INS Targets Community Leaders, Not Criminals
Sunday 21 November 2010
by: Roberto Cintli Rodriguez, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

(Photo: Arasmus Photo)
When people the world over think of Arizona nowadays, they generally think of Governor Jan Brewer, Sheriff Joe Arpaio or state representative Russell Pearce – the poster children of the state's move toward legalized discrimination and racial profiling. If they are closely following the politics of the Sun State, they also think of state superintendent of schools, Tom Horne, the architect of the state's move to abolish Ethnic/Raza Studies.
Here, we think of the vast human toll of the policies promoted by these powerful few.
Combined, these Arizona measures are becoming the modern version of Indian Removal and the colonial policy of "reducciones" – a policy aimed at civilizing the "savages."
To those outside of this insane asylum, this state is being described as the New South. It may indeed be just that, not least because it is providing a laboratory for setting the stage for apartheid governance in a part of the country that is browning every day. Politically, this is all about the clash of civilizations; one civilization indigenous to this continent, the other seemingly hell-bent on continuing the policies of manifest destiny.
Yet there is something more taking place here. To gain more understanding of some of the key aspects of Arizona's political climate, read "Brown Tide Rising" by Otto Santa Ana. In it, the author poignantly observes that, in this society: "Only humans have human rights." There can be no doubt that the red-brown peoples of this state are being treated as less than human.
Better yet, read "A Decade of Betrayal" by Francisco Balderrama and Raymond Rodriguez. In it, they write about this nation's obsession with targeting Mexicans during times of economic crises, going back to the period between 1910 and 1920. And yet, what the Balderrama and Rodriguez point out is that some of the numerous campaigns that deported hundreds of thousands and even millions of Mexicans, including US citizens, were not indiscriminate (particularly the one conducted in the 1930s). The deportations were targeted, and the individuals singled out for deporting were not criminals - they were those whose roles embodied anything resembling the roles of leaders, especially community, educational, and labor organizers.
In Arizona there are numerous policies and programs in place (such as Operation Streamline) to criminalize migrants – policies that, not coincidentally, line the pockets of the private prison industry. What's more, an array of law enforcement agencies continue to become extensions of the US Border Patrol – operating as though SB 1070 were already the law of the land.
In Tucson, these draconian measures have now begun to affect the parents of our top students and student organizers. This summer, the father of a young high school activist DREAM student was picked up by a sheriff's deputy while riding in a truck as a passenger. Even though SB 1070 was not in effect, as happens regularly he was handed over to the Border Patrol. This happened in the middle of the annual Raza Studies Transformative Education Conference this summer. As a community, we rallied to the support of the family, successfully getting him out on bail. I've written about his daughter previously, as she has publicly identified herself long before several DREAM students occupied the offices of Senator John McCain this past summer. As a proud community organizer, she publicly identifies herself, but I don't – in fact, I don't even identify her school because I still feel that the government has the potential to target her family and those of the other activists who protested in McCain's offices.
For example, this past weekend, the father of one of our top students at the University of Arizona, Michelle Rascon – who is an incredible poet, a Raza Studies alumni, a US citizen and a prospective law student – was picked up at his own home in what appears to have been an elaborate ruse by the FBI. After luring Jesus Gilberto Rascon outside, they proceeded to call the US Border Patrol. As we speak, he is undergoing deportation proceedings that may keep him incarcerated for at least several months – until his final disposition. Of course, there are legal details involved which will be addressed in court, but suffice it to say that cases such as these point to the absurdity of what the government is doing to divide families. Neither Gilberto Rascon or the DREAM student's father are criminals in any sense of the word.
The federal government claims to have ceased targeting students or their families and asserts that its policies are designed instead to primarily go after criminal aliens. The draconian enforcement measures seen around the country, especially in Arizona, belie this so-called policy. If the nation criminalizes nonviolent aliens through its various operations and 287(g) agreements - including Secure Communities – these people become criminal aliens and, thus, primary targets. Circular logic at its best.
We appear to be in the midst of another decade of betrayal.
Michelle Rascon can be reached at: mixelle1322@gmail.com.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
More hate BS from corporate
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 13:00 — Juan (not verified)More hate BS from corporate America. The Feds refuse to guard the border, and refuse to pick up criminal aliens from county jails unless they have committed a violent felony. Illegals drive down wages and use resources for our poor minorities. So Arizona simply granted their police the same authority used by fed police to charge aliens so the Feds would have to deport them.
Meanwhile, TO sides with corporate America to stick it to working class Americans. For example, I doubt this guy Roberto is really from Arizona like he implies. The people here support the successful effort to chase illegals back to California, where that state is collapsing under the burden of millions of poor Mexican refugees.
Why does Truthout post this
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 13:02 — Anonymous (not verified)Why does Truthout post this anti-American and anti-worker crap? Is it trying to be fair and balanced by posting spin from Corporate America? The Chamber of Commerce also sponsors guys like this Roberto to fool the workers.
Why do the racists come to
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 13:48 — Cybernaught (not verified)Why do the racists come to TO? Don't they have skinhead and KKK sites?
You might want to change
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 13:58 — Will C. (not verified)You might want to change "INS" in the title since it hasn't existed since 2001/2. Maybe ICE or US Immigration agencies?
We are not collapsing due to
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 15:00 — Anonymous (not verified)We are not collapsing due to illegals over here in California thank you very much. It seems that the only ones who complain make plenty of money to live quite well, and then who will do their laundry, clean their house, wash their car if we deport these 'illegals'?
The only logical thing to do
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 15:24 — Edgar Valderrama (not verified)The only logical thing to do if you are in the prison racket is to drum up business by obtaining "clients". One more business influencing the politicians, this time looking for people to lock up. If this trend spreads, look out citizens, the justice system will soon be paid a "commission" (bribe) to incarcerate you.
I think the crucial question
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 15:32 — Anonymous (not verified)I think the crucial question is why our President has not made the manifest destiny based policies in AZ a topic of loud discussion.
THE AUTHOR STATES...THE
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 16:01 — cheyennebode (not verified)THE AUTHOR STATES...THE WHOLE WORLD IS THINKING NEGATIVELY TOWARD ARIZONA..HE MUST HAVE A GIANT CRYSTAL BALL TO KNOW WHAT THE WHOLE WORLD IS THINKING...AS THE PRO ILLEGALS SEE THEIR CAUSE SLIPPING THE MORE DESPERATE THEIR LIES..THE BIGGEST BEING THEIR CHARGE OF RACISM AND ZENOPHOBIA...70% OF AMERICANS WANT ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION STOPPED AND THESE AMERICANS ARE AN AMALGAMATION OF MEXICAN AMERICANS..ASIAN AMERICANS..AMERICAN INDIANS ..WHITES..BLACKS ETC.THE TRUE RACIST ARE LA RAZA AND THEIR ILK OF ILLUSIONISTS..
I do not see why borders are
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 17:27 — Rogue (not verified)I do not see why borders are used against workers, while the international corporations can cross those made up lines at their will.
WE are all citizens of this world and we all need employment to support our families.
Turning the workers against each other id an old Fat Cat trick. WE need to unite against the Fat Cats.
This is a complex problem.
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 18:35 — Orly (not verified)This is a complex problem. Some immigrants do not respect the law. Even a stop sign. They illegally get naturalization cards, driver license, working permits and more. And this makes people mad. Now, do they issue these documents? The answer is no. Some corruption encouraging this illegal process has been exposed. Some corporations offer jobs to them and it is passed by word of mouth back into their native place. Their presence lowers salaries, it is said. The evidence is not conclusive in this regard. Some republicans (Miller, McMahon) campaigned to reduce the minimum wage. NOT for immigrants but for all Americans. We need to blame someone else for our problems. Unemployment is not caused by immigrants. We export jobs overseas to happily buy cheap products here. We have created our economic crisis and the level of unemployment. This is a consequence of the cyclical crisis of our economic system. Let’s see how much employment is going to be available in Arizona and how much their salaries will increase. Arizona has housing and some other problems. Speculative developers created this problem, not the immigrants. It is easy to distract people from the main problems we have, blaming others. If we could get rid of all illegal immigrants we will be facing the same problems we have today. Then we had to find another scapegoat.
Why are people so stupid?
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 19:29 — Anonymous (not verified)Why are people so stupid? Anyone who reads knows that California is going bankrupt. Yes, the rich love illegals, lest they have to pay Americans a decent wage to mow grass, wash cars, or cook food.
If 1000 illegals arrive in a town, and there are few jobs, how is this good?
Yes, the race card, used by corporate America to fool poorly educated Americans. Let's not discuss this, lest someone call us racist for protecting American jobs.
Why do so many liberals hate blacks, asians, and Americans of Mexican descent. They are ruining our lives by allowing a flood of cheap foreign labor.
Illegals are international scabs.
Lets just EMULATE "MEXICOS"
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 19:58 — George Orwell (not verified)Lets just EMULATE "MEXICOS" immigration Policies. If you overstay your VISA..you're DEPORTED! If you sneak into Mexico & get caught they put you in the SLAMMER! Sooooooooooo whats the beef with doing the same in rizona, California, Texas & who knows where else. Time to ENFORCE the laws as they are on the books. If you wanna satudy "La-Raza" go back to Mexico & make a difference there. Dream Act...Forget it! Problem is Now even an American College Grad is'nt GUARANTEED a job why add more UN-EMPLOYED Grads to the Labor Force, or go to Mexico City University !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Designate January as amnesty
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 20:05 — brother_unknown (not verified)Designate January as amnesty month. Transport all the Mexicans who are in this country back to Mexico via passenger train at taxpayer expense during this month. Yes, Baggage is included! They are then eligible to apply at a US embassy in Mexico to immigrate to the U.S.
After January, deport all Mexicans who are in this country illegally via boxcar, trucks,and non-air conditioned, unheated buses back to Mexico. Charge then $500 bucks apiece. They are forever ineligible to apply to immigrate to the US.
This is an absurd article.
Sun, 11/21/2010 - 21:38 — Anonymous (not verified)This is an absurd article. Don't TO editors read stuff before it is posted?
It seems arresting criminals is "targeting" them. And this nut thinks that illegally immigrating to the USA is a human right.
And DREAM is BS. Lets use taxpayer money to educate Americans first. Every foreigner allowed in a university takes a slot from an American, including blacks.
America's leading corporate
Mon, 11/22/2010 - 09:02 — Anonymous (not verified)America's leading corporate bullhorn is the American Chamber of Commerce. It is anti-union and anti-worker. It openly supports open borders, more worker immigration, and another amnesty. Why are some TO readers on their side?
Why are wages so low in
Mon, 11/22/2010 - 09:06 — Anonymous (not verified)Why are wages so low in China, Vietnam, Indonesia, Philippines and Mexico?
Its because they have far more workers than jobs. So what is the best method of driving down wages in the USA. Its to flood this nation with more workers. This has been a very successful strategy for the past two decades.
Why don't worker revolt. Because corporate TV calls any opposition -- racist. The people of Arizona raise objections and demanded it stop, and look how corporate TV treated them. Even TO joined in thumping that democratic movement. And we all know the Democratic party is owned by corporate America, which is why the DREAM act arose.
My guess is that if it was
Mon, 11/22/2010 - 10:53 — Anonymous (not verified)My guess is that if it was made more difficult for US jobs to be outsourced, then the people who are here without documentation would be better loved by the very people hounding them now. I think a lot of it boils down to the money as usual.
OK, Anonymous on 11/22 at
Mon, 12/06/2010 - 13:13 — Frances in California (not verified)OK, Anonymous on 11/22 at 2:38 - Let's assume that when YOUR people arrived in the US, immigration wasn't a human right and deport you since they're probably long gone.
No, brother_unknown. I have
Mon, 12/06/2010 - 13:14 — Frances in California Again (not verified)No, brother_unknown. I have a better idea. Lock YOU in a boxcar and just forget where the key is.
Well, Anonymous on 11/22 at
Mon, 12/06/2010 - 13:18 — Frances in California Again - Really Mad Again (not verified)Well, Anonymous on 11/22 at 00:29 - if you want a real view of stupidity, just go look in a mirror. California is bankrupt but it's not due to immigrants. California is morally and intellectually bankrupt due to stupid people like you.
Please, T/O, can't you block
Mon, 12/06/2010 - 13:31 — Frances in California Again and Again (not verified)Please, T/O, can't you block posters like Anonymous on 11/21 at 18:02, who are obviously on Rove's payroll? Rodriguez is NOT sponsored by the US Chamber, and I bet Anonymous 11/21 @ 6 IS!
Wow, This Is Interesting
Tue, 03/15/2011 - 12:46 — Shelia (not verified)I absolutely love this website.
http://www.blogigo.com/bransonmo8219