Guestworker Group Exposes Forced Labor in Tennessee

by: Jacob Horwitz  |  Labor Notes | Report

Guestworker Group Exposes Forced Labor in Tennessee
(Photo: Matthew C. Wright / Flickr)

Hilario Jimenez was a farmer from a poor town in the Mexican state of Nayarit. Working on tobacco, bean, and tomato farms, he would earn as little as $12 a day.

In April, Jimenez took on $1,000 of debt—a crushing amount in rural Mexico—for the promise of fair, well-paid work in the United States on an H2B guestworker visa. “I don’t like being separated from my family, but the necessity makes you do it,” Jimenez said.

Guestworker program rules bind workers to one employer. No matter how severely an employer exploits them, guestworkers cannot leave to work for anyone else.

He and 11 other Mexican guestworkers arrived in Smyrna, Tennessee, to work for a company called Vanderbilt Landscaping. Vanderbilt obtained guestworker visas by claiming to the U.S. Department of Labor that it could not find a single American to fill its highway-side landscaping jobs—at a time when Tennessee suffers a 10.1 percent unemployment rate.

Though Vanderbilt had received $2.46 million in state contracts and $900,000 in guaranteed loans through the federal stimulus program, the company chose the guestworker program rather than hiring locally.

One of the bosses’ first acts was to seize the Mexican workers’ passports. “Everyone had to turn over their passports,” Jimenez said. “No one said anything because we had all just arrived and we had the debt hanging over our heads.”

Vanderbilt created an atmosphere of terror for the workers. Bosses openly carried pistols and brandished them. They placed workers in filthy, overcrowded housing under constant surveillance. “We were not allowed to talk to anyone,” Jimenez said. “We were not allowed to go to the store or anywhere else without supervision.” The workers’ official wages were $12.33 per hour, but they were routinely paid for far less than the hours they worked.

What is trustworthy information worth to you? Truthout needs your help. Make a donation today.

Guestworker program rules bind workers to one employer. No matter how severely an employer exploits them, guestworkers cannot leave to work for anyone else. If they quit or are fired, they can be arrested and deported back home—still stuck with the debt they took out in the first place.

When Jimenez and his fellow workers started to organize and reach out to the community for help, bosses further terrorized them through individual interrogations, threats, and illegally firing one of Jimenez’s co-workers for speaking out. They gave the worker 20 minutes to gather his belongings and forced him to spend his last paycheck on bus fare back to Mexico.

The story could have ended there, but it didn’t. Jimenez joined the Alliance of Guestworkers for Dignity, a growing network in states across the South. Late on the night of August 11, Jimenez escaped down a dirt road to tell the world the truth about forced labor in Tennessee.

On August 13, Jimenez and nearly 50 allies from the Tennessee labor and civil rights communities marched on Vanderbilt’s headquarters to confront the company for involuntary servitude and human trafficking.

Under pressure, co-owner Joffrey Vanderbilt turned over Jimenez’s passport and final paycheck. Local law enforcement arrived on the scene, took statements from Jimenez and witnesses, and confiscated the remaining workers’ passports from the Vanderbilt office.
“Hilario struck a blow not only for guestworkers around the country who have been locked into involuntary servitude,” said Saket Soni of the New Orleans Workers’ Center for Racial Justice, “but for American workers who are being locked out of jobs by dishonest employers.”

The workers and their allies are continuing a campaign to bring Vanderbilt to justice, and to demand accountability from the state of Tennessee and the U.S. Department of Labor for rewarding forced labor with state and federal funds. They are demanding protection for guestworkers laboring in this federal visa program.

Jacob Horwitz is an organizer with Alliance of Guestworkers for Dignity, a project of the New Orleans Workers’ Center for Racial Justice. See more at www.nowcrj.org. 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Thanks much Jacob for

Thanks much Jacob for reporting this. As a resident of Memphis, I felt it my duty to forward this column's link to a local TV station (WREG), to two investigative journalists and their generic e-mail, plus to a reporter for the local paper (Commercial Appeal). We'll see how corporate these news outlets are.

This is why illegal immigrants are so prevalent - they're in demand by dishonest American companies who seek to profit off those in dire situations and have no rights. It's these companies that are parasites, not the workers.



From the article - "

From the article - " Vanderbilt obtained guestworker visas by claiming to the U.S. Department of Labor that it could not find a single American to fill its highway-side landscaping jobs".

So thats what Vanderbilt "claimed" huh ? Well who could doubt the word of such an upstanding business.

A REAL unemployment rate of 20 percent in the US and companies are being allowed to import excess labor into this country.

Importation of excess labor has had a devastating effect on poor american workers. They use to barely get by. Now they are being driven into even greater poverty. TRUE compassion requires that we address their plight and secure them stable, good paying employment before we import any workers from another country.



Maybe we can start holding

Maybe we can start holding employers accountable for this and that? Maybe we can start enforcing the laws of this country on employers? Maybe we can start treating workers in America with a bit of dignity? Maybe...

But my guess is that these guys will skate on all this, continue to get state contracts and continue to grease the skids with a bit of cash here and there to support their political supporters.



Many a small business owner

Many a small business owner will tell you that many U.S. citizen applicants for jobs actually turn down offered jobs because they do not either pay what they want, or they pay less than the total of unemployment benefits available. in Illinois those benefits for a family of four can total more than $33,000 per year. This huge difference crates the market for abusing anyone not a U.S. citizen.



Great article. The key

Great article. The key question is why the Feds allow any foreign worker visas. That one million jobs a year denied unemployed Americans. If Obama simply spotlighted this racket and ended it, the Dems would sweep the Nov. Elections.
Of course Corporate American would deny Obama's "request."



Great story, and it's great

Great story, and it's great that Vanderbilt will be investigated. Let's hope the authorities are honest.
Midwest Tom says Americans won't take the work offered by "many a small business owner;" my guess is that many of these small business owners offer jobs like Vanderbilt--abusive and underpaid.



EVERY claim put forward in

EVERY claim put forward in support of H2B (and H1B) visas should be publicized a month before being granted. This should include the nature of the work, wages and benefits.

Just as people who want to claim unemployment benefits have to document their job-seeking efforts, employers must be required to document their efforts to hire.



Meanwhile....just last

Meanwhile....just last months 1,100 jobs from the Whirlpool plant in Evansville, Indiana were shiped to Mexico leaving 1,100 workers, many of them in their 50s, and their families in economic despair and panic.



One wonders just which

One wonders just which outrage--if any--will instigate a rebellion of the workers against employers who mis- treat their workers--American or foreign.



Don't forget, y'all: NAFTA

Don't forget, y'all: NAFTA made all this misery possible.