"We Made Them Millions, and They Complain About Insurance"

by: David Bacon, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

"We Made Them Millions, and They Complain About Insurance"
Lupe Chavez with her family. (Photo: David Bacon)

    Lupe Chavez, a housekeeper at the San Francisco Hilton, tells her story to David Bacon.

    San Francisco - I was born in Santa Tecla, near San Salvador. My father was a big-rig driver and my mother was a stay at home mom. We had a big family - four brothers and two sisters. When I was old enough, I worked in the Armando Araujo coffee and soap factory. We Salvadoreños are hard-working people.

    From the time I was 12, my aunts took me with them whenever they had a demonstration. They were teachers, and taught me that we have to fight for what we need, because that's the only way to achieve anything. Even before the war, it was dangerous to be involved with a union. After the war started, many died protesting.

    I was 19 years old when I came to the US to care for an elderly woman. My family was very poor and when the opportunity came I didn't hesitate. The woman eventually returned to El Salvador, but I stayed on with her family. I thought I was going to earn money and help my family, but they didn't pay me for an entire year. They told me I had to repay the transportation fee and all the money they'd spent on me.

    A friend of my grandmother told me I was being treated as a slave. She said she'd rescue me, so I found my passport where they'd hidden it, grabbed my bag and left. But my rescuer took me to another home, to care of another elderly woman. They hardly paid me anything - just $100 a month. When I said I wanted to go to school, they told me immigration officers would get me.

    Finally I met my husband - a carpenter who'd come to put in new windows. He rescued me and we got married. That was 1974, and we've been married ever since. When I married him, I no longer felt like a slave.

    I already had a Social Security number - it wasn't so hard to get a number back then - and, in 1986, I got my green card through the amnesty. I brought my brothers here, too, but I told them that they would never suffer like I did.

    In those years, we could live in San Francisco because the rent was only $150 for a one-bedroom apartment. Now, living in San Francisco is almost impossible, and we moved to the East Bay.

    After my first daughter was three, I told my husband I wanted to go back to work. I found good daycare and applied at the Hilton. They hired me right away as a housekeeper, the same job I've been doing for 29 years.

    Since I've been here for so long, I work on only one floor. It's a very big hotel, with three buildings. At the beginning of the day, I fill my cart with new linens, towels, pens, and everything I'll need. We carry everything from toilet paper to a vacuum cleaner, and the cart easily weighs 100 pounds.

    When I get to a room, I first organize the hangers in the closet, and make sure it has one pillow and blanket. Then, I empty the garbage cans and make the beds. I continue on to the bathroom, clean the tub and toilet, and restock the toilet paper, towels and Kleenex. I clean the mirror, sink and counter - they have to be spotless. It's hard work to clean the mirrors and shower doors because you have to stretch so much to do it.

Lupe Chavez with her family.

Lupe Chavez. (Photo: David Bacon)

    Making the beds is backbreaking because they're a lot larger now and you have to lift up the mattress. You have to put three sheets on - the fitted sheet, flat sheet and down comforter. Work wasn't as hard when I first started there because the beds were small with one pillow per bed. Now, beds are bigger and some have four pillows. Sometimes guests even ask for four more.

    They switched accessories from plastic to silver, which weigh a lot more. We have to lift the ice bucket with both hands to clean it with Windex, soap or sometimes hot water. The garbage cans are also silver. They warn us that they don't want any fingerprints on them, and managers follow us into the rooms to check. It takes an extra half an hour everyday just to clean the silver accessories.

    We have to finish all 14 assigned rooms by the end of the day. Some of us don't go on breaks or take shorter lunch breaks in order to finish. Recently, I had a room with a big family, but in a room with only one bed. I wasted an extra 40 minutes because the room was so messy. At the end of the day, I was exhausted. When I got home, I just wanted to sleep.

    Like it or not, there is pressure to have the room spotless. I've seen other workers weep because the job is so hard. It's never good enough and managers want more. I've heard them tell housekeepers that they came to the US to work, so they should work harder. They call them crybabies. I tell them it's not right to make women cry - it just makes it harder to do the work. Because I've been there for so long and I'm very outspoken, they don't follow me around, but I feel pressured too.

    In the long run, you end up with permanent problems working this way. I now have to wear a brace on my arm. When I don't have it on, my arms hurt tremendously. I had to go on disability because my tendons hurt so much. When I returned to work, I couldn't taken a morning or afternoon break because my legs hurt too much for me to walk down to the break room. I simply stayed up on the floor.

    My hands tingle and ache, and my fingers go numb. Sometimes, my arms start to hurt during the night and I can't sleep. The pain starts about 3 AM and I can't stand it. The doctor said I have carpal tunnel syndrome and gave me two braces, one for each hand. My hands now feel better, but I still use them during the day. I take a Motrin pill before leaving for work in the morning and another one in the afternoon and before going to bed. I don't want to be dependent on them, but it's hard. My doctor told me many housekeepers have the same problem. It's very difficult to work in pain. It's something I cannot get used to.

    I have to continue working because I need the insurance. If I don't work, I'm not accumulating hours and my insurance stops. I had to return to work because I had no insurance left. My husband, daughter and myself depend on it. My daughter's 19, and she needs medical checkups and to go to the dentist. My husband has high blood pressure and clogged arteries so he needs expensive medication daily.

    My back and knees hurt from moving the heavy cart every day. I don't want to get even more injured than I already am because I'll be replaced. There are many workers still working with disabilities right now. It's like a circus in there when we're changing into uniforms. We all smell like Bengay and have braces all over. We all have medical conditions. They say it's the handicap room, because we're all injured.

    With the union, at least we feel we have someone who will back us up. I was suspended a few years ago. The manager was upset because I had criticized her during a meeting. The other workers were in an uproar. My union representative told the general manager they were going to protest in the lobby. They called me that afternoon to say I could return to work the next morning. We all fight for each other.

    Medical insurance is the most important issue for us this year. They're talking of increasing the hours needed to qualify for health benefits. That is what we're trying to avoid. I just have a few years left until I can retire. I'm lost my health at the hotel, and all they think about is money. We made them millions of dollars, and they complain about paying insurance.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



David Bacon is a writer and photographer. His new book, "Illegal People - How Globalization Creates Migration and Criminalizes Immigrants," was just published by Beacon Press. His photographs and stories can be found at http://dbacon.igc.org.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



I wrk in the catering field,

I wrk in the catering field, and it's an hard work, but when I saw the kitchen worker I feel they working so hard, unbelievable hard and for little money. I truly understand this woman.


Another strong case for both

Another strong case for both union card check and universal health care legislation. It's heartbreaking to hear this hardworking woman's story. She has worked harder than any CEO, and yet the ruling elite is still trying to wring a few more dollars out of her meager compensation. Is there any fairness in our current system of capitalism on steroids?


This wonderful lady, who has

This wonderful lady, who has worked so hard to support her family, has a work ethic and family values ethos that should be the envy of those right wingers who espouse family values as their guiding philosophy. Yet, in fact, the right (let's not confuse them with conservatives..as in conservative values) and the insurance behemoths they cater to, is not interested in hard working Americans like Lupe. Add to this that there is economic discrimination against persons like Lupe since she is hispanic and maybe 'illegal'. We all know that tacit employment of illegal aliens is quietly promoted by the wealthy as a source of inexpensive labor. To digress a little, readers may be aware of more of our elderly working in super markets and fast food restaurants, as they are also becoming another source of inexpensive labor as retirement funds have lost so much value in the past several years. This is no accident, the short term profiteers can project the long term benefits of a society rendered wholly dependent upon the hand outs of the corporate entities. Lupe and her wonderful children should be proud and savoring the fruits of their hard work, not wondering if they will financially survive Lupe and her husbands physical ailments resulting from their hard work and constant worries.


I see allot of this where I

I see allot of this where I live. It is demeaning, and I am ashamed to be white because of it. Once had a spanish girlfriend. and I was treated more like family than by my own. A long time ago, hispanic people had set up civic centers to help each other out. It is a great example of community. Maybe we should not be so quick to judge, or repeat the lies of the news, or the incorrect stories of hate passed down by our parents. Just maybe, us white people may learn a thing or two about acting more human with one another. I can not think of a finer example, then the hispanic people I have met in my city. To hate another, is to hate yourself, and me. We all live on this Earth, and I would rather spend my time working on a future involving a mutually beneficial relationship.


Most successful US companies

Most successful US companies treat their employees like trash, folks tolerate abuse out of fear. It's across the spectrum, from brutal, dangerous work in meat packing plants to abusive white collar hell holes - employees have no rights in this country.


I Am An Ex Hospitality

I Am An Ex Hospitality Worker. Anyone who has worked in the hospitality (hotel) industry is well aware that there is NOTHING out of the ordinary about this woman's story. Hotels slave-drive the hell out of people I am sad to say- and the biggest most successful chains are the hardest on their workers. In the United States- I am ashamed to say- those who speak out the loudest and in the most hateful way in regards to immigrant workers are the quickest to hire them under predatory circumstances- and use them up for as long as they can in order to profit from them- without regard to their health or worth as human beings.


Beautiful article. Such a

Beautiful article. Such a small story brings home the wrongness of the capitalist enterprise. At least the wrongness without strong labor checks and balances. People will be happy to work at difficult, poor-paying jobs, making the rich richer as long as there is some recognition of the work they do and some decent compensation. But the rich, sadly, don't feel rich and are ever in a bind about how to keep it all. Eventually there will be no apples left to fill the whole pie they're going for. and rich people will start sinking into the pit of the dying middle class. Watch me now! It's called Trickle Up Poverty!


Sad, but not the whole

Sad, but not the whole story. My father is a "white" born in American citizen who was born dirt poor in Louisiana, helped invade the beaches at Normandy, came back to no job, ended up working in a factory hand-lifting about 3 tons per day of materials on his bsck. had no union, worked 6 days a week for about $8 an hour, had to work until he was 67, was crippled by his work, etc. Being a wage slave is NOT limited to being an immigrant, a woman, Latina, etc. It's for everybody except the elites. Another thing is, people choose to have children, even when they are poor. Then they complain that they are poor. it is a sad fact of Latin America that the Pope and others brainwashed people into believing that having lots of babies was God's will. But the earth cannot support all the babies, and neither can capitalism. This article is heart-rending and it's classic liberal journalism, but it doesn't tell the whole story. The bottom line is that the earth cannot support all humans or their desires for Western lifestyles. I feel bad for all exploited people, but in many cases, they are also at fault for their own situation. And nobody is writing articles about my poor dad either. He is as much of not more of a victim of this lady in the article!!


i am not clear what the

i am not clear what the message is? You work, you support yourself, what else do you want? She has a choice, stop working. All you bleeding hearts, why dont you get her address and pay her for nothing and provide her with a doctor you pay for. But keep me away from her and my money shouldnt go to help her cause i dont know her, i have my own family to support. GET OFF MY BACK and stop it with the false analogies. Tears from your eyes should not be connected to money in my pocket.


My wife is a relative low

My wife is a relative low level manager in the cubicles of a large company. A short while ago she was required to attend a meeting on the subject of how the company would handle things if workers tried to unionize. My wife and other managers like her were told they might have to go work in the factory if there was a picket line there. Several means of discouraging people from unionizing were also mentioned. More recently, the company held a teleconference about the health care reform bill. Anti reform lies were told. Pre-written letters to legislators urging them to vote against "this and any future bills" were available which contained more lies. Corporations do NOT want to be regulated. They do NOT want to be socially responsible. They do NOT want to treat their employees decently. Corporations MUST be stopped in their never ending pursuit of profit or they will destroy us all.


Sen Baucus and his campaign

Sen Baucus and his campaign contributors don't see it that way. I guess that's because they're all pious Christian Republicans. But close to home --- why can't the "value voters" and the more conservative members of the middle class see how BaucusCare is really screwing over the Middle Class?


Today I read on CNN.com that

Today I read on CNN.com that 45,000 Americans die each year for lack of health care. If this many people were to die on the battlefield people would be out in the streets like we were during the Vietnam war. What is the difference? I believe we need to take health care out of the hands of insurance companies AND employers. The "and employers" is something I have not heard about from anyone on the left or the right. This simple step (Universal Coverage) would allow companies to be free of the overhead of health care and hopefully put more money back into the paychecks of the workers. (ha ha, with OVERSIGHT that is!) Companies have been forcing labor to accept pay DECREASES for years and blaming it on the high cost of health care insurance for their workers. This should not be a "right," "left," "liberal," or "conservative" issue. It should be what it truly is: a Human Rights issue. The right to "LIFE," liberty and the pursuite... " Flora MacColl - Hawthorne, Florida


@weisscrow: you aren't clear

@weisscrow: you aren't clear what the message is?? Don't worry, you'll hear it loud and clear someday, when the tears in YOUR eyes aren't met with the same cavalier attitude ("tears from your eyes should not be connected to money in my pocket" - you put Ebeneezer Scrooge to shame). Everyone gets old, everyone becomes infirm. Some people must work physically demanding jobs - and even those who sit in an office all day are subject to carpal tunnel, cataracts, ergonomic injuries, etc. - and their joints, tendons and muscles can't handle repetitive strain without pain and breaking down. And obviously, the woman in this article - having worked at this job for THREE DECADES - you did catch that, right? - has suffered physically because of the type of work it requires. The MESSAGE, sir or madam, is that our present system of healthcare - in which one's ability to receive quality medical care is hinged upon one's ability to work, and not everyone's employer offers it, has a policy that's adequate, or gives a damn about workers - is inadequate to the needs of many of our citizens, this woman included. The MESSAGE, and as someone with your "own family to support," I'm shocked you haven't thought of it before now, is that you may have health insurance through your job now, or even be covered under your partner's policy - but if one or the other of you becomes disabled, unemployed, etc., your only options right now will be COBRA (which is, in case you don't know, spectacularly expensive), private health insurance (even more expensive, and pray you don't need it after the age of 35 or 40, or that you don't have problems they can use to reject you), or public assistance (the ER, which taxpayers subsidize at ever-mushrooming cost). The MESSAGE, you dear, sweet, tender-hearted weisscrow, is that even an humble housemaid is a human being, just like the lord of the manor in which she serves. People like you make me so freakin' angry - I don't know if you're intentionally cruel or intentionally clueless, but you sure seem intentionally nasty, and I can only hope you're not a boss somewhere. Perhaps Saul on the road to Tarsus could be an inspiration to you: you truly need an epiphany. Until then, please keep your meanspiritedness to yourself... it's nauseating.


"Values voters" want to

"Values voters" want to legislate your values and mine. But, they don't want anybody telling them that caring about their neighbor and their neighbor's health care is a good old-fashioned Christian value.


yup, hard work is hard

yup, hard work is hard work....it takes a toll on ya...making beds and washing mirrors may be considered hard, but, in my life's experience, it's cake.


This lady should go back to

This lady should go back to her doctor, for there are other good treatments for carpal tunnel. Weight loss may help (by reducing pressure on the nerve in the wrist ) as well as cortisone injections, possibly acupuncture and as a last resort: surgery


To Weisscrow - Did you read

To Weisscrow - Did you read this woman's story at all? Never did she ask for a hand out from you or the public or taxpayers. She only spoke of how the hotel owners and managers treated their workers and how little the workers got in return. Weisscrow, I really don't know where you got the idea this woman and others like her were trying to take money from you. She's thankful that a union came in and fought for some basic rights and respect for people who work hard, are exploited and earn little. She doesn't want a handout.


Weisscrow, I'm not religious

Weisscrow, I'm not religious at all, and don't really believe in the myth of an afterlife. But should I be mistaken, I sincerely hope there's a special place in Hell for you and your ilk! Unfortunately, MY taxes make possible for you to make whatever money you make -- that is, if you have a legitimate/legal source of income; MY government creates the conditions for you to have/own whatever you own; MY community supports, in some way, your business/profession by paying for your goods or "services"; the Constitution of MY country sets forth, in its first ten amendments, certain inalienable rights that are guaranteed to all citizens and legal residents, including you, even if you don't deserve them nor honor those rights for anyone but yourself. Basic human empathy would honor this woman and be touched by her story. Your impotent invective notwithstanding, she deserves much better, as do all people, everywhere. Now kindly stop breathing MY air, and taking up space on MY planet. You have a date with Beelzebub!


"Did [Weisscrow] read this

"Did [Weisscrow] read this woman's story at all?" Short answer: no. Long answer: no, probably because he doesn't believe anyone who commits the sins of being Latin, female AND poor can have a story worth hearing. This has been another inciting exstallment of "Snappy Answers to Rhetorical Questions Asked of Right-Wingers".


When I read these comments

When I read these comments from David "...I feel bad for all exploited people, but in many cases, they are also at fault for their own situation. ..." I was appalled. This is what my father and many others fought against in the war; selective breeding is a NAZI theorem, long discredited. What does this person advocate, castration? That only those with funds are able to breed? The moral judgement of a nation is predicated on it's treatment of its poor and vulnerable. This is perhaps why your president wants to include the poor in a comprehensive health scheme. If you are unable and unwilling to make provision for your weakest citizens, you have no merit, and you cannot hope to ever be anything but a nation of slave workers and slave employers. The US is bigger than this. but it requires, apparently a change in heart from all those that believe the adage"I'm all right Jack!" and then complain the government isn't doing enough. SHAME, SHAME, SHAME


To the poster who remarked

To the poster who remarked that if 45,000 died on a battlefield, we would be up in arms: Actually the 45,000 is the most conservative of all estimates..some are double that number. That having been said, look at the uproar over 9/11 and how many were killed? The country went hysterical..and yet when we kill our own, it is business as usual.


History repeats itself. Be

History repeats itself. Be it Weisscrow vs. Lupe, Colonial Brits vs. Revolutionary Americans, FOX vs. "normal" news, Cesears vs. Rome, Scrooge vs. Tiny Tim, or the Insurance debate... step back and look throughout history. Consequences are evident when one group in society puts basic moral values aside w/decisions that affect the well-being of another group in their society. How scary is it that the Romans before their fall were also over-taxing their citizens to pay for mercs w/out whom they couldn't continue unnecessary wars? Just b/c for the moment U.S. taxpayers are too apathetic, unaware, or content w/typing away on forums to do anything, this doesn't mean a remedy isn't on its way. History repeats itself.


Forgot her background, she's

Forgot her background, she's a legal American worker, and a hard working one at that. And simply in the same trap so many working poor are: slowly injuring themselves on brutal jobs because they can't afford not to. There are plenty of non Hispanic folks/"native born" (read: white) Americans in same boat, I assure you. Even college educated. Our system is broken. We need universal health care, and we need to de-couple it from our employment. To management, we are all disposable. Just watch. (And leave a large tip for the maid, meanwhile).


Wow ... people like

Wow ... people like weisscrow are sadly indicative of the selfish, bitter, frothing-at-the mouth right-wing movement that's so loud in the country lately. As others pointed out so clearly, she's not asking for ANYTHING from your self-centered behind. Only a fair shake from a huge, multi-national corporation who, despite the recession, continues to profit handsomely and is still more than able to cover their employees health care costs. I would call this case a no-brainer, but I guess I can't because some without brains obviously don't get it.


Isn't it time to insist that

Isn't it time to insist that our "leaders" give up any but the kind of insurance and health care that Lupe Lopez gets. Until Senators and Representatives are required to live with the same opportunities in health care for themselves and their families that the poorest of their poor constituents get, we'll not have true reform. enough, boys and girls of the Congress. And out with you unless you begin to serve the needs of the country. And shame on you if you incite actions against the best interest of the country.


designer boutiques online

designer bags online suprisely NMHauJzz http://designeronlinestor.blogcindario.com/



burberry outlet store

you love this? burberry swimwear online WdFsmXpj http://www.burberryoutlet--online.com/



sHunHSBxuBRnEftUlP

hf9wEc gvfazvqztqeg, [url=http://suybyfahwyjo.com/]suybyfahwyjo[/url], [link=http://hmjczzhdvqov.com/]hmjczzhdvqov[/link], http://nvodtpuzrocr.com/



yrRbqDQtXzSqAmw

BBd2Ue ubvyirxwywvr, [url=http://fkjzswoeinil.com/]fkjzswoeinil[/url], [link=http://avjdxewhnzzu.com/]avjdxewhnzzu[/link], http://vgwitgicwmxi.com/



mBUMidEhNluN

hzopdC iomnrzydutcl, [url=http://tdpzxupcnxab.com/]tdpzxupcnxab[/url], [link=http://uapewmqufxwe.com/]uapewmqufxwe[/link], http://ivtykqeyrfes.com/