Document Reveals Military Was Concerned About Gulf War Vets' Exposure to Depleted Uranium

by: Mike Ludwig, t r u t h o u t | Report

Document Reveals Military Was Concerned About Gulf War Vets' Exposure to Depleted Uranium
(Photo: John Out and About / Flickr)

For years, the government has denied that depleted uranium (DU), a radioactive toxic waste left over from nuclear fission and added to munitions used in the Persian Gulf and Iraq wars, poisoned Iraqi civilians and veterans.

But a little-known 1993 Defense Department document written by then-Brigadier Gen. Eric Shinseki, now the secretary for the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), shows that the Pentagon was concerned about DU contamination and the agency had ordered medical testing on all personnel that were exposed to the toxic substance.

Shinseki's memo, under the subject line, "Review of Draft to Congress - Health and Environmental Consequences of Depleted Uranium in the U.S. Army -- Action Memorandum," makes some small revisions to the details of these three orders from the DoD:

1. Provide adequate training for personnel who may come in contact with DU contaminated equipment.

2. Complete medical testing of all personnel exposed to DU in the Persian Gulf War.

3. Develop a plan for DU contaminated equipment recovery during future operations.

The VA, however, never conducted the medical tests, which may have deprived hundreds of thousands of veterans from receiving medical care to treat cancer and other diseases that result from exposure to DU.

The Armed Forces Health Surveillance Center recently reported that ten years of data confirm that service members tend to have higher rates of certain cancers compared to civilians, according to the Army Times. While researchers suspected that service members are diagnosed with cancer more often and at a younger age because they have guaranteed access to health care and mandatory exams, the data does not explain the disparities in diagnosis among branches of the military. For example, the rate of lung cancer among sailors is twice that of other branches, while Marines have much lower cancer rates across the board.

On Tuesday, the VA's ongoing failure to treat and diagnose Gulf War related illnesses came up during a House Veterans Affairs subcommittee hearing where a veterans advocacy group urged Shinseki to undertake comprehensive research on the correlation between chronic illness and exposure to DU in munitions during the Gulf War.

Armed with Shinseki's August 19, 1993 memo, Veterans for Common Sense (VCS), said the VA, and Shinseki in particular, have "a rare opportunity for a second chance."

"In military terms, VCS asks VA for a ceasefire," said Paul Sullivan, the executive director for VCS. "VCS urges VA leadership to stop and listen to our veterans before time runs out, as VA is killing veterans slowly with bureaucratic delays and mismanaged research that prevent us from receiving treatments or benefits in a timely manner."

Sullivan, himself a Gulf War veteran, told the subcommittee that the VA has refused to listen to scientists and veterans who are concerned about DU, leaving thousands of veterans suffering from chronic illnesses related to the conflict unsure if they will ever receive a solid diagnosis to justify the benefits and treatment they need.

Of the 697,000 men and woman who served in Gulf War operations Desert Storm and Desert Shield between 1990 and 1991, about 250,000 suffer from symptoms collectively known as "Gulf War Veterans' Illnesses." The symptoms include fatigue, weakness, gastrointestinal problems, cognitive dysfunction, sleep disturbances, persistent headaches, skin rashes, respiratory conditions and mood changes, according to the VA.

The VCS also petitioned Shinseki to investigate the 2009 termination of a $75 million research project on Gulf War illnesses at the University of Texas medical center. Last year the VCS filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for records of the "internal sabotage" of Gulf War Veterans Illnesses research and the intentional delaying of research and treatment, according to Sullivan. The VA has yet to release any documents about the impeded research, and VCS filed a FOIA appeal on June 29.

Sullivan said the VCS simply wants the government to support independent testing on veterans exposed to DU, but the Department of Defense prefers a "don't look, don't find policy."

"As a Gulf War veteran, I have watched too many of my friends die without answers, without treatment, and without benefits," Sullivan said. "In a few cases, veterans completed suicide due to Gulf War illness and the frustration of dealing with VA."

Sullivan testified as disturbing reports have emerged in recent months from Fallujah, Iraq, about the skyrocketing rates of birth defects and cancer,  which are being blamed on DU-laced bombs and munitions used by US and British forces during a brutal coalition assault on the city in 2004. Iraqi human rights officials are reportedly planning to file a lawsuit.

Don’t miss a beat - get Truthout Daily Email Updates. Click here to sign up for free.

DU is a dense metal added to munitions and bombs to pierce tanks and armor, and the military seems to chose unrestricted use of the radioactive substance over its soldiers' safety. Sullivan told Truthout that original medical tests ordered in a 1993 memo, which also called for personnel to be trained in dealing with contaminated equipment, were canceled after a training video scared soldiers.

"It was pulled after [the training video] was seen by some soldiers who became upset when they saw soldiers in moon suits holding Geiger counters, and the military realized that the training could present a problem in the battlefield where soldiers need to disregard exposure issues while trying to kill the enemy," Sullivan said.

Sullivan said that the DU "follow-up" program the VA consistently references was inadequate as it consisted of sporadic studies on only a small fraction of estimated 400,000 veterans exposed to the radioactive heavy metal.

"The VA does not listen to expert scientists. The VA does not even listen to Congress," Sullivan said in his testimony. "Two decades of inaction have already passed. Gulf War veterans urgently want to avoid the four decades of endless suffering endured by our Vietnam War veterans exposed to Agent Orange."

Sullivan said it took 40 years and an act of Congress to fund and sanction independent studies that proved the VA was responsible for providing benefits to soldier suffering from Agent Orange-related diseases.

The VA now recognizes that exposure to Agent Orange, an herbicide sprayed across Vietnam to kill foliage and expose guerrilla fighters, has plagued veterans with several deadly diseases and disorders.

VCS also advocated for the research on post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) that became the foundation of new PTSD rules, making it easier for veterans to receive benefits.

Last week, the VA announced $2.8 million worth of research on Gulf War Veterans' Illnesses, a sum Sullivan called "paltry." A VA press release announcing the research does not mention DU. The release references a recent Institute of Medicine report that identified the quarter million veterans affected by various symptoms associated with Gulf War illness, which "cannot be ascribed to any psychiatric disorder and likely result from genetic and environmental factors, although the data are not strong enough to draw conclusions about specific causes."

Popular medical science holds that kidney damage is the primary health problem associated with exposure to high amounts of DU. The heavy metal is 60 percent as radioactive as natural uranium, and is also linked to lung cancer in some cases and leukemia in even fewer cases, according to the World Health Organization (WHO).

Some critics have claimed that the WHO and governments have suppressed links between DU and cancer.

The debate over the use of DU in conventional warfare will rage on as the Fallujah fallout continues, but according to Sullivan, there is only one way for thousands of Gulf War veterans at home to know the truth and receive the relief they deserve.

"After 20 years of waiting, we refuse to wait on more empty promises from VA. The first step is for Secretary Shinseki and Chief of Staff Gingrich to immediately clean house of VA bureaucrats who have so utterly and miserably failed our veterans for too long," said Sullivan, vowing to petition Congress if the VA refuses to respond. "Our waiting must end now."

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Mike Ludwig is a Truthout Fellow.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Pretition Congress???? Are

Pretition Congress???? Are you joking??? Don't you understand YET that it is time to demand the IMPEACHMENT of ObamaFRAUD? He is Sock Puppet TOOL of the British Empire, as was BUSH.. (witness BP for oney, Wall St. and foreign bank - Bank of England, etc. "Bailouts" - what a clever way to name OUTRIGHT THIEVERY in Broad Daylight) and is Overseeing the DESTRUCTION of the USA. Only a Grass Roots REVOLUTION, by the overwhelming mass of American People, SEEING THRU the FRAUDULENT TYRANNY will turn things around. ObamaFRAUD and his appointee co-conspirators in FRAUD are serving a FOREIGN POWER. Private Corporate and Royalist Globalist Criminal ELITE in Genocidal DePopulation Schemes. And PLEASE recognize that there is NO Two Party System - just TWO CHEEKS of the Same Ass...serving Private Interests and IGNORING the Best Interests of the NATION and its' PEOPLE. Wake UP America - GOD and the and the Spirit of the Founding Fathers are WATCHING! Freedom ISN'T Free - - ETERNAL VIGILANCE is the Price of FREEDOM!!! No more SLEEPING - - time to Get UP off your KNEES!!!



Quite early they realized

Quite early they realized the monetary costs involved in treating all personnel exposed to DU and simply decided to pretend there was no problem to avoid the cost ... better to pay a few lawyers for years than to have to treat the entire force of military personnel.



Previously undisclosed? I

Previously undisclosed? I wrote about it here in 2005, http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0327-21.htm.



The military never denied DU

The military never denied DU was used in warheads, it was and is listed in specs. The issue is after the round is fired and hits a target, most of the rod explodes into dust that may be inhaled by anyone near the target in the days afterward.



Check your facts, especially

Check your facts, especially in the lead paragraph.

DU is SUPPOSED to be the U-238 left over after the enrichment process has extracted the fissile U-235, and SUPPOSED to exclude any material that was used in reactors for the production of Pu-239.

Unfortunately there is evidence that this material has been used in munitions as well.



Just check out these

Just check out these stories:
http://www.nbcactionnews.com/generic/news/local_news/investigations/Topic-Investigators-Bannister



Civilized nations -- such as

Civilized nations -- such as Canada -- have banned the use of depleted uranium by their own troops. Perhaps some fine day we will become civilized too.



As a gulf war veteran who is

As a gulf war veteran who is suffering from some of these symptoms without health benefits, I would personally like to thank the US taxpayers for their support and their continued support. Your yellow ribbon campaigns, Today show segments, and Prime time TV specials, have given the War Veterans the quality care and comfort you want to provide for them.



How about spraying the halls

How about spraying the halls of Congress with Agent Orange and Depleted Uranium to see how quickly our draft dodging Congressmen react .One possible solution would be to demand that 25 % of all Congressmen be drafted into the Military for a 1 year tour of duty on the front lines of Iraq or Afghanistan . The second year we will send their spoiled brats boy / girl to the front lines .



The film producer Frieder

The film producer Frieder Wagner made a documentary about DU in 2006. The documentary is entitled Todesstaub -- Deadly Dust. Unfortunately the documentary is only in German.



Check Army Reg. 700-48. The

Check Army Reg. 700-48. The rule describes the debris removal process whenever a du weapon is used. It has not been followed in Iraq or Afghanistan. An estimated 5000 tons of du has been detonated and none of the debris, soil, and water has been removed as per Army Regulations. Kuwait made the Army come back and clean up the radioactive debris from the first Gulf War.



Since I wqas the officer in

Since I wqas the officer in charge of Atomic Ammunition at Fort Huachuca in 1956 I amk totally aware of the atomic ammo. The government would state that there was no such animal in the vaults in the Fort. I was listed as the Fort Motor Officer and never saw a motor pool.



The real dirty bomb. It has

The real dirty bomb. It has long struck me as ironic that we are asked to embrace increased surveillance and possible detention without rights as necessary measures because terrorists might be coming with the dirty bomb (not quite having the means to make and deploy a genuine nuclear device), yet we have already exploded hundreds of dirty bombs in Iraq, for that is exactly was DU munitions are.



Munitions that penetrate

Munitions that penetrate armor plate are called "kinetic energy" rounds. They are very heavy, and fired at a very high velocity (over 5000 fps) from cannon in a "direct fire" mode: in other words, not lobbed like an artillery round or a mortar shell, but like a bullet from a rifle. The "penetrator" part of the munition is a rod (mentioned above) of solid metal: no explosive in it. In tank gunnery, these are usually called "sabot" rounds, because the penetrator is way smaller than the barrel of the cannon, and a ceramic shoe ("sabot") holds the rod in the center of the gun bore, and falls away after the round leaves the muzzle of the gun. Some are spin-stabilized like a rifle bullet, others are fired from a smooth-bore weapon, and small fins deploy to act like arrow fletches. When an anti-armor round hits a hard target, the sheer force of the rod moving so fast actually burns through the armor, creating deadly fragments of the target's armor that ricochet inside the vehicle that has been hit, creating enormous heat and spalling which detonates anything inside , such as fuel, ordnance and hydraulic fluid. The penetrator vaporizes; it becomes micron sized dust and is almost a hot plasma. Metals other than DU are as effective, for example, tungsten, but then how would the Government dispose of all the spent fuel from Naval reactors , which is very difficult stuff to process? This DU is also in "tank-buster" munitions fired from Air Force A-10 attack jets and helicopter gunships. It's one thing to spread this stuff around a desert, but it was also used in the Balkans. When Europeans begin to get sick, and the toxic farmland grows radioactive vegetables , perhaps the EU may take notice. The Soldiers and Marines exposed to this stuff should be closely monitored, as well as their families, cared for and compensated. But these people are usually enlisted rates, or tactical officers of the lower grades, so I don't expect a lot of Generals to be worried about this.



The excellent, informative

The excellent, informative DDVD, "Poison Dust", published in English in 2006, can easily be rented or purchased inexpensively..



DU munitions are health

DU munitions are health hazards while in stockpile--consolidated quantities. To read about this go to: http://www.indymedia.org.nz/article/72508/du-you-dont-have-inhale-or-ingest-it-it-
Some links no longer work, as it was first published in 2006. And it isn't just military who are at risk.



The VA treats its veterans

The VA treats its veterans like corporations treat those who file a class action or civil suit against them. They drag it out for years as the plaintiffs die or drop out of the action out of disgust. Then they pay nickels and dimes on the dollar to make those left go away. This was done with the Vietnam Vets over agent Orange and PTSD. It has been done with the Gulf Veterans. It is currently being done with the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans. Those of us still alive ten, twenty, thirty years from now will still be reading about the need for research to determine what caused our Veterans to have "issues" and medical problems.



Depleted Uranium is not

Depleted Uranium is not dangerous because it is radioactive, it is dangerous because it is a toxic metal, like lead. While this is a serious concern, it is not likely to kill nearly as many people by accident, as it is on purpose. It would be better to ban landmines and cluster bombs as well as other chemicals used by the military, like bags of Chromium +6 used to stop underground pipe corrosion.

Larry



"Use 'em and lose 'em": the

"Use 'em and lose 'em": the Pentagon's policy toward troops.



Marion Fulk, retired from

Marion Fulk, retired from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, has been trying to draw attention to the dangers of breathing the dust of DU for years now. That the response of army officials has been so minimal has not surprised me. To listen to Fulk, or to follow through on the suggestions of General Shinseki, would have been very expensive. Anyway, these guys and gals who have been exposed are for the most part just grunts. A great nation like ours has better things to care about than the likes of them. Right?

By the way, the comment of Larry above strikes me as unfortunate. It doesn't seem to take note of what happens when DU become a virtual gas and is then ingested.



Didn't read past the

Didn't read past the headline.

The reference to the Persian Gulf as " Gulf" was enough to show me the author is an IDIOT.



I have bad news for the dork

I have bad news for the dork that says DU isn't radioactive. it is extremely so. As some of you rocket scientists out there have surmised, DEPLETED URANIUM is not made of silly putty, eraser rubber, or papier mache. IT IS DEPLETED SPENT REACTOR FUEL!! IT is not at ZERO half-life by any means.

and it's in the upper atmosphere of this planet now, encircling the globe, and falling virtually everywhere. That's why, rocket scientist who declared this to be NON RADIOACTIVE, that if you actually pull your head out of your anus and get a GEIGER COUNTER, you'll notice that the background radiation signature where you live is now HIGHER than it was in, oh, 1944.

So, in time, this DU dust will be in everyone's lungs, in all plants, and all animals, and someday when the rocket scientist who declared this shit to be NON RADIOACTIVE gets a clue, we can all realize we are going to DIE FROM GENETIC MUTATIONS of our DNA and RNA.

but, hey, the guy who says it's not RADIOACTIVE, he can put all of it in his godddamned CORN FLAKES he so chooses, by my fuckng guest, dork!



Stop giving Depleted

Stop giving Depleted Uranium, cluster bombs and other illegal weapons to Isreal and who knows where else they have gone. We saw Isreal use them in their attack on Lebanon.



Pure U-238 has a half life

Pure U-238 has a half life of nearly 4.5 BILLION years and decays mostly by emission of an energetic alpha particle. If the "DU" used in munitions is indeed all or partly spent nuclear fuel, it will also contain many more contaminating radioactive elements/isotopes, not to mention some residual U-235, which decays more readily to yield fission fragments. Many of these contaminants are many more times radioactive than U-235, so the radiation danger is significant, especially when the decaying atom is within living tissue.

Uranium is also a very toxic heavy metal, much like lead, chromium, etc., so exposure to any of its isotopes is likely to produce toxicity when it is taken up by living organisms.

Furthermore, uranium is pyrophoric, i.e. it burns spontaneously in the presence of air when subdivided into small enough particles - as it does when the munition round strikes a target. The ultrafine dust produced instantly burns, producing even smaller particles of oxide smoke that permeate the surrounding area and are capable of being taken directly into the bloodstream and tissues on exposure.

Nice stuff, eh? Makes nerve gas look almost benign.



War crimes. Mission

War crimes. Mission Accomplished.



Obfuscation like this,

Obfuscation like this, bleeding thru into popular culture is why I stopped watching "House".



In your OPINION, Sean, the

In your OPINION, Sean, the author is an idiot. Since you stand zero chance of being exposed to DU yourself, I guess that means you must be working for EXTORTIONISTS.



burberry coats

burberry umbrella to get new coupon EVmyDHco http://www.burberryoutlet--online.com/



childrens ugg boots uk

kensington ugg boots uk with low price dsKGBkVN http://www.uggboots--uk.net/



genuine ugg uk

uggs for men uk online sBmOqGUa http://www.uggboots--uk.net/



louis vuitton outlet online

buy louis vuitton factory outlet online with confident wBNTePwU http://www.louisvuitton--onlineshop.com/



gucci uk

buy a gucci online uk for gift GPscyMcC http://www.gucciuk.us/



replica christian louboutin boots

check replica christian louboutin wedding shoes online vcteoZQp http://www.replicachristianlouboutin.net/



hermes handbags replica

view replica hermes bags to get new coupon YTkCSxcr http://www.hermes--replica.org/



louis vuitton online store

check this link, lv online for gift rKUNHyQx http://www.louisvuitton--onlineshop.com/



ryan grant jersey

iexlx percy harvin jersey
xknqc michael crabtree jersey
opdsp mario manningham jersey
vlzqz chris johnson jersey
uieme jerod mayo jersey



heel lift

Thanks so much for the post. Keep writing.



shoe lifts for men

Thanks-a-mundo for the blog article. Much obliged.



michael kors hamilton

fnksyii