Immigration Reform Meeting Postponed to Sharp Criticism From Advocates

by: Yana Kunichoff, t r u t h o u t | Report

A meeting among President Barack Obama and Sens. Charles Schumer (D-New York) and Lindsey Graham (R-South Carolina) on immigration reform, scheduled to take place Monday, has been postponed due to a canceled flight from South Carolina - Senator Graham's.

The meeting, intended to make a plan for introducing bipartisan immigration legislation this spring, was the second one canceled since reform came on the table formally at a White House summit hosted by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano in August 2009.

The push for reform by the Obama administration, which promised it would deal with the issue in its first year in office, also takes place just weeks before a planned march on Washington for March 21, intended to raise the pressure for legislative action on immigration.

"People are suffering. Millions and millions of people cannot drive, cannot go to school, live in fear," Dae Joong Yoon, the executive director of the Korean Resource Center in Los Angeles, said of the stall in immigration reform. "In 2008 many of our community members voted for change.... We've been waiting, waiting, waiting. But since then our president, our Congress members, have been in a deep sleep. So now we're saying, 'We can't take it anymore! Wake up! Do something!'"

The proposed bill would include a path toward citizenship for the more than ten million undocumented people living in the United States. It would also require undocumented workers to register, pay taxes and pay a penalty if they break the law - if they fail to follow these strictures, they face deportation.

According to The Wall Street Journal, Schumer has also disclosed a plan to include a proposal for a new national identity card in the bill. This would be mandatory for all workers, regardless of their citizenship status, and would contain biometric information such as fingerprint details. Schumer hopes this would discourage further unauthorized immigration.

However, some Democrats are wary of plunging into new legislation while the health care debate is still unresolved.

"Right now we have a little problem with the 'Chicken Little' mentality: The sky is falling and consequently we can't do anything," Rep. Raul M. Grijalva (D-Arizona) said.

Schumer said getting the bill off the ground depends on getting another Republican sponsor, a task that has been trying so far.

"We're very hopeful we can get a bill done. We have all the pieces in place. We just need a second Republican," said Schumer, who met with Napolitano Thursday to speak about possible GOP co-sponsors. "It's tough finding someone, but we're trying."

Immigrant rights activists fear that if a proposal is not moved by April or early May, it will not have a realistic chance of passing as the focus will shift to the November elections instead.

Ali Noorani, executive director of the National Immigration Forum, said this view may be short-sighted. "A legislative show is not going to be acceptable," he said. "The necessity here is a bipartisan piece of legislation that gets to the Senate floor, and that will be the marker that immigrant voters and others will use in November 2010 and November 2012 and beyond."

Obama campaigned on the promise to be "a president who isn't going to walk away from something as important as comprehensive immigration reform when it becomes politically unpopular," and said he would "rise above fear, the demagoguery, the pettiness, the partisanship, and finally enact comprehensive immigration reform ... In this country, change does not come from the top down. Change comes from the bottom up."

Nick Shapiro, a White House spokesman, said, "The president's commitment to fixing our broken immigration system remains unwavering."

However, for many Latino activists, they see a different side. "Our community is angry," said Brent Wilkes from the League of United Latin American Citizens of the figures recently released by the Fair Immigration Reform Movement, showing more deportations during Obama's first year in the White House - 387,790 - than during George W. Bush's last year in office - 264, 503. "Our members feel betrayed." 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Yana Kunichoff is an assistant editor at Truthout.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



The only problem with our

The only problem with our immigration system is a lack of enforcement. Only a small crazed minority wants another amnesty (disguised as reform) yet they are backed by big corporations that want to keep flooding the USA with cheap labor to force wages down further.



I experienced some cognitive

I experienced some cognitive dissonance at the statement in support of the “suffering millions” by the Korean pro-invasion advocate. Koreans’ attitudes are strongly racially delineated, and those that have any sympathy at all for the teeming masses from south of the border are very few and very far between.



Most of us are descendants

Most of us are descendants of immigrants. Yeah, but they were all legal-you my say. only because there were no immigration laws until Chinese workers on western railroads wanted to stay (after being Shanghaied to come here) and braing their families. Our immigration laws are pure racism.-big numbers for Europe (except just before WWII when Jews weren't allowed) and small for Mexico and the Far Eat. If we are going to have immigration reform, only Native Americans should be allowed to write the rules.



I am a white guy from Texas,

I am a white guy from Texas, I was born here so I am a native American. Some people just can't grasp the English language. Also, American Indians immigrated from Asia. None of this matters. Our poor people need jobs and housing, and their biggest problem is all these foreign visitors who snuck in to steal their work.



Really, that post of yours

Really, that post of yours must have hurt big time when you yanked it from your posterior, An. Immigration, legal or not, has been overwhelmingly non-white for decades, and this by design.



I was born some place else I

I was born some place else I am not native American. and Yes! I pay taxes. For" I am a white guy from Texas" You got wrong!!most to the time the foreign visitors do not steal your jobs. This foreign visitors do the jobs some guys DO NOT want to do. Thats the difference!!



I have researched the issue

I have researched the issue of "jobs American's don't want" and in every case there are legal Americans working side by side with illegals in such jobs. There are many jobs Americans don't love because the pay is very low because employers have the option of hiring illegals should a legal worker demand more.



Shumer is not thinking well.

Shumer is not thinking well. We already have a national ID with biometrics and fingerprint data, its called a passport. Just require a passport to get a job. The new Green Cards have the same, for legal aliens.



A day without immigrants

A day without immigrants nowadays would be a day without a lot of nasty corrupt people in medical billing telling American to cough it up.

A lot of nasty corrupt people denying Americans medical appointments when they need it.

Go back to your homelands and work on the medical systems there. Take your Mexican government officials with you, and their collusion with the insurance companies, and get out of our medical system!

Mexico is not a country lacking in resources! The richest man on earth lives in Mexico!

Deport people speedily and humanely. You don't want to be in prison? Then go home! Nothing's stopping you! Stop wasting our money with your gaming our legal system!

Get the "legal" visa office workers out!

If you're not a legitimate asylum case, go back to your homeland! Stop taking jobs and driving down American wages!



Pass single payer for all

Pass single payer for all American citizens. Use your national health card, the way they have in Canada.

There are a lot of "legal" people here who should be thrown out. Sometimes even moreso than illegal ones. If they're really "legit" mandate insurance and make them carry that card.



Maybe Congress would

Maybe Congress would understand if their jobs didn't require citizenship.



I'm from the East coast,

I'm from the East coast, born and bred in NYC. That also means I'm an opinionated native American chick with a Brooklyn accent that is following me whereever I go. I have grandparents who immigrated, but they came in legally, and the records are there to show it, at ports of entry. To "An", Jews immigrated legally at the turn of the century, not just before World War II. They had pogroms in Europe and lost their citizenship and had property and businesses seized in many places. People came over on ships, there were no cells phones, airplanes, internet. They were expected arrivals, most knowing they would never again see the places they'd left behind or speak to their families. It was an honor and a privilege to become an American citizen and speak English, many coming in from countries where they not even allowed to speak the language of the countries that took their citizenship away from them. Speaking English was an honor, something to take pride in, as Americans in a great nation. There was also nowhere for anyone to go back to.



While the politicos stall

While the politicos stall (until December; see if they don't!), people should read and thoroughly understand Federika Randall's article in the March 15th issue of The Nation, about how organized crime is oppressing North African immigrants in Italy. Any American who pretends to even the slightest tinge of nativism (MIKE IN NYC - THIS MEANS YOU!!!) is declaring himself AT ONE IN NATURE AND EFFORT WITH ORGANIZED CRIME. No white person in the USA has anything to say about "legal" immigration; not with any integrity. Besides, Mike, you've proved almost daily that you're proud of your criminal attitude.



Frances in California,

Frances in California, you're a reverse racist for sure. Yes there is such a thing as legal immigration.