Review of Henry Giroux's: Youth in a Suspect Society

by: Tolu Olorunda  |  The Black Commentator

Youth in jail.
(Photo: Palgrave Macmillan)

    "In a radical free-market culture, when hope is precarious and bound to commodities and a corrupt financial system, young people are no longer at risk: they are the risk."

    - Giroux, Henry. "Youth in a Suspect Society: Democracy or Disposability?" New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009, p. x.

    "If youth once constituted a social investment in the future and symbolized the promise of a better world, they are now entering another stage in the construction of a global social order in which children are increasingly demonized and criminalized ..."
    - Ibid. p. 29.

    "As the politics of the social state gives way to the biopolitics of disposability, the prison becomes a preeminently valued institution whose disciplinary practices become a model for dealing with the increasing number of young people who are considered to be the waste products of a market-mediated society."
    - Ibid. p. 82.

    It need not be said, though I find it necessary to restate, that Henry Giroux is one of the most important public servants the last 100 years have produced. In his expansive three decade plus academic career, Henry has written over 35 books, contributed to countless scholarly journals, and received numerous educational honors.

    But perhaps what most makes this former high school basketball star distinct is his tireless advocacy on behalf of the frail, the vulnerable, the disposable.

    Henry has focused much of his writing over the fragile existence disenfranchised populations are largely relegated to. Giroux's "critical sympathy" to the often forgotten, as Georgetown professor Michael Eric Dyson once mentioned, is what pushes him time after time to engage issues many of his peers would rather stay far away from - for fear of sanction, resentment, or job loss.

    In that spirit of deep moral determination and fervent conviction, comes his latest work: Youth in a Suspect Society, which, above all else, is an attempt to interrogate the increasingly hostile future our society is preparing, with no sense of shame or irony, for its next tenants - young people.

    Giroux wastes no time condemning the "assault against youth" being waged by all those blind to the radical realities of youth, and especially those of color being confined by way of policy and legislation. An example of this is provided in the case of Deamonte Driver, a seventh grader from Prince George's County, Maryland, who "died because his mother did not have the health insurance to cover an $80 tooth extraction."

    Under the Lyndon Baines Johnson administration, Giroux writes, there was at least a "willingness to fight for the rights of children, enact reforms that invested in their future, and provide the educational conditions necessary for them to be critical citizens." But all advancements made in that era were rolled over as one neo-conservative administration after the other found its way into the White House. And the most devastating of them, in theory and practice, Giroux insists, was the 43rd one.

    But government alone isn't responsible, he notes, because anti-Youth legislations couldn't be established as law without a media complex that has "habitually" reinforced representations, however false, of young people as "variously lazy, stupid, self-indulgent, volatile, dangerous, and manipulative." It's important to note that these suggestions "do more than degrade young people and resonate with their underlying marginality and disposability"; they also "legitimate the passage of draconian measures, policies, and laws at the highest levels of government."

    So, it then makes sense when schools become transformed into secondary stations for police officers, military personnel, and other agents of the State.

    The message: Kids and, especially, Youth are a threat to society - a threat which must be watched with close scrutiny, dealt with diabolically, and, when necessary, punished with the power of the law.

    Students are, as a result, targeted and treated as potential criminals, paving way for a society in which "children who commit a rule violation as minor as a dress code infraction or slightly act out in class can be handcuffed, booked, and put in a jail cell."

    In Youth in a Suspect Society, Giroux also takes special time out to dive deeper into the challenges confronting children, as they try to navigate a world where giant corporations see them as nothing but disposable commodities - to be bought and sold.

    Children, Dr. Giroux writes, "constitute the primary index through which a society registers its own meaning, vision, and politics." And today's children are having to become more accustomed to a speed-driven society; a society that treasures punctuality over poignancy, and impatience over incandescence. Thus, kids are being encouraged to revel in "the suspension of judgment, the inability to think critically, [and] the avoidance of responsibility." (Never mind that these very kids are still ultimately barraged with blame for low test scores or poor performance on state standardized tests.)

    Kids would also have to get used to "a society that measures its success and failure solely through the economic lens of the Gross National Product (GNP)"; a society unable to "define youth outside of market principles determined largely by ... market growth and the accumulation of capital."

    This society, children should be aware, sees them not only as an "expansive and profitable market but as the primary source of redemption for the future of capitalism."

    Examples of such thinking abound in Youth in a Suspect Society. Giroux's meticulous research unearths numerous reports of kids being selected by toy companies to act as representatives (unpaid employees), such as a GIA-sponsored event, "Slumber Party in a Box," which enlists "agents" to "invite their friends to an overnight party, hand out free products to them, and then provide ëfeedback through quizzes' to GIA headquarters." Corporations have found kids and pre-teens great resources - peer pressure power - to use in expanding their brand - even if it commodifies the non-market value of friendship.

    Giroux also turns a sharp gaze on pro athletes like Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods, who, he says, appear more interested in inflating their back account figures than "using their celebrity status for educating young people about character, hard work, the value of sportsmanship, and the sheer joy of athleticism."

    But there's another angle to this, which hasn't gotten as much press among progressive circles. As Giroux writes:

More and more youth have been defined and understood within a war on terror that provides an expansive, antidemocratic framework for referencing how they are represented, talked about, and inserted within a growing network of disciplinary relations that responds to the problems they face by criminalizing their behaviors and subjecting them to punitive modes of conduct.

    The war on terror and drugs, Giroux asserts, has added a new target: Youth.

    This war, unlike the more glamorous cross-national disputes, doesn't necessarily involve two sides in contentious combat. This war is characterized by "4th grade reading scores and graduation rates [being] used to determine how many prison cells will be built." This war is against the growing population of "pint-size nihilists" amongst us. Extinguish them!

    And so,

    Instead of being viewed as impoverished, minority youth are seen as lazy and shiftless; instead of being recognized as badly served by failing schools, they are labeled uneducable and pushed out of schools; instead of being provided with decent work skills and jobs, they are either sent to prison or conscripted to fight in wars abroad; instead of being given decent health care and a place to live, they are placed in foster care or pushed into the swelling ranks of the homeless.

    These enemies of our peace are then rightfully placed in schools where the squeaking sound of metal detectors is omnipresent, where police forces are dominant, where arrests, suspensions, and expulsions are as commonplace as being frisked, cussed-out, or strip-searched by security officers on your way to class. These enemies of our peace might be too young to legally "marry, drive a car, get a tattoo, or go to scary movies, but not too young to be put in prisons for the rest of their lives."

    And while we're at it, let's make sure they're excluded from "various forms of student aid," post-conviction, including but not limited to "welfare payments, Medicaid, veterans' benefits, food stamps, and ... public housing."

    Isn't it so heartwarming to know that young people growing up have such a splendid future awaiting them?

    Giroux calls on "intellectuals" of great courage to "take a stand" against these "collective problems" putting at risk "not only young people and adults ... but the very possibility of deepening and expanding democracy itself." But how many of these intellectuals wouldn't have to be summoned from the dead?

    As he rightly notes, the university has witnessed a radical shift in vision this past decade. Through hysteria whipped up by right-wingers following 9/11, many liberal or left-leaning professors have been silenced or fired to quell the paranoia expressed by some students that they're being brainwashed. Their professors tried to force upon them "Marxist" and "Socialist" values - values that go by such scary prospects as critical thinking, intellectual freedom, and independent reasoning.

    These young people, Giroux writes, have been bamboozled by the likes of David Horowitz, president of the Center for the Study of popular culture, who've "hijacked political power and waged a focused campaign against the principles of academic freedom, sacrificing the quality of education made available to youth in the name of patriotic correctness."

    Cheated out of an enlightening educational experience, Giroux contends, are young people, who, in exchange for being provided the tools to "critically engage what they know and to recognize the limits of their own knowledge," are infantilized by appeasing academics. They are denied "opportunities to engage knowledge critically ... [and] assume responsibility for what it means to know something."

    Giroux's hopes are for a "larger public dialogue about how to imagine a democratic future," in the context of a Youth-centered pedagogy. Unfortunately, "We have entered a period in which the war against youth, especially poor youth of color, offers no apologies because it is too arrogant and ruthless to imagine any resistance." Nonetheless, this ambassador of hope reassures: "... [P]ower as a form of domination is never absolute, and oppression always produces some form of resistance."

    And though the laborious work of resistance must engage all sectors of society, Giroux's call to young people is direct: "[G]o out into the world and actively try to change it."

    Youth in a Suspect Society is an unnerving prophetic call to action. Through tedious research and meditation, Giroux has provided a blueprint that all concerned can use in restoring the faith Youth once had in society - faith planted in the soils of non-privatized, non-corporatized values.

    This faith, however, has been uprooted by years of indifference and antipathy, callousness and bellicosity.

    Children are now much too aware of the degree of disregard society disses them with. And they respond to it in ways that anger some and amuse others.

    But the concrete work of restoring this faith has hardly been addressed, let alone acted upon, before the publication of Youth in a Suspect Society.

    I recommend it with inestimable gratitude to Dr. Giroux for his moral vigor and matchless vitality.

--------    

    BlackCommentator.com Columnist, Tolu Olorunda, is a Nigerian native and cultural critic. Click here to reach Mr. Olorunda.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Thank you for the excellent

Thank you for the excellent review. I think that the reviewer and Henry Giroux so clearly understand howunfairly we are treating our youth. I am a great and grateful fan of Henry Giroux. When I feel discouraged, I read one of his articles in Truthout and feel once again encouraged that a sane and reasonable voice is speaking to the important issues of our time. I hope that many in Congress and the White House are reading his work and consulting with him. I hope that many Americans are listening as well. Again, thank you. I will try to do my part as well. With gratitude.


Sometimes you have to wonder

Sometimes you have to wonder what it is that motivates people to behave the way they do. I take the position, frankly, that we keep too many people alive, but to consider children (especially) as disposable is beyond the pale. I have no problem with saying that there should be limits to the number of us on the planet ... and since wars and disease are truly natural means of keeping populations within bounds they do have a place in the order of things. But the sort of criminality being expressed against children that this book exemplifies makes me wonder about the soullessness of our cruel and indifferent society. The real reason so many Americans seem hell bent to halt the concept of universal health care has nothing to do with the cost ... methinks ... but rather exemplifies that long extant tendency of Americans to be, simply, cruel and unfeeling. All of the rhetoric to the contrary, we would not be in Iraq and Afghanistan, nor would we have destroyed native americans and invaded mexico, nor currently hate immigrants with the passion we do were we NOT a cruel nation. So, as a librarian at the local high school, this will hit the shelves soon. rg the lg


And so it goes. Another

And so it goes. Another "natural resource" exploited and abused. Commercialed to death, technologized into war, assaulted with "bigger, better" throw away mateials, deprived of "at home" parents, entertained with horror and violence that never stops, fast junk food on top of it all. And we wonder what they will grow up to "be." What a revolution is in store for us when they do grow up! God bless each and every child on this entire planet. Let's hope they will forgive us.


I am glad this book is

I am glad this book is available with meticulous research to convince others. I have been speaking about this for more than a decade. I am 70 years old and witness to it.


In China, & some parts of

In China, & some parts of India, married people abort a fetus unless it's male, because males are "worth more" than females. Females need dowries. In the US, farm families often had at least 3 children (and they really hoped at least one was a boy), to provide for "free" labor on the farm. Sometimes, when there wasn't enough food, children were "encouraged" to leave or essentially thrown out of the house. Of course, the latter still happens today although it's more likely to be for out of control behavior than lack of food, in the US anyway. In other countries, children were apprenticed to various types of business owners/tradespeople, with the parent receiving whatever income the child earned. No school, but an apprenticeship. How well the child was treated was up to the person to whom the child was apprenticed--no laws protecting how children were treated. Then there was factory work. Daughters didn't get to keep the wages they earned, their fathers got it, because women weren't "competent" to handle money or own property (only widows could own property in their own names). Very young children worked long hours in factories. Children, boys & girls were taken out of school when they were old enough to earn a wage, on a farm, in a trade, in a factory, by their parents. In the US, there are cultures, religious organizations that do not acknowledge females as equal with men, as "good" as men, acceptable as ministers, or priests, and strong effort is made to teach children that this is the "right" way to perceive women, as subordinate creatures. Yep, things sure were better & children were regarded as less of a commodity, in the good old days. I strongly disapprove of the marketing that's directed towards children & adolescents. I don't like the increasing relinquishment of government & education to the private, usually corporate, sector (i.e., the government as run or controlled by Goldman Sachs, for instance as far as finances go). But when were things so much better? Are they alot better in the EU? Why not tell us how/where things are better?


We are all bic pens in a

We are all bic pens in a disposable society, but pity the youth...


Sandra Lilith Cawthern Yes,

Sandra Lilith Cawthern Yes, I am 68 and have been witness to it also. There WAS hope when I was young. I can't imagine what the future holds for our youth, but I know that whatever happens, we can't afford this useless apathy. Will we become a nation of psychopaths? Isn't that the ideal that we hold up for young people? I am so grateful that my daughter decided to homeschool her children. They are bright, interested, interesting, non-materialistic and hopeful. Why do we allow the persecution of youth of all classes? Persecution takes many forms.


from mexico, my thanks to

from mexico, my thanks to all who are writing here. because, as one reads the news, inhales the stories of middle america turning to methamphetamines, one also wonders of the sanity of a society that can engage in trillion dollars wars costing perhaps a hundred thousand lives, and then exhibit the hate turned against health reform and a public option. and it is always the children in any society, the collateral damage of a failed culture, who suffer most. it is not only intellectuals who have a responsibility to change this absurd system. perhaps we must begin by asking whether today democracy has any meaning. for sure the neofascists who are leading the charge of the right have no such illusions. only when we can confront the naked reality of a society can we hope to change it. henry giroux is putting the case, but the roots are not only in the education system.


Giroux's book is a natural

Giroux's book is a natural extension of a 1967 essay by Jerry Farber, The Student as Nigger (http://ry4an.org/readings/short/student/). Little seems to have changed in 42 years.


It's true. When young men

It's true. When young men between 20 and 30 have a 20% unemployment rate, and more than 1/3 of them live with their parents or in a similar supported situation, the blame is put on the young men. But few older adults seem willing to recall that where they had access to a free or very inexpensive college education that all but guaranteed a good career, a young man now must pay as much as $100,000 for a full education, and can expect marginally better prospects for secure employment and pay.


In answer to all this

In answer to all this despair and hand-wringing, let me introduce you to the class 0f '09, Walter Johnson High School, Bethesda. MD. By good fortune and a lot of effort by students, faculty and parents, the class turned out as self-aware citizens who don't take themselves too seriously and are not afraid to face difficult and draining tasks. They are well-grounded, not just well-rounded, and they cherish the differences between each other. My twin sons, who have learning disabilities, shared in the graduation ceremony as certificate recipients while their classmates were awarded diplomas, but this distinction didn't matter to anyone. I am absolutely confident that these young people have the ambition and perception to form a better community. How good are they? At the graduation ceremony, the principal urged them to give serious consideration to public service. The college admissions officers who turned down the applicants from WJHS will be kicking themselves in the next five years.


AT 75 , MY BIGGEST WORRY IS

AT 75 , MY BIGGEST WORRY IS FOR THE YOUTH OF "THIS "COUNTRY "Formerly USA . The Corporations and the failure ,or unwillingness of adults to understand that 911 was a"false Flag "operation and only the young and the poor suffer 'SPORTS and PHONY ENTERTAINMENT is our only product left. Bring back the DRAFT ,with NO exception . BUsh is still AWOL.


An interesting twist on the

An interesting twist on the social phenomena of gang recruitment is happening in Chicago. While Pilsen's past had a gangster hanging out on the corner recruiting children to carry his gun and run his drugs, one not for profit program is paying community artists to hang on the corner and create the phenomena of "art kids." They are hip hopper, break dancers, and graffiti artists, but they do serve as the substitute "family" that the "lost" children need: but instead of a pathway to addiction and violence they get creative. For example, when "JDeff" got gunned down in a case of mistaken identity, the "art kids" organized a week long car wash and raised the $6,000 for his funeral instead of falling into a cycle of revenge. One organization, the Pros Arts Studio, has initiated this "arts kids" initiative, and I hope it becomes a national template for the tragedy that befalls so many of our city youth.


Bubble Shooter

This is an amazing share. Many thanks for this writing.



burberry sport

burberry trench with confident EbWCBUDC http://www.burberryoutlet--online.com/



uggs in the uk

uk ugg store for more detail PZRRfGKh http://www.uggboots--uk.net/



ugg coupons

ugg boots coupons online RzrOvBlS http://www.ugg-coupon-code.com/



designer online store

buy best designer online stores to get new coupon DJcXfKpP http://designerhandbagsonline.clammo.com/



coach handbags wholesale

look at wholesale coach handbag at my estore AOAXPWlO http://www.wholesalecoachhandbags.us/



louis vuitton outlets

you must read louis vuitton handbags online for gift QQeoHzGW http://www.louisvuitton--onlineshop.com/



phil dawson jersey

wvzks jeff saturday jersey
qhbxy mark sanchez jersey
zebdg darren mcfadden jersey
tqlvv dane sanzenbacher jersey
cpyxj james starks jersey



ghd australia heditn

ghd cfrljble GHD Hair Straightener vejatexg GHD Australia xqpthmot cheap ghd