Land of Day Laborers, Farm Workers and Guest Workers

by: David Bacon, t r u t h o u t | Photo Essay

Oceanside, California - In Oceanside, Carlsbad, Del Mar and north San Diego County, immigrant day laborers wait by the side of the road, hoping a contractor will stop and offer them work. Alberto Juarez Martinez slings his jacket over his shoulder while he waits. His hands show the effect of a lifetime of manual work, plus arthritis suffered as a child in Zapata, Zacatecas. The hands of Beto, a migrant from Uruachi, Chihuahua, also show the effect of a lifetime of manual work. Juan Castillo, a migrant from Tehuacan, Puebla, waits with his friends in the parking lot of a market they've nicknamed La Gallinita, because of the rooster on the roof of the building.

Alberto Juarez Martinez slings his jacket over his shoulder while he waits. His hands show the effect of a lifetime of manual work, plus arthritis suffered as a child in Zapata, Zacatecas. The hands of Beto, a migrant from Uruachi, Chihuahua, also show the effect of a lifetime of manual work.  Photos by David Bacon.

Police in north county towns have started cruising by day labor sites in plainclothes, pretending to be contractors offering workers jobs, and then citing them and turning them over to immigration agents, even those with green cards. Many community organizations are protesting this practice.

Juan Castillo, a migrant from Tehuacan, Puebla, waits with his friends in the parking lot of a market they've nicknamed La Gallinita, because of the rooster on the roof of the building.  Photos by David Bacon.

Francisco Villa operates a lunch truck that visits the areas where migrant day laborers live on hillsides and under trees. Villa hands out leaflets advising workers of their rights and letting them know that they can find help from California Rural Legal Assistance. Across the street from Villa's truck, Zaragosa Brito and Andres Roman Diaz, two migrants from Arcelia, Guerrero, sit next to a fence where workers look for day labor, or get rides to the fields for farm work. The men sleep out in the open in the field behind the fence, and have worked on a local strawberry ranch, Rancho Diablo, for many years.

Francisco Villa operates a lunch truck visiting an area where migrant day laborers live.  Zaragosa Brito and Andres Roman Diaz, two migrant farm workers, sit next to a fence where workers look for day labor.  Photos by David Bacon.

A few miles away, farm workers harvest marjoram and basil at Herb Thyme Farms in Oceanside. Harvesting marjoram means using a short knife that requires workers to work bend over double. Years of this labor can cause permanent damage to the spine.

Migrant farm workers bend over double to harvest with short knives.  Photos by David Bacon.

One possible future for migrant farm laborers is visible in a crew of workers picking tomatoes on the Camp Pendleton Marine Corps base. These are H2-A guest workers, recruited in Mexico by grower Harry Singh. On the base, the workers are hidden in the rows behind a barbed wire fence, and outside labor organizers or legal advisers can't gain access. At the end of the day, these guest workers are taken to a labor camp on Singh's ranch, where access is also restricted in order to keep them isolated from the surrounding community. H2-A guest workers can't leave their jobs without being deported back to Mexico. They fear that if they protest or even speak with legal aid, they won't be hired the following season. Singh used to be the only California grower importing H2-A workers, but now there are several. The number is growing.

Migrant farm workers walking through rows at farm.  Photo by David Bacon.

Photos by David Bacon.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



David Bacon is a writer and photographer. His new book, "Illegal People - How Globalization Creates Migration and Criminalizes Immigrants," was just published by Beacon Press. His photographs and stories can be found at http://dbacon.igc.org.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



As always David's articles

As always David's articles and photos are cutting edge labor exposes. This situation with the H2-A guest workers, recruited in Mexico by a grower, needs to be studied to see what the real effects are of this indentured servitude. Do they get better or worse treatment, more or less rights? Are they less likely to leave their families stranded in Mexico without a father/husband? Are the workers feeling trapped by the employer's conditions or would they consider organizing? -- can they organize or are they living in a 'company town' totally dependent on the whims of the bosses? Thanks David!!


I once upon a time, had the

I once upon a time, had the responsibility for the landscaping maintenance at the Encina Power Plant, in Carlsbad. Part of my job included cleaning up after the season workers (most likely not here 'kosher-fashion', so to speak). It was touching, tragic, and heartrending to see big homes on the hills above squalor and human travail. For a period of years a couple of farmers would call 'La Migra', just before payday. Nice people, these paragons. It is hard living in the North County. Shame in us for not being more human.


The article doesn't offer

The article doesn't offer any guesstimate on how many of the people involved are here illegally, but those who are here in violation of the law should certainly realize that they have little to complain about. If they are here legally, and in fact have been recruited by American employers, it is a different story. The employers should be held to strict standards and punished if they fail to follow them. However, why can't some of these jobs be automated, and have machinery do most of the really onerous, back-breaking work? There must be a way to design machines that could handle most of the stoop labor. Then we wouldn't need so many day workers, at least in agriculture.


Counselor Troi, you are

Counselor Troi, you are positively sophistic today, with your imaginary Rube Goldberg machine that's supposed to make criminal corporations eschew exploitation of the poor and willing-to-work. I want your job; it sounds so cushy!


Surely CounselorTroi

Surely CounselorTroi realizes that whatever the status of agricultural workers, they are entitled to and can receive the same legal protections as anyone else. Instead, they are disproportionately abused and frequently afraid to assert their rights under the law. It's true the employers should be held to strict standards, but that is in every context, including the standards relating to employees' rights. If employers are more easily able to abuse (and therefore unjustly benefit from) undocumented workers, they are perversely encouraged to violate the law. This puts them at an unfair advantage over employers who diligently comply with legal requirements. And I won't get into the ridiculousness of mechanizing the agricultural industry. mbc


oxKOCbuZcCRkTXIXeSU

L5sJkM lsbbpnabqvpg, [url=http://vnaoofhaqnrt.com/]vnaoofhaqnrt[/url], [link=http://zycektggcgxe.com/]zycektggcgxe[/link], http://gydxxcivtxce.com/



pVeySCawEFlqB

HdvFpM zqeszeksduyt, [url=http://ymjylcwmuylt.com/]ymjylcwmuylt[/url], [link=http://qcvfmisoehbl.com/]qcvfmisoehbl[/link], http://mqgkgbrlmrsz.com/



bvhxwUeIDOHEQFzewj

uGZ0Bo lrvltoswtrlz, [url=http://lolgjpavupgp.com/]lolgjpavupgp[/url], [link=http://novusfmrzxsh.com/]novusfmrzxsh[/link], http://gdyfptisvccs.com/



ubwoAeFwIVnqFpf

uJ3xgS ifcekirzocpf, [url=http://osnegurmhaym.com/]osnegurmhaym[/url], [link=http://orvpjmoakfkh.com/]orvpjmoakfkh[/link], http://upgnrqqywmqu.com/



AXnLHvTtJqYFAhEK

lbcGtQ izedxdluveoc, [url=http://vvntbpzntofm.com/]vvntbpzntofm[/url], [link=http://dfycynihbdyq.com/]dfycynihbdyq[/link], http://wbonilrtxhsz.com/



tJAspNIvjwWIDjaDkQ

2f8X1I gdrxkopxbcjk, [url=http://xfxtwquocoqa.com/]xfxtwquocoqa[/url], [link=http://nthnwyjhkseh.com/]nthnwyjhkseh[/link], http://vrdirwghqjzi.com/



uPojQwKzpDoFHvS

ksWjdG nyyhbmyeptkq, [url=http://esddxnckekdz.com/]esddxnckekdz[/url], [link=http://brxtrbovensb.com/]brxtrbovensb[/link], http://gasnhooyolwh.com/