Stop the Raids in the First 100 Days

by: David Bacon, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

Stop the Raids in the First 100 Days
Citizens of Postville, Iowa, march for immigrant and worker rights after a federal raid of the Agriprocessors meat-packing plant resulted in the arrest of 388 workers. (Photo: AP)

    The first of the 388 workers arrested in the immigration raid on the Agriprocessors meatpacking plant in Postville, Iowa, were deported last week, having spent five months in federal prison. Their crime? Giving a bad Social Security number to the company to get hired. Among them will be a young man who had his eyes covered with duct tape by a supervisor on the line, who then beat him with a meathook. The supervisor is still on the job.

    Postville was one of the many recent immigration raids leading to criminal charges and deportations for thousands of people. Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff calls this "closing the back door." Meanwhile, his department seeks to "open the front door" by establishing new guest worker programs called "close to slavery" by the Southern Poverty Law Center.

    Something is clearly wrong with the priorities of immigration enforcement. Hungry and desperate workers go to jail and get deported. The government protects employers and seeks to turn a family-based immigration system into their managed labor supply. Yet national political campaigns say less and less about it. Immigrant Latino and Asian communities feel increasingly afraid and frustrated. Politicians want their votes, but avoid talking about the rising wave of arrests, imprisonment and deportations.

    This month, national demonstrations across the nation are protesting the silence, asking candidates to speak out. Immigrant communities expect a new deal from a new administration, especially from Democrats. They want a new president to take swift and decisive action to give human rights a priority over fear, and recognize immigrants as people, not just a source of cheap labor.

    In its first 100 days, a new administration could take these simple steps to benefit immigrants and working families:

• Stop Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from seeking serious federal criminal charges, with incarceration in privately run prisons, for lacking papers or for bad Social Security numbers.

• Stop raiding workplaces, especially where workers are trying to organize unions or enforce wage and hour laws. This would help all workers, not just immigrants, to raise low wages.

• Double the paltry 742 federal inspectors responsible for all US wage and hour violations, and focus on industries where immigrants are concentrated. The National Labor Relations Board could target employers who use immigration threats to violate union rights.

• Halt community sweeps, where agents use warrants for one or two people to detain and deport dozens of others. End the government's campaign to repeal local sanctuary ordinances, and to drag local law enforcement into immigration raids.

• Allow all workers to apply for a Social Security number and pay legally into the system that benefits everyone. Social Security numbers should be used for their true purpose - paying retirement and disability benefits - not to fire immigrants from their jobs and send them to prison.

• Reestablish worker protections ended under Bush on existing guest worker programs, force employers to hire domestically first, and decertify any contractor guilty of labor violations.

• Restore human rights in border communities, stop construction of the border wall between the US and Mexico, and disband the Operation Streamline federal court, where scores of young border crossers are sent to prison in chains every day.

    After the first 100 days, Democrats will have to decide what reforms to bring before Congress, and when. Some would delay action for a year or more. But the US Chamber of Commerce and dozens of trade groups will not sit on their hands. They have been pushing for years for big guest worker programs, more raids and enforcement, and a weak legalization program. Many immigrant and labor rights activists want an alternative, and advocate three steps toward a more progressive reform:

1. A moratorium on raids, while protecting human and labor rights, in the first 100 days.

2. Introduce a bill to give green card visas to the undocumented, and clear up the backlog of people already waiting for them. If more visas are more easily available abroad, people won't have to cross the border without them. That bill should also create jobs in unemployed communities, repeal employer sanctions laws that make work a crime for immigrants, and pass labor law reform to protect workers' rights. Guest worker programs with a record of abuse should be ended, as they were in 1964.

3. Change trade policy and renegotiate agreements like NAFTA, so they stop causing poverty and uprooting communities, making migration peoples' only alternative for survival. Defeat new trade agreements with countries like Colombia, which will cause job loss in the US and spread low wages, labor violations and displacement abroad. US tax dollars, instead of being spent on war in Iraq, could expand rural credit, education and healthcare in Mexico and other countries, easing the pressure behind migration.

    There is a common ground between immigrants, African-Americans and other communities of color, unions, churches, civil rights organizations and working families generally. Legalization and immigrant rights, tied to guaranteeing jobs for all working families, can bring people together. All workers, including immigrants, need the right to organize and enforce labor standards - the same goal sought by unions in the Employee Free Choice Act. Changing trade policy will benefit working class communities in the US, while helping the families of immigrants back home from Oaxaca to El Salvador.

    The diverse communities who need these reforms can and will find ways to seek them together. In fact, if Barack Obama and a larger Democratic majority in Congress gain office in November, they will owe their victory to this coalition.

    After the election, this same coalition will need jobs and rights. But immigrant workers are going to jail now. The wave of raids continues to divide families, even as candidates hold rallies and ask for votes. In Los Angeles' Placita Olvera, activists have begun a hunger strike to stop the deportations. Marches and demonstrations are making the same point from coast to coast.

    Promises of change are not enough. For candidates who want working-class votes, the first step is to speak out.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



David Bacon is a writer and photographer. His new book, "Illegal People - How Globalization Creates Migration and Criminalizes Immigrants," was just published by Beacon Press. His photographs and stories can be found at http://dbacon.igc.org.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



call me a conservative,

call me a conservative, though ive been a life lone dem and would vote for nader if he had a snowballs chance, but it seems to me if those guys in the article were here legally they could join a union, raise wages for a higher natl avg. and not be treats so shabbily. im sorry, but what part of illegal dont they understand?


Perhaps Mr. Bacon's new book

Perhaps Mr. Bacon's new book should have been called "Nations (not Communities) Without Borders," since he obviously agrees with former Mexican President Fox that the border between our two countries is "just a line on a map." Like most progressives, I fully agree with the author that NAFTA has caused terrible trouble for poor Mexicans and Central Americans. It's truly a Lose/Lose trade agreement that should be scrapped. Mexico and Central America need land reform so that farmers can make a decent living. And America needs to have far fewer undereducated, unskilled and uninvited workers.


What part of "imperialism"

What part of "imperialism" don't conservatives understand? Americans must be the only people on Earth who think toothpaste comes out of a tube without being squeezed. And in this case, the same corporate thugs that suborned our government, put the NAFTA squeeze on Mexico. Do conservatives realize that under the terms of NAFTA Mexico was prohibited from supporting it own family farms whereas the US was allowed to shovel all the dollars it could at ADM, Cargill and Tyson? Result? The economic devastation of whole village. The New York Times (ever the shill for corporate plunder) calls this "shake up" a "good thing". For whom? Not for Mexican campesinos, who are reduced to migrating up here (ever so "illegally") in order to survive on slave wages in slave-factories and then get thrown into prison camps by ICE squads working for a Goon Government. What part of NAZI don't conservatives get?


Um...their crime is being in

Um...their crime is being in this country illegally and providing a false ssn is a federal offense for anyone regardless citizenship status. Why should someone have special privileges just because they are Hispanic? As an descendant of immigrants, I am very insulted by that idea. You either follow the law and enter this country legally or you violate the law and then you are considered a criminal. That is how a nation that run by the rule of law works. To say that having to follow immigration laws is somehow racist is the biggest bunch of crap i have...even bigger than the crap that comes out of Bush's mouth every day. Quit making excuses for the illegal behavior of people jusat because they come from Mexico. To me...that is racist.


Duct tape and beating with a

Duct tape and beating with a meat hook, along with other such crimes should never happen. Likewise, entering this country with forged documents is also illegal and cannot be tolerated! I live in Iowa and see this nonsense going on right under my nose everyday, so skip the sob stories. It falls on deaf ears here. They have helped to destroy so much of our once thriving industrial base here...to the point that people born and raised here can no longer find decent jobs. It's impossible to compete with people who are WILLINGLY allowing themselves to be victimized into working for low wages and in horrid working conditions. They need to come here LEGALLY just as all immigrants are required. Until then- let the raids continue!


What brands does this

What brands does this company sell? Who do they sell it to? I'll stop buying these products and stop shopping at their outlets. This is outrageous!!


Speeding is a crime. Murder

Speeding is a crime. Murder is a crime. Both are illegal. But I think most people would agree that murder is more serious than speeding. The same holds true in immigration. Yes, it's illegal to cross our border without a valid visa, or to allow your visa to expire while you're already here (the latter being how about 40 percent of our "illegals" got here -- they came here legally, but stayed illegally). But isn't it a far more serious crime to knowingly employ illegals, particularly when you do so because they're a vulnerable group that will work for next to nothing? If labor standards were enforced across the board, there'd no longer be an incentive for companies like Tyson or Smithfield Foods to recruit them -- because they'd have to pay these immigrants the same as everybody else, provide benefits like everybody else, and treat them like everybody else. And if they had to treat them like everybody else, well, they may as well just hire U.S. citizens.


This is the one thing I am

This is the one thing I am conservative about. Rather than going through a multi-step solution that is prone to failure, why don't we just enforce current employer laws? I live in Southern California, and employers are never fined or arrested for hiring illegal immigrants. Yes, there are raids, but the employers don't even get a slap on the hand. Once employers start going to jail and paying huge fines, they will stop hiring undocumented workers and the illegal immigrants will have no incentive to run the border. The solution is simple: Enforce our existing laws. It's not rocket science.


it never ceases to amaze me

it never ceases to amaze me the blinders people chose to wear. in schools i watch how white kids can taunt and bully kids of color with impunity. however, when a kid of color reacts and pushes back they are punished with detention and/or expulsion. the situation with immigration is the same. the usa bullies, pushes, squeezes and forces unbearable living conditions which compel people to come north to try and survive. then people here get on their high horse and root for the abuse of these people. mighty white of you conservatives! maybe you might put all your venom into efforts to undo NAFTA and other trade agreements which squeeze the life out of others in true colonialist and imperialist fashion. this is done in your name and you bear personal responsibility for the conditions created in other countries. i think it is americans that chose to be blind, wanting their cake and eating it too without any remorse for the misery their comfort is based on. how about working on changing this country and begin to put some ethics back into our national life. how about getting better educated on what this country does to people in parts of the world, particularly people of color. now that is racism!


All you folks on here saying

All you folks on here saying that the illegals are getting what they deserve or that they should stop coming across or that they are taking jobs have your heads up your a**es. Do a little bit of research and discover the conditions and situations that the US has created that have forced hundred..nay...thousands of people to head north and across our borders. Facts which the article covers and which you have chosen to conveniently overlook. WE have created the problem. I agree that folks should enter the country legally, no doubt about it...but before you folks start preaching about illegals taking our jobs and blabbity blab, realize that they are performing jobs that very few Americans would be willing to do. Cause if thats the case why aren't these poor unemployed Americans doing these jobs? Why aren't they protesting the companies that continue to hire illegals and flaunt the law? Are they not criminals too? You Americans, b*tch b*tch but unwilling to propose any realistic and reasonable solutions.


These raids aren't about the

These raids aren't about the illegals, they're about filling the private prisons and charging US to house these poor people. If the laws were enforced, the employer would be fined and jailed, not the workers. Major Corp run rough shod over the country and its laws and in general make trouble. The new admin should call a halt to these raids and also call a cease fire in Iraq and Afghanistan...until we have FACTS that tell us exactly what the real situations are.


What part of starving to

What part of starving to death do you anti-immigrants not understand? I wish it were possible to all of a sudden deport all of the illegal immigrants back to their countries with out any human rights violations so that you hypocritical freaks would understand the burden of poverty. "They are here illegally" whine whine whine. How much are you willing to pay for a head for broccoli? $.99, $1.00 how about $5.00. For every job the they have "stolen" from American workers, your prices for food go down. The xenophobia of people who call themselves Dems or progressive or American is disgustingly racist. We are all human beings, with the same rights and responsibilities. We should all be treated accordingly. Oh and by the way, the main reason there are not enough jobs for "american" citizens is because those jobs have been shipped over seas to places that have the same low standards for protecting employees from predatory employers. Ask yourself this, "When was the last time you purchased something made in Amaerica?" If you can't remember when, then you are part of the reason these people are here illegally. Own up, fess up, and then shut up.


Immigrant workers who give

Immigrant workers who give bad Social Security numbers are not simple, innocent victims. The employers to which these numbers are given collect them so that the worker's wage's may be accurately reported to the IRS for collection of taxes. The employer becomes the target of the IRS when this happens and is suspected by the IRS of fraud unless and until a good-faith showing is made. This is not anecdotal; this is personal experience. Immigrant's rights are important in a land where all of our rights have come under assault. But giving amnesty to workers who pass bogus Social Security numbers is no answer; the burden-of-proof for collection of taxes on that reported income and for the immediate suspicion against the employer of underreporting gross income by hiring "fake" workers falls on the employer. A system of work permits or visas that also taps into the Social Security reporting system will solve the problem for both worker and employer.


online shopping designer

designer handbags online suprisely CvEGUZbb http://wikibookia.com/designerboutiquesonline/



christian louboutin outlet chicago

sell christian louboutin outlet suprisely sEzjjjoG http://www.christian-louboutin-outlet.us/



louis vuitton luggage outlet

view louis vuitton shoes outlet to your friends kCsExnJv http://www.louis--vuitton-outlet.com/



fnnzvg

rzhmgh



bopcaona

cuqehc