"Somebody Has to Respond"

by: David Bacon, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

"Somebody Has to Respond"
Protesters in New York demonstrate in front of a Bank of America branch in support of Republic Windows and Doors workers in Chicago. Bank of America Corp. offered loans to the firm to resolve issues of pay to fired workers. (Photo: AFP / Getty Images)

    When the day finally comes that Raul Flores loses his job, he will face a bitter search for another one. "I've got a family to support, so I've got to do whatever it takes," he says. "It's going to be hard. The economic situation is not good, but I can't just wait for something to happen to me."

    That puts Flores in the same boat as millions of other US workers. Last month alone, 533,000 workers lost their jobs - the highest figure in 34 years. A week ago, the heads of the Big Three auto companies were in Washington, DC, pleading for loans to keep their companies afloat. As a price, lawmakers and pundits told them they had to become "leaner and meaner," and in response, General Motors announced it would close nine plants and put tens of thousands of workers in the street. Ford and Chrysler described a similar job-elimination strategy.

    What makes Flores special? He didn't just accept the elimination of his job. Instead, he sat in at the Chicago plant where he worked for six days, together with 240 other union members at Republic Windows and Doors.

    Republic workers were not demanding the reopening of their closed factory, at least not yet. They have been fighting for severance and benefits to help them survive the unemployment they know awaits them. Yet, their occupation can't help but raise deeper questions about the right of workers to their jobs. Can a return to the militant tactics of direct action, that produced the greatest gains in union membership, wages and job security in US history, overturn "the inescapable logic of the marketplace"? Can employers, and the banks that hold their credit lines, be forced to keep plants open?

    Unlike the auto giants, Republic is not threatening bankruptcy. It makes a "green product," Energy Star-compliant doors and windows that should be one of the bedrock industries for a new, more environmentally sustainable economy. But Bank of America, as it was receiving $25 billion in federal bailout funds, pulled the company's credit line, leaving workers in the lurch. Perhaps that alone led President-elect Obama to support the workers. The bank-enforced closure undermines his program for using environmentally sustainable jobs to replace those eliminated in the spiraling recession. He called Republic workers "absolutely right. What's happening to them is reflective of what's happening across this economy."

    Federal law requires companies to give employees 60 days' notice of a plant closure or pay them 60 days' severance pay to give them breathing room to find other jobs. Republic workers got three days and no money. "They knew they'd be out on the street penniless," says Leah Fried, organizer for Local 1110 of the United Electrical Workers. "When the negotiating committee came back to the factory to report that the company didn't even show up to talk with them, the workers were so enraged they voted unanimously not to leave until they got their severance and vacation pay."

    While the workers acted to gain their legally-mandated rights, the plant occupation resurrects a tactic with a radical history. In 1934, auto workers occupied the huge Fisher Body plants in Flint, Michigan, and when the battle was over, the United Auto Workers union was born. Sitdown strikes spread across the country like wildfire. Occupying production lines in plant after plant, workers won unions, better wages and real changes in their lives.

    Seventy years later, the workers who have inherited that legacy of unionization and security are on the brink of losing everything. Just since 2006, the United Auto Workers union has lost 119,000 members. The threat of plant closure has been used to cut the wages of new hires in half, to $14.50, the same wage paid on the window lines at Republic, where the union is only four years old.

    Flores certainly hopes that those whose livelihoods are in peril will rediscover the tactic. "This is the start of something," he urges. "Don't let it die. Learn something from it." And the sitdown was successful. After a thousand people rallied in front of Bank of America at the end of the day on December 10, the bank announced it would put up $2 million in loans to meet the money owed the workers. Flores and his coworkers then voted to end the occupation.

    Fran Tobin, midwest organizer for Jobs with Justice, a coalition of labor and community groups with chapters around the country, shares Flores' optimism. "I think this is not the last time we're going to see American workers occupying American plants, as part of a move to save jobs and turn things around," he says. Organizers for Jobs with Justice are fanning out with a program they call a "Peoples' Bailout." Tobin emphasizes that, "We need to ask, 'What kind of an economy and recovery do we want?'" He lists funds for a jobs program, rather than huge loans to banks, a moratorium on home foreclosures, investment in infrastructure repair, and helping local and state governments (and public workers) survive the crisis without massive budget cuts.

    Flores, Tobin and Fried all agree that none of those demands can be won without unions and workers willing to fight for them. That makes the Republic plant occupation more than just a local confrontation. "This might not be the right tactic in every situation, but people know we need to be fighting back," Fried says.

    Will the unions in auto plants and other workplaces hit by layoffs take up the challenge of the Republic workers? To Flores, they have to do something more than just watch the elimination of their jobs. "We've got to fight for our rights," he emphasizes. "It's not fair that they just kick us out on the street with nothing. Somebody has to respond."

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



David Bacon is a writer and photographer. His new book, "Illegal People - How Globalization Creates Migration and Criminalizes Immigrants," was just published by Beacon Press. His photographs and stories can be found at http://dbacon.igc.org.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Thirty years of anti-labor

Thirty years of anti-labor propaganda has taken its toll, but us working stiffs have to stick together or we are going to keep getting screwed. It's not a coincidence that, once the interests of the wealthy are threatened, $750 billion materializes instantly. This is after all that preaching about fiscal responsibility to those of us lower on the food chain.


Thirty years of labor union

Thirty years of labor union sellouts by well paid union executives lead to this celebration of a Victory at what really is a funeral. The only victory is that the bosses agreed to pay a part of the funeral expenses. From the UAW to every major union in the US, the union hacks denied the very reason people join unions--the contradictory interests of employers and workers. Using the corporate state slogan that We Are All in the Same Boat, when it is abundantly clear that we are not all in the same boat, rather we witness harsh class war, the union misleaders demolished worker struggles as in the Detroit Newspaper strike, the California Grocery Strike, the Detroit Teachers Wildcat, and on and on. Now, unions are unfit to meet the challenges ahead. Unions do not unite people. They divide us along lines of job, industry, race, nationality, and sex. Worse, the union bosses live high on wages won from demolishing worker movements outside the US, as with AIFLD and the CIA. Those union hacks know what they are doing and we should too. I would celebrate a seizure of Solidarity House as much as I would another Flint Sitdown.


Exactly what is "the

Exactly what is "the inescapable logic of the marketplace"? Tromping on those of us who have little? Maybe there should be some required courses in Corporate Social Responsibility to balance the greed mentality of University Business Management Education (aka How to cheat and cook the books for CEOs).


Where are our pensions?

Where are our pensions? Where are our jobs? Why aren't our unions stronger? Why does not the government that we pay for help the workers? This is class war, and if we do not organize, we are lost before we begin, for they are already organized in their corporations. The fate of the wage-slave is a burden the wealthy have placed on all of us. Bail outs for the starched white shirts, but the workers are left to fend for themselves, taken from their previous job in payroll taxes deducted from a reduced wage and shortened hours.


in a global economy, it was

in a global economy, it was just a matter of time before the big sell-out of the American people. And here it comes. The opportunity we have now is to transform this economy into one which can sustain itself, and one which is sustainable. This doesn't include the continuance of funding for the upper class which has made its meal off of unsustainable, yet lucrative, short-term capitalism. There will be a revolution, and it's beginning now. Where can they hide when millions will be looking for them? No amount of money can protect them from the pending outrage of workers who have spent their lives doing the right thing, and that should never be underestimated. This is capitalism and global economy's biggest flaw in thinking that somehow we would continue to accept this business as usual style as the rug is pulled out from under us. Big mistake.


let us not forget folks, the

let us not forget folks, the unions, specially the bigones have become as bad and as corrupt as the companies they battle with. Blame lies on evryones shoulders...an the average American is the one that suffers. REVOLUTION NOW!


At first, I was so offended

At first, I was so offended by Republic's and the Bank's violations that I began forwarding this article to friends. But as i tried to compose the email, I found every step to be on thin ice. This article is significantly short of real information. We are given no information about the reason for the closure; Republic Window and Door is, according to the article, not threatening bankruptcy. Bank of American is portrayed as the villain, but their role is unclear; if Republic is not threatening bankruptcy, it is not the Bank's position to arrange severance with employees. I must conclude that Bacon either did a poor job or intended to manipulate readers.


There is a very simple way

There is a very simple way to correct and reverse this economic crisis, and I hope President Obama continues to show the guts he's risen so far on. Instead of taxing all income and benefits over $250,000 at 39% instead of 35%, confiscate it. Seize it. Take it outright. Union workers are actually only making about $50K, but even if they were making $100K, they are neither the cause of the problem nor the cost. The managers, the executives, the golden-parachuters -- the ones who made the stupid decisions, and then rewarded themselves for being greedy and stupid -- are the problem, and if they think that learning to live on a quarter of a million instead of ten million is too hard for them, then TOO DAMN BAD. You want socialism? I'll give you socialism: everyone who shows up for work gets a living wage. Everyone who does something necessary -- firefighting, teaching, garbage pickup -- gets a salary commensurate with their importance to society, say $100K. Everyone who does something that no one really needs -- lip-flappers, advertisers -- gets NO income, only a percentage of what they sell. (That way, stupid people pay taxes on their own stupidity.) Sure, some people are better at organizing and paperwork than others. Let the workers vote on who they want to run the business. But the economic class warfare established and perpetuated by the incompetent to conceal their own failure has nearly ruined this country, and it's going to take the workers, with the force of numbers unified by government, to haul us back.


to anonymous - if you are

to anonymous - if you are looking for a space to bring workers and organizations together across race, sexuality, gender, industry, etc... look no further than Jobs with Justice (mentioned in the article). We may not be flashy or all over the papers, but we take action, confront decision makers, and work hard as hell to win victories for working families like yours and mine. Check it out- get plugged in. http://www.jwj.org/bailout/12-08report.html


Bank of America is the

Bank of America is the villan. Stan, let's be clear. The very top management, a micropercentage of the human beings who work at BoA, are the problem. They are profiting in good times and in bad times. Your economic arguments about corporations being good are a relic. Unless we solve the legalized criminality by the CEOs, the United States will completely collapse. There is no explanation for any corporation other than the CEOs are ruining America and America's businesses.


That doesn't sound as much

That doesn't sound as much like socialism as it sounds like common sense, and simple fairness, Die Hard.


I agree with the comments

I agree with the comments ahead of me about revolution. The time has come for people to realize that more and more of their freedoms are being taken away from them, and from their children, right before their eyes. What is that I have recently read about the government beefing up troops in the USA, just in case of "emergency" conditions? Isn't it an emergency when people have lost their homes and are living in their cars? The Union Gospel Misssion recently gave me a call for money. They said this was one of their worst years, with the most homeless needing help. Maybe the government expects the public to revolt and are making plans for it. Can you spell "detention camp"?


I am a proud member of the

I am a proud member of the ILWU. The ILWU came into being in the 1930's via an immigrant called Harry Bridges. He spoke to and touched everyone about collective bargaining. There were difficult struggles, yes. But he proved that in the end, if you stick together and have the rest of the community behind you, you will prevail. Today we have a very strong union. But I must remind everyone, WE elect our Union leaders and officials. If they don't represent us, they have NO business being a union official! Know your candidates. It starts with your own Local. DO NOT allow corruption. Collective bargaining is the only way that the American worker will ever be able to earn a living wage. United we stand!


As a long time and long

As a long time and long discouraged leftie, I was delighted at the spontaneous action of the unionized Republic workers. Just what the ghost of that unmentionable bearded German guy ordered. Unions are one of the keys to reversing the upward gush of wealth since Ronnie conned us into the purposefully misnamed free market. Too many unions are no better than company unions, corrupt, undemocratic, and rotten with nepotism and cronyism, but some like ILWU and SIEWU aren’t. Moreover, even at their strongest, unions represented only a small fraction of the folks they should have. Two mystifications have kept unions weak. One is that of the middle class. Look at a graph plotting income against the number of people. The vast bulk of people are bunched at the lower end of the income scale while fewer and fewer occupy the almost interminable upper end. So how to distinguish the middle from the lower class? The ancient and cross cultural distinction between those who work with their hands, our blue collar workers, and those who work with their heads, our white collar workers, does the trick. Unions are alleged only for the Handwerker schlubs who get dirty. (As a young professor I argued in a faculty meeting for a union; I was dismissed by the reply that we were after all professionals accompanied by a self-satisfied chorus of hear-hears.) This second strongly reinforced mystification covers up, as it is meant to, the dirty little fact that both white and blue collar workers have no control over the physical, social, and economic conditions in which they produce what they produce. There’s that ghost again. Unless white collar workers get over their incessantly encouraged delusion that they are more similar to the rich than their blue collar brothers and sisters even the best unions will remain convicts chipping at Everest with jeweler’s hammers.


Seriously, isn't this the

Seriously, isn't this the problem of the management of the company that let their credit line default? Should banks extend unlimited credit to any takers regardless of ability or care to pay it back?