Hypatia and the Clash of Civilizations in Late Antiquity
Sunday 19 September 2010
by: Evaggelos Vallianatos, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed
When the Greeks spoke of "agora," they meant a place for political discussion, jury trials, and a market. In other words, agora was the center of Greek life.
In October 9, 2009, the Spanish movie producer, Alejandro Amenabar, released a film he pointedly named "Agora," in which he zeroed in the clash of Greek and Christian civilizations in the fourth and fifth centuries in Alexandria, Egypt.
The violent Christianization of polytheistic Greece even redefined agora as just a place for trade, eventually becoming the "free market" of today.
The protagonist of "Agora" is Hypatia, c. 370 - 415, daughter of the mathematician Theon who headed a school of philosophy and science in Alexandria. Following her father, Hypatia became a philosopher and mathematician. She taught the philosophy of Plato and Aristotle in both Athens and Alexandria. In Alexandria, she defended the Greek way of life against the Christians who sought to abolish it.
In "Agora," Rachel Weisz, beautiful and eloquent, very successfully played the demanding role of Hypatia.
I saw the film in late June 2010 in Claremont, California. The movie is a masterpiece of cinematography, acting and drama. But the most valuable aspect of "Agora" is its documentary-like character, bringing to life the violent globalization of Christianity.
What Christianity did to the Greek culture of Alexandria was paradigmatic of why the Greek world turned upside down and Rome itself and the West fell to the barbarians and a millennium of darkness.
Alexandria, founded by Alexander the Great in early third century BCE, was a center for Greek culture for almost a thousand years.
Alexander the Great initiated the Hellenization of the ancient world. Greek became a global language and Roman, Jewish or Christian authors who wanted to be read wrote their books in Greek. But, sometimes, spreading Greek culture was not entirely a peaceful process.
The Greek kings of Egypt, the Ptolemies, made Alexandria their capital. They built and supported modern-like institutions for scientific research and advanced studies like the Mouseion or House of the Muses. A vast library was part of the Mouseion.
Christianity came to power in the fourth century of our era, by which time the empire of Alexander the Great was a province of Rome for about 400 years.
The Christians resented the polytheism of the Greeks and Romans. They also did not like books that differed from their Bible. And when, as in Alexandria, there was a vast quantity of Greek and other non-Christian books and Greek scholars like Hypatia were teaching philosophy and science and openly worshipping the gods, the situation inevitably would get out of hand.
In fact, in 391, archbishop of Alexandria, Theophilos, was behind the destruction of the library of Alexandria. Hypatia was then about 21 years old.
According to Edward Gibbon, the British historian of the eighteenth century, the decision of Emperor Theodosius in 391 to destroy the "idols" of Alexandria "sent up a shout of joy and exultation" among the Christians. "The valuable library of Alexandria was pillaged or destroyed."
Gibbon rightly puts much of the blame for this crime on the Christian leader, archbishop Theophilos: "The perpetual enemy of peace and virtue; a bold, bad man, whose hands were alternately polluted with gold and with blood."
In the twentieth century, the classical scholar James Westfall Thompson accuses the Christians of destroying the library and literature in Alexandria.
The American historian, Ramsay MacMullen of Yale University, says that the Christians silenced, burned, and destroyed Greek civilization as a form of "theological demonstration."
The Italian classical scholar, Luciano Canfora, reports that the "burning of books was part of the advent and imposition of Christianity."
"Agora" successfully captures this climate of terror by focusing on Hypatia and her enemies, in the early fifth century, the archbishop of Alexandria Cyril and the Gestapo-like troops of monks doing his bidding.
Hypatia did not have a chance. One of her former students, Orestes, was the governor of Egypt. Orestes loved Hypatia and did whatever he could to protect her from the monks. Cyril, however, had the ear of the emperor. The church was becoming the state.
Sokrates, c. 380 - post 439, a lawyer and an ecclesiastical historian, was a contemporary of Hypatia. He says the monks:
"[W]aylaid her returning home. They dragged her from her carriage, took her to the church called Kaisareon, where they completely stripped her naked, and then murdered her with tiles. After tearing her body to pieces, they took her mangled limbs to a place called Kinaron, where they burnt them."
Another Greek who probably knew Hypatia was an Alexandria schoolteacher named Palladas. His epigram on Hypatia speaks of his passionate love for her, only because her wisdom had made her almost divine. He says:
"Revered Hypatia, ornament of learning, undefiled star of wise teaching, when I see you and your wisdom I worship you, seeing the starry house of the virgin. Your enterprise is in heaven."
Gibbon summarizes the life of Hypatia as follows:
"In the bloom of beauty, and in the maturity of wisdom, the modest maid [Hypatia] refused her lovers and instructed her disciples; the persons most illustrious for their rank or merit were impatient to visit the female philosopher; and [archbishop] Cyril beheld with a jealous eye the gorgeous train of horses and slaves who crowded the door of her academy. A rumour was spread among the Christians that the daughter of Theon was the only obstacle to the reconciliation of the praefect [Orestes] and the archbishop; and that obstacle was speedily removed... the murder of Hypatia has imprinted an indelible stain on the character and religion of Cyril of Alexandria."
The murder of Hypatia in 415 was one of countless other crimes the Christians committed against the Greeks. The Christians dug their Greek enemies into obscurity and nothingness, nearly destroying their spirit and certainly wiping out the outward signs and material culture of their civilization.
"Agora" does translate this horrific Christian attack against the Greeks into a living event unfolding in front of our eyes. We see the magnificent buildings of the Alexandria library and the Mouseion, the throngs of people selling and buying in the fading agora.
We also see Hypatia teaching young men math, astronomy and philosophy, stubborn to the very end about the virtues of Greek culture and science: asking questions in order to grasp the secrets of nature and the cosmos. Her vision also made learning a bond for building a just society.
Perhaps, "Agora" is a metaphor for our enormous loss from the violent eclipse of Greek culture. It may also be a warning of the emerging hubris coming out of the clash of civilizations in our time.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Same phobia as our Manifest
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 10:02 — Vic Anderson (not verified)Same phobia as our Manifest Insanity.
ORGANIZED RELIGION SEEMS
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 12:23 — cheyennebode (not verified)ORGANIZED RELIGION SEEMS ALWAYS TO BETRAY ITS PROPHETS...CHRISTIANS HAVE KILLED MORE OF THEIR OWN THEN ANY OTHER...MOSLEMS COME IN SECOND....WE EACH HAVE OUR OWN PATH TO GOD....UNFORTUNATELY MOST SEEKERS LOOK TO MEN TO GUIDE THEM AND END UP PAWNS...GLADDEN YOUR APPRECIATION OF THE GIFT OF LIFE...AND GOD WILL TOUCH..
Not to criticize, just to
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 12:50 — Andrew (not verified)Not to criticize, just to inform.While I agree that the crimes by early institutionalized Christianity are deplorable with the destruction of the books of the library of Alexandria and the importance of scientific thought along with Hypatia's murder, it's best not to romanticize the Greek culture. The Roman Empire start crumbling before Christianity due to corruption in its own internal mechanism, you've heard the stories of Roman excess and orgies. The Greek and Roman religion had become an establishment religion that supported the ruling classes, with the mother goddesses turned into hysterical nymphs and Mt. Olympus turned into a riviera of trite scandals and affairs, the gods themselves reduced to literary favorites and civic patrons that served the emperor. Early Christianity at first was one of the strongest humanistic forces as they banned infanticide, tried to outlaw capital punishment and encouraged the construction of early institutions and hospitals to care for the elderly and the sick. Christianity began a downward slope when the bishops began coming from the aristocratic families of the imperial courts and becoming part of the establishment. I guess the gist of what I'm saying is I agree the loss of the Greek culture is a tragedy, especially when at the hands of what at first was a progressive institution but, like all human movements, became corrupted, it's best not to romanticize the Roman Empire and Greek culture with corruption being present as well.
O.K. So why not make a film
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 13:25 — Anonymous (not verified)O.K. So why not make a film about the Destruction of African civilization in Ta-Merry, or as the Greeks profaned it, Egypt?
First the Persians then the Greeks came to learn from Wise Men on the Nile. Only both sought to destroy what they couldn't understand.
Hypatia? She taught the little the Greeks learned of the knowledge of the Pyramid Builders. Neither she nor the Greeks invented reason. In fact they all came to Kemet to learn Reason.
This article only serves to promulgate the Euro-Centric myth versus the objective truth.
Even with their
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 13:27 — rob (not verified)Even with their "corruption", those cultures are far more "romantic" than Christianity's Dark Ages, and even today's right-wing evil evangelical leaders!
La plus ça change, la plus
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 13:30 — Texas Aggie (not verified)La plus ça change, la plus c'est la meme chose.
We seem to be living through the very same thing now with the "Christians" doing what they can to destroy learning and science, and then replace it with superstition and ignorance. Exhibit A - The Texas State Board of Education.
Some people have been physically assaulted by creationists for advocating evolution (Kansas), and some of the more extreme have taken the position that evolutionists should be charged with crimes. It's only a matter of time before the destruction of Greek learning repeats itself in the US.
Another excellent homage, if
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 13:57 — JEN (not verified)Another excellent homage, if a more indirect one, to this great woman is found in Umberto Eco's novel"Baudolino".
"When the Greeks spoke of
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 14:38 — alaskadiva (not verified)"When the Greeks spoke of "agora," they meant a place for political discussion, jury trials, and a market. In other words, agora was the center of Greek life." Agoraphobia is the order of our day, isn't it? I think 'Andrew' hit the nail on the head. ..welcome to the study of human behavior 101. The establishment fossilizes, groups rebel and splinter off, they become the new establishment, and the cycle begins again. ...
Thank you, Andrew, for the
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 14:44 — ari (not verified)Thank you, Andrew, for the nuanced historical perspective. Agree 100% that romanticizing either side, any side, does not serve the cause of truth.
Still, I am glad the film was made if only to remind Christian hatemongers that they are the latest in a thousand-year line of bloodthirsty believers, ever since the early Christian progressive passion had been co-opted and corrupted.
Who would Jesus bomb? Who would Jesus hate? The interplay of religion, culture and history is a dynamic tapestry soaked in the blood of slaughtered innocents.
This is without doubt a
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 18:46 — Anonymous (not verified)This is without doubt a great film. It is also a most timely film, showing dangerous/lethal patterns at work here now.
Why then does the film have only nominal distribution in the U.S.? What forces have stopped its being shown here? Has anyone studied this?
Now there is a dark drama in itself.
Unfortunately the terrorist
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 19:23 — Loren Bliss (not verified)Unfortunately the terrorist history of Christianity has become a tabooed truth in the United States.
It is the sole source of the false belief there was no civilization on this planet prior to Christianity, a Big Lie sustained by the fact that what the Christians did to Alexandria and Greek culture, they also did to the British Isles, Mainland Europe and the Americas.
Though a lively and promising secular, even formally pagan culture was evolving in the present-day U.S., it is now threatened by the same sort of extermination. When the fundamentalists take over -- and the unabated economic collapse is their vehicle to power -- the fate of Hypatia will be the fate of any of us, male or female, who refuse to bow to the Christians' Fuhrer "who art in Heaven."
Meanwhile those in denial about the Christian threat should be reminded that the very first American death squad, the Ku Klux Klan, is colloquially known throughout the South as "the Saturday Night Men's Bible Study Class."
The chrisitan inquisition
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 20:21 — Anonarcmous (not verified)The chrisitan inquisition marches on, esp here in the americas , it continues to hold down the native americans on their reservations. Just another example of a repeating no reconciliation ever possible.
I too wondered why I had not
Sun, 09/19/2010 - 21:53 — Anonymous (not verified)I too wondered why I had not heard of this film which has been out a year now. If Mel Gibson can get "Passion of the Christ" out there, why not this film in wider distribution?
Evaggelos,thank you for
Mon, 09/20/2010 - 06:04 — Anonymous (not verified)Evaggelos,thank you for enlightening me about Hypatia and the Alexandria Library,in my ignorance I believed the Muslim Jihad was responsible for this barbaric deed.
When I was dragged off to
Mon, 09/20/2010 - 09:25 — Anonymous (not verified)When I was dragged off to Sunday school as a kid, I learned about how the Romans fed Christians to the lions.
They never mentioned that the Christians later took over the Roman Empire and went on to a "glorious" history of Crusades, Inquisitions, witch trials, burning "heretics" at the stake, conquests, imperialism, forced conversions, justifying slavery, opposing scientific inquiry (Hypatia, Galileo, today's Young-Earth Creationists, etc.), and so on.
What propagandists.
About the destruction of the
Mon, 09/20/2010 - 17:07 — Anonymous (not verified)About the destruction of the Alexandria library: The truth is not so simple. The Great Library was first almost destroyed by Caesar, and then later fully accomplished by a Muslim raid. However, there was another library know as the Serapeion. This was indeed destroyed by a Christian mob. And this unfortunately only one of the tiny inaccuracies of this article.
@14:25 Please tell me you
Mon, 09/20/2010 - 22:19 — Roguefreq (not verified)@14:25 Please tell me you are not lumping in Young-Earth Creationists with scientific inquiry.
Mohammed was born in the 7th
Mon, 09/20/2010 - 23:37 — Anonymous (not verified)Mohammed was born in the 7th cent. CE. There is no way Muslims were involved during the timeframe of the film.
Her manner of death was
Tue, 09/21/2010 - 01:28 — Tres Jordan (not verified)Her manner of death was known as oestreka, where they scrape off your skin with shells and tiles, not shown in the film probably because it would be too much.It's probable she was raped and burned too.
Although they portray her as a Pagan the truth was that most of the friction was between the Christians themselves which had been going on since the beginning. The Gnostics and the Literalists. Gnostics believed that the Christos was an extension of the Dionysis/Osiris myths as they are so close in many details and that the story and message were paramount. Literalists which became the Katholic Chuch believed it happened and that Jesus was GOD. There was a good chance she was Gnostic.
What the filmakers got right was that this was class warfare. This had nothing to do with destroying Greek culture in Alexandria. The Gnostic/Pagan faction was well educated, wealthy and slave owners who did little for the poor. The Literalists were poor, uneducated, superstious and servile. The only reason they werent kicked out of Rome was cause they took care of the poor something the Romans were loathe to do.
The saddest thing though was that in our theater in NYC there were 100 people max and across the street they were lined up around the block to see four of the worst role models women could have in "Sex and the City Pt II".
I had never heard that poem in your story but it echos my adoration of Hypatia.
To do my generally weak
Tue, 09/21/2010 - 04:46 — Judith (not verified)To do my generally weak school history books' credit, they did describe Hypatia as a scholar and philosopher. To their discredit, they said nothing about who murdered her, nor did they give due discredit to Cyril for the burning of the library at Alexandria. The Christian right has far too much to say about the teaching of history in America's public schools. People should not have to learn history in post-grad school or at the movies.
03:19: You need to learn to
Tue, 09/21/2010 - 07:33 — Anonymous (not verified)03:19:
You need to learn to read more carefully. I am lumping Young Earth Creationists in with other efforts to suppress scientific inquiry and deny scientific facts.
"by which time the empire of
Fri, 09/24/2010 - 13:07 — David Friedman (not verified)"by which time the empire of Alexander the Great was a province of Rome for about 400 years."
The empire of Alexander was never a roman province, or even provinces. Parts of it, including Egypt, ended up under Roman rule, but large parts--roughly speaking, everything east of Asia Minor--didn't.
Your account of the destruction of the Great Library, like the other two standard stories (Caesar and Umar), is historically dubious. For a detailed discussion, see the Wikipedia article.
The world continues to
Sun, 09/26/2010 - 08:45 — Anonymous (not verified)The world continues to suffer from Constantine and Eusebius' invented "world government" called Christianity. Had this evil, fear- and ignorance-based con not been contrived, we would also not have Islam, which was
contrived as a defense against Christianity. Monotheisms are the least humane forms of government ever conceived by evil, power-mad men.