Kucinich Requests to See Bradley Manning, Soldier in Solitary Confinement for Alleged Leaks
Saturday 05 February 2011
by: Zaid Jilani | Think Progress | Report

(Photo: SEIU International / Wikimedia)
Last May, the military arrested Private First Class Bradley Manning, a military intelligence officer who had served overseas in Iraq, over charges that he was involved in leaking numerous classified documents and videos to the Wikileaks whistleblowing group, including a video of a U.S. attack helicopter killing numerous unarmed journalists.
Since his arrests, numerous civil liberties groups and investigative journalists have protested the conditions under which Manning is being held, noting that he has been kept in solitary confinement and is denied even access to a pillow or bed sheets. This is particularly shocking in light of new information revealed that Manning was suspected of having poor mental health before he was deployed to Iraq, with some superiors even requesting that he not be given firearms. Yet despite this press coverage of Manning’s treatment the military has offered very limited access to him and has refused to address the concerns of human rights and civil liberties advocates.
Now, Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-OH) has sent a letter to Defense Secretary Robert Gates inquiring about Manning’s condition, protesting the Army’s treatment of him, and requesting a visit with the imprisoned solider. In the letter, Kucinich writes that if Manning is need of mental health treatment, the “Army must end the extreme conditions of” his confinement, or at the “very least…explain the justification” for taking such extreme measures during his imprisonment:
Now, reports indicate that the Army has taken Pfc. Manning, a soldier with documented mental health problems, and confined him under conditions that are almost guaranteed to exacerbate his mental health problems. If true, the Army’s treatment would obviously constitute “cruel and unusual punishment” in violation of the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
If these reports are true, the Army must end the extreme conditions of Private Manning’s confinement, and provide him with the mental health treatment that the Army recognized he needed even before his deployment to Iraq. At the very least, the Army must explain the justification for confining someone with mental health problems under conditions that are virtually certain to exacerbate those problems and explain the danger he now presents that only these extreme conditions of confinement can avoid.
While Manning’s treatment has made waves in the media, it is important to remember that solitary confinement is a practice that is common in America’s prison system. A 1999 report by the Department of Justice found that some states locked up as many as 20 percent of their prisoners into penal systems that placed them under solitary confinement for 23 hours a day.
Last month, leading human rights groups Amnesty International and the Physicians for Human Rights both sent letters to the Department of Defense protesting Manning’s treatment; they noted that solitary confinement is widely used across the United States, it is almost unheard of for it to be used against a prisoner like Manning who has yet to even be convicted of a crime.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
I am so glad to see that
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 17:18 — Kaye (not verified)I am so glad to see that Rep. Kucinich doing the right thing. Thank God for this man. Someone needs to do something. I am really proud of a politician for a change.
The WikiLeaks story is
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 17:24 — Cockroach Hunter (not verified)The WikiLeaks story is starting to not add up. The idea that this low level person was able to get all that data is absurd - ask an expert in computer security, as I have. WikiLeaks is a piece of fiction - a propaganda piece to justify the wars and reinforce the fables that that we all accepted in the rush to war.
Manning is looking more and more like just another mentally ill person used as a patsy in what amounts to a psy-op. The embarrassment of some expendables, while leaving The British and Dutch Royals, Israel, Rothschilds, Murdoch and other PTB unscathed is what supposedly gives it credibility - that we take the bait. I reject WikiLeaks as a fraud.
Big Corporations
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 17:36 — Anonymous (not verified)Big Corporations
Obama has his Hands tied on
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 17:41 — Anonymous (not verified)Obama has his Hands tied on Bradley Manning , seeing that Wall street and the Banks that cant fall,really do control the White House . Are these not Corporate Wars we as a country are in . The real Terrorist work for Wall Street ..
Dennis Kucinich is a man of
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 18:58 — dlomartin (not verified)Dennis Kucinich is a man of conscious...what a great man and how much we need more leaders like him. His presence is like a breath of fresh air.
Look how a U.S.
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 20:39 — Anonymous (not verified)Look how a U.S. representative has to request a meeting with an American prisoner as if he were being held in a foreign prison. A situation reflecting how far removed the incarcerating powers have become -- to the extent that it's not even the same country.
I hope Dennis will challenge Obama in the primaries so that people can send a message to the "Democratic" administration as to who put them in power, to begin with!
Dennis, of course, has a record as a representative on standing for certain issues. Something Obama never had, to begin with. He just "appeared" on the scene, a public relations creation by Plouffe et al.
Sarah Palin is a P.R.
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 21:01 — Anonymous (not verified)Sarah Palin is a P.R. creation, too, FWIW. That's why she and her husband were on the sidelines of her daughter saying, "Stay in character, stay in character."
The Democrat/Republicans are going to whoop her up to frighten everyone into a voting fever when the time is right.
Barely anyone rational will be left standing by the time they're finished come election time.
May I suggest people make a personal commitment to hold on their brains for the long run.
Rep.Kucinich, what took you
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 21:11 — Douin (not verified)Rep.Kucinich, what took you so long ? It is despicable that no one in Congress, until Kucinich, has opened it's mouth on the subject of this uncalled for cruel treatment of PFC Manning. Since when does the Military take precedence over our Government. According to the United States Constitution, the Military are to take orders from the Government. Where is a Truman when we need one ?
Why is this lowly PFC being held in the first place without any charges actually being filed against him ? Seems he has been judged Guilty and is being punished and he has not even had a trial. Where is Justice in that? It is time the people stood up and shouted at the top of our breath, " We are mad as Hell and we are not taking it anymore," and put some action behind our words. Denied justice for one is denied justice for all. It is an insidious version of 'creeping Fascism.'
Rep. Kucinich, You have the full support of all true Americans. Demand that PFC Manning be brought before a Court of Justice immediately. You have the power...so use it.
Dennis Kucinich is the ONLY
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 22:28 — Cheryl (not verified)Dennis Kucinich is the ONLY one who has had the courage to do ANYTHING, including the Articles of Impeachment against George Bush. Pelosi and Obama and Reid took it "off the table". This incarceration of Bradley Manning is appalling and a symptom of all the crime and corruption that has been allowed to be permitted in "our name" and cast a terrible smear on America. Committing torture to our own countrymen or others is AGAINST THE LAW. The crimes committed by Bush and Cheney and Rumsfeld have gone unprosecuted and unpunished while a "whistleblower" is tortured and incarcerated indefinitely without even being charged. Thanks to the "Patriot Act" which doesn't seem to have much to do with Patriotism at all and "Homeland Security" which is more of an agency to aid in the coverup of government crimes and protecting our elite appointed and elected criminals from harm. Our country has come to represent the very wretched individuals and dictators that we "claim to abhor". Walk softly and carefully , Mr. Kucinich, lest harm should befall yourself. Many of the people you walk amongst are untrustworthy and of the worst criminal nature.
Well done Mr. Kucinich!
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 22:30 — Daniel J. Lavigne (not verified)Well done Mr. Kucinich!
After you meet with Mr. Manning, please tell the American people about their duty to speak up about the crimes committed by too many in power.
Would it be possible to have Mr. Manning held, for his own safety and to protect "The Rule Of Law" in a neutral country, perhaps by the ICOJ (International Court Of Justice.
After all, he has committed NO crime. He has, in fact, acted on his duty to help reveal the many crimes against humanity committed by US Armed FForces as the act to enhance the reach and grasp of America's corporate masters.
When the truth is finally available regarding this sad chapter in America's tale of insatiable greed leading to collapse, we shall be able to hope that the whole of humanity will come to terms with the nature of our existence as animals. Animals who, at present, unfortunately have no concept of such as "Limits To Growth".
Maintain the Rage! Consider your duty to all before supporting a society that would be party to mass murder. Thank you.
To all those saying: Dennis
Sat, 02/05/2011 - 23:09 — Paul W (not verified)To all those saying: Dennis for President. Have you forgotten? He did run. And the Mainstream Media actually had the gall to call him a "Dwarf"!!
And you, the American Sheeple, when you had the chance, overwhemingly rejected the possibility that a decent, honest man can become President of the U.S.
At this stage, it is no longer possible for people like Kucinich or Nader to become President. You must know that by now.
And to all those dreaming of a million people protesting in front of the White House or the Capitol, Dream on! The Sheeple don't do that, they'd rather be slumped in front of the Boob Tubes, watching the CorpoRat-orchestrated spectacle of the Superbowl, gobbling Cheetohs and beer, as braindead, millionaire behemoths bump up against each other in the name of 'Sport'.
I worked for Kucinich's
Sun, 02/06/2011 - 00:23 — KTB (not verified)I worked for Kucinich's election. For anyone who cares about the present and the future, he is one of the few straight talking politicians. Because of his stance on Iraq (against), and workers (for), regulation of corporations (for), protection of public institutions (for), and medicare for all (a champion) he has been marginalized by the corporate media. When it comes to any moral issue, Kucinich is there putting his actions where his ethics are.
I am not at all surprised that he is making Manning's conditions an issue for congress to confront. I think he should have just showed up. Don't give his keepers a chance to clean up the prisoner.
04:09, Paul W, I agree that
Sun, 02/06/2011 - 00:30 — Anonymous (not verified)04:09, Paul W, I agree that it's not possible because of the way elections are funded -- and who and what is running the country -- but people run for offices more than once, and history shows, that they can build up even more of a following with repeated campaigns. The point being, too, that in a primary, while Obama would win as the incumbent, being opposed by someone like Kucinich - who would likely have more support, not less, this time around - would pressure the democrats more to the left. Obama couldn't have been elected the first time around without his left base. They must speak up in some way, at primary time, to show the administration where they should be standing. That being said, I agree that Americans are shepple slumped in front of their football games that will probably be airing "pro-life" commercials and what-not this weekend. LIke the good clones our fascist educational system turned them out to be. At times like this I am grateful we killed our television.
Denis Kucinich should be
Sun, 02/06/2011 - 04:46 — Bearzerker (not verified)Denis Kucinich should be president... and this is only one of many reasons why a man of his character needs the promotion
I've read that the "secret"
Sun, 02/06/2011 - 11:13 — William Lee (not verified)I've read that the "secret" network that Manning supposedly "leaked" was open to about 300,000 people. Now, let me ask - If you tell a secret to 300,000 people, is it still a secret? Obviously it's not. The defense, as if anybody needed one, if that there were no secrets. The offense, if there was one, was that the government told 300,000 people some of the most stupid and embarrassing things - and having made these things more or less public, came to regret their own idiocy. Wrong guy locked up, it ought to be the fellas that were in charge - The Chimpster and Dr Evil...
We don't need to wait for
Sun, 02/06/2011 - 18:42 — Sayward (not verified)We don't need to wait for Mr. Kucinich to report, to express our opinion. I have the White House (http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact) and my Senate and House representatives on my Bookmarks Toolbar, and every time I read an article like this, I drop them all a note. You can do it, too.
They need to be reminded---often---that we're watching, and that we do care how they're running things---that we aren't all being sidetracked by Glee and the Super Bowl, and such.
Upset by what you're reading? Write! To the Prez, to Congress critters, to the editor of your local papers. Speak up! It's up to us.
With respect toward Mr
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 11:35 — A. Benway (not verified)With respect toward Mr Sayward, if "it's up to us", as he says, why write to anybody? If it's up to us then it's not up to them, is it?
The only thing that's going
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 16:17 — Anonymous (not verified)The only thing that's going to get Manning into humane conditions, if not out of Quantico, is a civilian-led lockdown and blockade of the base. The time for airing our discontent to apathetic aristocrats is past.
Somebody, was it Derrick
Mon, 02/07/2011 - 20:14 — A. Benway (not verified)Somebody, was it Derrick Jensen(?), said that every time we find a method that works [to stop some evil] "they" make it illegal.
Does anyone doubt that their lordships would claim that a "lockdown" or "blockade" was illegal or that it would be ruthlessly dealt with?
Manning is being made an example of. They are "teaching" us all a lesson in servile obedience.
However there is also another lesson they are teaching, quite unintentionally I'm sure.
They are teaching us to avoid getting caught... Teaching us all to avoid standing in front of a train... Teaching people in just the same way that their inspiring friends in the nazi gestapo taught so many Europeans. Teaching just as Steinbeck described in "The Moon is Down".
Manning? - there is a Constitutional requirement that he get a speedy trial. Absent that the law's clear - they have to let him go. Of course that's not happening - so much for law...
I look at the dates on these
Sun, 02/13/2011 - 06:20 — PM (not verified)I look at the dates on these posts and see that the last one was Feb 7th. The impression is that people stopped reading it at that date and that it is now dead in the past, not worth commenting on.
Suggestion for TO. To make the news you report more relevant and empowering for your readers, why not use a rating system where you quantify the comments and keep each story alive in position of priority on your webpage and e-mail feeds, relative to the number and continuity of the comments? For instance, if this story has a lot of comments it gets sorted to the top and mentioned in the e-mail feed. You could also link related related stories on the same theme. This is just one way you could serve the interest of your readership. Let their attention and interest become a way for them to highlight the issues of most importance to them.
Tiffany Schmuck Günstig
Mon, 01/21/2013 - 12:24 — Tiffany Schmuck Günstig (not verified)http://karasawamiho.jugem.jp/?eid=930