BP Oil Leak Setback: "Top Hat" Removed, Oil Flow Continues
Wednesday 23 June 2010
by: | McClatchy Newspapers | Report

(Photo: Zac Crawford / US Coast Guard)
Washington - Workers pulled the "top hat" device collecting crude oil from BP's gushing Deepwater Horizon well Wednesday morning in a major setback to efforts to contain the leak.
Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen, the Obama administration's point man on the BP oil leak, told reporters in his daily briefing that the long term impact of the decision was uncertain, but video from the leak showed crude gushing unhindered into the water for the first time since the "top hat" device, also referred to as the Lower Marine Riser Package, was set in place June 3.
It was unclear how soon the top hat might be put back in place, Allen said. He said he had only learned of the problem as he was headed to the Coast Guard headquarters briefing room in Washington. A BP press statement later said the incident had occured at 8:45 a.m. Central time.
BP called the measure temporary, but provided no information on when the device might be reinstalled.
The incident came a day after BP collected the most crude oil captured at the site -- more than 27,000 barrels, including 10,429 that were burned by the Q4000 drilling rig.
Allen said the Discoverer Enterprise drilling ship, which has been collecting oil through the "top hat," removed the device from the bleeding well after workers detected what appeared to be gas coming directly into the ship through a line that was being used to run warm water into the top hat to prevent a buildup of ice-like hydrate crystals. With the ship burning off thousands of cubic feet of natural gas each day, workers were concerned the gas might ignite, creating an explosive situation aboard the ship.
Allen said it was unclear how the gas came to be in the warm water line, but that initial suspicions centered on the possibility that a robot vehicle working neaer the top hat had accidentally bumped it and closed one of the vents through which the crude continues to escape. That may have increased pressure within the top hat, forcing gas into the warm water line.
Allen said workers would have to determine if hydrates had formed into the top hat and pipeline leading to the Discoverer Enterprise. If so, new pipe will have to be run to the top hat before collection can begin again.
Collection of oil through the Q4000, which draws crude directly from the well's blowout preventer and doesn't depend on the top hat, was unaffected by the incident, BP said.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
And yet even though Big Oil
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 15:44 — Anonymous (not verified)And yet even though Big Oil doesn't have a clue how to deal with an oil gusher at the bottom of the sea, a US judge blocks the (temporary) offshore drilling moratorium. These activist judges must be stopped before our nation is broken beyond repair!
The conduct is not a
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 16:29 — Anonymous (not verified)The conduct is not a "mistake" it's negligence. There were precautions & backstops that were supposed to happen and didn't.
That's negligence. Of course, having pushed for waiver of various safety procedures etc., from a "captured" agency that was supposed to regulate in the public interest (except under Bush, Cheney, Inc., the corporate was considered to be the only "public" that mattered) BP will now (or later) claim as a defense that the gov't should've stopped BP but didn't so it's really the gov't that's at fault.
naturally, all the brainwashed folks who believe (not think, there's no thinking involved) that corporations only do right and the "gov't" is wrong no matter what. So BP's "defense" will fly well with them--it's already got one member of the GOP apologizing to BP for BP's negligence.
Brainwashing, it really works!
"What appeared to be gas..."
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 17:58 — Bill W (not verified)"What appeared to be gas..." is methane, and it represents 40% of what's coming out of the hole, according to a university professor in Texas. It is toxic, flammable and 27x more polluting to the atmosphere than CO2. Between that and BP's "dispersant" COREXIT, the amount of VOCs in the region make it a tinderbox. Imagine the potential conflagration if they listen to the Navy and try to seal the well with a nuke!
God's will. And a great
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 18:00 — Anonymous (not verified)God's will. And a great excuse to raise oil prices. The fishermen of the Gulf should be pleased because look how much shrimp and redfish will cost now that they are less plentiful. And it will be warmer for the walruses of the Gulf, too. They will now not need heavy winter coats.
Just kidding. What a disaster, caused by a whole host of poor decisions. Criminal negligence. Death and plenty of destruction. But, like Bush and Cheney and all the other scofflaws out there, the key players will all get a skate and the little guys will lose their businesses, their homes and maybe their families.
I note that 53% of Americans feel that offshore drilling should continue. And a judge ruled that the drilling moratorium was illegal. You believe that things will change? Really?
And a fisherman despondent
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 23:17 — Anonymous (not verified)And a fisherman despondent over the situation committed suicide today. The comments thread on the story (by MSNBC) was yet more depressing -- people were taking the opportunity to say (a) that he must have had other problems (apparently not, and isn't losing your livelihood and way of life enough?) and (b) that it was Obama's fault.
So no, with a public like that, things are not likely to change.
Evidently, the BP idiots can
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 23:37 — Byronator (not verified)Evidently, the BP idiots can do nothing right. If the rest of the oil industry and Republicans want to identify with one of the most incompetent corporations on the planet, that will be their place in history. Of course, they couldn't care less about tomorrow.
The American public will
Thu, 06/24/2010 - 01:02 — LB (not verified)The American public will believe anything except the truth.