Investigation Confirms Pennsylvania Fracking Well Blowout Was Easily Preventable, Potentially Catastrophic
Wednesday 14 July 2010
by: Mike Ludwig, t r u t h o u t | Report

First responders used cell phone cameras to photograph natural gas and wastewater spewing from the EOG Resources "fracking" gas well during the June 3 blowout in Clearfield County, Pennsylvania. (Photo Courtesy of the PA Department of Environmental Protection)
Pennsylvanians are wondering if their state could become the next environmental ground zero after officials confirmed Tuesday that irresponsible drilling practices and a failed "blowout preventer" caused the June 3 blowout of a gas well in Clearfield County, Pennsylvania. Well operator EOG Resources uses controversial "fracking" techniques to harvest gas from the massive Marcellus Shale reserve, where the state has permitted thousands of wells.
No one was injured, but the busted well spewed highly-combustible natural gas and an estimated 35,000 gallons of wastewater that contaminated a nearby spring and stream, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).
DEP Secretary John Hanger announced that an independent investigation confirmed that the incident was preventable and EOG Resources ignored industry standards by failing to install proper barriers in the well and hiring uncertified operators. Hanger also said that EOG Resources failed to alert emergency authorities until several hours after the blowout, which hindered the state's response.
"Make no mistake, this could have been a catastrophic incident," Hanger said. "Had the gas blowing out of this well ignited, the human cost would have been tragic, and had an explosion allowed this well to discharge wastewater for days or weeks, the environmental damage would have been significant."
John Vittitow, an experienced petroleum engineer hired by the DEP to conduct the investigation, made an eerie comparison to the Deepwater Horizon disaster in the gulf as he described the failed blowout preventer that led to the incident. Vittitow said that EOG Resources only installed one pressure barrier during a well clean-out procedure, while industry standards call for at least two barriers in case of failure.
Hanger admitted that state regulations on well operations are broad and regulators would have to be "more prescriptive" to ensure that well operators use at least two barriers in the future.
Vittitow's investigation also revealed that the C. C. Forbes operators lacked industry certifications that are mandatory in most companies.
The DEP fined EOG Resources and C. C. Forbes a total of $400,000 collectively, lifted a suspension on activities at the well and ordered the firms to follow nine procedural rules in the future. When asked why EOG Resources' drilling license was not revoked, Hanger said that the order "had teeth," and explained the company has the potential to be a "first class" natural gas producer as the state seeks to benefit from massive gas reserves in the Marcellus Shale formation.
The Marcellus Shale, which spans hundreds of miles across Pennsylvania and New York, has become the battleground in a controversy over hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, which involves pumping a cocktail of liquids - some of them toxic - into the earth to force natural gas to the surface. Proponents claim fracking is an efficient way to take advantage of the massive amounts of clean energy to be found in the Marcellus Shale region and elsewhere, but researchers and environmentalists blame fracking for hundreds of instances of water contamination in Pennsylvania and across the country.
EOG Resources operates 139 of its 297 active Pennsylvania wells in the Marcellus Shale formation, according to the DEP.
The public outcry against fracking and a Congressional mandate included in an appropriations bill last fall prompted the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to begin a massive scientific study on how the practice affects water supplies, according to ProPublica.
The EPA investigation, to be completed by 2012, could help push Congress to approve the FRAC Act, which was introduced into the House last year. The FRAC Act would allow the EPA to regulate fracking and demand that drilling companies reveal what chemicals they pump into the ground, information the industry often attempts to conceal as "trade secrets." ProPublica recently reported that 50 House representatives have co-sponsored the act since last year.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Fracking happens ib Oklahoma
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 16:36 — Jean (not verified)Fracking happens ib Oklahoma @two areas..No one discusses this..tild now!MR Fox is coming to Tulsa to show the film "Gasland" Oklahoma is run by Chesapeake Energy
As for studying the effect
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 16:43 — Anonymous (not verified)As for studying the effect of fracking on water wells at this time, and with thousands of wells drilled already, I'd have to say the fracking horse is already out of the barn.
NO FRACKING = $150.00 BBL
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 17:44 — DUBBYA (not verified)NO FRACKING = $150.00 BBL OIL!
My 91 year old dad purchased
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 17:46 — MJH (not verified)My 91 year old dad purchased 11 acres in Bradford Co in 1975 for the purpose of keeping it pristine. It is adjacent to PA State Game Lands, including a reservoir that feeds a stream and pond on the 11 acres. My dad put the land in the names of his 4 children and I have always viewed my role as steward. We now find ourselves the only land owners within miles who have not leased our land to gas companies and that includes the State Game Lands we thought would be protected in perpetuity. There are at least three drilling sites with 3 wells each within a half mile of us and we are at the point of leasing our mineral rights in a nonsurface agreement as it is clear our land is at risk regardless of what we do. Having fought the gas companies in NY state where I live, I ignored offers from these companies for months but my siblings did not. It is heartbreaking to think what might become of this beautiful place. In this economy, very few people are in a position to turn down offers of bonuses and royalties when they may find their land contaminated even if they refuse. The state of PA is so hard up for money, they have every interest in facilitating this rush. In a Catch-22 they need the money to set up a regulatory system and to set up the water treatment facilities that can handle the massive enterprise, dependent as it is on municipal water treament plants not designed for either the chemicals or the volume of water at issue. Meanwhile gas may have a lesser carbon footprint that oil but that doesn't take into account the thousands of huge water tankers used in the transportation of water (both yet to be used and unused). THe effects of these trucks alone on these beautiful rural areas is a concern let alone ruptures and the like. Opposition groups are just beginning to form but really only a moratorium will stem this tidal wave...it needs to be stemmed before there's a major disaster.
By the way, Jean, What is
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 17:58 — anon. (not verified)By the way, Jean, What is Chesapeake's record in Oklahoma...are they known for cutting corners and destroying water supplies and habitat? My relatives seem to think they have a pretty good record. Is this wishful thinking?
I fear not much will change
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 19:13 — Anonymous (not verified)I fear not much will change until the great US public (that includes you and me) finds ways to use a whole lot less energy produced by fossil fuels.
Looks like 2012 is upon us,
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 20:26 — Liced-christ (not verified)Looks like 2012 is upon us, ladies and gents. Get ready for more, a lot more. This is just the tip of the iceberg. Human stupidity will now destroy the world, step by step, inch by inch (to quote or paraphrase the Three Stooges).
And all because some people
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 23:26 — Anonymous (not verified)And all because some people are too pig-headed to put on a sweater.
MJH, that is really sad and
Wed, 07/14/2010 - 23:37 — Lakshmi (not verified)MJH, that is really sad and depressing. I live "downstream" from you guys - in Bucks County. Many people have been approached by companies that intend to use fracking even here in the upper part of Bucks County, and they've sold their rights for a pittance, in comparison with what's being paid upstate. Despite a great deal of effort that was put into trying to educate people regarding exactly what the risks are in selling mineral rights from underneath your land, only now are many people around here finally experiencing seller's remorse.
But as you say, chances are we're all going to reap the consequences, now, of the shortsightedness of those who sold to make a quick buck. There's precious little "perc" in this area as it is. It does not take a degree in geology to figure out the tremendous dangers inherent in this "fracking" procedure.
You are a steward of your land. Don't give up what you know is your promise to the land itself. Stand firm. Things may still change for the better. It is possible people will wake up before it is too late.
Farking Fracking! We need
Thu, 07/15/2010 - 09:44 — Anonymous (not verified)Farking Fracking! We need full disclosure of all the stuff being dumped into the land and groundwater and real safety and regulation of these cowboy companies before the entire state is polluted -- Love Canal was a tidbit in the scale of all the negative impacts from this drilling and extraction.
We need alternatives to the consumption of these fossil fuels, not rhetoric and obstructionism.
Followup to my earlier
Thu, 07/15/2010 - 22:21 — MJH (not verified)Followup to my earlier post...PA is passing a severance tax on the gas companies. These companies are responding by trying to attach an amendment that will force people to lease their mineral rights...essentially declaring the entire state's mineral rights at their disposal. They may not succeed but this is yet another pressure we leasing holdouts are facing. Do we sign--in my case what would be a nonsurface agreement that prohibits any surface activity including drilling--- and get a bonus and decent royalties, knowing that at this point our land is at risk regardless of what we do, or do we holdout and get completely screwed...Taking the money will give some of us the means to take action in the event our land is contaminated. At present I am utterly lacking in the means to take legal action in the event they contaminate my unleased lands.
More bits of info---!) The
Thu, 07/15/2010 - 22:47 — MJH (not verified)More bits of info---!) The state of PA has leased the mineral rights to hundreds of thousands of acres of state game land and state forest land. 2) The so-called fracking method of gas extraction is very new. It was developed at Penn State & SUNY in just 2004 so there is no way for us to know the long term environmental effects even in a best case scenario. The state of PA is the guinea pig.
Meanwhile, forget about calling lessors sellouts. People have a broad range of reasons and intentions in leasing...some lessors actually think it's a step in the right direction concerning global warming and the environment, as power plants convert from coal and nuclear to cleaner burning gas. Some are desperate for money to keep their farms going, etc. or to pay for medical expenses, college, etc, and yes, some are in it to make a quick buck. The real problem is the gas industry. These companies have little experience with this method but smell the money and they have been tripping all over each trying to carve out units or pools of property owners. When one company gains a majority, they swap leases with other companies who have a majority elsewhere. They compete but also cooperate all endeavoring to make as much money as possible in the great Marcellus Gas Play, as it is called. Meanwhile in 2005 the Congress gave them exemption from the Clean Water Act. Only the state of PA can prevent them from wrecking the place and the state is rolling in debt. Hence the need for gas revenues...Ingredients of a perfect storm.
Spaghetti sauce and red wine
Fri, 07/16/2010 - 12:52 — anonymous (not verified)Spaghetti sauce and red wine contains anti-angio-genesis which helps prevent cancer tumours from getting blood vessels. Not sure the effects on liver cancers which ultimately are the ones that arise from drinking water contaminated by chemicals. Recommend Mediterranean diet for you and your kids. Including daily red wine! Good luck!
@DUBBYA That $150 barrel
Fri, 07/16/2010 - 16:34 — Anonymous (not verified)@DUBBYA
That $150 barrel price only because of decades of energy policy failures of administrations since Carter. We could have advanced solar and fuel cell technology by now to have replaced oil. We could have also had new public transportation solutions by now too.
Too many Texans in the White House and Pentagon in this country. They make too much money from status quo trading oil by the short and curlies everywhere, and of course invading other countries for oil.
TX now the Big Leviathan from Hobbes!
Thank you for this article.
Thu, 07/22/2010 - 16:06 — Susan (not verified)Thank you for this article. People should know that the race is on in Virginia. We've just had out first application for hydrofracking (in the beautiful Shenandoah Valley). We must learn from our neighboring states, and enact regulations before the drilling begins.
Many are already working to ensure this. Which Virginia legislators will take the lead and stand up for the people and our environment? We'll see...
Read more about the hydrofracking issue in Virginia, including a photo essay:
http://7bends.com/category/hot-issues/hydrofracking-in-virginia-hot-issues/
Let's get off of FRACKING
Tue, 08/03/2010 - 15:05 — billy bob (not verified)Let's get off of FRACKING oil already and start putting some FRACKING money into clean fuel, like FRACKING wind and FRACKING solar.
I'm getting FRACKING tired of this!
pakistan internet scandel
Sat, 09/24/2011 - 18:57 — ebony gagger tube (not verified)Good post, I always like them
coach outlet
Wed, 11/07/2012 - 04:07 — rainapew (not verified)must check coach outlet at my estore wWnQneHv http://www.coach-outlet--online.org/
pxjiuayw
Mon, 12/31/2012 - 08:40 — pxjiuayw (not verified)kwaakso
ghd australia kpppmn
Wed, 03/20/2013 - 17:36 — Mandykxc (not verified)ghd mjsppyfj GHD Hair Straightener tfisfwqq GHD Australia xqeyduyl cheap ghd