A Disturbing Meeting at the Gym
Saturday 08 January 2011
by: Dave Lindorff | This Can't Be Happening | Op-Ed
At the local YMCA today, I ran into a boy who was a childhood friend of my son's. As my kid goes to a public arts high school in Philadelphia outside of our local school district, I don't see much of his old grade-school friends any more. This boy, who used to be over at our house years ago at least once a week, recognized me right away though, and said, "Hey Mr. Lindorff, I haven't seen you in years. How's Jed!"
I was impressed by how he'd grown up, tall and strong looking. He was headed for the basketball court. I asked him, since both he and my son are seniors this year, where he was applying for college, and he stunned me by saying he had signed up for the Marines. "I'm going to be going in after graduation," he said proudly. "The recruiter came to school, and he convinced me it's a good move."
I asked him what he planned to do, and he said, "Helicopter gunner! I'm really excited and proud!"
This was really shocking. This kid doesn't own a gun. I doubt if he's ever shot at anything except maybe a target with a .22 rifle at Boy Scout Camp, and now he's all excited about manning a machine gun in a helicopter, where he'll be shooting down at Afghan fighters--and inevitably at civilians, too--in a matter of months.
I really didn't know what to say. I awkwardly told him "congratulations," because I could see he was proud of his "accomplishment" and because I didn't want to have him cut me off as a possible confidante. Then I added, "You know of course that I'm not really in favor of what the Marines are doing?"
He smiled and said, "Yeah, I know."
"Well, good luck and stay safe," I said, again not knowing what else to say. How could I, standing in the hall there, tell him that he was simply signing on to be another expendable tool in the American Empire's effort to subdue an impoverished people on the far side of the world who pose absolutely no threat to America? And while I don't want to see him killing people in Afghanistan, I also want him to come home safely.
Unaware of my conflicted state of mind, and of how upset I was at his news, he ran off to play his game, at least for now still just another kid on a basketball court.
I had finished my run, so I headed for the exit to get my car and go home, when I ran into the boy's mother and older sister, both just coming into the building. I hadn't seen either of them in at least a year either.
They both greeted me and asked how my family was, and what my son's college plans were. After I had caught them up, I said, a bit hesitantly, "I ran into your son. He told me he's joining the Marines."
His mother looked upset and said, "Yes. I don't know. We were going over colleges with him, and getting ready to work on his applications, and then he told us he wanted to enlist."
"I hear he's going to be a helicopter gunner," I said.
The mother stiffened and looked at her daughter, a senior in college who looked surprised, too. "He said he was going to be a helicopter mechanic!" she said.
"Oops," I told them. "I guess I shouldn't have said anything."
"No," she said. "I'm going to have to talk with him. But the trouble is, if that's what he says he's going to do, there's nothing we can do to stop him."
Well, maybe, and maybe not. I'd certainly try if it were my son, starting with showing him that horrifying footage of a bloodthirsty US helicopter crew's joke-filled slaughter of a bunch of innocent civilians in Baghdad, including two employers of Reuters. I'd also have him read the letter of apology to the Iraqi victims' families, written by two soldiers, former Army Specialists Josh Stieber and Ethan McCord, who had appeared in that video because they came on the scene of slaughter at the end, and realized what had been done was an atrocity.
But while it may tragically be too late for my son's childhood friend, who has already signed on the dotted line, there is something we can do to stop more of this kind of thing from happening, and that is to protest the actions of Marine recruiters and recruiters from the other branches of the military in our public high schools.
The schools have been told, thanks to a law passed by Congress, that they must allow recruiters into high schools to speak with students and to try to lure them into signing up. Parents have a right to have their children's names removed from recruiting lists so they won't be personally invited to meet with a recruiter, or get recruiting literature sent to them, but they are still free when roaming the halls, to go see a recruiter on their own.
The only answer to this effort to suck our kids into service of the Empire as more cannon-fodder is to demand, and to provide, an alternative. Contact your local Veterans for Peace chapter or nearest Iraq Veterans Against the War Chapter, and urge them to send a representative to talk sense and reality to the kids at your high school. If you're a veteran, volunteer to go yourself, and tell kids why signing up is a bad idea. If you're not a veteran, or relative of a veteran, get people with experience to go and tell what war is really about, and about why it's not what America should be doing. (Colleague John Grant, who is with VfP, says don't expect getting a counter-recruitment presence in your high school to be easy. Most schools only allow such speakers to go to a specific teacher's classroom, not to an assembly session, whereas the most appropriate thing would be to have access to match whatever the recruiters are offered. That doesn't mean VfP or IVAW activists aren't anxious to get access, so contact them and try to get them to the kids.)
If you want a good argument, check out the little film at the bottom of our home page, which quotes Marine Brigadier General Smedley Butler, and is addressed to parents, and particularly mothers of young children.
Stop the propagandizing of our kids into becoming soldiers for Empire. We've had enough death and killing!
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
I agree that recruiters
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 10:07 — Anonymous (not verified)I agree that recruiters should not be allowed in the high schools. Our kids are impressionable and believe all that rah-rah about the military and the glamour of war. No one wins in a war. This is evident in our useless wars in Iraq and Afganistan.
I have learned, since
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 10:50 — Dave Lindorff (not verified)I have learned, since writing this article, that in fact the students who are lured into signing up for military duty by high school recruiters are generally brought in under the so-called Deferred Enlistment Program (DEP), and that this is not irreversible. These kids can back out of their agreement, despite whatever they have signed, right up until the moment they step on the bus to go to basic training.
Any one who has trouble getting out of a DEP sign-up should immediately contact the GI Bill of Rights organization (www.gibillofrights.org tel: 877-477-4487), which has experts including lawyers who can help.
Dave Lindorff
www.thiscantbehappening.net
The Arizona gunner is
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 11:17 — Vic Anderson (not verified)The Arizona gunner is mentally ill (schizoprenic); Bully Puppet Obama and his DEMiserepubilkans have no such alibi for their global policy of murderous Manifest Insanity.
CORRECTION! The organization
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 12:12 — Dave LIndorff (not verified)CORRECTION!
The organization to go to for help in getting out of a high school recruitment is:
The GI Rights Hotline
The website is:
www.girightshotline.org
The phone is: 877-477-4487
Sorry for the confusion.
Dave Lindorff
www.thiscantbehappening.net
We should demand equal time
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 15:23 — jruss (not verified)We should demand equal time to show video clips of soldiers being treated at Walter Reed hospital and the horrific injuries they've suffered--nothing censored. Also footage of the massacres in Iraq by Blackwater mercenaries and US soldiers. It's hard to overcome the simplistic rhetoric of the Army and Marine recruiters--nonsense about "fighting them over there so we don't have to over here." Kudos to parents who make the effort to send their kids to alternative schools where they get an enlightened world view and not that of the corporate dominated media. JR
As an ex-marine, I can tell
Mon, 01/10/2011 - 21:12 — mysterioso (not verified)As an ex-marine, I can tell you that you can't pick ahead of time what you want to do in the corps. And, your recruiter can't either. You go through a battery of tests - physical, mental, marksmanship and psychological that will determine your "MOS", military occupational specialty. This kid was yanking your chain Mr. Lindorff.
Or the recruiter was yanking
Tue, 01/11/2011 - 08:22 — Dave Lindorff (not verified)Or the recruiter was yanking his...
Don't blame The Marines for
Tue, 01/11/2011 - 08:44 — Anonymous (not verified)Don't blame The Marines for what the government and politicians are doing. Soldiers follow orders. If you want to change those orders, change the people in the chain of command who issue them.
Military service is an honorable calling. Don't fault the military for the actions of politicians and a corrupted officer corps.
Most of the people who join
Tue, 01/11/2011 - 16:43 — Dave Lindorff (not verified)Most of the people who join the service for other than purely economic reasons do so out of good intentions, I agree, but they are also for the most part terribly misinformed.
When the US invaded Iraq, it was a war crime, because Iraq did not pose an imminent threat, which is the only legal justification for an invasion of another country.
The proper thing for American troops then would have been and continues to be to disobey that illegal order to invade.
The invasion of Afghanistan was justified as a need to take out Al Qaeda, and the government that had hosted him and his gang. That was accomplished in short order. Al Qaeda is gone, and the Taliban was ousted, but the US kept occupying Afghanistan, propping up a corrupt narco-government. Now we are occupiers, and our role again has become criminal.
Again, the proper stance of an honorable soldier is to refuse to fight.
I'll tell you what: I'll honor the intentions those who sign up, if you'll defend those who stand down on principle.
Dave Lindorff
ThisCantBeHappening!
Canada Goose Hinta
Mon, 10/29/2012 - 13:48 — Canada Goose Hinta (not verified)On people will show who could understand the cords holding up the actual spaceships¡±
Ralph Lauren Shop
Mon, 01/21/2013 - 13:39 — Ralph Lauren Shop (not verified)http://www.fzmconsultoria.com/index.php/component/k2/item/4-available-vacancies/4-available-vacancies?start=810
Scarpe Calcio
Fri, 01/25/2013 - 21:28 — Scarpe Calcio (not verified)"You may possibly need to alter that last line," Rob said.
Longchamps Outlet
Thu, 01/31/2013 - 01:21 — Longchamps Outlet (not verified)Spontaneity. Perfection is actually a solution to be in manage. But manage limits spontaneity.
www.adidasjeremyscott.ias3.com/
Mon, 04/15/2013 - 01:20 — www.adidasjeremyscott.ias3.com/ (not verified)grasp a lot of brand-new merchandise beneath in contrast to anybody or else!