America: Standing in the Way of Democracy
Monday 07 February 2011
by: Dave Lindorff | This Can't Be Happening | Op-Ed
It is pathetic and even laughable to hear American leaders, and the leaders of the other Western democracies in Europe, cautioning that Egypt’s revolution needs to move slowly, as they call for a “transition” government that would be gently guided to elections by the very man, Omar Suleiman, who for years has headed the dreaded Mukhabarat, the Egyptian secret police, all under the protective umbrella of the Egyptian military.
What is this nonsense?
Did America’s revolutionary government have a slow transition to democracy? Did America’s revolutionaries sign the Declaration of Independence and then hand over the reins of government to a general from the British Army to oversee things as they prepared for elections? No. They immediately set up a democratic system, even in the midst of a bitter war for independence. Did the African National Congress turn to a general from the South African military to run a transition government in South Africa when they finally ousted the Apartheid regime in that country? No, they held an election, and went on to rule as the elected majority. When the People Power revolution in the Philippines toppled the Marcos dictatorship after a generation of autocratic and brutal martial law law, did the people turn to the country’s military and ask it to run the country for a transition year to democracy? No, of course not! They held a snap election and elected the widow, Corazon Aquino, wife of the martyred democracy activist Benigno Aquino.
Democracies don’t need “transitions” run by military rulers and hold-over tyrants. These are tactics designed to subvert, delay and even prevent true popular rule.
How tragic, sad and outrageous to hear our own political leaders, like Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and President Obama, calling for a period of interim rule--either under the hated dictator Hosni Mubarak himself, or under his hated enforcer, Suleiman. Is this what the young people who have already defended, with their blood, the idea of a truly free, democratic Egypt, were struggling, and even dying, for? Of course not!
How many times have we heard that the vast army of 100 million unemployed, uneducated young people in the Middle East, including Egypt, is a vast “breeding ground” for terrorism, as if these young people were just some species of deadly mosquito larvae. And yet, here these young people are, in Tunisia, in Egypt, in Yemen, in Algeria, in Gaza , in Iraq, and even perhaps in Syria and Saudi Arabia, engaging not in terror, but in peaceful if militant protest to demand what we in the West take for granted: freedom and a voice in their own destiny.
How insulting for us in America--we who cannot even name three or four cities in Egypt, who don’t bother to vote in elections, and who readily equate Arab with terrorist -- to imply that these brave protesters “may not be ready” for democracy, adopting the classic fall-back position that colonial, neocolonial and imperialist rulers have turned to for centuries.
Instead of getting in their way, instead of trying to work out behind-the-scenes deals with other would-be tyrants and generals as we help ease out the hated current rulers of these kleptocratic Middle Eastern dictatorships, we should be helping these brave Middle Eastern and North African democracy activists to crush their tyrannical rulers and drive them out of power entirely.
America has fallen a long way from those heady days in the late 18th Century, when that celebrated American revolutionary tribune Tom Paine was declaring that America’s revolution could become the inspiration for a new and better, more humane society around the world. “We have it in our power to begin the world over again. A situation, similar to the present, hath not happened since the days of Noah until now,” he wrote.
Today, our leaders and government actively support tyranny (witness the provision, as part of America’s military aid package to Egypt, of tear gas canisters used against the democracy activists in Liberation Square), urge delay when they find they cannot stop the tide of rebellion, and then exert economic, diplomatic and covert efforts to try to foil or water down efforts to establish a truly democratic government. Even our special envoy, supposedly sent to broker a deal to usher in democracy, former US Egypt ambassador Frank Wisner, turns out to be simply another crook on the take. His lawfirm in Washington, DC, Patton Boggs, is dictator Mubarak’s legal agent in the US. It also represents the interests in the US of the Egyptian military. This creep is our tribune of freedom?
Should the US succeed in its efforts to block these grass-roots rebellions by the young people of the Middle East we should not be surprised if at least some of them, instead of trying to emulate us, turn into our most bitter enemies.
It’s what Tom Paine would have done.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Thankyou DaveLindorff. WTF?!
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 14:20 — Anonarcmous (not verified)Thankyou DaveLindorff. WTF?! Y-toungue USA. This "slow" is absolutely vicious and shameful: if Pres/DictHosniMubarak -- or any of his inclination -- did not get it right in the past 30 years, then they are SOL. No reason on Gods green earth for anyone to be patient[?] with them anymore while Egyptian citizens die. Be as patient with them as they are with you. This time is so they can qwithdraw their assets from the country's reach. Mubarak family seems to be very comfortable and healthy--this is the classic delay and require tactic taught by the schoolofamericas--anything at any cost to harm the others.
It's because commercial
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 14:23 — Harry Thomas (not verified)It's because commercial interests trump democracy every time. We're seeing here in our own country; we've seen it hundreds of times in countries that have some resource that the commercial interests want.
In Egypt's case, there is a lot of money to be saved by shipping through the Suez Canal as opposed to sailing around the African continent. That's why we turn a blind eye to the strong-arm tactics of all the little dictators that work for us. Plus there's the protection of Israel, which has a much better lobby in Congress and among the Religious Right.
Except for the part about
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 18:36 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)Except for the part about voting in American "(s)elections" (because we must not be in any way complicit in voting for those who always perpetrate evil over and over again), this is a right-on article. It goes to show that the U.S. is not a "democracy" in the sense that you and/or other lovers of freedom mean it. Democracy is mob rule by the minority, in this case the mob rule of the minority of globalist corporate-fascists who want to completely subjugate all of us and the entire world; in other words, enslave all of us. They are the new "national socialists" (neo-liberals, neo-cons and neo-fascists), the modern-day version of the Reich, this time the "Fourth Reich". They are as they have long been, including in "America", the imperialist overlords who do not AT ALL tolerate ANY "democracy" as you mean it, and they don't want anyone to ever be Truly Free and "masters of their own destiny", but want them all to be entirely under the globalists' thumb, with no true free will, and no true self-determination, whatsoever. In short, they hate True Freedom, they hate us having any at all, and they will not be satisfied until we have none...
...The global,
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 18:37 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)...The global, corporate-fascist imperialist-nihilist, totalitarian-autocrats want to be the masters of everyone's destiny, and they will not stop seeking to be such until they have totally succeeded in being such, as they are completely succeeding in becoming such right now, by deluding the masses that the "security and freedom from terrorism, dissent and 'disorder'" that they fraudulently offer at the total expense of True Liberty and Freedom, will supposedly be everyone's savior and deliver them into "the promised land"; when, in reality, it will only deliver the entire world's population into abject slavery with no True Freedom and Liberty, Free Will and Sovereign Dignity whatsoever. Let's face it, most "Americans" love their enslavement under so-called "democracy", under materialism, under narcissism and self-centeredness, and under the elitist, corporate-fascist oligarchs' absolute tyranny and control that they've been totally deceived into believing is "freedom", when it is nothing but the exact opposite of freedom, enslavement in the extremely insidious, nefarious and treacherous guise of "liberty".
Unlike Egypt or Burma or
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 22:15 — Here's the thing about saying the US has no democracy... (not verified)Unlike Egypt or Burma or China, where people get killed for pushing for freedom, we in America have it, but we don't use it. We don't exploit it. We don't push the envelope. We don't challenge authority. We don't demand that our votes mean something.
We waste it.
The demagogues, the crooks, the liars, the charlatans all exist because we let them exist.
To say otherwise, to blame it on "The System," is simply a cop out.
Having lived in China, having spent time in other dictatorships, I can say without equivocation that people in America, including leftists who bemoan the control of the corporate elite, just don't know what real fascism and repression are like. We could take this place over in a minute if the American people would just stop being so frickin' lazy and smug.
When I look at what these kids and young people and their parents are doing in Egypt, facing down thousands of killer cops and American supplied tanks, it makes me sick to think of my own country, which can't even stop a criminal war.
Dave Lindorff
www.thiscantbehappening.net
Some excellent points, Dave
Tue, 02/08/2011 - 01:12 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)Some excellent points, Dave Lindorff, but I think you may have misunderstood me. I wasn't saying the U.S. has no "democracy". I was saying that it only has the appearance of "democracy" as you DON'T mean it, and does NOT anymore have what you mean by the word. I also meant that people, particularly "progressives" and "liberals" try to make the word stand for constitutional "republic-anism", which it in reality does NOT stand for, and which in truth it cannot apply to, at all. To me, "democracy", especially the "democracy" of today, is better known as "demonocracy", the presence of, as I said above, minority elitist corporate fascist mob rule, or of an autocracy, and/or an authoritarian state where The People only enjoy a semblance of "liberty" and "freedom", which can, and very soon will be, yanked away at any time. The U.S. is now what the "democracy" of Germany morphed, or metamorphosed into...
...As Dahr Jamail now
Tue, 02/08/2011 - 01:13 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)...As Dahr Jamail now believes and says, "The U.S. is already a police state", which is the opposite of what you mean by a "democracy". It is already authoritarian, and fast becoming totalitarian. It is no longer a constitutional republic except for what is left of it, in a very thin, and rapidly growing thinner and thinner, veneer. What little is left of constitutional republic-anism is being very quickly eradicate; and, already, none of us is safe as a result. All of us who stand for True Freedom, and/or True Constitutional Republic-anism, and absolutely refuse to sell our souls to the evils of "democracy", authoritarianism and totalitarianism, are at the mercy of the predatory whims of the Machiavellian state which the U.S. has become, and is fast becoming more and more; and very soon that state will come after, and dispose of, all those who dissent against it, also as they did in Germany...
...You are of course quite
Tue, 02/08/2011 - 01:14 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)...You are of course quite correct that if the majority of "We, the People" rose up and demanded True Liberty and Freedom, "(w)e could take this place (the U.S.) over in a minute"; but, because "the American people (are)... so frickin' lazy and smug", and because for the most part they have been brainwashed to love corporate dictatorship with a thus far "benign" guise, which quickly become anything but benign more and more, we will not stop the corporate-fascist takeover and "totalitarianization" of the U.S.; and, instead, most people will sellout and bow down to it for the sake of their "safety", once again just as the "good Germans" did. They have been dumbed-down to no longer have any true spine or backbone; because, very sadly, the "revolutionary spirit" has by and large been surgically removed from them, to the extent that very soon all vestiges of True Freedom and Liberty in U.S. will be stamped out, and will be nothing but a mostly forgotten memory.
The Obama Administration has
Tue, 02/08/2011 - 10:02 — Andrei Vyshinsky (not verified)The Obama Administration has seen effectively to the disembowelment of peoples' democracy in Egypt with its active support of this maggot, Suleiman, from all reports Mubarak's Lavrenti Beria. As to the Middle East, it is clear that American government exists solely to further the ends of Israel's fascist expansionism.
David, You say: "On the
Tue, 02/08/2011 - 10:23 — Andrei Vyshinsky (not verified)David,
You say:
"On the other hand, having lived in real police states, I think it is important to draw some kind of distinction between a place where anyone can at any time for the most minor infraction end up disappearing without a trace into the maw of a police state gulag, and a place like America where I can openly call President Bush or President Obama a war criminal, can write a book calling for their arrest and jailing for war crimes, where I can organize a political party calling for the overthrow of the current government (by peaceful means), and can write articles critical of the police, all without fear."
I'm afraid we'd learn rather quickly that the making of distinctions of this kind would be farce should the American people ever muster the courage that Egyptians have recently in dealing with the theft of their democracy. Two million people in Washington and the ruling class would make Tiananmen Square look like a walk in the park, have little doubt about it. Then we can reflect on the deeper meaning of the term "police state" and isolate appearance from substance, eh? One has a "police state" if one's government is likely to act like a "police state".
We are, in the U.S.,
Wed, 02/09/2011 - 00:09 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)We are, in the U.S., unfortunately a very short step away from "a place where anyone can at any time for the most minor infraction end up disappearing without a trace into the maw of a police state gulag", Andrei Vyshinsky, Dave Lindorff and others.
Canada Goose Suisse
Fri, 11/23/2012 - 02:05 — Canada Goose Suisse (not verified)Very uplifting place, Kudos !
Rosetta Stone Dutch
Sat, 01/19/2013 - 12:03 — Rosetta Stone Dutch (not verified)http://www.sbcefaleia.com/associados/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=6&limitstart=30
Adidas Wings 2.0
Sun, 01/27/2013 - 15:56 — Adidas Wings 2.0 (not verified)I forced a modest grin.Properly, I stated.He tried to wink, a undesirable attempt, and I broke down and laughed.
bottega veneta outlet
Mon, 05/20/2013 - 16:13 — bottega veneta outlet (not verified)Hop Over To These Guys