Economic Recovery for the Few

by: Rick Wolff  |  Monthly Review | News Analysis

Economic Recovery for the Few
(Photo: gabemac)

Where is this elusive recovery? The banks, some say, have "recovered." Yet they remain dependent on Washington, they do not make the loans needed for a general recovery, and many medium and small banks keep collapsing. The stock market shows no recovery. The Dow index was 14,000 in late 2007 when capitalism hit the fan, and it is around 10,000 now. The Nasdaq market index was 2800 then and is 2300 now. Everywhere else -- unemployment, foreclosures, bankruptcies, depressed housing market, and so on -- no recovery in sight. Yet, my search finally found genuine recovery for one group, and its recovery offers a better policy to treat this crisis.

Every year, two major companies catering to rich investors co-author a survey of their clients. Capgemini and Merrill Lynch Wealth Management's World Wealth Report covers the two groups that interest them: High Net Worth Individuals (HNWIs) and Ultra-High Net Worth Individuals (Ultra-HNWIs). The first group counts all individuals with at least $1 million of "investible assets" in addition to the values of their primary residence, art works, collectibles, etc. The second group includes individuals with at least $30 million of such investible assets.

Their latest Report, covering the year 2009, finds 10 million HNWIs in the world that year: 3.1 million in North America, while Europe and Asia-Pacific each had 3.0 million. The rest of the world had a mere 0.9 million of the rich and richer.

The 10 million HNWIs -- in a global population of 6.8 billion in 2009 -- amounted to 0.14 per cent of the earth's people. Together, they owned a total of $39 trillion in "investible assets." To see what this means: in 2009, the US GDP (total output of goods and services) was $14.6 trillion. The combined GDPs of the world's 9 richest countries (US, Japan, China, Germany, France, UK, Italy, Russia, and Spain) totaled less in 2009 than the investible assets of the world's HNWIs.

During 2009, as tens of millions lost their jobs, the number of HNWIs rose by 17.1 per cent and their combined wealth rose by 18.9 per cent. They had a genuine "recovery." HNWIs regained in wealth most of what they lost in 2008. No wonder they celebrate "recovery" while the rest of the world wonders (or rages at) what they are talking about. In the US, for example, the HNWI population grew by 16.6 per cent in 2009 while the US GDP fell by 2.4 per cent.

Only 1 per cent of all HNWIs were Ultra-HNWIs, but what a group that was and is. Ultra-HNWIs alone owned 35.5 per cent of the $39 trillion owned by all 10 million HNWIs. And they recovered more during 2009 than their fellow HNWIs.

Capitalism is the name of the global economic system that delivers the outcomes summarized in these numbers. Capitalism produces "recovery" for those who need it least while offering austerity for nearly everyone else. Today's business and political leaders tell the people of all advanced industrial countries that there is no alternative to years of government budget austerity (raised taxes and/or reduced government employment and services).

They don't explain that they could tap instead the immense wealth of the richest 0.14 per cent who (a) made huge gains in wealth over the last 25 years, and (b) already recovered in 2009 what they had lost in 2008.

What notions of fairness, decency, ethics, or democracy could justify such economic performance, especially in a time of global economic crisis? Recall as well that these same rich and richer people contributed so significantly (as industrial employers, bankers, and investors) to generating that global economic crisis.

Let's now concentrate on the HNWIs in just the US (including its Ultra-HNWIs). They numbered 2.9 million in 2009: well under 1 per cent of US citizens. Their investible assets totaled $12.09 trillion. For 2009, the total US budgetary deficit was $1.7 trillion. Had the US government levied an economic emergency tax of a modest 15 per cent on only the HNWI's investible assets, it could have erased its entire 2009 deficit. Over 99 per cent of US citizens would have been exempted from that tax.

The European, Japanese, and other governments could have treated the crisis likewise in their countries. Then governments would not have had to borrow trillions. They would instead have taxed the super rich tiny minority a small portion of its immense wealth. Those governments would not then have had to turn to lenders (often those same super rich). There would be no current "sovereign debt crisis" in Greece, Portugal, Spain, Ireland, etc., and no need for the resulting austerities to satisfy those lenders. Republicans would have no "deficit, deficit" drum to beat hoping for election-day gains.

Taxing the HNWIs and Ultra-HNWIs would be the policy of governments responsive to the needs of their working-class majorities instead of their rich and super-rich patrons. Austerity is not the only policy. Modestly taxing the wealth of HNWIs is the far better policy choice. The two wealth management companies that cater to HNWIs have kindly provided us all with the facts and figures needed to support the better policy.

Across Europe, coalitions of trade unions, socialist, communist, and some green parties, and many social, religious, and community organizations are organizing growing mass demonstrations and general strikes. These oppose austerity and demand alternative ways to deal with economic crisis. In France, mobilization focuses on a nationwide general strike September 7. Plans are underway for an all-European day of public actions on September 29. National actions like this have already happened in Greece, Portugal, and other countries.

The business and political leaders generated by the last 30 years of neoliberal capitalism simply assumed that they could impose the costs of their crisis on their countries' people. That assumption is now being contested. The European people are beginning to fight back. And here, in the US?

Rick Wolff is a Professor Emeritus at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst and also a Visiting Professor at the Graduate Program in International Affairs of the New School University in New York. He is the author of New Departures in Marxian Theory (Routledge, 2006) among many other publications. Check out Rick Wolff’s documentary film on the current economic crisis, Capitalism Hits the Fan, at www.capitalismhitsthefan.com. Visit Wolff's Web site at www.rdwolff.com, and order a copy of his new book Capitalism Hits the Fan: The Global Economic Meltdown and What to Do about It.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



It is astonishing that human

It is astonishing that human beings have so little regard for their own worth that they permit a tiny percentage of aggressive and ruthless individuals to pile up so much wealth for themselves that the entire global economy collapses under the sheer weight of all those riches at the top.

Half the American people swear blind allegiance to this system that condemns them to lives of relative squalor and misery, so the rich can live like kings, off the backs and sweat of their labor.

How can we be this stupid?



Marx was correct. The

Marx was correct. The wealthy will always devise ways to further their interests, no matter what the social or environmental costs. The theft of the economy by the financial sector and the total destruction of this country's manufacturing base, has guaranteed third-world status for the rest of us. Our open border policy will only hasten this process. The dominant elites have no allegiance to this or any other national ideal. If things get too bad here, these elites will just move to their chalet in Switzerland or big acreage in Ireland. I think what really astonishes me is that this group of elitist bigots scream the loudest about how downtrodden and abused they are, with their Glen Beck fueled hysteria about the poor taking over the country. Gosh, where is my violin and box of tissues?



Actually... Madam LaFarge

Actually... Madam LaFarge was correct.

SzhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhCHOP! CLUNK Clunk clunk.

knit one, pearl two

AMERICA AWAKE!



"Taxing the HNWIs and

"Taxing the HNWIs and Ultra-HNWIs would be the policy of governments responsive to the needs of their working-class majorities instead of their rich and super-rich patrons."

And therein lies the rub, for governments are NOT responsive to the working class. Governments are OWNED by the rich and the super-rich and thus will not respond to the plight of the working class. Far too many liberals and "leftists" do not see this fundamental truth and thus go around in circles seeking a solution. Once people see the problem, only then can the solution be thought of. And since people do not see the problem (because the rich and the super-rich are so good at creating and reinforcing false consciousnes), there will be no solution.

End of story. Go back to sleep, sheeple. Better yet, go shopping.



How to get these facts

How to get these facts widely publicized when the media seems to turn a blind eye? Unions should take the lead in explaining these facts. Alternative papers, and socially aware religious groups should join the chorus. How about infiltrating anti-tax tea parties? Some of them might actually find these facts of interest.



From the article: "...they

From the article: "...they do not make the loans needed for a general recovery..."

This is only true if your definition of recovery is to re-inflate the bubble that caused this mess. We're going to have another 15-year depression unless we stop with all this "stimulus" nonsense and give people back economic freedom.

and: "Capitalism is the name of the global economic system that delivers the outcomes summarized in these numbers. Capitalism produces "recovery" for those who need it least while offering austerity for nearly everyone else."

Wow. Capitalism bashing. That was unexpected. Feel free to bash the world's economic system, but stop calling it capitalism. The "capitalist" world is really mercantilist. You know, it looks a bit like capitalism but politicians decide who wins and who loses.



President Obama has become a

President Obama has become a Community Organizer for the Rich.



The "elusive" recovery will

The "elusive" recovery will remain as long as the Banks (who ALL got theirs thanks to J.Q.Public) continue to sit on their hands ala the regressive Republi-WON'T Party of NO! miscreants in Washington who are their masters. They blame the President and the Democrats because there are no jobs but it was THEY who shipped their corporate headquarters off shore to avoid taxes, as well as out-sourcing all our Industry to third World countries to avoid Unions, OSHA and other drains on THEIR economy. They don't give a damn about Americans who live and try to find work here. Interest rates What happened to all the new Banking rules and regs? Oh yeah, the Republi-WON'Ts stripped it of any meaningful changes for the poor working stiffs. Profit is their god. Their C.E.O.s, whether successful businessmen or NOT, continue to get Millions in salary and bonuses. HOW is that possible in THIS economy? Politicians own or run Companies like Halliburton and Blackwater ( Xe ? ) who are awarded government contracts over and over again despite the fact that their employees are thugs and criminals. The War needs to end. Bring the troops back home to help rebuild America and let the Afghani's bury their dead and deal with Pakistan on their own. We need some nation building of our own right here at home.



That movie starring Gordon

That movie starring Gordon Gekko was not so far fetched as it seemed . Looks like he is the role model for the Wall Street Con Artists and the Banksters. It seems like this SCUM can never reward [ not earn ] themselves enough , it it a game with these people to see how far they can push the limits . The country as a whole can be suffering but they give themselves ever increasing salaries and BONUSES , at the expense of the share holders. Shareholders , the real owners of a company get pennies [ chump change ] as dividends. Heads they win , tails you lose . But obviously they deserve it , as Lloyd Blankfein recently said , "He is doing Gods work " The man is not only greedy but EVIL . I started out poor and bought 2 bankrupt restaurants , built them up and over time bought 3 more . All were successful . But even though my decor and the food was above average , my prices were about 15 % below my competition . I also over the years bought 3 and 4 family houses in the Providence , R.I. area , fixed them up when necessary to my standards and yet rented them out again about 10 to 15 % below a comparable apartment . [ had less turnover ] . Why be greedy ? I made enough money that I could live a fairly comfortable life. My reward came once my loans and mortgages were paid off . I would say it is time for the lumpen masses to WAKE UP . The masses in Transylvania finally woke up to the threat of Frankenstein in Count Draculas castle and marched with torches and pitchforks on the castle to destroy the threat to the innocent naive citizens . The time is long past due for us to march on Wall Street and Washington with pitchforks in hand and to " neutralize " the ENEMY . Silence gives consent !



March away from banks and to

March away from banks and to cooperatives and credit unions. You have to vet credit unions because some run on a bank model, but some really are working for their customers. My credit union is lending, and it discloses everything, all the costs. It also makes me say if I'm going out of town, to protect against unauthorized charges, and they know my name. Loans have heretofore not been sold away, although they do reserve the right to do that in the future. Also, they display returns on their website to give depositors a first chance on them. Credit unions can go down, but you can find ways to vet them on the net.



The rich will take more and

The rich will take more and more until they've taken too much. After that it's general anarchy or revolution - mass uprisings of the desperate populace and overthrow of the money-hungry dogs clinging to power and wealth that belongs to the people who made it.



The French Revolution: Very

The French Revolution: Very bloody. First they lopped off the heads of the royals & their lawyers. But they never could agree on how to divvy up the spoils.

Will history repeat itself?

Unfortunately, revolutions usually result in a new batch of thieves, bullies, & their thugs who make the new rules, and the wealth just transfers to the hands of the new wealthy class, who strangely, always seem to forget what it was like when they were the poor or middle class.

The best bet is to keep working on tax reform & keep voting the sob-storied-bullies out of office. The poor must keep exercising their patience and their majority vote: they have nothing else.

Perhaps a general strike, nationwide, would work.



We have passed the point

We have passed the point where blogs, emails, phone calls, faxes and the like have any effect. We have to take to the streets and shut things down... strike the companies and picket them and the homes of the CEOs to get noticed and demand an immediate end to the corporatocracy and reimbursement to the people. This theft has been going on for 40 years and picked up under Reagan. Now we have to return to a tax rate on the rich under Eisenhower of about 90% when the middle class trived. The dishonest ones need to be jailed, not given a slap on the wrist at recent Justice Dept do...



Madame Defarge was not

Madame Defarge was not correct, and if you talk like that, the people who join you will be thugs and sociopaths just like her. Also, learn to spell.



Message from the top: ESAD

Message from the top:

ESAD (Eat Sh*t And Die)



It's all very simple -

It's all very simple - rendered into Jargonese for the greedy illiterate: The People Who Work the Hardest Must Seize the Means of Production. Cut Out the Gold-Bricking Middlemen in Every Transaction. Keep the Money in Our Own Banks. When the Feckless Rich Come Begging, Make Their Assets Forfeit. Oh, and Anonymous on 8/2 at 15:52: Mme. DeFarge was FICTION! Chip has found a way to cope with reality, why don't you?



cheap designer handbags

[URL=http://www.cheap--designer-handbags.com/]designer cheap bags[/URL] at my estore oyjqDXSH http://www.cheap--designer-handbags.com/



ugg boot outlet uk

uggs sale uk to get new coupon pGbtrSsA http://www.uggboots--uk.net/



louis vuitton online outlet

look at louis vuitton outlets online with confident MnwErhVE http://www.louisvuitton--onlineshop.com/



chanel online shop

check chanel online shop for gift GvCgWmnF http://www.chanel-online--shop.net/



chanel outlet

for chanel outlet for gift RbgCIQXl http://www.chaneloutlet-handbags.com/



christian louboutin outlet real

sell christian louboutin outlet store at my estore apJbPfWW http://www.christianlouboutin-outletstore.org/



gucci outlet

purchase gucci outlets to take huge discount nDWzPcHy http://www.gucci--outlet.net/



ridspyuy

uegjca