Just The Same Old Dumb

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

Just The Same Old Dumb
(Photo: Arlo Bates / Flickr)

I endured a moment of deep crisis on Thursday, upon realizing that there might actually be more Pure Dumb in the world than I was aware of.

Now, understand that I have been a Chronicler of Dumb for a very long time now. I am a Student of Dumb, and a well-worn one at that. I got my Bachelor’s Degree in the Study of Dumb during the Clinton impeachment. I got my Masters in the aftermath of the 2000 (s)election. It took a grueling eight years, but I got my first Ph.D in Dumb Studies during the George W. Bush administration. After that, earning my second Dumb Studies Ph.D came a lot easier over the last two years of observing and reporting on the demented frenzy of Dumb that has been emanating from a broad swath of the Republican Party since the election of a president who is a Democrat and also not White.

I know Dumb, my friends, inside and out. But this “story” sent me into a death-spiral of total incomprehension and self-doubt for longer than I care to be honest about in the telling. I stared at the headline for an hour – “Michelle Obama’s ‘Get Moving’ Program Linked To Pedestrian Deaths” – like a proto-human trying to figure out the Moon. I think I even made a few proto-humanoid utterances – “Gu ba? Fuh buh duh wah…urp?” – in the process of trying to work my way through those nine words. Slowly, painfully, as if I had a combination of sand and ground fiberglass in my eyes, I turned my gaze to the beginning of the actual article.

Join the movement for truth - support brave, independent reporting today by making a contribution to Truthout.

The Governors Highway Safety Association says pedestrian deaths increased in the first half of 2010 and the First Lady's program to get Americans to be more active could be partly responsible.

Gu ba?

Fu bu duh wah?

Urp?

Yup.

You read that right.

The First Lady’s campaign to fight obesity by getting folks to – wait for it – walk around a bit is actually killing people. Michelle Obama is maiming and slaughtering amongst the masses by trying to get people to exercise.

It was at this point that I began to experience a deep and personal crisis of confidence. I thought I knew Dumb. I thought I understood Dumb. I thought, in fact, that I was moving beyond my superior scholastic degrees in the Study of Dumb to something more akin to Jedi status. And then here comes this thing, and wham! My legs get taken completely out from under me. I know nothing of Dumb, I said to myself in something close to wonder. I thought I did, but here is this vein of truly supernatural Dumb, here is Dumb with enough sheer mass to bend the very light.

I did not know this. Here was Dumb of epic proportions, and it had eluded me.

I was crushed.

Despondently, I read on. The rest of the article happened to mention that, well, yeah, more people are walking around with headphones in their ears – thanks to the rise of the iPod, cell phones that play music, and people who walk and talk on their cell phones and make you think they’re either talking to themselves or spouting gibberish at you, until you see the little earbug strapped to the side of their heads – and step into the road lost in their little dream world, unable to hear the screech of tires and blaring horn that would normally be the last sound they hear on earth…if they weren’t wearing headphones.

And, well, yeah, the article went on to mention in passing that there are entire legions of idiot drivers on the road who talk on cell phones and text their friends while manipulating very heavy and lethal machinery at high speeds through areas where other people are trying to walk. I live in Massachusetts, and they actually had to pass a law forbidding “Driving While Texting,” because “Having Just A Scintilla Of Common Sense” wasn’t getting the job done.

And, well, yeah, the ever-popular “Incredibly Drunk Person Who Wanders Into The Road And Gets Killed” got a mention in the article, along with what was described as “aggressive pedestrians,” a phenomenon I am all too familiar with in Boston. People around here hurl themselves into traffic as if they have 30 seconds to live and the cure is just across the street…sometimes wearing headphones, sometimes not, sometimes drunk, sometimes not, but definitely aggressive about it, and the local papers are filled each year with stories of such “aggressive pedestrians” losing their lives.

But no.

The lead paragraph – nay, the first two paragraphs and the headline – declared that First Lady Michelle Obama bears responsibilty for myriad deaths in America because of her fight against obesity. Her suggestion – hey you, walk around – has put the freight of many lost souls upon her head. She drowns in their blood.

I almost gave up right then and there. If this much Dumb could exist without my knowledge, I scolded myself, then I am no scholar, no Jedi.

But then, hey...wait a minute.

Hang on one damn minute.

The banner at the top of that article reads “Talk Radio.”

There is an advertisement in the banner for the Sean Hannity show.

Just below an advertisement for the Rush Limbaugh show.

And – how did I miss this? – a picture of Rush Limbaugh below the banner that is bigger than anything on the site.

Talk radio. Hannity. Rush. More Rush.

Ah.

OK.

Whew.

It was, I decided, the headline that threw me. I lost it for a bit there, but eventually figured it out. This is not some heretofore unknown species of Dumb that I had managed to miss, like a paleontologist who was unaware of the Tyrannosaurus Super-Rex living in his back yard.

This is just the Same Old Dumb.

I was restored.

Oh, and for the record: walking is awesome. My wife and I have not smoked a cigarette for a combined total of 70 days, and walking many miles has been a large part of the continued success of our quitting process. I am getting more fit, as is she, and the walking has as much to do with that as the lack of smoke in our lungs.

Thanks, Mrs. Obama. You played a part in saving our lives. Keep it up. 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



William Rivers Pitt is a Truthout editor and columnist.  He is also a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



NOT "dumb" but VERY

NOT "dumb" but VERY intelligent planning by KRove/Consulting/Right/RepubicanEtc to repeat ANY opportunity to associate anything bad with Pres/Left/Liberals/Etc.This is the "repetition/miss no opportunity rule"-- GREAT intelligence is this is fully funded by corporations who now view the US labor force =Haiti workforce.Of course, no mention on the lives saved due to better health. Or the lives lost b/c Republican attemps to remove h-e-a-l-t-h-c-a-r-e from constitutional us citizens except themselves!!



First, congratulations on

First, congratulations on kicking the habit. Doing hard things makes us better people - and healthier, to boot. And the exercise will probably help you cope with the ever-increasing level of Dumb. Hang in there.



In Oakland, CA we call them

In Oakland, CA we call them "kamikaze pedestrians".



So the whole thing was just

So the whole thing was just Limbaugh pulling your leg? Hey, the guy's an idiot, but occasionally his humor comes through. We've always laughed with village idiot--how is this any different?



Any chance this is a right

Any chance this is a right wingnut ploy intended to get the heat off Sarah Palin and her ilk for the Arizona shooting? You know, "change the message?" a.k.a. "Wag the Dog?"



Today's dumb is "More than

Today's dumb is "More than 60 House Republicans signed on to a new bill to permit interstate sales of health insurance. The goal would be to lower premium costs by avoiding requirements in many states that insurers cover certain services, such as maternity care, cancer screenings and mastectomies." Also note that the GOP is pushing more restrictions on abortion, an outright ban being their goal. So, taken together, this party wants more unhealthy children and lower health care costs. There is some real dumb for you.



Will, you know that if it's

Will, you know that if it's coming out of a republican's mouth it's going to be more than dumb, it's also going to be a lie.



The right-wing hate-lie

The right-wing hate-lie machine is all about chutzpah. Make the craziest, most illogical, counter-factual points possible, but keep 'em simple & keep repeatin' 'em. I think it's a (power) game for some of these mendacious twits, "reshaping reality" (or at least little minds) in their own image, so we should be surprised by absolutely nothing they say. Just keep getting the truth out there . . .



@drosera This is different

@drosera

This is different from a Village Idiot because it has a billion dollar propaganda machine behind it, crafting the language - which is propagated to varying degrees across all participating media,

And this for a big enough percentage of the population to vote for GWB twice, makes up the political discourse.

This, has been so massively polarising that people are getting shot, any useful political process instantly goes intnick@tangerineworks.como log-jam and it accelerates a type of hyper-capitalism that is so utterly divorced from actually getting anything done, that it's probably going to destroy (if not the country) then certainly the dollar.

So no - this is not just a village idiot.

--

Background here: http://berkeley.edu/news/media/releases/2003/10/27_lakoff.shtml



Spot on as always, Mr. Pitt.

Spot on as always, Mr. Pitt.



great piece of work! I love

great piece of work!

I love the First Lady.

She is smokin' hot.

I bet she puts out a press release asking people to watch out for traffic just to show everyone how classy she is.



The Moron Majority!

The Moron Majority!



It's supremely stupid, but

It's supremely stupid, but it's also viciously malevolent, & that can stay with the reader who discards the idea.



“Gu ba? Fuh buh duh

“Gu ba? Fuh buh duh wah…urp?”

While studying Dumb throughout the Bush years, I see you also learnt to speak fluent Dubya.



Yeah, that headline smacked

Yeah, that headline smacked ME across the face, too... and the whole article was so stupid, I nearly fell into a deep stupor myself... it's like Sarah Palin's name, it just sends me into that giant sucking sound..............



When I first saw the story,

When I first saw the story, I had the same reaction, until further reading mentioned that I was supposed to take this seriously.

Mr. Pitt, your articles are always so amusing and enlightening to read, but this one had me ROTF laughing.

What is not funny is the desperate attempt to smear our wonderful First Lady and her family.

Fat heads like Limbaugh, should try some walking.



No, this is not the village

No, this is not the village idiot. This is a propaganda machine of the ruling class with a purpose: to drain the assets of this nation while it is still a major power. When they are done, they will move on to the next great empire, where ever that is. They have no loyalty, except to money. No nationality. No interest in anything except profit.



Absolutely nothing they do

Absolutely nothing they do or say anymore surprises me. I am past being stunned by the Republican propaganda machine. What confuses and angers me is that they continue to be a part of the national discourse in spite of the stupidity, meanness, and arrogance that vomits out of them. The fact that they actually have a good portion of the American population bamboozled into believing ANYTHING they say is a real stumper for me.



but it's so slick.. from the

but it's so slick.. from the POV of Rove et. al.. 101 million mindless idiots will see (& remember) that Michelle is "KILLING AMERICANS" and have one more reason to "HATE OBAMA".. That headline was no accident.. and we'd best not underestimate it.. a combination of (supposedly) limited evil & (apparently) limitless stupidity will be the death of us.. in the individual & collective sense..



Well, this clarification is

Well, this clarification is vital. I had obviously been misled to believe that "people kill people" (especially not Chryslers) and that Obama had nationalized America's auto industry. Apparently 'anything' can be further from the truth.



It's more about greed than

It's more about greed than being dumb. Greed will destroy the U.S. and that is dumb.



My mother always said "you

My mother always said "you tell people to stop being stupid"



Great and humorous article

Great and humorous article William. In todays environment, you must learn to think and speak like a Neanderthal.

Some suggested viewing...
I just purchased 'Quest for Fire' and see striking similarities between the characters portrayed in the film and followers in the GOP.

Auhh...auhh, auhh, auh,auh,auh, AUH!



cheap ralph lauren

look at ralph lauren outlet for gift SSeZTwsW http://www.ralph--lauren-outlet.com/



Tiffany And Co

Considering that Illacme plenipes happens to be discovered, the level of longer is there placed?



Ralph Lauren Shop

http://www.giuseppe-debiasi.it/blog/tutte-le-categorie/item/142-sala-borsa-giornata-per-i-saperi-tecnici/142-sala-borsa-giornata-per-i-saperi-tecnici?start=2250



Hollister Antwerpen

http://www.bluepoint.gr/la-bella-vita/wording-bikini-235773/item_limitstart/page-2



kzKMJcLcEasImPDB

AS76OT kvrcgydsprgc, [url=http://amocnliwzyrz.com/]amocnliwzyrz[/url], [link=http://xnbckpdgvuqq.com/]xnbckpdgvuqq[/link], http://mxxlmpbeivoc.com/