations-no exceptions'.


Amen.

Amen.


The more people go to

The more people go to church, the more they support using torture to get information. War IS Hell and it corrupts all values. Killing becomes commonplace in warlike cultures like ours -- weeks in basic training with "Kill Kill Kill" as the theme, along with tremendous peer pressure from everyone is simply brain washing -- Think that this does not have any impact on a 18 year old kid? Think they can go off to War and not be changed forever as well as de-sensitized to most things human? How can Christians actually support killing people for land or beliefs or similar??? Yet most armies are led by Very Christian Republican Leaders...


Mr. Hedges put his finger on

Mr. Hedges put his finger on the core problem in the following excerpt: "We all have the capacity to commit evil. . . . human beings find a perverse delight in destruction and death, and . . . few can resist the pull. At best, most of us become silent accomplices." We struggle to be what we like to think of as "moral" beings, but we are a species that has not evolved socially to the same degree it has developed technologically. The discrepancy may well be the end of us in the long run.


This article is a

This article is a hard-hitting truth that is seldom voiced, and yet one that is needed. I can only second all that is written here, comments as well as the article. I am sure that there are many young men that never return to their families ..and I am not speaking of those that were killed doing the Business of their Masters. Oh, Many return, but without their souls. The saddest part is that they are unable to speak of that fact to the ones that love them--especially them ! It is, to them, a shame that is best left unspoken. So in that regard, they are still suffering a form of alienation that is like a prison; one that does not have a key to let them out. Some never physically return even though they still live..out of shame at the prospect of facing those that love them for fear that they will Know that this is not the same loved one that went off so Proudly to war ! Yes, War is a Racket..nothing can make it Right.


Thank you, Chris, for

Thank you, Chris, for articulating so well what I suspect a majority of humans feel, sense or intuitively KNOW, even if they can't put it into words. It would be easy to excuse our complicity, by reference to so many "having other priorities" in our lives, but probably it's just moral cowardice that enables us to ignore conscience and go along to get along. These truths also describe quite clearly the bankruptcy and abject failure of any religion on the face of the earth that condones, excuses or glorifies war, for any reason. The resort to war is screaming evidence of failure of the human spirit, and in a perverse sort of way, the failure of evolution. Despite all the beauty in the world, we humans are largely a failed experiment.


Perhaps if we had mandatory

Perhaps if we had mandatory national service we could develop "leaders" who would be enlightened enough to dismantle the military industrial combine and convert that into machinery for humanity's well being.


Powerful... hope the the

Powerful... hope the the people who really need to pay attention will read this.


Alternative? Ok, so war is

Alternative? Ok, so war is bad. Civil human beings understand this. But open-heart surgery is bad, gruesome, violent, affects its victims' lives forever, and it can and does kill people all the time. It saves more people, however, than it kills, and it's only done when necessary, yet routinely. How is war different? Three thousand people were murdered here eight years ago, and the purported purpose of US military action is to prevent it from happening again. And, it hasn't. So what IS the solution, if not military action? You really should address this, Chris.


Damage continues when they

Damage continues when they return - Comment from a OIF veteran e-mailed to me... I gave the info (the www.CGOF.org business plan) to the chaplain RRR RRRRR today to look over and see what he thinks and/or any ideas he may have. But after talking to him I just got a bad vibe from him or I felt he was very untrustworthy. He acted like he was interested but deep down inside I could sense he had his own agenda on how things should be. This just adds fuel to my fire that these 20 year retired "veterans" do not understand or really care about today’s combat veterans. Most of these people served mostly during peacetime and have no idea what being in combat does to your body and mind; only to come home to a society that doesn’t really care what you went through just to be sent back again, and again, and again. Each month hundreds of Iraq and Afghanistan combat veterans are committing suicide, yet the "system" is working for them!!?? Sorry to go off on another rant here but his lack of understanding or wanting to understand just set me off today. Keep me updated. Thanks – OIF tours ‘04 and ‘05 Please see www.CGOF.org and find a way to join me. Bob 310-625-3366


While I agree with the

While I agree with the article and all of the comments, I want to respond to David (posted 6/2) in regards to his claim that our volunteer army is made up of people who "chose" to become part of the killing imperialism that is the US military. That may be true for many in the officer class, but the so-called grunts are the product of a well organized society that assures that there will always be an underclass of young people so poverty stricken, living in a society that offers them very little chance to better themselves, that service in the military seems like a way out. Of course, the recruiters know this as does our government, so all promotional materials emphasize the "positive" - "Be all you can be - Be Army." Who of the poorest amongst us can resist such a siren call? And if this is true in the United States, how much more so in nations where abject poverty and lack of opportunity is a way of life for the vast majority of the population - so much so as to create people willing to blow themselves up for the "just cause" ? Meanwhile, our religions aid and abet this, including the bishops of the Roman Catholic Church for all their claims to perfection and absolute truthfulness and authority.


Your words are powerful

Your words are powerful because they are truth, the well we avoid to seek out, or to drink from. It never ceases to amaze me that Christian churches can tout the Ten Commandments as basic to their existence and pass over Thou Shalt Not Kill without so much as a blink on the radar. Thank you for expressing, in your well-written article, my deepest, most sincere, and most disturbing feelings for the political, military and religious animals that run, and have ruined our country and our world.


No nation wins in the

No nation wins in the fighting of a war, especially where there is killing, and loss of innocent lives. It only goes to prove, mankind has know idea who we really are in our relationship God and to each other. Lets get this straight once and for all. God is everything that exist. Therefore we are a part of what God is, but then so is everybody else. We are a part of God and thus we are also parts of each other. Every thing that exist in this world even the world itself is a part of God and Creator. We are one with all of this. When you destroy another human being, you in effect destroy part of your own self, and also part of God. It is a no win situation. If men like Kissenger, McNamara, Rumsfeld, Cheney and Bush want to fight a war, fine, put them in uniform and let them lead fools who want to join in the battle. At any rate, no person under the age of fifty should have to fight in any army. The young men and women should rebel against any subscription into an armed force for any reason. Yes, I served in the U.S. Air Force and I am thankful I served during a time of peace. So for me that was a good experience. But I am happy I can so no to this today.


A further comment: to 16:33:

A further comment: to 16:33: what is this thing about "mandatory national service" that some "progressives" have? Don't you understand that this just means more bodies for the government/corporate complex? Lack of respect for individual rights is a huge problem in the US; it's one of the things that got it into its current mess.


It may seem like "apples and

It may seem like "apples and oranges" but everything Chris Hedges says about war can illuminate the economic Depression we've been plunged into by the Kissingers and Cheneys of Wall Street. The war metaphor in macro-economics [e.g. "capturing market share"] makes global war a self-fullfilling prophecy. First we are corporate raiders; then we are firing smart-bombs at civilians in reprisals for insurgents in the streets of Mosul using IEDs against our soldiers. It is labeled as "the American Way." Why was the World Trade Center chosen as primary


Yes, Hedges reminds us of

Yes, Hedges reminds us of one of our greatest failings, among others. Generations follow generations, but a people who tout themselves as rational, progressive and humane cannot seem to operate in the world without resorting to periodic warfare, always claiming a defensive war or war to secure national well being, of course!


Suppose they gave a war and

Suppose they gave a war and nobody came.


I think the article is

I think the article is indeed full of truth. Self awareness is I think not something many people experience or even try to comprehend - it's so much easier to just believe whatever gets preached. Wouldn't it be amazing to learn this before guns are fired though .. I have heard this saying so many times.. and I really didn't get it until well the last ten years.. "The truth shall set you free". and indeed it will.


In answer to Paul - what is

In answer to Paul - what is the answer? It's like leaving home, taking your first job or asking out your first girl. In other words you can't know in advance. We have to CHOOSE another way because we don't accept those dark corners of our own nature that would take us down the same endless road again and again - not because there is a guaranteed outcome. That is courage and that is what growth of human conciousness is - and that can only happen when enough people are ready to stop taking the "easy way out" - not that Chris' and the soldiers that he describes would see war as an "easy" option - but for those in power - and of course, those that vote them in (or don't vote them out) it actually is. It is a refusal to look at our own natures and what we are capable of. As Chris' says here - these fighters come back having seen the ghost of all those whom they hold dear at home - out there murdering others like themselves - others who are also patriotic, also proud, also human - like them, but of another nationality and culture - and so different enough to be sacrificed. ...and the worst of all? There are some of us who are actually cynical enough to sell this on purpose, knowing but not caring to put a stop to it, because it feeds them the power they crave. It's not hard to see the demon that drives them - he's laughing all the way to the grave.