Know-Nothing Politics

by: Paul Krugman  |  The New York Times

Know-Nothing Politics
(Illustration: Glenn McCoy)

    So the G.O.P. has found its issue for the 2008 election. For the next three months the party plans to keep chanting: "Drill here! Drill now! Drill here! Drill now! Four legs good, two legs bad!" O.K., I added that last part.

    And the debate on energy policy has helped me find the words for something I've been thinking about for a while. Republicans, once hailed as the "party of ideas," have become the party of stupid.

    Now, I don't mean that G.O.P. politicians are, on average, any dumber than their Democratic counterparts. And I certainly don't mean to question the often frightening smarts of Republican political operatives.

    What I mean, instead, is that know-nothingism - the insistence that there are simple, brute-force, instant-gratification answers to every problem, and that there's something effeminate and weak about anyone who suggests otherwise - has become the core of Republican policy and political strategy. The party's de facto slogan has become: "Real men don't think things through."

    In the case of oil, this takes the form of pretending that more drilling would produce fast relief at the gas pump. In fact, earlier this week Republicans in Congress actually claimed credit for the recent fall in oil prices: "The market is responding to the fact that we are here talking," said Representative John Shadegg.

    What about the experts at the Department of Energy who say that it would take years before offshore drilling would yield any oil at all, and that even then the effect on prices at the pump would be "insignificant"? Presumably they're just a bunch of wimps, probably Democrats. And the Democrats, as Representative Michele Bachmann assures us, "want Americans to move to the urban core, live in tenements, take light rail to their government jobs."

    Is this political pitch too dumb to succeed? Don't count on it.

    Remember how the Iraq war was sold. The stuff about aluminum tubes and mushroom clouds was just window dressing. The main political argument was, "They attacked us, and we're going to strike back" - and anyone who tried to point out that Saddam and Osama weren't the same person was an effete snob who hated America, and probably looked French.

    Let's also not forget that for years President Bush was the center of a cult of personality that lionized him as a real-world Forrest Gump, a simple man who prevails through his gut instincts and moral superiority. "Mr. Bush is the triumph of the seemingly average American man," declared Peggy Noonan, writing in The Wall Street Journal in 2004. "He's not an intellectual. Intellectuals start all the trouble in the world."

    It wasn't until Hurricane Katrina - when the heckuva job done by the man of whom Ms. Noonan said, "if there's a fire on the block, he'll run out and help" revealed the true costs of obliviousness - that the cult began to fade.

    What's more, the politics of stupidity didn't just appeal to the poorly informed. Bear in mind that members of the political and media elites were more pro-war than the public at large in the fall of 2002, even though the flimsiness of the case for invading Iraq should have been even more obvious to those paying close attention to the issue than it was to the average voter.

    Why were the elite so hawkish? Well, I heard a number of people express privately the argument that some influential commentators made publicly - that the war was a good idea, not because Iraq posed a real threat, but because beating up someone in the Middle East, never mind who, would show Muslims that we mean business. In other words, even alleged wise men bought into the idea of macho posturing as policy.

    All this is in the past. But the state of the energy debate shows that Republicans, despite Mr. Bush's plunge into record unpopularity and their defeat in 2006, still think that know-nothing politics works. And they may be right.

    Sad to say, the current drill-and-burn campaign is getting some political traction. According to one recent poll, 69 percent of Americans now favor expanded offshore drilling - and 51 percent of them believe that removing restrictions on drilling would reduce gas prices within a year.

    The headway Republicans are making on this issue won't prevent Democrats from expanding their majority in Congress, but it might limit their gains - and could conceivably swing the presidential election, where the polls show a much closer race.

    In any case, remember this the next time someone calls for an end to partisanship, for working together to solve the country's problems. It's not going to happen - not as long as one of America's two great parties believes that when it comes to politics, stupidity is the best policy.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Hillarious! If it wasn't so

Hillarious! If it wasn't so sad. Is it stupidity, or is it evil? I think it's evil greed. The pod people can go their way and I'm going mine.


The choise is yours to make,

The choise is yours to make, Americans:) Stand up, wake up and make the world a safer and better place:) Have our kids look back at the 2010´s where responsibility came back to life... One. One voice.


Although I agree with the

Although I agree with the majority of your points, I have to take issue with the idea of the polls showing a possible Republican win in the presidential race. I just don't find it conceivable. What I see happening across America is a public waking up to the fact that Republicans no longer represent their interests. When comparing the enthusiastic turnout Obama experiences anywhere he shows up, to the tepid-at-best responses McCain receives, it's pretty clear which way the wind is blowing. When you add to that the fact that voter registrations have exploded across the country to record levels, it looks to me like McCain is about to get hit ass handed to him on a platter. So why do the polls show the race being close? I think it's because of the simple fact that polls are only conducted with people who have telephone land lines. The fact that Obama enjoys his biggest support from the same age group (40 and under) that has made the biggest leap from land lines to cell phones suggests to me that the polls aren't even beginning to give us a clear picture of public sentiment. At least that's my hope. The idea that the majority of my fellow Americans are stupid enough to vote for McCain is just too depressing to contemplate. As an aside, Paul, my Mom worked for Samuelson and Solow next door to you at MIT. How's that for pointy-headed elitist bonafides?


The truth is hard to find,

The truth is hard to find, and it often smells bad. Who needs it? Power and money can be attained by despising it. And 'twas ever thus.


Could not have said it

Could not have said it better myself. Seems these days Americans come mostly in two versions - stupid and more stupid, gullible and gullible to the extent they ought to be seriously considered a threat to the national security WHICH THEY ARE! The threat comes from INSIDE the privileged, anyone notice that yet? It is a sad state of affairs that made me leave my country of choice but who could deal with the flag-waving stupidity of the Christian Right any longer? Not me!!!!!!!!!!! A country gets the leadership it deserves - I still wonder WHERE is the OUTRAGE we saw in the 60s an dearly 70s????????????????????Are they still shopping at the mall running-up credi- card bills they will never be able to pay off? It is an interesting world out there - truly even more so when examined from the outside looking in.


To keep the "i" in the

To keep the "i" in the slogan, we could change the "party of ideas," have become the party of idiocy.


What Krugman apparently can

What Krugman apparently can not bring himself to say is that the U.S. populace is stupid. Obviously, you can have two guys selling a series of products on the same street corner for years and years, one using deception and lies to sell his products which are more defective and more counterfeit than the other guy's. Sure the guy selling the defective and counterfeit products may be stupid but what does it say of a consumer (i.e., voter) who keeps buying the defective counterfeit products year after year, despite seeing the results of his last purchases. It says he and she, the U.S. citizenry, are absolute imbeciles incapable of thinking themselves out of the energy box, the war & peace box, the health care box, the retirement/social security box, or any of the other boxes. And why can't they think their way out of any of those boxes, because they do not have the intellectual where-with-all and guts to call the system a failure, look for leaders outside of the two party ruling class consensus and do the painfully hard work of a democratic revolution. (Addressing the issue of the possibility that the Republicans could win the presidency, don't put anything past the infinitely stupid American voter. They are already clearly confused by the Republican razzle dazzle about race, religion, age and experience vis-a-vis Obama. They will continue to work on Obama's weak spot -- the ignorance and the mallability of the U.S. electorate--until a final confunding question or dilemna put to them close to election day leaves them dumbfounded, speechless, in the hands of and at the mercy of the pundits, and -- voila -- a single final push and we have another Republican president. As for me, I believe there is little hope for the U.S. people and that the hope for the world comes from the global citizenry which increasingly sees the political impotency and ignorance of the U.S. populace. Another 4 or 8 years of Republican rule will only make that impotency and ignorance all the more clear. The result will be what we are already seeing-- peoples and nations increasingly unwilling to stand with us, increasingly willing and (in our bankrupt and debilitated stated) able to defy us and create alternative alliances and mechanisms to address their needs and to confront the U.S. Don't get me wrong, I don't see a Democrat as that much better. They just put the velvet glove on the iron-fist of U.S. imperialism abroad and unbridled capitalism at home with the result that the populace goes to sleep. A Republican -- while not a pretty or benevolent site (quite the contrary) -- in the end will serve the purpose of exposing U.S. ruling class domination for what it is -- ruthlessness, U.S.-centric, and militarist. ) In summary, the U.S. populace may simply be choosing ignorance as an alternative to the work that would be required to deal with the fiasco we have in this country if they made an intelligent, honest and thoroughing analysis FOR THEMSELVES of what we are living through, who controls our lives, and why we are unable to change it. Unfortunately, I anticipate the status quo. Ignorance and impotence on the part of U.S. citizens in the face of imperialism, imposition of increasingly fascist rules, and idiocy in the service of corporate rule.


It is not stupidity--it is

It is not stupidity--it is sales and conditioning, hand in hand. Some of it is cultural. Who do you really trust to lead your group? That may be a) non-verbal, b) learned from childhood and c) subject to the pressures that advertising and group behavioral cues work together to put on thinking. There is a reason that faith healers have crowds. "Stupid" could be another name for conditioned. If advertising does not work, why are billions spent on it? If group leadership does not have a place, why are there ever huge cathedrals or megachurches?


Well it's about time Paul.

Well it's about time Paul. Was wondering if you had it in ya. Now all we need is a few more players, on that pro wrestling circuit, they call the main stream media these days, to step up out of the rabbit hole. I don't fault the American people as much as I do the ones intrusted with informing them. "In a World of Universal Deceit Telling the Truth is a Revolutionary Act" - George Orwell


To those who say that

To those who say that Americans are stupid, I would say, that the voting patterns of Americans in these early years of the 21st century (for whatever that's worth -- since our last two general elections seem to have been stolen anyway) should not just be dismissed as stupid. Although I'm sure there is so shortage of Americans who might qualify for that label, I think something else might be at work here -- perhaps a disinclination to "rock the boat", as anyone who has worked a certain amount of years in the American economy is now "invested" in its financial institutions, like it or not. Our pension plans and 401.ks are tied into our stock market and our common wisdom is that our stock market doesn't like "change". No wonder that so much of Obama's passionate following seem to be among those least likely to be directly personally influenced by fluctuations (i.e., the college age youth) in our financial markets, even though we are all somehow inextricably intwined. Think about it...I'm not saying it's right, I'm simply pointing out what I think is a rather obvious fact.


That has always been the

That has always been the undercurrent in American culture. We pride ourselves on our ignorance as if we're too big and bad to care... And so we reap the rewards of such an approach. We pretend to reward the smart, all the while celebrating those who possess brute strength... To boot, we preach teamwork while focusing on our individuality to the detriment of the team... Makes a lot of sense eh? Too many blindly follow pundits who dupe them into voting against their self-interest, convincing them that various petty issues which don't cost them a thing matter more than collective health care, education, infrastructure, poverty, the family... the list goes on. To our credit we've many who continue to struggle for the collective rights of Americans, for a better life for all.... but more often than not... stupidity and ignorance prevail, thanks in no small part to that very same cultural undercurrent...


An American philosopher

An American philosopher said, "government of the people, for the people, by the people only works if the people can think clearly for themselves, or at least recognize clear thinking of the part of others". If the American voters cannot see through the attack adds of the GOP then they will get the government they deserve. They will in fact be looked on by the rest of the world as "stupid". Without a fundamental shift in the direction America is going, America will lose its influence in the rest of the world and slowly implode. The choice is yours.


I'm real tired of stupid.

I'm real tired of stupid. The one counterargument I'd like to see used more often is the future consequence of drilling now. Oil is a limited resource. Demand is not likely to abate. Anything done on the supply side to temper the price rise now will cause the price rise to be more precipitous at some future date. Typical republican approach - borrow from our children's quality of life - after all greed is the new republican virtue. Goes so well with stupidity.


Rg." Could not have said

Rg." Could not have said it.." I am in full agreement with your evaluation. I also look at my country from the outside in... and what a clearer view it is. Lets hope this is the "Great Awakening" if not it might become the "Eternal Sleep". At least, Paul, you have recovered your long missed sense of humor again.Welcome back!!!


Even the gods have fought

Even the gods have fought stupidity in vain.


''walk on two legs not on

''walk on two legs not on four,walk on four legs breaks the law,what happens when we break the law? we all know where we go from there,to the house of pain'' seeing as how the majority of americans have shown in the last 8 years that they are dumb as a box of rocks,this stupidity is something they can understand,get behind and elect the idiot.


"We won't get fooled

"We won't get fooled again! "Meet the new boss...same as the old boss!" The Who


Four legs good? Two legs

Four legs good? Two legs Bad? As someone who walks on all fours daily for exercise, I can only say Mr. Krugman ought to try it before making such a stupid comment. I wonder if he's on Karl Rove's secret payroll.


Campaign 2008: Nonsense,

Campaign 2008: Nonsense, Nostrums, and Carnival Barking


Democrats, Republicans, they

Democrats, Republicans, they are both coercive megalomaniacs. Liberty is the only way, the market works if you let it. Stop getting the government to control my life, it makes me nervous having all these guns and jails pointed at me making certain i dont screw my taxes up or smoke pot. Eliminate the real problems: eliminate the government.


Regarding big media

Regarding big media sponsored election polls that continually purport a so, so close race. The controlling oligarchy will obviously need the fiction of, "It was always a very close race." to use voter ID laws, vote switching fraud and the direct theft of votes so the lack luster candidate can win/steal the election. Look at the last two federal presidential elections. Pay close attention to the build up and the sell out. The powers in Washington seem certain they have it down to a corporate patent 'science' in 2008. The other fail safe would be a well timed plotted 'international incident' to provoke a disastrous war with Iran, scare the American people into giving up the rest of our Constitution and Bill of Rights and maybe the unimpeachable Bush and Cheney will stay on and help the chosen few privatize what is left of the federal government and the Pentagon.


Re: Voter Registration Local

Re: Voter Registration Local County clerk has said people need to worry about Identity theft from people trying to register them to vote. This is just a week or so after the Dems have open many offices in Southwest MO and across the country to do just that. His body language (clerk's) showed he knew it was bs. He never looked the camera in the eye as he said it. Latest scare tactic by the GOP to keep voter registration down! Also, Obama is American as apple pie-related to Wild Bill Hickok and Pilgrim Timothy Blossom (as well as Chaney and B. Pitt). Why don't people look at his white side rather than the black side he had no contact with for years.


Ninety percent of Americans

Ninety percent of Americans can't locate Iraq on a map, and it's somehow a revelation to Krugman that voters are stupid? Maybe it isn't just the public that's slow to learn.

The vast majority of Americans steadfastly associate themselves with a religion that proclaims virgin birth, resurrection from the dead, transfiguration, human sacrifice (expiation by blood), Noah's Ark, the parting of the Red Sea, the sun being stopped in the heavens, Jonah surviving three days in the belly of a whale, the feeding of the multitude with the loaves and fishes, etc, etc, etc -- and yet it's a revelation to Krugman that these same people willingly place themselves, their children and the future of the planet in the hands of a fool who would be king?

C-mon, Paul, you've got to know better.

As long as America's domestic policy is dominated by politicians in debt to the Stupid for Jesus crowd, and as long as our foreign policy is dominated by the Israel lobby and the Christian Zionist fanatics, America will continue this disgraceful, dangerous downward spiral.