In Defense of the World's Meddlesome Central Banks

by: Paul Krugman, Krugman & Co. | Op-Ed

In Defense of the World's Meddlesome Central Banks
A new subway line in Warsaw is among the public works projects, including roads and bridges, which attest to Poland's resiliency. (Adam Lach / The International Herald Tribune)

There exists a widespread, false impression that Keynesian fiscal policy failed to rally the United States’s battered economy.

This is wrong — the truth is that Keynesian policies were never tried.

The clear lesson that has emerged from these troubled times is that currency flexibility is valuable when dealing with macroeconomic problems. Well, one would hope the lesson is clear.

I have already written about how Britain, Sweden and Argentina have all reaped the rewards of flexibility. Let’s look at the examples of Poland and Iceland, which have benefited recently from currency depreciation.

In a piece published in The New York Times on Dec. 6, the reporter Jack Ewing outlined the advantages Poland has derived from not having adopted the euro (yet): the zloty has fallen about 18 percent against the euro since last year, prices for goods from Poland remain competitive in world markets, and the nation has been isolated from the effects of other countries’ sovereign debt crises.

Iceland is growing again for the first time since its financial system collapsed in 2008 — real gross domestic product grew by 1.2 percent in the July-September quarter.

Of the nations on the periphery of the euro zone where borrowing and spending was excessive before the downturn — Ireland, Iceland, Latvia, Estonia — Iceland had by far the biggest excesses, with a totally ludicrous buildup of debt.

But Iceland allowed private banks to fail and the krona to decline, and through the magic of default and devaluation, it’s actually doing better than the other three nations.

But one of the remarkable things about the crisis of the past three years is that it has actually strengthened the political hand of the hard-money, austerity-imposing orthodoxy — yet the reality is that heterodoxy has worked much better in practice.

Unfortunately, this lesson has been lost on the hard-money crowd in the United States.

Republicans want the Federal Reserve to focus on keeping the dollar strong, and to abandon concerns about unemployment.

Republican congressmen Paul D. Ryan of Wisconsin and Mike Pence of Indiana have repeatedly called for an end to the central bank’s dual mandate to promote both jobs and price stability.

Let Truthout send our best stories to your inbox every day, for free.

Mr. Pence also said the Fed’s latest quantitative easing program (in which it plans to buy $600 billion in Treasury securities by June) is an example of the central bank’s overstepping its bounds.

“It’s time that the Fed focus solely on price stability and the dollar,” Mr. Pence told The Wall Street Journal on Dec. 7, in reference to the Fed’s new initiative. “QE2 is an example of what happens when the Fed involves itself too much in macroeconomic meddling.”

In other news, Republicans have demanded that doctors consider reintroducing the practice of treating illness by bleeding their patients.

© 2010 The New York Times Company

Truthout has licensed this content. It may not be reproduced by any other source and is not covered by our Creative Commons license.

Paul Krugman joined The New York Times in 1999 as a columnist on the Op-Ed page and continues as a professor of economics and international affairs at Princeton University. He was awarded the Nobel in economic science in 2008.

Mr Krugman is the author or editor of 20 books and more than 200 papers in professional journals and edited volumes, including "The Return of Depression Economics" (2008) and "The Conscience of a Liberal" (2007).
Copyright 2010 The New York Times.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



"This is wrong — the truth

"This is wrong — the truth is that Keynesian policies were never tried." ... please explain how they have not been tried....



Yes, let the banks fail -

Yes, let the banks fail - starting with Goldman Sachs. Stop rewarding failure with bailouts!



Isn't that what QE2 is all

Isn't that what QE2 is all about? Printing more money to trigger deflation - making all of our money worth less?

Of course, what this also does is penalize savers..



"QE2?" The Cunard ocean

"QE2?" The Cunard ocean liner?



QE II Quantitative Easing -

QE II
Quantitative Easing - the rerun

more BS from the failed jugglers of finance

may they all get a lump of coal shoved down their throats



"Of course, what this also

"Of course, what this also does is penalize savers.."

It doesn't penalize savers nearly as much as it assists debtors. Ongoing debt is what is preventing recovery. It's a black hole into which every spare dime is plummeting.

Without keynesian policies, in particular aimed at the middle class and poor to help them out of their financial straits, there will be nobody spending.



Fish wrapped in xmas

Fish wrapped in xmas wrapping paper and pretty bows, dear P. K., is still fish



Krugman explicitly advocates

Krugman explicitly advocates debt default here ie. deliberately breaking the sanctity of contract in a capitalist society. Essentially, he advocates lying, stealing and cheating. Which should be no surprise for someone who claims that the US "truthfully" is not applying Keynesianism - after an $11 trillion official Wall St. bail-out, with $trillions more ongoing unofficially via heavily subsidised interest rates. This is the definition of Keynesianism. I guess getting a Nobel makes you stupid.



Transparent propaganda, as

Transparent propaganda, as usual, from Krugman. The world banks and bankers, along with their allies in government and industry, are borrowing on our future and robbing us blind. Krugman's writings have become ever more bizarre after he received his Nobel Prize, which apparently spurred his ego inflation and a deflation of honesty and cognitive ability. When Truthout publishes Krugman, it is promoting the neo-con New World Order agenda.



Krugman is right. He is

Krugman is right.

He is trying to save us from the 'hard-money' and 'austerity' loving Republicans who would happily see the USA return to recession/depression so that Obama loses in 2012.

Krugman is without question the leading left-wing economist and he deserves the full support of truthout and its readers.



Lets not be so hasty to

Lets not be so hasty to glorify the world bank. Working in the shadows the world bank and the international monetary fund have been refusing to grant loans to poor countries that won't accept Monsanto genetically modified seeds. Once these seeds are used these countries owe Monsanto royalties in perpetuity. The seeds produce plants that will not produce new seeds for use in the future by farmers who save their seeds. This way poor farmers around the world have to buy new seeds every season, each time paying Monsanto.



Somehow I don't think the

Somehow I don't think the Wall Street bailout qualifies as true Keynesianism. It was more like "trickle down."



It wasn't just "trickle

It wasn't just "trickle down", Anonymous on 12/23 at 13:25, it was "trickle ON Main St".



tory burch

tmewogzr That's a good post. tmewogzr