A Marine Remembers: Learning to Kill, Learning Not to Kill
Wednesday 02 February 2011
by: David Lindorff | This Can't Be Happening | Op-Ed
One of my grandsons recently asked me, “What is wisdom?” After some discussion, we together concluded that wisdom comes only with experience.
When it comes to war, though, living in a country that has not experienced a war on its own soil since 1865, Americans, other than those veterans who have actually fought abroad, have no such experience to draw on.
Perhaps this is why so many Americans easily accept, and even cheer the nation’s militarism, and why most of us accept our government’s reflexive resort to military action to settle international disputes.
Einstein, who had his share of wisdom, advised forgetting everything one has learned. This was his way of getting his thinking out of a box.
Rather than add more to this somewhat evasive notion, let me reflect here on my own experience of war, and on how the concept of war has permeated my life, in hopes of finding a bit of wisdom to counter the temptation to turn to cynicism.
“The war to end all wars” ended four years before I was born. The patriotic fervor that had induced men to fight and kill in WW I was still alive at that time, although my father’s courage as a medic in France, for which he received a silver star, had left a psychic scar. He had seen more than his share of death, including that of his best friend, who had gone to war despite opposing it, asking to become a machine-gunner to counter accusations that his anti-war sentiment was a reflection of cowardice.
It wasn’t until I was in my 20s that I was drafted into the Marines. (Actually, I chose the Marines out of the Navy pool.) This time, in WW II, there was a sense of duty, but no fervor.
Boot camp was my first experience at someone trying to indoctrinate me with the code: ‘’To hate the enemy is a requirement."
While I didn't become a slave to this principle myself, most of the men in the platoon bought it. We were told over and over that a soldier’s mission is to kill, and that message sank in for most of the recruits. To help drive the message home, with our bayonets attached, we were ordered to assault dummies while shouting "Kill!"
After boot camp, just before my platoon shipped out for the assault on Iwo Jima, I was transferred to a technical assignment working on the development of air-borne radar, but while that transfer probably saved my life, it left me with a sense of guilt that I was abandoning my platoon to face the slaughter without me. Later I met another survivor from the platoon who said he had shot himself in the foot to miss the invasion. That was his source of guilt. Only one man in the platoon had survived the initial landing, I learned later.
How did this indoctrination process apply to the atomic bomb, and the killing of hundreds of thousands of civilians? The face-to-face killing in this case was missing, but the scale of killing was multiplied thousands-fold.
I knew the man who developed the switch used for releasing the two atomic bombs used against Japan. The actual bombing was far removed from his reality.
As for myself, it took years for me to realize the tragic nature of such acts, in which I had played a small part. Years later, in conversation with a German who had experienced the Allied fire-bombing of Darmstadt, which destroyed the entire city, I learned first-hand of the horror such bombing of a purely non-military city had wreaked.
On the other side, a one-time American bombardier told me he had become so inured to what he was doing that he could as well have pulled the lever over New York City, if ordered to do so.
Today our military has pilotless attack drones flying over Pakistan, controlled by military personnel who sit comfortably with cups of coffee at their desktop computer monitors in Nevada. As such automated killing takes over, the question becomes, “Who is the robot?
How does one approach the humanistic ideal of pacifism, when war, like a cancer, has no cure?
Jack Kennedy mused, “There will always be war.”
Seeing our nation fighting a supposed war with terrorism for 10 years, with no end in sight, lends reality to that grim prediction.
With the deployment of ever more sophisticated weaponry that separates the actual killing from the killer, and the whole process of war from the broader public, has America become a modern warrior nation?
Wisdom doesn’t come cheap. Einstein admitted, “Writing the letter to Roosevelt advocating development of the atomic bomb was the biggest mistake of my life.”
And here I am still dutifully paying my taxes.
DAVID LINDORFF, father of TCBH founder DAVE LINDORFF, is a retired professor of electrical engineering, and a Jungian analyst based in Storrs, CT. He is author of the book Pauli and Jung: A Meeting of Two Great Minds (Quest Books, 2010).
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Pretty funny, and confusing.
Fri, 02/04/2011 - 12:55 — Pretty Funny (not verified)Pretty funny, and confusing. Was there a point to this article? Or just an outlet for long-carried guilt? Mr Lindorff's service to our country is commendable, although his guilt is misplaced. Due to the vagaries of military service he was removed from the path that would have taken him to combat. Having met with a similar fate myself, I understand his pain.
As to his quote from President Kennedy, my former flying squadron had a saying, "Only the dead have seen the end of war." There will always be someone, some nation, who thinks he's the biggest kid on the block and therefore unreproachable. Too often those kids need to be taken down a notch or two. Unfortunate, but true.
To "Pretty funny, and
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 00:15 — Of monkeys and men (not verified)To "Pretty funny, and confusing"...
Seems to me that Mr. Lindorff is sharing incredible insight about the true nature of war. Stripped of its symbolism and propaganda (i.e. taking down that faceless bully of yours), wars have more often than not involved people who have no reason to want to kill each other besides being told to do so doing just that. History reveals a common through line for the motive: manipulation of the causes for war by those who have everything to gain from the actions and outcomes of it. Some people are aware, or awakening to these notions of manipulation and control, and they get it. And I guess there will always be those who'll just giggle away what they find uncomfortable or out of their grasp.
Bring the war home. Let
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 06:11 — Anonymous (not verified)Bring the war home. Let America experience a little of what it has been inflicting on others since 1944. How appalled we were about the twin towers in NYC. But that was NOTHING compared to Nagasaki, Hiroshima, Tokyo, Dresden, Hamburg, Hue, Baghdad, Falluja & on & on. A little taste of their own medicine wouldn't hurt America at all. The USAF continues to do what it does best, which is bombing civilians. True to form, the bully America rarely picks on anyone who can fight back.
Semper Fi, A$$hole. Don't
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 06:36 — Anonymous (not verified)Semper Fi, A$$hole. Don't cry me no tears.
The author of "Semper Fi
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 11:37 — Dave Lindorff (not verified)The author of "Semper Fi A$$hole" illustrates the unfortunate attitude of those soldiers and Marines who are successfully indoctrinated by the military. Semper Fi to what? Certainly in this particular writer's attitude, assuming he is a Marine (though one would think that someone from an outfit that claims to be courageous would not hide behind an anonymous posting!), bespeaks the idea that it's fidelity to the Marines, but that is not what a service person swears allegiance to. They swear to defend the Constitution. Speaking out against unjust or illegal wars and against the war crimes that have been committed in those wars, as my father has done, or as Gen. Smedley Butler, the most decorated Marine in the history of the Marines did, when he said "War is a racket!" is showing fidelity to the Constitution, and consequently to the Marines, who are supposed to be defending that document.
Abercrombie Brugge
Tue, 12/25/2012 - 21:01 — Abercrombie Brugge (not verified)Is one place that has to be of service for yourself!
Adidas Schoenen
Wed, 01/09/2013 - 15:11 — Adidas Schoenen (not verified)Inquisitive to find out what whatever you intellectuals must state about this?*?:.
Louis Vuitton Tassen
Mon, 01/21/2013 - 13:24 — Louis Vuitton Tassen (not verified)http://hv7.ru/servisy/novosti/k2-item?start=6120