Afghanistan: Where Empires Go to Die

by: Dahr Jamail, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

Afghanistan: Where Empires Go to Die
(Illustration: Troy Page / t r u t h o u t)

    On September 7 the Swedish aid agency Swedish Committee for Afghanistan reported that the previous week US soldiers raided one of its hospitals. According to the director of the aid agency, Anders Fange, troops stormed through both the men's and women's wards, where they frantically searched for wounded Taliban fighters.

    Soldiers demanded that hospital administrators inform the military of any incoming patients who might be insurgents, after which the military would then decide if said patients would be admitted or not. Fange called the incident "not only a clear violation of globally recognized humanitarian principles about the sanctity of health facilities and staff in areas of conflict, but also a clear breach of the civil-military agreement" between nongovernmental organizations and international forces.

    Fange said that US troops broke down doors and tied up visitors and hospital staff.

    Impeding operations at medical facilities in Afghanistan directly violate the Fourth Geneva Convention, which strictly forbids attacks on emergency vehicles and the obstruction of medical operations during wartime.

    Lt. Cmdr. Christine Sidenstricker, a public affairs officer for the US Navy, confirmed the raid, and told The Associated Press, "Complaints like this are rare."

    Despite Sidenstricker's claim that "complaints like this" are rare in Afghanistan, they are, in fact, common. Just as they are in Iraq, the other occupation. A desperate conventional military, when losing a guerilla war, tends to toss international law out the window. Yet even more so when the entire occupation itself is a violation of international law.

    Marjorie Cohn, president of the National Lawyers Guild and also a Truthout contributor, is very clear about the overall illegality of the invasion and ongoing occupation of Afghanistan by the United States.

    "The UN Charter is a treaty ratified by the United States and thus part of US law," Cohn, who is also a professor at Thomas Jefferson School of Law and recently co-authored the book "Rules of Disengagement: The Politics and Honor of Military Dissent" said, "Under the charter, a country can use armed force against another country only in self-defense or when the Security Council approves. Neither of those conditions was met before the United States invaded Afghanistan. The Taliban did not attack us on 9/11. Nineteen men - 15 from Saudi Arabia - did, and there was no imminent threat that Afghanistan would attack the US or another UN member country. The council did not authorize the United States or any other country to use military force against Afghanistan. The US war in Afghanistan is illegal."

    Thus, the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan, along with the ongoing slaughter of Afghan civilians and raiding hospitals, are in violation of international law as well as the US Constitution.

    And of course the same applies for Iraq.

    Let us recall November 8, 2004, when the US military launched its siege of Fallujah. The first thing done by the US military was to invade and occupy Fallujah General Hospital. Then, too, like this recent incident in Afghanistan, doctors, patients and visitors alike had their hands tied and they were laid on the ground, oftentimes face down, and held at gunpoint.

    During my first four trips to Iraq, I commonly encountered hospital staff who reported US military raids on their facilities. US soldiers regularly entered hospitals to search for wounded resistance fighters.

    Doctors from Fallujah General Hospital, as well as others who worked in clinics throughout the city during both US sieges of Fallujah in 2004, reported that US Marines obstructed their services and that US snipers intentionally targeted their clinics and ambulances.

    "The Marines have said they didn't close the hospital, but essentially they did," Dr. Abdulla, an orthopedic surgeon at Fallujah General Hospital who spoke on condition of using a different name, told Truthout in May 2004 of his experiences in the hospital. "They closed the bridge which connects us to the city [and] closed our road ... the area in front of our hospital was full of their soldiers and vehicles."

    He added that this prevented countless patients who desperately needed medical care from receiving medical care. "Who knows how many of them died that we could have saved," said Dr. Abdulla. He also blamed the military for shooting at civilian ambulances, as well as shooting near the clinic at which he worked. "Some days we couldn't leave, or even go near the door because of the snipers," he said, "They were shooting at the front door of the clinic!"

    Dr. Abdulla also said that US snipers shot and killed one of the ambulance drivers of the clinic where he worked during the fighting.

    Dr. Ahmed, who also asked that only his first name be used because he feared US military reprisals, said, "The Americans shot out the lights in the front of our hospital. They prevented doctors from reaching the emergency unit at the hospital, and we quickly began to run out of supplies and much-needed medications." He also stated that several times Marines kept the physicians in the residence building, thereby intentionally prohibiting them from entering the hospital to treat patients.

    "All the time they came in, searched rooms and wandered around," said Dr. Ahmed, while explaining how US troops often entered the hospital in order to search for resistance fighters. Both he and Dr. Abdulla said the US troops never offered any medicine or supplies to assist the hospital when they carried out their incursions. Describing a situation that has occurred in other hospitals, he added, "Most of our patients left the hospital because they were afraid."

    Dr. Abdulla said that one of their ambulance drivers was shot and killed by US snipers while he was attempting to collect the wounded near another clinic inside the city.

    "The major problem we found were the American snipers," said Dr. Rashid, who worked at another clinic in the Jumaria Quarter of Falluja. "We saw them on top of the buildings near the mayor's office."

    Dr. Rashid told of another incident in which a US sniper shot an ambulance driver in the leg. The ambulance driver survived, but a man who came to his rescue was shot by a US sniper and died on the operating table after Dr. Rashid and others had worked to save him. "He was a volunteer working on the ambulance to help collect the wounded," Dr. Rashid said sadly.

    During Truthout's visit to the hospital in May 2004, two ambulances in the parking lot sat with bullet holes in their windshields, while others had bullet holes in their back doors and sides.

    "I remember once we sent an ambulance to evacuate a family that was bombed by an aircraft," said Dr. Abdulla while continuing to speak about the US snipers, "The ambulance was sniped - one of the family died, and three were injured by the firing."

    Neither Dr. Abdulla nor Dr. Rashid said they knew of any medical aid being provided to their hospital or clinics by the US military. On this topic, Dr. Rashid said flatly, "They send only bombs, not medicine."

    Chuwader General Hospital in Sadr City also reported similar findings to Truthout, as did other hospitals throughout Baghdad.

    Dr. Abdul Ali, the ex-chief surgeon at Al-Noman Hospital, admitted that US soldiers had come to the hospital asking for information about resistance fighters. To this he said, "My policy is not to give my patients to the Americans. I deny information for the sake of the patient."

    During an interview in April 2004, he admitted this intrusion occurred fairly regularly and interfered with patients receiving medical treatment. He noted, "Ten days ago this happened - this occurred after people began to come in from Fallujah, even though most of them were children, women and elderly."

    A doctor at Al-Kerkh Hospital, speaking on condition of anonymity, shared a similar experience of the problem that appears to be rampant throughout much of the country: "We hear of Americans removing wounded Iraqis from hospitals. They are always coming here and asking us if we have injured fighters."

    Speaking about the US military raid of the hospital in Afghanistan, UN spokesman Aleem Siddique said he was not aware of the details of the particular incident, but that international law requires the military to avoid operations in medical facilities.

    "The rules are that medical facilities are not combat areas. It's unacceptable for a medical facility to become an area of active combat operations," he said. "The only exception to that under the Geneva Conventions is if a risk is being posed to people."

    "There is the Hippocratic oath," Fange added, "If anyone is wounded, sick or in need of treatment ... if they are a human being, then they are received and treated as they should be by international law."

    These are all indications of a US Empire in decline. Another recent sign of US desperation in Afghanistan was the bombing of two fuel tanker trucks that the Taliban had captured from NATO. US warplanes bombed the vehicles, from which impoverished local villagers were taking free gas, incinerating as many as 150 civilians, according to reports from villagers.

    The United States Empire is following a long line of empires and conquerors that have met their end in Afghanistan. The Median and Persian Empires, Alexander the Great, the Seleucids, the Indo-Greeks, Turks, Mongols, British and Soviets all met the end of their ambitions in Afghanistan.

    And today, the US Empire is on the fast track of its demise. A recent article by Tom Englehardt provides us more key indicators of this:

  • In 2002 there were 5,200 US soldiers in Afghanistan. By December of this year, there will be 68,000.
  • Compared to the same period in 2008, Taliban attacks on coalition forces using Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs) has risen 114 percent.
  • Compared to the same period in 2008, coalition deaths from IED attacks have increased sixfold.
  • Overall Taliban attacks on coalition forces in the first five months of 2009, compared to the same period last year, have increased 59 percent.
  •     Genghis Khan could not hold onto Afghanistan.

        Neither will the United States, particularly when in its desperation to continue its illegal occupation, it tosses aside international law, along with its own Constitution.

    Creative Commons License
    This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





         

    »



    Dahr Jamail, an independent journalist, is the author of "The Will to Resist: Soldiers Who Refuse to Fight in Iraq and Afghanistan," (Haymarket Books, 2009), and "Beyond the Green Zone: Dispatches From an Unembedded Journalist in Occupied Iraq," (Haymarket Books, 2007). Jamail reported from occupied Iraq for nine months as well as from Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Turkey over the last five years.


    Comments

    This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



    A truly disgusting outrage,

    A truly disgusting outrage, what the US military is doing in Afghanistan, and Barack Obama is leading the effort. America will be the next, and most stupid, in line for frustration and failure in that most independent country. Most stupid because it fought against Russia in Afghanistan only 20 years ago, and knows what the situation is. If they think it's a good place to test their tactics, and weapons, it just shows how barbaric they are, and what America is really about. What about Pakistan, boys? Afghanistan is a parking lot, Iraq is almost a parking lot. Are you looking for something to do with all that hardware?


    I voted for Obama because I

    I voted for Obama because I thought McCain was too war like. Boy was I along with 1,000,000’s of people mistaken. My thought is this, “Who is really running this country?” It’s certainly not our president.


    Those tricky Taliban -

    Those tricky Taliban - posing as civilian patients in Afghan hospitals, what will they think of next! And to pick a hospital run by wonderful, peace-loving Swedes, I mean really! No-so-wonderful Swedes recently killed eight suspected Taliban. One can only hope that the good hospital Swedes save more lives than the bad killer Swedes take. And that somebody is keeping track of this sort of thing. Peter Edler, member Swedish Writers Union, Stockholm


    It seems the United States

    It seems the United States are in the same position as a cornered rat, and are behaving as such.


    The truly loyal opposition,

    The truly loyal opposition, not the nut cases and down-with-anything-Obama Repugnicans, MUST stand up and tell DULY ELECTED President Obama to get out of Iraq and Afghanistan. A reading of history should tell him he does not want another fiasco. George and the big Dick lied us into Iraq. We went in, created the rat's nest that has encouraged terrorism's growth, and now are mired in a conflict that enriches the war mongers, impoverishes America, and daily feeds anti-American sentiments around the globe. ENOUGH!> GET OUT!


    Anonymous, the people may be

    Anonymous, the people may be independent, but the country itself has always had tribes vying with each other for space. The real problem for us is, no matter the cost to all, which always exists in war, what the heck are we doing there? The title of this article is a bit misleading, for its thesis is What A Drag It Is [for Everyone] To Be There. I was looking for some history, some "into the Valley of Death Rode the 40,000" analogies. On that count, it may be true that the Soviet Union went there to die, but I don't think it was where the British Empire went to die. Britain, after a bloody reign of denial, got to die peacefully in bed with India at its side.We should be so lucky.


    Reason 'Afghanistan is the

    Reason 'Afghanistan is the place where empires go to die' is because by the time they get such involved with Afghanistan, these empires have lost their moral compass: they would have refused long ago to be there for their reasons or conditions, they would not intrude to bring continual harm to a country. The ONLY WAY TO POSSIIBLY REVERSE THIS TREND IS TO RESTORE to Afghnaistan its lands south of the Durand Line of 1896--as done for Israel-- drawn whimsically & arbitrarily by the British at the height of their power-wielding-empire. Once again, the sons--& brothers&cousins--of the country will never end. & it should not. The REASON the British did this--goes to moral compass--is they spitefully pitted the tribes against each other so they could reign supreme over these feudal entities.


    Storm Troopers and Nazi

    Storm Troopers and Nazi policy. This same policy and tactic was used by the Nazi military and SS Troops during WWII on the hospitals and clinics during the Nazi occupation of Europe including France, Italy, Poland, Spain, Greece Belgium, Holland etc, etc.. Now the USA uses it and no one objects?? How can this be possible? Look around you very closely and be aware!


    As an ex-marine I'm sickened

    As an ex-marine I'm sickened to hear of marines in Afghanistan carrying out these horrible actions. Any marine commander on the ground absolutely knows the rules of war, (yes there are written rules), and can refuse an illegal order no matter what level it originates from. I'm hoping more marine and army officers and non-commissioned officers will begin to act within their legal rights and refuse or refuse to give illegal orders. Most of the world used to look up to us because of our system of laws and adherence to them. No longer.


    We are barbarians,

    We are barbarians, crusaders, mercenaries, thugs, tortures, assassins, murders, human rights abusers. We will pay a heavy, heavy price for this, beyond the price of a few thousand U.S. soldiers coming back in bags and limbless in wheel chairs. The people's patience is not eternal. Memory is long when one's homes and wedding parties are bombed and when hospitals are invaded. But where really is the outrage? In my city of metropolitan area of 500,000 people there are perhaps a handful of car signs referring to U.S. out of Iraq. I see no protests. I hear no anti-war songs. Are we soul-dead? U.S. out of Iraq and Afghanistan and Colombia NOW!


    Don't say that Barack Obama

    Don't say that Barack Obama is leading the effort since most of this falls on the watch of the previous administration and Obama is trying to clean up all their dirty work. However, I fully agree and will forward this to the Obama Administration so they can read it although I assume they already know and are trying to do something about it within the Military. And yes, it is atrocious what is happening in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and the whole World. Ike, our last good Republican President, warned about the Military Industrial Complex in his farewell address and the Bush/Cheney Administration allowed torture and anything goes. We are seeing the results.


    Marjorie Cohn, president of

    Marjorie Cohn, president of the National Lawyers Guild, Thomas Jefferson School of law professor, author and TRUTHOUT contributor states that: "The Taliban did not attack us on 9/11. Nineteen men - 15 from Saudi Arabia - did..." So how is it that an educated and intelligent academic professional publicly states that she buys the phony "official" story of 9/11? Please, Marjorie, read at least "The Road to 9/11" by Peter Dale Scott or "The New Pearl Harbor Revisited" by David Ray Griffin. It will open your eyes and cast a new perspective on Afghanistan.


    A former CIA official

    A former CIA official pointed out yesterday that the basic premise for why we're in Afghanistan is flawed: even if al Qaida could set up training camps there again, that would not be an imminent threat to the US. He pointed out that the 911 plotters trained in apartments in Germany and on the civilian airfields in Florida, not in Afghanistan. I'm beginning to think, though, that Obama can't get out of there, because the military would try to kill him if he did. The only interests lobbying for more troops there are the military, the Republicans (and their media) and defense contractors somewhat less overtly. The overwhelming public sentiment is to get out, or at least not to send more troops in. Obama is a poltical animal; he knows the resistance to more troops. If he sends them, I doubt it's because he's convinced of the rightness of that strategy, but more because he has to keep the military at his back. Unfortunately, the US is now very much like Tojo's Japan, where the military call the shots and the impotent civilian government just has to go along. So, the question is: why Afghanistan? Because it offers a good prospect for larger budgets and more fancy hardware? As for raiding hospitals, that ain't all: I recall that there were bombings of them in the past.


    It helps to have hearts and

    It helps to have hearts and minds embodied if they are to be won at all. Afghanistan will endure yet another assault as it has for centuries. I just hate to keep seeing the country used as a proxy and the people as collateral damage, all the while publicly touting their salvation. Even stoning is not this cruel.


    While I, like many other

    While I, like many other respondents, deplore the deaths of Afghan civilians and believe that our invasion of Afghanistan was premature and certainly not the solution to our Al Qaeda problem, I don't think that an abrupt withdrawal of NATO forces at this stage is in the best interests of the Afghan people, particularly women. Are we going to abandon them once again, the way we did in 1989? I think we have a responsibility to the Afghan people to leave them with a functioning state - not a perfect democracy, but at least a more stable structure and greater security than they now enjoy. I'm willing to give the troop increase and new military strategy a chance to work before we just cut and run. I understand that the administration is looking to beef up the civilian component of our presence. I hope it works.


    If you haven't read '1984'

    If you haven't read '1984' you ought to. Then realize this was written in 1948. Orwell didn't dream this stuff up, people in the communist party told him of plans to infiltrate and break America up. The four parts were education, religion, science, and politics. Schools are dumbed down, religions are coming 'together' as one. Science is distorted to be used by the corporations for money. Politics? In order to have two parties you must have two different policies, we don't. We are only led to believe have two parties, keeps us thinking we have democracy. It is all the same no matter who is in office. Nothing makes sense anymore and that is by design. It is all 'double speak', And if you are confused or depressed take your anti-depression, or your viagra. Realize this 'redistribution' is among the world, not America. The global banking cartel is splitting up the goods, and soon the physical property. The Army National Guard site is now hiring 'Internment / Relocation Specialist', they need 67,000. If you are hungry there is a job for you. (go to there site if you need to check). When people are hungry they will work for the destroyers. And people are getting becoming hungry and homeless! It is all by design. How else could all the dots connect from 1948- 1984-2009-.. Why can things pass without elected officials being allowed to even read them? Wake up. check the sites, MAJOR changes things put into place with false flag 9-11 architects and engineers for 911 truth, firefighters for 911 truth.org, pilots for 911 truth.


    This war is not so much

    This war is not so much about Al Qaeda or Afghanistan as it is keeping the military-industrial complex going. If this conflict miraculously "ended" tomorrow some new threat would soon require attention elsewhere. The war budget & lobby keep too many rich people rich and this will always remain so until American citizens get out from behind their computer screens & take to the streets to elicit real change...


    The mistake evryone is

    The mistake evryone is making is to assume that winning any of these wars was the point they start them.


    Main Reason: Pipeline(oil)

    Main Reason: Pipeline(oil) and Drugs for the elite to wage war, global empire building. We must defend against the genocide of humanity: over there and here at home. The battle at home is the swine flu vaccine: it is the genocide of all, for the elite to have profits and control for their new world order. We need our troops home for protection, their oath is to protect "us" from foreign and domestic warfare. Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, etc.. never attack us on our shores. The attack came from within.


    We need to show unwavering

    We need to show unwavering support of our US military. We must not forget nor forgive what has been happening since 1979 with Islamic-fundalsim. Without relentless pursuit of those that are responsible how are we to have a sense of justice? American's will have to face the fact that war is ugly, people will die, good and bad, that is tragic, that is life. I wonder, if many of you would've supported the US during WW2 and its mass bombing campaign on Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan? Would you have questioned our motives and tactics? Politics? When will the cowering end?


    I can't imagine a smart guy

    I can't imagine a smart guy like Obabma not knowing that, historically, it is folly to send a big army into Afghanistan. There have to be other forces at work.


    Definitely an excellent and

    Definitely an excellent and important article!


    Orwell's world projections

    Orwell's world projections are in the making and almost completed. Endless war for the profit of a few pigs in the Animal Farm.


    Afghanistan is and has

    Afghanistan is and has always been the graveyard of foreign empires. To be honest with those who today see the beginning of the end of another failed occupation, it was written in the sky above Kabul before the 2001 invasion: "Another Failed Zombie on the Way" (approximate translation).... The same causes produce the same effects!


    Opium is why we are in

    Opium is why we are in Afghanistan, the CIA runs it, and life here in America is getting worse year by year... I don't blame Obama, just us for believing he could make a difference.


    The elephant in the room is

    The elephant in the room is 9/11. If we assume that The Dick Chenney had nothing to do with 9/11 and that sick men on dialysis machines living in caves carried out the attack, then we go down the road of the stupidly absurd and cross over to the disgustingly grotesque when our arrogance tries to soften the blow of our leaders and military being anything less than the worst criminals in human history. But we are an immoral people dumbed down by an equally criminal fascist media and driven into fundamental cowardice by our militarized police-state society. This is an incapacitating mental illness that is causing our decline, rooted in racism, sexism and imperialism.


    Let's not forget we are

    Let's not forget we are still stuck in Iraq and our military presence in the middle east still attacks Pakistan and Somolia and anywhere else we feel like attacking. There should be a debate over whether we can AFFORD to stay in the middle east, which is costing us at least as twice as much as healthcare would.


    Thanks for the law from the

    Thanks for the law from the U.N. Chater. I was looking for that! Good research.


    We need to line up all our

    We need to line up all our enemies for a Swine Flu shot instead of our citizens...that should create a lot of good will.


    USA government and

    USA government and industrial military complex two sides of the same coin. Murder INC!


    I found a good quote from

    I found a good quote from Obama's speech for the U.N., in which he called for a new era of engagement with the world. "Those who used to chastise Americn for acting alone in the world can not now stand by and wait for America to solve the world's problems alone," the president said.


    http://www.CAMMMO.org

    http://www.CAMMMO.org



    America is the new Fourth

    America is the new Fourth Reich.

    Starting with the obvious false flag attacks of 911 and The Reichstag and The Enabling Act and The Patriot Act.

    The parallels are off the charts and the rest of the planet sees it.

    America has been turned into a force for evil and it's never been this apparent.

    It's sad to see my great neighbors destroyed by design.

    The bankers and Wall Street are AL QAEDA and need to be treated as such.

    There are the robber barons and then the rest of us.



    erbjudanden intersport

    qdutxy tviwdn srdlbn erbjudanden yasuragi bbvdjk zyppdg bkxnew

    snunbw yrfakb wndchp gratis vertalen van nederlands naar engels ccnfkk aisxir xeuxoq

    ofbeka dvhsgc ebreal http://www.gamesforhealth.org/wiki/wikka.php?wakka=GratisErbjudanden - gratis wallpapers - axynzu jwnukv zwgovb



    buy viagra brand cialis

    lr06 http://azithromycinb.net/#91kq buy cheap zithromax azithromycinb.net online without a prescription buy zithromax ds04 http://sildenafilb.net/#qo11 sildenafilb.net www.sildenafilb.net buy viagra in rome



    cialis andorra precio

    dl38 http://viagra-de.net/#00zp25 hirschhausen viagra qr87 http://cialis-espana.net/#ie36 cialis 20 mg generico op08 http://acheterviagracialis.net/#oz56 prix generique cialis



    levitra tadalafil 20 mg

    if12 http://viagra-de.net/#78zj91 acm viagra



    cialis cheap generic

    nv27 http://instantpaydayloansameri.pro/#m08o ctp payday advance www.instantpaydayloansameri.pro payday loans florida law



    found that this

    Yes, correctly.
    . http://cheap-viagra-generic.com/#3362 - cheap viagra. has n't seen this
    viagra cheap viagra
    .



    tpibga

    sueyphyu



    kbzdtkj

    gaiebthf



    jjwbqp

    nazbzgjf



    YkDZPGwTESYjRP

    4zT4sO twnlehiemppw, [url=http://acolyuqrxmij.com/]acolyuqrxmij[/url], [link=http://wjwpjfdujnmx.com/]wjwpjfdujnmx[/link], http://kebtgwlkrbpa.com/