Former UN Official Urges Irish-Americans to Defend the Rachel Corrie
Thursday 03 June 2010
by: Robert Naiman, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

(Photo: freegazaorg)
Former UN Assistant Secretary General Denis Halliday said it was imperative that the Obama administration supported Ireland's call on the Israeli authorities to ensure safe passage for the Irish-flagged Rachel Corrie to carry humanitarian aid to Gaza, the Irish Times reports. Speaking by satellite phone from on board the Rachel Corrie, Halliday called on Irish-Americans to lobby the Obama administration: "We also feel there is a role for the Irish diaspora here, in the US and elsewhere to lobby politicians over this continued illegal blockade of Gaza, which is causing such hardship to the Palestinian people."
Halliday has some experience with this issue, having resigned from his position as UN Humanitarian Coordinator in Iraq in 1998 over the impact of UN/US sanctions on Iraqi civilians.
The issue of the Gaza blockade has tremendous resonance in Ireland, partly because of Ireland's high degree of engagement in international humanitarian causes - John Ging, head of the UN Relief and Works Agency in Gaza, who had called on the international community to break the siege by sending ships loaded with aid, is also Irish - but also, of course, because the Irish people have some experience with the consequences for civilians of a colonial blockade.
Between 1845 and 1850, more than a million Irish people starved to death under British rule, while, as Sinéad O'Connor famously noted, food was shipped out of Ireland under armed guard. A million more fled Ireland to escape starvation, many to America, including Falmouth Kearney, President Obama's great, great, great grandfather.
Many Irish people - and Irish-Americans - take the responsibilities of this legacy very seriously.
Mary Robinson - former president of Ireland, and former UN high commissioner for human rights, has said:
The best possible commemoration of the men and women who died in that Famine, who were cast up on other shores because of it, is to take their dispossession into the present with us, to help others who now suffer in a similar way.
That's what Halliday is trying to do. Doesn't he deserve all our support?

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Arrest Haliday, deport him,
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 15:58 — Anonymous (not verified)Arrest Haliday, deport him, confiscate the Rachael Corrie and sell it for scrap. Run a legal blockade at your own peril. The Irish Diaspora? Oh what a world these crackpots live in.
Evergreen's student body
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 16:54 — Jade Queen (not verified)Evergreen's student body voted overwhelmingly for divestment from war profiteers. This latest stick in the eye at Turkey and others will speed calls for boycotts and divestiture from companies like Caterpillar. Gaza must be freed from Israeli-imposed poverty and humiliation. The Israeli government controls far more munitions than the Palestinians, but Palestinians are winning the hearts and minds of the world's people. The U.S. government will eventually be forced to stop subsidizing harm on the scale we have seen in recent years. Putting a stick in Irish eyes is poorly, poorly advised.
Hey anonymous, why don't you
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 17:09 — Michael Perkins MFSO-MN (not verified)Hey anonymous, why don't you have the courage to use your name when you attack people w/ statements like those ? You must think yourself a real man but are sorely mistaken, the people on those boats make you seem very small. They have real courage & are backed by most of the world.
The U.S. must now lead a UN
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 17:37 — Anonymous (not verified)The U.S. must now lead a UN security council effort to safeguard--guarantee--relief to Gaza. Naval escorts are no threat to anyone. That would be a peaceful use of force. Would demonstrate honesty and purpose behind what otherwise becomes empty words of resolution. Petition your politicians!
We can't speak to Anonymous
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 17:52 — Leo Ray Ingle (not verified)We can't speak to Anonymous because he/she didn't give his/her name. I suspect that, between 1845 and 1850, when over a million Irish died of starvation caused by the Empire of the Day, the British Empire, there was a contention that it was a legal blockade. The British may have contended it was--or was the art of public whopper-telling not so developed back then?
Read U.S. newspapers closely. U.S.A. Today contended those on largest boat attacked with firearms, knives and clubs. The Israelis, elsewhere, admitted the only firearms found were two of the commandos handguns in the hands of dead activists. Empty magazines were cited as evidence the activists fired.
With disinformation and lies from our corporate-controlled media, is it any wonder we are the only country standing between Israel and an enraged world?
Leo Ray Ingle
Why haven't all these
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 18:33 — Anonymous (not verified)Why haven't all these "outraged" nations (as referenced @22:52), and through the United Nations, offered to oversee a lessened blockade in which shipment of weaponry in and out of Gaza would be stopped?
It seems that the Israeli
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 19:18 — Anonymous (not verified)It seems that the Israeli government has indicated that they plan to handle things differently since their people were not prepared to board this kind of vessel under those kinds of circumstances.
Likewise, the Irish activists have indicated that they plan to be sitting upon being boarded, with their hands in plan view, so as not to be misinterpreted.
My hope for the journey of the Rachel Corrie is that the Irish activists show more self-discipline than the Turkish activists who endangered everyone on the boat with their individual decision-making and actions. And that the Israeli officials, likewise, use a more informed strategy for dealing non-violently with protesters.
continued
continued Obviously, the
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 19:22 — Anonymous (not verified)continued
Obviously, the self-discipline of protestors would have extend, as well, to not resisting arrest. They can either walk cooperatively with the authorities, or be carried out, something like the Israeli protestors who didn't want to leave their homes.
But apparently, they are planning for things not to even go that far, since they are supervising the delivery of shipment, and perhaps with the participation of one or two persons from the ship itself who would like to see for themselves that everything is delivered.
Maybe the outraged U.N. could help with that a little bit. Hm?
I have to wonder how many people supporting the Rachel Corrie want this entire episode to happen peacefully. And are ENCOURAGING that to happen peacefully. Vs. (secretly wishing for violence).
Why for example is the Rachel Corrie already, in the words of the writer, being "defended" or "attacked" by Irish Americans?
Peace activists don't
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 21:28 — Ken Hall (not verified)Peace activists don't secretly hope for violence, what they hope for is increased international attention brought to bear upon an unsustainable, cruel occupation, hoping Israel will confront its intransigence, bend to international opinion, and change its "facts on the ground" policy that it thinks will implement its desire to annex land set aside by UN partition for a Palestinian state. With so many of the world's nations opposing Israel's military land-grab and ethnic cleansing, it would be wise for Israel to listen. Israel and its great enabler the US do not a majority make, and eventually the crows will come home to roost, maybe not in our lifetimes, but eventually and most assuredly. This is a very dark time for the Jewish people, an era they will not look back on with pride. They have come to power and are using it in much the same way it was used for so long against them.
Ken Hall, with all due
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 21:39 — Anonymous (not verified)Ken Hall, with all due respect, your kind of response leaves me with the feeling that people are just talking past one another.
I leave you with your rhetoric.
Since apparently, you can't even voice the same practicable hopes.
The cast of Irish characters
Thu, 06/03/2010 - 21:43 — Anonymous (not verified)The cast of Irish characters revealed in this article shine a whole new light on Gaza for us:
Ging
Halliday
Robinson
Corrie
and this call by Halliday and Robinson for Americans to join in and break a legal blockade of Terrorist Gaza. And the article clearly states that Ireland, officially, is clearly behind the running of this blockade.
Hamas would perhaps have folded by now if not for your efforts to prop them up. This is a stunning indictment. This is shocking.
Anonymus 02.43:your arrogant
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 03:56 — Anonymous (not verified)Anonymus 02.43:your arrogant zionism oozes its poison, in your thinking,you have a poisoned mentality that will lead you and the likes of you to yet another downfall.
Z.
Just give Palastinians the
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 07:03 — wdn (not verified)Just give Palastinians the home they need and deserve. That is the proper thing to do. It is the honorable thing to do. It is the mature and adult thing to do. But Israel won't. Deep in their collective psychology they wish to enslave the way they were enslaved, torture the way that they were tortured, kill the way they were killed.
Will the world continue to tolerate and coddle Israel's malignant historical paranoia? Let's hope for everyone's sake that it does not.
Picture these
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 07:50 — Anonarcmous (not verified)Picture these disproportions: Israel is surrounded by1] 22 hostile nations, 2] comprising 640 times its surface area, with 3] 60 times its population with 4] all the oil resources of those regions. Most 5] muslim arab countries do not allow any other religion but their own to be a citizen--you convert or leave.Period. Don't even suggest anything else. So 6] about 13 million jews are blamed for the 1.5+ billion arab's problems. 7] that dissolving the nation of Israel would solve all their problems & is 8] the #1 stumblingblock to world peace All this lasered at a country 9] 20,770 kilometres square which is about the size of the US 5th smallest state New Jersey...& this might justify some of ”Israel’s malignant paranoia. Once again, in no way does this make everything the Israelis do right.
Israel is a Euro-Asian
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 09:37 — Ken Hall (not verified)Israel is a Euro-Asian colony forced on an indigenous population by the machinations of the British Empire. Jews and Arabs had been living peacefully on the land until the Zionist movement began and Arabs became afraid of exactly what has happened, their marginalization and disenfranchisement in their own land. So yes, Israel is surrounded by a hostile population. Does one take other people's property and kill and brutalize them and expect them to be happy about it? And let's consider the number of dead on either side, overwhelmingly lopsided. As Daniela Perdomo recently noted, the Israelis just killed more civilians in one day than Gazan rockets have in the past ten years. Operation Cast Lead, less than ten Israelis dead, more than a thousand Palestinians. Who is it has the security problem? If Israel returned to its '67 borders there might be peace but actions speak louder than words, Israel doesn't want peace, it wants the land and resources set aside by UN mandate for a Palestinian nation. One can only hope that with enough international pressure, divestment and boycotts of Israeli goods and trade, Israel will reconsider its expansionist policies.
Ken Hall, if you are so
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 10:43 — Sharonsj (not verified)Ken Hall, if you are so upset over marginalization and disenfranchisement, perhaps you could take a look at how Jews have been treated in Arab lands, where you claim people were living peacefully?
Baghdad once had 150,000 Jews. They all fled the wrath of their Arab neighbors so that when the U.S. invaded, only 27 were still living there.
In Yemen the few hundred Jews who have not managed to escape need police protection because their peaceful neighbors keep trying to slaughter them.
In Iran, Jews are not allowed to leave and are periodically accused and hung for being "spies."
Jordan--no Jews there because they are not allowed to become citizens or own land.
If you're upset about dead civilians, are you planning a march on Turkey for killing 35,000 Kurds? And when the Palestinians and the rest of the Muslims kill all the Jews--which they daily claim is their aim--will you be writing outraged emails on their behalf?
Israel, by far the most
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 12:50 — Ken Hall (not verified)Israel, by far the most powerful military in the region and armed with nukes, is in no danger of being wiped off the map. The "poor little defenseless Israel" claim is silly and old, and proven time and again to be false. Israel invades neighboring countries at will. Look at the numbers of dead on either side and then tell me who has the security problem. It's not Israel. I deplore genocide wherever it happens and add my voice in protest, but Turkey, Ruanda, etc, are not the subject of this article. The vast majority of countries in the UN are in favor of Israel's return to '67 borders as a condition for peace in the region. To contend that Israel conform to international law and Geneva conventions, which it obligated itself to do when it joined the UN, is neither anti-semitic nor anti-Israel.
Hopefully, the Irish will
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 15:14 — brother_unknown (not verified)Hopefully, the Irish will soon be investing in small manufacturing plants in Palestine, so that the Palestineans need no longer depend on handouts. We know that no Moslem organization has the slightest intention of helping Palestine create jobs.
Those few who survived the
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 23:07 — gehan (not verified)Those few who survived the German camps knew the situation was hopeless. But some persevered nevertheless and many of those who did moved to Israel. People as smart as today's Zionists know that in the long-run the situation is equally as hopeless - inch by inch and rocket by rocket the Arabs will ultimately prevail. But I just can't reproach Israelis for trying what ever it takes to last "one more day." I beg my Jewish friends not to move there or to leave - some do and some don't. I can also see where the Arabs are coming from and would probably do the same in their shoes. Lord Balfour has a lot to answer for - let us hope he resides on one of the more unpleasant circles of the Inferno.
These Israeli scum were no
Sat, 06/05/2010 - 16:07 — Low Key (not verified)These Israeli scum were no different than the Somali scum who board ships at sea in international waters. Even had there been guns and other weapons in use by the Turks on their ship, they were well within their rights to repel boarders. I think it highly unlikely there were any weapons other than improvised weapons on board those ships. The Israeli government is acting just like the Natzi government that they so hate. They've created their very own gettos for the Palestinians and next they will be looking for a final solution.
I live in Texas. The
Sun, 06/06/2010 - 15:43 — harriet irby (not verified)I live in Texas. The blockade of Gaza is not understood here. this is part of the US bible belt
Many Christians here are unthinking Zionists.
We have also Jewish people here who are not zionist at all.It is a strange paradox. It has much to with "defense economics" and the church being at the service o f the " national security state"
The Gaza Blockade can not stand. It is intolerable