The Far Right's Hate Element

by: Eugene Robinson, Op-Ed

The Far Right's Hate Element
(Image: Jared Rodriguez / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: Jule_Berlin, Thomas Hawk)

Washington - The arrests of members of a Michigan-based "Christian" militia group should convince doubters that there is good reason to worry about right-wing, anti-government extremism -- and potential violence -- in the Age of Obama.

I put the word Christian in quotes because anyone who plots to assassinate law enforcement officers, as a federal indictment alleges members of the Hutaree militia did, is no follower of Christ. According to federal prosecutors, the Hutaree -- the word's not in my dictionary, but their Web site claims it means "Christian warrior" -- are convinced that their enemies include "state and local law enforcement, who are deemed 'foot soldiers' of the federal government, federal law enforcement agencies and employees, participants in the 'New World Order,' and anyone who does not share in the Hutaree's beliefs."

According to the indictment, the group had been plotting for two years to assassinate federal, state or local police officers. "Possible such acts which were discussed," the indictment says, "included killing a member of law enforcement after a traffic stop, killing a member of law enforcement and his or her family at home, ambushing a member of law enforcement in rural communities, luring a member of law enforcement with a false 911 emergency call and then killing him or her, and killing a member of law enforcement and then attacking the funeral procession motorcade" with homemade bombs.

Nine members of the Hutaree were named in the indictment. Eight were arrested during weekend FBI raids in Michigan, Ohio and Indiana; one suspect remains at large. The group's Web site shows members in camouflage outfits traipsing through woods in "training" exercises. They could be out for an afternoon of paintball, except for the loony rhetoric about "sword and flame" and the page, labeled "Gear," that links to several gun dealers. Along with numerous weapons offenses, the Hutaree are charged with sedition.

The episode highlights the obvious: For decades now, the most serious threat of domestic terrorism has come from the growing ranks of paranoid, anti-government hate groups that draw their inspiration, vocabulary and anger from the far right.

It is disingenuous for mainstream purveyors of incendiary far-right rhetoric to dismiss groups such as the Hutaree by saying that there are "crazies on both sides." This simply is not true.

There was a time when the far left was a spawning ground for political violence. The first big story I covered was the San Francisco trial of heiress Patricia Hearst, who had been kidnapped and eventually co-opted by the Symbionese Liberation Army -- a far-left group whose philosophy was as apocalyptic and incoherent as that of the Hutaree. There are aging radicals in Cuba today who got to Havana by hijacking airplanes in the 1970s. Left-wing radicals caused mayhem and took innocent lives.

But for the most part, far-left violence in this country has gone the way of the leisure suit and the AMC Gremlin. An antiglobalization movement, including a few window-smashing anarchists, was gaining traction at one point, but it quickly diminished after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. An environmental group and an animal-rights group have been linked with incidents of arson. Beyond those particulars, it is hard to identify any kind of leftist threat.

By contrast, there has been explosive growth among far-right, militia-type groups that identify themselves as white supremacists, "constitutionalists," tax protesters and religious soldiers determined to kill people to uphold "Christian" values. Most of the groups that posed a real danger, as the Hutaree allegedly did, have been infiltrated and dismantled by authorities before they could do any damage. But we should never forget that the worst act of domestic terrorism ever committed in this country was authored by a member of the government-hating right wing: Timothy McVeigh's bombing of the federal building in Oklahoma City.

It is dishonest for right-wing commentators to insist on an equivalence that does not exist. The danger of political violence in this country comes overwhelmingly from one direction -- the right, not the left. The vitriolic, anti-government hate speech that is spewed on talk radio every day -- and, quite regularly, at tea party rallies -- is calibrated not to inform but to incite.

Demagogues scream at people that their government is illegitimate, that their country has been "taken away," that their elected officials are "traitors" and that their freedom is at risk. They have a right to free speech, which I will always defend. But they shouldn't be surprised if some listeners take them literally.

Eugene Robinson's e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com.

(c) 2010, Washington Post Writers Group 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



I expect the perspective

I expect the perspective looked the same to George III, confronting the minutemen across the green at Lexington.



Except the minutemen didn't

Except the minutemen didn't have a right to vote and truly had no say in what was to be. They should not be compared to the "patriots" of today.



What can one expect when

What can one expect when 'news' purveyors inject 'balance' into stories where none exists? "Democrats do it too!" isn't going to work anymore, just as 'vote for us, we're not Republicans' is no longer effective either.



The first mistake is to

The first mistake is to label these groups as "right wing" or "anarchist". These are sad, depressed, low self esteem folks who've seemed to have found each other and believe they have a solution to their depression. If only there were no government, if only we could get rid of the police, if only life itself weren't so oppressive. Their solution seems to lie in weaponry because they have lost, or never had, the ability to work hard to improve themselves or their situation in life. They are without the verbal, mental skills and social skills required to move within any government without blaming it for their ills. I have no doubt that most of these folks don't even vote, believing that it will change nothing. That may be true but guns and ammo will not change much except making guns and ammo laws tougher.



There is no such thing as a

There is no such thing as a person who understood the philosophy of Jesus and is a member of a "right-wing militia". They are just a group of armed ignorant yahoos who are most probably racist.



One of these days when the

One of these days when the right grows up, maybe they'll have somewhere close to the numbers of hate-spewers of the left. Naw, that could never happen. They're amateurs compared to the the pros.



Another case of badly mixed

Another case of badly mixed up Americans. Every time a movement tries to fold in both Faith and Politics, it is the faith part that suffers and the politics that are ascendant.
Since politics involves one's human needs and desires, God gets small attention and issues start looking like human means and methods can make the difference. I pity these fools.
Let's get this straight: the USA is a secular democratic republic and was intended as such from the start. That arrangement left us each free to pursue our own faith without fear of interference or reprisal by the government. People who mix up end times eschatology with the ongoing growing pains of our democracy miss both boats, and prove only that they understand neither. But then again, demagoguery is cheap and pretty danged exciting for a time. Truth be told, the world devours its own. God help these people.



If these were Muslims,

If these were Muslims, they'd be called "terrorists" and subjected to our shadow pseudo-justice system -- i.e., "indefinite detention" and "harsh interrogation techniques". But because they're white, native-born, and "christian", they get the standard criminal treatment. What a pathetically dishonest country we are.



Well, what shall I say?

Well, what shall I say? there was a time in the land of the free, when Kill a commie for Jesus was one of the best sold t -shirts and comics. Is it me only who has a sense of Deja vu?



Most comments here have it

Most comments here have it backwards. Most deaths now and throughout history have been because of religion. Christians (including US military persons who considered themselves christian) have killed and are now killing in the Middle East many. Christians even worship death - one of their most religious symbols is death on a cross.



@Phot > actually most

@Phot > actually most violent deaths are cause by one's own government. Read - "Death by Government", by far the greatest killer ever.



Unfortunate, Obama does not

Unfortunate, Obama does not confront these groups. In fact, I think he intends to win them over with his bomber jacket gear.



There is a large difference

There is a large difference between a Christian, most of whom are enslaved by the concepts of "faith" and religion, and someone who understands, respects, and appreciates the philosophy and ideas of Jesus. Christianity has a huge history of violence, the most notable of incidents being the Crusades (and/or the Spanish Inquisition). Religion, especially when mixed with politics, is a bad idea for societies to subscribe to.



As a friend said yesterday

As a friend said yesterday "Why are these people in Michigan being referred to as "militia" & not "terrorists"? Is because they're white and not Muslims?"



What, Eugene, no mention of

What, Eugene, no mention of Eric Rudolph (the Olympic Park Bomber, among other "achievements"), or Scott Roeder (the murderer of Dr. Tiller)? The examples of Right Wing violence go beyond just Oklahoma City.