Why Granny Gets Searched

by: Eugene Robinson, Op-Ed

Washington - It's hard to love the Transportation Security Administration, especially now that airport personnel seem so intent on touching people's junk. But the TSA's job isn't to be adorable, it's to be infallible -- and also, apparently, to suffer being unfairly maligned.

Sure, the "don't touch my junk" guy touched a nerve. I spend enough time fighting my way through airport security lines to share his frustration at ever-changing procedures that seem capricious, intrusive and sometimes just bizarre. But what, specifically, is the alternative?

Last Christmas, Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab allegedly tried to bring down an airliner by detonating explosives concealed in his underwear. The device did not properly explode, but the incident sensitized the TSA to the danger of terrorist bombs that might make it past a metal detector -- hence the rush to install full-body scanners that give a clear view of what's beneath a person's clothing, junk and all.

An unacceptable, un-American invasion of privacy? That's not what critics were saying at the time. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano's assessment of the underwear bombing attempt -- that "the system worked" because a fellow passenger jumped Abdulmutallab -- was ridiculed. If there was technology that could have detected the underpants device, critics asked, why hadn't it been in place?

So now the scanners are being installed -- and some people complain that they do too good a job, clear-picture-wise. The TSA's response is to give travelers the option of submitting to a manual search that is comparably thorough. It would defeat the whole purpose of the machines if people could just say "no thanks" and then undergo a cursory search that might leave a device like the underwear bomb undiscovered. The pat-down, if it comes to that, has to be thorough.

Is all of this really necessary? That depends on how safe we want to be, or rather how safe we want to feel.

The device that Abdulmutallab was wearing is believed to have been designed and built by Osama bin Laden's affiliate organization in Yemen, called al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, or AQAP. This group has been increasingly active and makes no secret of its continuing desire to blow U.S. airliners out of the sky.

On Sunday, AQAP boasted of putting two sophisticated bombs -- disguised as printer ink cartridges -- into cargo shipments bound for the United States last month. The powerful devices were intercepted en route, in Britain and Dubai, and appeared to have been designed to detonate in transit.

In other words, these AQAP people are resourceful and determined. Now, we could decide that treating air-traveling Americans like Guantanamo inmates is going too far -- that by doing so, we invest a bunch of terrorists with power they do not deserve. That might make sense, but we'd have to understand the consequences.

For any individual, the chance of being killed or injured in a terrorist attack would still be infinitesimal. But the chance that somewhere, somehow, AQAP or some other terrorist group eventually downs an aircraft would greatly increase.

We have not decided, and probably will not decide, to put this in the category of acceptable risks, along with plane crashes due to bad weather or flocks of geese. The economic and psychological damage from terrorist attacks is so great that we have resolved to prevent them. This is what we ask the TSA to do.

What the critics really mean is not that the TSA should let underwear bombers board planes. What they're saying is: Don't search me, and don't search my grandmother. Just search the potential terrorists.

In other words, they want profiling. That's a seductive idea, I suppose, if you don't spend a lot of time worrying about civil liberties. But it couldn't possibly work. Our terrorist enemies may be evil but they're not stupid.

If we only search people who "look like terrorists," al-Qaeda will send people who don't fit the profile. It's no accident that most of the Sept. 11, 2001, hijackers were from Saudi Arabia; at the time, it was easier for Saudi nationals to get U.S. visas than it was for citizens of other Arab countries. If terrorists are clever enough to hide powerful explosives in ink cartridges, then eventually they'll find a suicide bomber who looks just like you, me or Granny.

Be patient with the TSA. And have a happy Thanksgiving.

Eugene Robinson's e-mail address is eugenerobinson(at)washpost.com.

(c) 2010, Washington Post Writers Group 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Dear Mr. President, Re: the

Dear Mr. President,

Re: the TSA and such, Reinventing the wheel is stupid but, that's just what we are doing. Let's do this instead:http://www.thestar.com/printarticle/744199

" Israelification - That is, how can we make our airports more like Israel's, which deal with far greater terror threat with far less inconvenience.

"It is mindboggling for us Israelis to look at what happens in North America, because we went through this 50 years ago," said Rafi Sela, the president of AR Challenges, a global transportation security consultancy. He's worked with the RCMP, the U.S. Navy Seals and airports around the world.

"Israelis, unlike Canadians and Americans, don't take s--- from anybody. When the security agency in Israel (the ISA) started to tighten security and we had to wait in line for — not for hours — but 30 or 40 minutes, all hell broke loose here. We said, 'We're not going to do this. You're going to find a way that will take care of security without touching the efficiency of the airport."

That, in a nutshell is "Israelification" - a system that protects life and limb without annoying you to death." ..............(see above link for the rest)

Please make sure everybody reads this vital article. I further urge you to try much harder to make the policies you campaigned on a reality. Yes, the country desperately needs to find its common ground but, trying to reason with those who have repudiated reason in favor of superstition, lies and avarice is tantamount to bringing a knife to a gunfight. The last two years looks like elegant Tango dancing, solo - sans partner. It looks weird and disconcerting. Just stomp out corruption wherever you see it and fire those who can't get with the program. the old adage applies: "Never wrestle with a pig because you'll just get muddy and only the pig enjoys it."

Achieving meaningful results, irrespective of what the bought and paid for corporate minions posing as legislators say about it, will widen the bonds of brotherhood and unity among ordinary people living and trying to find work outside the Beltway. Ignore the cacophonous chorus. Let them play with their own poop as is their wont and press on with the tasks you were elected to perform. Who in their right mind would want a second term anyway?

Yes YOU can! NIKE says: Just Do It!

Hopefully Yours,
Mike Morris



This expat who hasn't

This expat who hasn't travelled in the USA for a while sums the whole thing up nicely. http://mayantrip.com
I couldn't disagree with you ideas more strongly. The reason for these reactive measures is much more about contracts for Chertoffs company and getting Americans used to having no dignity and feeling powerless against authority. A terrible article for Truthout, seems more like Fox!



Abdulmutallab and Mohammed

Abdulmutallab and Mohammed and Ahmed are higher security risks than Eugene's granny. We should allow low-risk passengers to get a background check and clearance in advance, and then those with a clearance should be able to go through metal detectors just like the old days.

We are under attack by Muslim Jihadists, not by Eugene's granny. Let's get real. People with no criminal history and no connection with Islam should not be treated as potential terrorists.



Great idea! Let's ignore

Great idea! Let's ignore white people with no criminal history and no connection with Islam. Timothy McVeigh comes to mind....



Here's an idea that's

Here's an idea that's actually assured of working, unlike anything the idiots at the TSA could dream up.

STOP GIVING PEOPLE REASONS TO KILL US.

Stop treating foreign nationals like serfs in their own land, meddling in their governmental affairs just so US companies can appease stockholders and idiot american consumers who just want more more more.

Stop letting our multinationals conduct their business outside the US as if the globe is just a toilet for them to dump our waste in.

Stop viewing the resources of the world as ours for the taking, once those impish citizens of the host countries shut up and do what we want.

Stop supporting oppressive regimes in countries we "need" while starting wars in countries over "democracy" we clearly care nothing about.

The best way to stop someone from flying a plane into a building is to take away their reasons for doing it in the first place. But what fun is that when there's MONEY to be made, the true american value.



I think things have now

I think things have now reached the point where I will not travel by air if there is any alternative. The balance between privacy and security has tipped far too far away from privacy. I'd rather some risk in exchange for dignity.



The author expresses a

The author expresses a shallow and complacent point of view. From video and photographic evidence taken at US airports, what is happening is clearly wrong. That so many embedded within the federal government and corporate media, peddling doubletalk and bogus polls, are engaged in trying to convince regular citizens who are rightfully appalled,convince them that this is all normal and for their own good - well, this is truly the boiling frog analogy in disturbing real-life display. One can hope that the mendacity of all those promoting the new measures will serve to utterly discredit them, but they hold the upper hand for now.

I believe if these measures were introduced back in the summer, a groundswell of opposition would have found voice in the mid-terms, and that these measures were deliberately held back to remove any effective political opposition.



This policy has next to

This policy has next to nothing to do with security and everything to do with sheep herding and animal husbandry. Wake up people, you're being led. How the hell did a piece such as this apology for the creeping fascist security state end up on Truth Out? Maybe my subscription to this website should be examined. Stop spreading the usual lies Truth Out, I had higher expectations of you. What a crock.



I think Lewis Black said it

I think Lewis Black said it best; Americans are willing to bomb countries and kill countless civilians but we draw the draw the line at getting a pat down.



17:49 Timothy McVeigh did

17:49 Timothy McVeigh did not blow up an airplane. The only group of people demonstrating a high likelihood of blowing up airplanes is Muslims. The rest of us should not have to be treated as potential terrorists.

PS Islam is not a race.



By most accounts, the

By most accounts, the underwear bomber was drugged out of his mind and put through Dutch security, despite their protests, by a well-dressed English-speaking man of South Asian appearance, who, interestingly, no one can seem to find. Another false-flag "terrorist" attack?

"We have not decided, and probably will not decide, to put this in the category of acceptable risks, along with plane crashes due to bad weather or flocks of geese. The economic and psychological damage from terrorist attacks is so great that we have resolved to prevent them. This is what we ask the TSA to do."

Who's "we"? To me and millions of other Americans, the infinitesimal chance of being involved in a terrorist incident isn't worth giving up my rights. Even a great possibility of dying in a terrorist attack isn't worth surrendering to.
Speak for yourself, Mr Robinson.



"What the critics really

"What the critics really mean is not that the TSA should let underwear bombers board planes. What they're saying is: Don't search me, and don't search my grandmother. Just search the potential terrorists."
Again, you're putting words in the mouths of millions of Americans who don't want profiling (beyond the obvious, like the underwear bomber, who had no checked-in luggage, no passport, looked disheveled, was with someone who didn't fit the picture, etc.)
And let's be clear about something else; anyone who wants to will be able to get weapons past the scanners by hiding them in their bodies. It's simple and effective.
And now I see Mr Robinson's email address is at the Washington Post--well, now things are a bit clearer. Perhaps we could keep Fred Hiatt's employees away from Truthout--or is Truthout trying to become truth-free?



Truthout and the Matrix are

Truthout and the Matrix are one. Surprise, surprise.

Yes. Let's be patient with the TSA, with Obama, with the Banks and Wall Street. Let's be patient with General Petraeus and Afghanistan, with Climate Change and Congress. Let's be patient as we walk into the showers while awaiting a savior. Yes let's be patient as we are trained to live without a Bill of Rights, without the 4th Amendment, without the Writ of Habeas Corpus. Yes my fellow Truthout readers, Let's be patient while listening in on the following:

Morpheus: The Matrix is everywhere. It is all around us. Even now, in this very room. You can see it when you look out your window or when you turn on your television. You can feel it when you go to work... when you go to church... when you pay your taxes. It is the world that has been pulled over your eyes to blind you from the truth.

Neo: What truth?

Morpheus: That you are a slave, Neo. Like everyone else you were born into bondage. Into a prison that you cannot taste or see or touch. A prison for your mind.

Morpheus: I'm trying to free your mind, Neo. But I can only show you the door. You're the one that has to walk through it.



[Please, please, Mr. Bush

[Please, please, Mr. Bush take your Book Tour in Spain and Italy!! And do some real bragging while you're at it!!! They'll have a good laugh with you!] We are on our way to Second Meltdown. The first was this Great Recession (or really a Depression), a gift from George W. Now that torture is once more Legal, and mega-theft by Wall Street is commonplace and encouraged (through absolutely no regulations worth a piss in a tornado), we are assured that the continued omni-presence of the surveillance, spying and intelligence networkswill continue the path of devastation predicted by none other – Osama bin Laden.  900,000 employees, 235 Agencies and $80 Billion Dollars plus, we will never be safe using the transportation industry because there now HASTO BE terrorists everywhere to justify the stupidity.
 

The real terrorists were never investigated, indicted, jailed or convicted.  But alot of innocents were.  Heartless Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Rice, Yoo, Tenet, Fielding, et.al., packed the 911 Commission with ass___es that did not do any
investigation of that, then current, administration.  No investigation of thecollapse of Building 7.  No investigation of ALL THE GD EXPLOSIVE MATERIAL ALL OVER DOWNTOWN NYC AT THE WTC!!  (Materials that were only made and used by OUR GOVERNMENT.)  Or explosive material of any kind.  No collection of evidence either. 
 
The reason the collapse is guaranteed for this next Meltdown is these treasonous morons (who definitely think and know, that they are the smartest and most dangerous idiots on the planet).  The collapse of the Transportation Industry is assured….no matter how many mergers and acquisitions are made.  With only 58.5% of the country actually having jobs, the rest are left to be inducted into the latest detention and interrogations centers for Fun and Profit.  Welcome to Heartless Cheney’s Funland!!
 
They have the weapons and the hearts of millions of extremists – who happen to be American fascists.  These are the people so willing to sacrifice anyone else (other than themselves) to keep Amurika safe and strong.  They are the number one reason we get attacked, got attacked and will continue to be attacked.  Actually, they don’t have an ounce of integrity left when they have an agenda under the false flag. More than willing to do in thousands, if not millions of their fellow citizens for a paycheck. 
 
Mr. Robinson’s assertions are frivolous and disconnected. His amazing ignorance and lack of understanding of science, dismissal of evidence and lack of gut check when it comes to these know issues is sad.  How amazingly obeisant he has become.  This debacle came from the horrific contrivance of 911.  And none of us are “safe” or ever will be from our own shadow government.

 



the author is a shill for

the author is a shill for corporate interests

The security theatre at american airports is completely unnecessary and over the top, it is an assault on innocent non-govt employee tax paying citizens.

The TSA procedures are invasive, ugly, repugnant, unnecessary, and an assault on the american air traveler.

You'd think all these people weren't paying customers if you didn't know otherwise, they are treated as if they are all criminals

and the searching of CHILDREN and disabled folks and folks with medical conditions is disgusting.



Let's imagine for a moment

Let's imagine for a moment that Afghanistan has a big Army and a hi-tech Air Force.

And let's further imagine that they send a few hundred thousand troops to New Jersey and Florida and California and Washington State and all of the states in between. And they start killing those of us who might oppose their invasion and occupation. And our families. And many U.S. residents who aren't actively opposing them. With drone aircraft. Afghan Marines kicking in doors in the suburbs and arresting or killing people in the process.

Wouldn't we then have people ready to put bombs on Afghan civilian airlines.

This is not to excuse terrorism. Ooly to offer a logical explanation for THEIR desperate desire to hurt us. It is not rational to kill innocent people. But we are doing it all the time in Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan with our military on the ground and with drone aircraft, killing "insurgents."

And it is making people angry in those countries. Angry enough to lash out with irrational retaliation.



What a condescending,

What a condescending, schmucky article. "Do you have any better ideas?" "Be patient with the TSA." "Have a good Thanksgiving." "

Sickening.

Agree with poster who says it's starting to sound like FOX around here.



Granny does not get searched

Granny does not get searched because of the underwear bomber.

She gets searched because politicians like John Kerry have hundreds of thousands invested in see-through technology, and a sprinkling of Republicans with a few thou each in the same.

She gets searched because Mr Robinson asks dumbly, "Whadya want them to do after the underwear bomber?"

Well, for one, check their lists better since the underwear bomber was one, as his father had reported his son as a risk.

Just like the 9-11 terrorist with a forged passport was coming in in spite of being groped. Because they didn't use procedures that would have revealed that he wiped out an entire Visa from a nation that would have caused the authorities reasonable suspicion because of his recent visit.

Reasonable suspicion is like probably cause Robinson. Ever hear of the 4th amendment? Freedom from UNreasonable searches and seizures?

Why Granny is NOT supposed to be searched.



Don't touch my junk. Is

Don't touch my junk. Is that, like, my breasts, my vagina, my penis, my testacles? Is that, like, my child's breasts, my child's vagina, my child's penis, my child's testacles? Or like, you are not allowed to see me naked just because I bought a plane ticket?

Robinson is seriously spaced out, if he thinks it is such a light matter for mass numbers of innocent people to be subjected to this behavior.

I think he should say these various words: Write the body parts, not "my junk."