American Chernobyl

by: Hervé Kempf  |  Reporterre.ne | Op-Ed

American Chernobyl
A never-completed nuclear power plant close to the epicenter of the Chernobyl disaster in Ukraine, Soviet Socialist Republic in 1986. (Photo: Stuck in Customs / Flickr)

An uncontrollable industrial catastrophe, a worm-eaten system controlled by a rigid nomenklatura, a dynamic leader who wants to change things: doesn't that remind you of something? Yes, of course: Chernobyl, the Soviet Communist Party, Gorbachev.

Let's recall the 1980s: during that era, people knew that the USSR was doing poorly, but who would have bet a franc or a dollar on its rapid collapse? Still less so, given that the country had found an appealing and modern leader. From the outset, Gorbachev committed to vigorous reforms (glasnost and perestroika) even as he changed the USSR's foreign policy through detente with Ronald Reagan.

And then Chernobyl exploded. The catastrophe revealed the system's fragility. In 1989, the Berlin Wall crumbled; in 1991, the USSR was dissolved. Russia entered a decade of hard economic recession.

People today know that the United States isn't doing well, but who would bet a Euro or a Yuan on that country's rapid collapse? Still less so, given that the country has elected an appealing and modern leader. From the outset, he committed to vigorous reforms (the stimulus and the healthcare law) even as he acknowledged that the United States could no longer run everything in the world.

And then Deepwater Horizon exploded... The unstoppable gushing of oil provoked is proving to be a historic environmental catastrophe. It simultaneously demonstrates the incompetence of big private companies and (after a first failure during Hurricane Katrina, in 2005) the state's inability to master the situation.

Like Chernobyl, Deepwater Horizon derives its meaning from its context - that of a society dominated by a capitalist oligarchy that rejects any in-depth change in spite of the financial disaster for which it is responsible. Wall Street remains as solidly attached to its privileges, as were Soviet dignitaries.

Moreover, politicians, advertising and media maintain the fiction that the American dream can endure without disruption. But a pillar of American power has been shaken: that of cheap energy. Mr. Obama tries to make his fellow citizens understand: "What we can predict is that the availability of fossil fuel is going to be diminishing; that it's going to get more expensive to recover; that there are going to be environmental costs that our children, our grandchildren and our great-grandchildren are going to have to bear," he said in a June 13 Politico.com interview.

The end of cheap oil is the end of the "American way of life." Will the United States stand up to the challenge? One may think they will. Or not.
 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Leslie Thatcher is Truthout's literary editor, French translator and sometime book reviewer.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Interesting! Somewhat uneasy

Interesting! Somewhat uneasy comparison though. Bit of a stretch, with respect to political structure of the USSR in the 1980's and its vulnerability with regard to geographic scope. If or as the USA loses world 'powership' over coming years, I don't believe it will include such territorial fragmenting as the USSR underwent. Also, the attempt to connection the tragedy of the Oil gush, corporate power, hurricane Katrina, Wall Street, the need for better energy sources and the children, is kinda jagged.

Piece needed to be longer perhaps. So much to say, yet so few words used. Good point though: Vibrant, forward thinking leaders, empires experiencing a gut punch, environmental disasters caused by risks taken to obtain energy.



Funny how a moron bent on

Funny how a moron bent on destroying America like Barack Obama can just "pretend" that he's one of the masses when it is obvious to everyone around him that he is Bush but worse.

As much as I hate Bush, at least he said what he was going to do and then did it. Obama pretends to be for the people and then stabs them in the back.

It'll be a wonderful day when that piece of crap ends up where he belongs and all pieces of sh*t belong, in the crapper!



The Establishment's indeed

The Establishment's indeed gone NUKING FUTS, especially with a serially lying DEM reneger "at the helm". So it's time for the BOWEL (Barack Obama's Worth Ever Less) Movement! Only 934 days To GO!



The enormity of our energy

The enormity of our energy situation today began 50 years ago when the consequences of foreign oil and climate change were little thought about except for Carter in the late 70's. To blame any recent president for the crisis we are now in is just blowing smoke. The blame for the crisis is fully in the hands of Big Oil who use the crisis to make enormous profits and keep drilling and to do so when they know that oil is no longer a competitive energy source. Only T Boone Pickens is capitalizing on the future of energy by trying to change from oil to natural gas and wind.



"The enormity of our

"The enormity of our energy"...hits the mark!!
50 years of inattention has finally come to a head in DWH..Natural Gas has been around for 60 years or longer yet it has been underutilized..Why??
No American President other than perhaps Carter has had the training or aptitude to even begin deal with the Gulf Well From Hell now spewing..

Fact is; there was never a need for it to be drilled in the first place...65% (or more) of ALL oil discovered in North America.IS STILL IN THE GROUND!!!...



Chernobyl is an apt

Chernobyl is an apt comparison. Instead of radioactive poisons, we have benzene, hydrochloric acid (from oil+sea salt), and a huge bubble of methane ready to pop. And of course, an absence of life in the northern Gulf, possibly beyond. The horror, the horror ...

Now that's change we can believe in, ... or die.



Some seriously mentally

Some seriously mentally unhinged 'commentators' here. The sites duty is to see they get treatment before they harm themselves or others.



I couldn't agree more. It

I couldn't agree more. It was a running joke in America that Soviet leaders would tell their people that Chernobyl was a minor nuclear incident and nothing to be alarmed about.

The current amount of oil initially being reported has grown 10 fold. It is doubtful that anything being told to the public is factual.

This is a complete breakdown of government. -The inability to tell the public the truth of the situation is mind boggling.



LFOD is at it again. "Funny

LFOD is at it again.

"Funny how a moron bent on destroying the Soviet Union like Mikhail Gorbachev can just 'pretend' that he's one of the masses when it is obvious to everyone around him that he is Stalin but worse."

Remember those old Stalinista ladies with their fur hats and Uncle Joe posters out in Red Square?

ROFL!



The BP Oil Volcano is like

The BP Oil Volcano is like Chernobyl in several ways. The Chernobyl reactor was known to be a defective design. When it failed, the Chernobyl reactor was being deliberately operated in an unsafe manner that violated government standards. The Soviets tried their best to cover up the disaster, and it poisoned a large area and killed many people and disrupted the lives of many others.

Unlike the BP Oil Volcano, the nuclear (sorry, nucular) people knew what to do to contain the explosion by helicoptering tons of absorbent material into the reactor. People outside the Soviet Union could see what was going on by monitoring the atmosphere and looking at satellite photos. And with Chernobyl, there was no apparent profit motive. Although the reactor itself might be unstable, Chernobyl did stop the radiation leak and limited the long-term danger to the planet.

I believe that we can safely say that the BP Oil Volcano disaster will prove to be a whole lot worse than Chernobyl. This is a Krakatoa-level event.



The oil spill is the same

The oil spill is the same thing our corporations have been doing to the rest of the world for decades. Remember Union Carbide at Bhopal and the Chevron toxic spill in the Ecuadorian rain forest? As the US approaches 3rd world status, we get the same treatment.



just read in the times of

just read in the times of london that new data suggest that as much as a billion barrels of oil could plausibly spill into the gulf and atlantic and not stop until the reserve is emptied in as long as a decade from now. who knows if or when this will appear in american media?

at least the spill isn't radioactive... but then the IAEI stated flatly in 2000 that there would definitely be more chernobyls, considering there are 440 nuclear power plants dotting the planet like measles... most of which are very old and impossibly expensive to clean up or make truly safe. so naturally, obama gives the GOP first $18.5 billion in the insipid 'stimulus' to build new nuclear power plants and now i sse that is being upped by more billions. i say, build plants under the white house, capitol hil, pentagon, CIA, NSA and the bush ranch.



Fine. We got it. Most

Fine. We got it. Most corporations are 'bad,' and Obama is also bad because he works for the bad corporations that own 'our' government.

And BP has nuked the Gulf of Mexico. We got that, too. Hit a jugular vein, can't stop the bleeding.

What we CAN do is save millions of Americans now living in a Toxic Waste Zone. Instead of ranting and raving about who did or didn't do what, we should be focused on the one thing we can accomplish - getting as many as possible out of harm's way ASAP. Cause our fellow Americans living in the Gulf of Mexico clearly are too shocked and angry and sad to evacuate themselves...



Uranium remains

Uranium remains radioactively toxic, mutagenic and carcinogenic to all life for millions years.

Had the BP oil disaster been a nuclear catastrophe it would affect not just one species or one generation. It would be increasingly toxic to all life for all time.

The inconceivably long periods of time these radioactive toxins last make the issue of eliminating the production of nuclear materials an urgent matter.

Here, the need for scientific, spiritual, religious and political wisdom merges. The necessity for overlapping “checks and balances” becomes essential not only to protect our own lives or the lives of our children. We are left with the imperative to develop the ethical insight and political will to protect all life.



"An uncontrollable

"An uncontrollable industrial catastrophe, a worm-eaten system controlled by a rigid nomenklatura, a dynamic leader who wants to change things"

Gets off on the wrong foot. We don't have a leader who wants to change things.



tazdelaney...@20:54 Could

tazdelaney...@20:54

Could you please give us that link to the article in the London Times?



Bad Person Tony Hayward got

Bad Person Tony Hayward got his life back. Our Big Polluter will mitigate it's awkward situation -- expect a change of name. Even though the Supreme Court said that corporations are indeed persons, there will be no criminal proceedings against those responsible for the disaster in the Gulf. We will redouble our misguided efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Big People will escape with their loot increased and the Little People will continue to give their lives and treasure in service to the Corporations and be deluded by various petty demagogues.



LFOD: Wowza. Did you

LFOD: Wowza. Did you notice, for example, baby bush's "Mission Accomplished", etc.? Never argue with someone who knows they're right. With the derision of "reality based thinking" I've had enough. Most all people have had enough. Protest and survive.



Amusing to see a few racist

Amusing to see a few racist Obama haters here. As if he caused this catastrophe? As if anyone has a solution right now? As if Obama isn't forcing BP to cough up $20 billion while the "drill, baby, drill" Republicans are apologizing to BP for this so-called "slush fund"? Thank the stars it's Obama at the helm now and not a Republican!



Can anyone imagine either

Can anyone imagine either John McCain or Sarah Palin leading us out of this disaster??

And, has no one remembered that the estimates for pulling the US out of this recession were in the 8 to 10 year range?

Further, haven't you wondered if both political parties were trying to LOSE this last election ...because the winner was doomed to failure. None of this can be fixed in 4 years.

I can hear the "Machiavellis" in the back rooms:

DEM - "American is not ready for a president of color. Let's run Obama, then wait for 2012 and see what happens."

REP - "John is starting to look pretty good. Let's give him Palin for a running mate ...then wait for 2012 and see what happens."

Now we have an UNnatural disaster to make the situation even more difficult. The right wing-nuts like to call it Obama's "Katrina." Perhaps Obama did not respond as rapidly or effectively as everyone wanted, but he only knew what BP could/would tell him. In the case of Katrina (the Bush disaster), we KNEW what was coming and how devastating it was going to be. Bush's lack of effective response was unforgivable.



To Brenda Helverson: If you

To Brenda Helverson: If you think another Krakatoa would be scary, take a look at this:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dk-matai/gulf-of-mexico-danger-of_b_619095.html



Chern what?it's the red neck

Chern what?it's the red neck riviera and who cares anyway, i'm to busy making lemonaide



Oh, dear, Anonymous on 6/22

Oh, dear, Anonymous on 6/22 at 19:03! Quick! Stand up! You're sitting on your brain again . . .



That's it, Vic Anderson;

That's it, Vic Anderson; enough of your Obama bashing. Every problem in America is not solved by Obama bashing. You need to get back in this thread and say EXACTLY whom you want to be President AND WHY! I heard you were a Vet, and tried to respect you but you're so disrespectful yourself, I'm not above harassing the good people at T/O to CUT YOU THE FRICK OFF!



gucci handbag outlet

look at gucci bags online for gift suMwEdSC http://guccibagsoutlet.urbanblog.dk/



chanel online store usa

you will like chanel online shop online shopping sdCXHWXZ http://chanelonlineshop1.mzk-pulawy.pl/



gucci handbags uk

look at gucci online uk to get new coupon RtYWWwpS http://www.blogvan.nl/gucciuk/



hermes bags outlet

check hermes outlet online shopping cCHRWfLx http://www.hermes--outlet.net/



sieipw

cdocxgkt



yHrRpPKrQDiXxlYSIV

H5HEQm navyeoxcfqan, [url=http://lfjqpzgnijix.com/]lfjqpzgnijix[/url], [link=http://kvnoaxjprcmz.com/]kvnoaxjprcmz[/link], http://bjycylytyweo.com/