2011: A Brave New Dystopia

by: Chris Hedges  |  Truthdig | Op-Ed

2011: A Brave New Dystopia
(Image: Jared Rodriguez / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: ZakVTA, Jeremy Brooks)

The two greatest visions of a future dystopia were George Orwell’s “1984” and Aldous Huxley’s “Brave New World.” The debate, between those who watched our descent towards corporate totalitarianism, was who was right. Would we be, as Orwell wrote, dominated by a repressive surveillance and security state that used crude and violent forms of control? Or would we be, as Huxley envisioned, entranced by entertainment and spectacle, captivated by technology and seduced by profligate consumption to embrace our own oppression? It turns out Orwell and Huxley were both right. Huxley saw the first stage of our enslavement. Orwell saw the second.

We have been gradually disempowered by a corporate state that, as Huxley foresaw, seduced and manipulated us through sensual gratification, cheap mass-produced goods, boundless credit, political theater and amusement. While we were entertained, the regulations that once kept predatory corporate power in check were dismantled, the laws that once protected us were rewritten and we were impoverished. Now that credit is drying up, good jobs for the working class are gone forever and mass-produced goods are unaffordable, we find ourselves transported from “Brave New World” to “1984.” The state, crippled by massive deficits, endless war and corporate malfeasance, is sliding toward bankruptcy. It is time for Big Brother to take over from Huxley’s feelies, the orgy-porgy and the centrifugal bumble-puppy. We are moving from a society where we are skillfully manipulated by lies and illusions to one where we are overtly controlled.

Orwell warned of a world where books were banned. Huxley warned of a world where no one wanted to read books. Orwell warned of a state of permanent war and fear. Huxley warned of a culture diverted by mindless pleasure. Orwell warned of a state where every conversation and thought was monitored and dissent was brutally punished. Huxley warned of a state where a population, preoccupied by trivia and gossip, no longer cared about truth or information. Orwell saw us frightened into submission. Huxley saw us seduced into submission. But Huxley, we are discovering, was merely the prelude to Orwell. Huxley understood the process by which we would be complicit in our own enslavement. Orwell understood the enslavement. Now that the corporate coup is over, we stand naked and defenseless. We are beginning to understand, as Karl Marx knew, that unfettered and unregulated capitalism is a brutal and revolutionary force that exploits human beings and the natural world until exhaustion or collapse.

“The Party seeks power entirely for its own sake,” Orwell wrote in “1984.” “We are not interested in the good of others; we are interested solely in power. Not wealth or luxury or long life or happiness: only power, pure power. What pure power means you will understand presently. We are different from all the oligarchies of the past, in that we know what we are doing. All the others, even those who resembled ourselves, were cowards and hypocrites. The German Nazis and the Russian Communists came very close to us in their methods, but they never had the courage to recognize their own motives. They pretended, perhaps they even believed, that they had seized power unwillingly and for a limited time, and that just round the corner there lay a paradise where human beings would be free and equal. We are not like that. We know that no one ever seizes power with the intention of relinquishing it. Power is not a means; it is an end. One does not establish a dictatorship in order to safeguard a revolution; one makes the revolution in order to establish the dictatorship. The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power.”

The political philosopher Sheldon Wolin uses the term “inverted totalitarianism” in his book “Democracy Incorporated” to describe our political system. It is a term that would make sense to Huxley. In inverted totalitarianism, the sophisticated technologies of corporate control, intimidation and mass manipulation, which far surpass those employed by previous totalitarian states, are effectively masked by the glitter, noise and abundance of a consumer society. Political participation and civil liberties are gradually surrendered. The corporation state, hiding behind the smokescreen of the public relations industry, the entertainment industry and the tawdry materialism of a consumer society, devours us from the inside out. It owes no allegiance to us or the nation. It feasts upon our carcass.

The corporate state does not find its expression in a demagogue or charismatic leader. It is defined by the anonymity and facelessness of the corporation. Corporations, who hire attractive spokespeople like Barack Obama, control the uses of science, technology, education and mass communication. They control the messages in movies and television. And, as in “Brave New World,” they use these tools of communication to bolster tyranny. Our systems of mass communication, as Wolin writes, “block out, eliminate whatever might introduce qualification, ambiguity, or dialogue, anything that might weaken or complicate the holistic force of their creation, to its total impression.”

The result is a monochromatic system of information. Celebrity courtiers, masquerading as journalists, experts and specialists, identify our problems and patiently explain the parameters. All those who argue outside the imposed parameters are dismissed as irrelevant cranks, extremists or members of a radical left. Prescient social critics, from Ralph Nader to Noam Chomsky, are banished. Acceptable opinions have a range of A to B. The culture, under the tutelage of these corporate courtiers, becomes, as Huxley noted, a world of cheerful conformity, as well as an endless and finally fatal optimism. We busy ourselves buying products that promise to change our lives, make us more beautiful, confident or successful as we are steadily stripped of rights, money and influence. All messages we receive through these systems of communication, whether on the nightly news or talk shows like “Oprah,” promise a brighter, happier tomorrow. And this, as Wolin points out, is “the same ideology that invites corporate executives to exaggerate profits and conceal losses, but always with a sunny face.” We have been entranced, as Wolin writes, by “continuous technological advances” that “encourage elaborate fantasies of individual prowess, eternal youthfulness, beauty through surgery, actions measured in nanoseconds: a dream-laden culture of ever-expanding control and possibility, whose denizens are prone to fantasies because the vast majority have imagination but little scientific knowledge.”

Our manufacturing base has been dismantled. Speculators and swindlers have looted the U.S. Treasury and stolen billions from small shareholders who had set aside money for retirement or college. Civil liberties, including habeas corpus and protection from warrantless wiretapping, have been taken away. Basic services, including public education and health care, have been handed over to the corporations to exploit for profit. The few who raise voices of dissent, who refuse to engage in the corporate happy talk, are derided by the corporate establishment as freaks.

Busy schedule? Click here to keep up with Truthout with free email updates.

Attitudes and temperament have been cleverly engineered by the corporate state, as with Huxley’s pliant characters in “Brave New World.” The book’s protagonist, Bernard Marx, turns in frustration to his girlfriend Lenina:

'Don’t you wish you were free, Lenina?' he asks.

'I don’t know that you mean. I am free, free to have the most wonderful time. Everybody’s happy nowadays.'

He laughed, 'Yes, ‘Everybody’s happy nowadays.’ We have been giving the children that at five. But wouldn’t you like to be free to be happy in some other way, Lenina? In your own way, for example; not in everybody else’s way.'

'I don’t know what you mean,' she repeated.

The façade is crumbling. And as more and more people realize that they have been used and robbed, we will move swiftly from Huxley’s “Brave New World” to Orwell’s “1984.” The public, at some point, will have to face some very unpleasant truths. The good-paying jobs are not coming back. The largest deficits in human history mean that we are trapped in a debt peonage system that will be used by the corporate state to eradicate the last vestiges of social protection for citizens, including Social Security. The state has devolved from a capitalist democracy to neo-feudalism. And when these truths become apparent, anger will replace the corporate-imposed cheerful conformity. The bleakness of our post-industrial pockets, where some 40 million Americans live in a state of poverty and tens of millions in a category called “near poverty,” coupled with the lack of credit to save families from foreclosures, bank repossessions and bankruptcy from medical bills, means that inverted totalitarianism will no longer work.

We increasingly live in Orwell’s Oceania, not Huxley’s The World State. Osama bin Laden plays the role assumed by Emmanuel Goldstein in “1984.” Goldstein, in the novel, is the public face of terror. His evil machinations and clandestine acts of violence dominate the nightly news. Goldstein’s image appears each day on Oceania’s television screens as part of the nation’s “Two Minutes of Hate” daily ritual. And without the intervention of the state, Goldstein, like bin Laden, will kill you. All excesses are justified in the titanic fight against evil personified.

The psychological torture of Pvt. Bradley Manning—who has now been imprisoned for seven months without being convicted of any crime—mirrors the breaking of the dissident Winston Smith at the end of “1984.” Manning is being held as a “maximum custody detainee” in the brig at Marine Corps Base Quantico, in Virginia. He spends 23 of every 24 hours alone. He is denied exercise. He cannot have a pillow or sheets for his bed. Army doctors have been plying him with antidepressants. The cruder forms of torture of the Gestapo have been replaced with refined Orwellian techniques, largely developed by government psychologists, to turn dissidents like Manning into vegetables. We break souls as well as bodies. It is more effective. Now we can all be taken to Orwell’s dreaded Room 101 to become compliant and harmless. These “special administrative measures” are regularly imposed on our dissidents, including Syed Fahad Hashmi, who was imprisoned under similar conditions for three years before going to trial. The techniques have psychologically maimed thousands of detainees in our black sites around the globe. They are the staple form of control in our maximum security prisons where the corporate state makes war on our most politically astute underclass—African-Americans. It all presages the shift from Huxley to Orwell.

“Never again will you be capable of ordinary human feeling,” Winston Smith’s torturer tells him in “1984.” “Everything will be dead inside you. Never again will you be capable of love, or friendship, or joy of living, or laughter, or curiosity, or courage, or integrity. You will be hollow. We shall squeeze you empty and then we shall fill you with ourselves.”

The noose is tightening. The era of amusement is being replaced by the era of repression. Tens of millions of citizens have had their e-mails and phone records turned over to the government. We are the most monitored and spied-on citizenry in human history. Many of us have our daily routine caught on dozens of security cameras. Our proclivities and habits are recorded on the Internet. Our profiles are electronically generated. Our bodies are patted down at airports and filmed by scanners. And public service announcements, car inspection stickers, and public transportation posters constantly urge us to report suspicious activity. The enemy is everywhere.

Those who do not comply with the dictates of the war on terror, a war which, as Orwell noted, is endless, are brutally silenced. The draconian security measures used to cripple protests at the G-20 gatherings in Pittsburgh and Toronto were wildly disproportionate for the level of street activity. But they sent a clear message—DO NOT TRY THIS. The FBI’s targeting of antiwar and Palestinian activists, which in late September saw agents raid homes in Minneapolis and Chicago, is a harbinger of what is to come for all who dare defy the state’s official Newspeak. The agents—our Thought Police—seized phones, computers, documents and other personal belongings. Subpoenas to appear before a grand jury have since been served on 26 people. The subpoenas cite federal law prohibiting “providing material support or resources to designated foreign terrorist organizations.” Terror, even for those who have nothing to do with terror, becomes the blunt instrument used by Big Brother to protect us from ourselves.

“Do you begin to see, then, what kind of world we are creating?” Orwell wrote. “It is the exact opposite of the stupid hedonistic Utopias that the old reformers imagined. A world of fear and treachery and torment, a world of trampling and being trampled upon, a world which will grow not less but more merciless as it refines itself.”

Chris Hedges is a senior fellow at The Nation Institute. His newest book is “Death of the Liberal Class.” 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



“Well”, to quote RayGun,

“Well”, to quote RayGun, it sure wasn’t the Huxley world of equable distribution of anesthetic drugs to ease the caste sufferings of our Idle CLASS’ dystopia! My vote, retrieved from the memory hole: 1984!! Today, Yesterday and Tomorrow, PERPETUALLY 1984!!! – OR WELL.



I fear Chris Hedges is right

I fear Chris Hedges is right on all counts. I saw the controlling influence of the corporate world, operating through governments, at the climate negotiations in Cancun. Only Bolivia correctly called the outcome "genocide and ecocide,"

Chris, I don't read your pieces right before bed. They are too scary.



Are there any clearer

Are there any clearer symptoms then this? :

"...the G-20 gatherings in Pittsburgh and Toronto were wildly disproportionate for the level of street activity."

Where does all the money come to build this infrastructure? You know where it's coming from, and the rulers are paranoid.



So do we take this lying

So do we take this lying face down in Toxic Mud? Or do we rise up and put down our cellphones, our "Google"..Do we turn our back on major and minor department stores...Do we leave the Wal-Martians to fend for themselves or do we try to bring them to our level of consciousness? Or do we fall in line and live out our time hoping against hope that we don't see the turn before we leave forever?

And what about the Children ?

God Damn.. I say "Gad Damn" The Pusher Man"!



The two parties are as much

The two parties are as much alike as Tweedledum and Tweedledee.

Deals continue to be made not subject to public scrutiny in Washington back rooms and corporate boardrooms.

The solution?

An alternative press that can bring these deals to light and whether or not they are for the collective public good.



read Steinbeck and check

read Steinbeck

and check youtube for
G20 PROOF POLICE IN TORONTO SAW HIRED INSTIGATORS VANDALIZE STORES AND DID NOTHING Pt 1 2 3



Great article. I don't know

Great article. I don't know how Chris Hayes has the time to do everything he does. I love his appearances on MSNBC. It's good to know that there are a few people on TV who really get what's going on.



This article is by Chris

This article is by Chris Hedges, not Chris Hayes. Both are excellent writers and informed progressives.



I think that Manning

I think that Manning personifies the humanity and courage we must find if we are to exercise the fundamental human rights our government "leaders" are stealing from us. We should play Hercules to Manning and Assange's Prometheus and thereby free those men, ourselves, and the truth.



Free Bradley Manning

Free Bradley Manning
Free Bradley Manning
Free Bradley Manning



Chris Hedges has seen it

Chris Hedges has seen it (war after war after war) and is a voice to be listened to. Read also Neil Postman's prescient book "Amusing Ourselves to Death" as well as Farenheight (spelling?) 451 (movie or book). Get off the drug (the web) and show up in person. All this venting online is taking your power away.



Chris Hedges is, as usual,

Chris Hedges is, as usual, spot on. The corporate control of our media is a major contributor to the demise of the middle class and consequently to America. I live in fear for my daughter's generation and the suffering that they will have to experience. I will keep my eye on the corporate automatons.



Chris Hedges has it exactly

Chris Hedges has it exactly right. Fortunately for me I will be dead, but before I go I will press on regardless in the attempt to create a better future based on my own actions. After all, with everything to gain, what do I have to lose? My advice to you all is to do what you can within your individual spheres of influence; eventually, those expanding spheres will intersect and effect a change for the better. Yes, dark days are ahead but they won't last for ever. Change is the one immutable fact of life. Those who can manage change will survive and prosper. Together we can create a more harmonious world and drive back the forces of darkness and bring forth a brighter world harmonious and upright.



Thank you, Chris, again.

Thank you, Chris, again. Finishes off quite well a week of reading Baudrillard's *Agony*, Graeber's *Fragments*, and *The Politics of Obedience*.

I "unliked" Truthout at Facebook before posting your essay, both pages on the screen. And still, within seconds, my Facebook activity was reported on this page. Bread and circuses! and let's all agree to surveillance. So much posting another Truthout article.



Right the hell on, Chris

Right the hell on, Chris Hedges! The only thing you have wrong is, that we're going from Aldous Huxley's "Brave New World"---that is anything but 'brave' or 'good'---to George Orwell/Eric Blair's "1984"... AND BACK TO HUXLEY'S "(UN)BRAVE NEW WORLD", the "New World Order (NWO)", one-world government and one-world religion, all false, extremely evil and gravely detrimental to everyone the world-over, but which will falsely convince most is supposedly their only option, their only escape hatch from the mass-insanity.

The completion of globalization, and cementing the worldwide enslavement in the guise of "the ultimate good", the biggest, final lie, will be presented as our only hope and salvation from all of the ills of the world; when, in reality, it will be the exact opposite; and, as is already very quickly happening, all of our True Liberty(ies) and Freedom(s) are being totally eradicated in the name of corporate-fascism's and counterfeit-"Christianity" so-called's complete subjugation and control of the entire world at everyone's expense...



... Anywho, someone who

...
Anywho, someone who truly "gets" what is really going on. How refreshing from someone who is a part of somewhat "mainstream" journalism. Please keep right on telling it like it is, Chris Hedges, and continue to unflinchingly do so, un-apologetically, courageously, truly patriotically and heroically, no matter what consequences the theocratic corporate-fascist militarized police state, and its oppression and repression, throws your (and/or our) way. Why? Because it is our undoubtable duty to do so for the sake of us all.

What does that "educated fool", Christopher Hitchins', and others like him at The Nation, think of your erudite, no-holds-barred, right-on-the-money "dissertations", as if I couldn't already safely guess? :) Thank you for writing what you do, and telling it like it is as you do.



The Left could stand to

The Left could stand to learn from the so-called "radical Right:" Thank God for the Second Amendment: "The right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."



Absolutely brilliant article

Absolutely brilliant article and interpretation of Huxley and Orwell. I am thoroughly familiar with both of their writings.



Mmmm. And who stands to

Mmmm. And who stands to benefit? Hedges writes with such authority and confidence, suggesting that this is all part of some darkly plotted plan. If so, who's behind it all? On the one hand, it points to a massive conspiracy with a mostly faceless cast of many thousands including such visible luminaries as Oprah and Obama. If that seems too incredible, the other alternative seems equally incredible - that it is all part of a much larger game directed by profoundly malevolent unseen, supernatural hand. So, which is it to be? Pick your poison!



who is behind all? well, i

who is behind all? well, i hate to say it, but "hope" is behind all. we, all of us, are letting this happen in hope that we may be the ones to profit from it one day. hope and fear complete the cycle. it's only possible when we keep hearing stories of poor kid becoming a rich "businessman", or a minority president. soooo few among masses, yet effective enough to keep us think/hoping it's possible and yield what's coming head-on to smash us. so right about what's nader, chomsky and others alike are facing. it upsets me hearing my democrat friends still saying nader has split the votes and is responsible for the bush administration... that's marginalization. so sad. one last thing, nothing is free, your free gps satellites, free internet search, free anything... that's just your regular drug dealers' business model.



I could not put it better

I could not put it better myself. I just finished re-reading, actually listening to, 1984. I wanted to get some people together to discuss this but when I saw Kate Gosselin was going to be on Sarah Palins reality show, Alaska, we opted out to watch that instead...



There are not enough martyrs

There are not enough martyrs at the airports.

We need to act up EVERY TIME we are groped and herded. EVERY TIME.

And the rest of us should support the fallen.

That woman who was thrown to the ground last week because she resisted gate rape... where are her heroes???

Janet Napolitano and her buzz cuts should not be allowed to grope our women and children.

There is a sexual side to this that nobody speaks of.



What is evil? Evil is not

What is evil?
Evil is not merely wrongdoing that disregards another's rights. Evil is wrongdoing disguised as good. That goes for our shadow-government and its corporate puppeteer.
The only vote we have that still counts is the one we make everyday with our wallets.
Waking up means unplugging from the mindless consumerism of the marketing matrix. Boycotting corporate products is getting harder due to mergers and acquisitions. It requires voluntary simplicity of lifestyle; liberation from the tar pits of materialism. It will take radical freedom and courage. Start with food purchases. No fast food, no corporate processed food--it's all poison anyway. Take it from there...



Don't forget the novel "We"

Don't forget the novel "We" by Zamyatin, written in 1921, that inspired both novels.



The object of wealth is

The object of wealth is wealth. That's what drives the corporate machine.



Ah, no, Mr. Gart, the object

Ah, no, Mr. Gart, the object of wealth is power. Power is never relinquished of its own accord. It must be pried from the grip of the powerful.

Remember, "we are not helpless, we are many. What lies between us can be set aside and ended..." When we see that we are all in this together, we will be able to overthrow the oppressors, but until then.

The GOP and their masters are very, very good at dividing us and making us hate each other. Stopper your ears and make friends with your enemies. We are all in danger.



I am considering last

I am considering last Monday's Chris Hedges column to be the State of the Union message for the remaining years of human history, a document as important or more so than the much revered Declaration of Independence. Mr. Hedges clearly defines what we have lost and where we are going unless some drastic actions are taken, such as people taking the political realm much more seriously.



Chris misses the bigger

Chris misses the bigger picture.... this is the result of egalitarianism and secularism, a continual devolution in the West from the Great Schism on down 'til today.



The prospect of a

The prospect of a "civilisation" disrupting catastrophe in 2012 is starting to look like the last best hope for freedom.

Interesting that NASA is forecasting massive damage to electrical infrastructure from solar flares in that year. It might just turn out to be a good thing.



NeExuLfRVunj

nw6Nfu uxuigeulqmqp, [url=http://xzggguawwsmm.com/]xzggguawwsmm[/url], [link=http://dejixscioomw.com/]dejixscioomw[/link], http://rzzxnyfaodpp.com/



IvPPlwWmiHKdl

KtyVEw ogzyqufgrkpf, [url=http://mrharcvrgksv.com/]mrharcvrgksv[/url], [link=http://exquotjothnz.com/]exquotjothnz[/link], http://jmwrgrkgnhly.com/



CEaylJgDBhxq

Xt6Gy7 famnerjxorkx, [url=http://hqcguorvrlbw.com/]hqcguorvrlbw[/url], [link=http://vpknevzcrcdp.com/]vpknevzcrcdp[/link], http://toduejnipdoq.com/



iPhmckzqrSKopN

1kwxGJ ioolrfamvpiw, [url=http://sfkccxrxwqyz.com/]sfkccxrxwqyz[/url], [link=http://djordincxdnd.com/]djordincxdnd[/link], http://wbnmizqfzikp.com/



dKNrwpGXshRF

uqHODj vtzhxgqmxnzj, [url=http://gpmcqepfqcfh.com/]gpmcqepfqcfh[/url], [link=http://jnmzbfujazql.com/]jnmzbfujazql[/link], http://lhibalffgcnf.com/