Mohamed ElBaradei: "If Not Now, When?"
Friday 28 January 2011
by: Robert Naiman, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis
Pro-democracy leader Mohamed El Baradei is calling for Western leaders to explicitly condemn Egypt's current President Hosni Mubarak. (Photo: Lukas Beck / The New York Times)
If Western leaders, who have backed the dictator Mubarak for 30 years, cannot stand before the Egyptian people today and say unequivocally, "we support your right of national self-determination," when can they do it?
That's the question that Egyptian democracy leader and Nobel laureate Mohamed ElBaradei has put before Western leaders today.
Speaking to The Guardian UK in Cairo, before the planned protests today, ElBaradei stepped up his calls for Western leaders to explicitly condemn Mubarak, who, as The Guardian noted, has been a close ally of the US:
"The international community must understand we are being denied every human right day by day," he said. "Egypt today is one big prison. If the international community does not speak out it will have a lot of implications. We are fighting for universal values here. If the west is not going to speak out now, then when?"
Giving forceful illustration to ElBaradei's words that "Egypt today is one big prison," Egyptian police later doused ElBaradei with a water cannon and beat supporters who tried to shield him, AP reported, then trapped ElBaradei in a mosque by surrounding it with tear gas:
Police fired water cannons at one of the country's leading pro-democracy advocates, Mohamed ElBaradei, and his supporters as they joined the latest wave of protests after noon prayers. They used batons to beat some of ElBaradei's supporters, who surrounded him to protect him.
A soaking wet ElBaradei was trapped inside a mosque while hundreds of riot police laid siege to it, firing tear gas in the streets around so no one could leave.
As I can attest from personal experience, having been under "hotel arrest" in Egypt during the Gaza Freedom March a year ago, this is a standard tactic of Egyptian police - prevent you from participating in a demonstration by detaining you where you are.
Do you like this? Click here to get Truthout stories sent to your inbox every day - free.
What does it say that ElBaradei, a Nobel Prize winner, the former head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, a former assistant to the Egyptian foreign minister, not to mention a 68-year-old man - is not allowed to peacefully raise his voice in protest against the Egyptian government?
Some folks in Washington still seem to be laboring under the illusion that the US can wash its hands of this matter, like Pontius Pilate.
If the Egyptian government were not one of the largest recipients of US "foreign aid," largely military "aid," it might be a different story. If the protesters in Egypt weren't painfully aware that the US has long backed Mubarak to the hilt, it might be a different story.
But that's not the world in which we live. The world in which we live is the one in which people in Egypt know that the US has backed Mubarak to the hilt. FDR famously said of the Nicaraguan dictator Somoza, "He may be a son of a bitch, but he's our son of a bitch." But FDR didn't say that in 2011. The world has changed. Expectations have been raised. US leaders today have to meet a higher standard today. "Our son of a bitch" isn't going to wash on the streets of Cairo.
ElBaradei told CNN on Tuesday:
"I was stunned to hear Secretary Clinton saying that the Egyptian government is 'stable,' and I asked myself at what price stability. Is it on the basis of 29 years of martial law? ... Is it on the basis of rigged elections? That's not stability. That's living on borrowed time. Stability is when you have a government that is elected on a free and fair basis. And we have seen how elections have been rigged in Egypt, we have seen how people have been tortured. And when you see today over 100,000 young people, getting desperate, going to the street, asking for their basic freedoms, I expected to hear from Secretary Clinton ... democracy, human rights, freedom."
In cities across Egypt today, thousands of people, young and old, secularists and Islamists, Muslims and Christians, workers, lawyers, students and professors, have placed their bodies on the line. Their willingness to sacrifice forces us to consider ElBaradei's question: if not now, when? As Rabbi Hillel said,
If I am not for myself, who will be for me?
If I am only for myself, what am I?
If not now, when?

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Robert, can you give Joe
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 17:43 — Ridiculous (not verified)Robert, can you give Joe Biden a call and ask him what's up?
My country continues to
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 19:11 — Dr. Bill Bushing (not verified)My country continues to contradict itself by claiming to model de,ocracy and "export it abroad" while supporting governments which are the very contradiction of that ideal.
No wonder we are not highly respected in so many areas of the world. They see right through us.
There will be many calls to
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 19:38 — S.O.Teric (not verified)There will be many calls to support Mubarak because of "the Muslim Brotherhood," in other words, a bogey-man. The fear really is an Egypt that no one can predict. Will it continue in its former alliances? What good are its former alliances if they have to be maintained by a brutal and corrupt police force in the streets of Cairo?
dangerous democracy....the
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 20:19 — newsfrombelow (not verified)dangerous democracy....the fact that egypt is a dictatorship and has long been a leading recipient of us military assistance speaks volumes.
obama says egyptians have "human rights and the usa will stand up for them everywhere..."
ironic no?
starting when??
when theie allies lose control of their authoritarian regime?
it would appear to be the case...
sad but true....the empire has no clothes....
and when these protests spread to saudi arabia???
oh my....what will our leader say then???
I don't know when, but if
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 20:48 — Jerry (not verified)I don't know when, but if things here in the US don't get better soon, I think there could be riots in Washington DC someday. And I really hope there are if inequality and corrupt congress people and corrupt senators and a weak president don't change and start doing the right thing for the 15 million laid off working people and the millions of homeowners facing foreclosure because of corrupt bankers. Our government is almost as corrupt as the government in Egypt. When our president has to plan on spending two billion dollars to get re-elected, and the hypocrite John Boehner has way over two million donated already from corporations for his re-election, this country needs a change. I really hope the people in Egypt are successful in their revolt and like I said earlier, this country needs another revolution.
Today an Egyptian friend in
Fri, 01/28/2011 - 22:18 — Heartbeatt (not verified)Today an Egyptian friend in Cairo said that the situation for people in the country is so bad, the poverty so great that most cannot care for anything but surviving. She said, one of the first things the people need is access to food, clean water and sewage treatment - the very basics that their corrupt government is indifferent to.
On the tv elsewhere the talk is about America's worries that a government less friendly to the USA will be installed. That is secondary, as long as it is a government that cares for its own people. And maybe if the US doesn't interfere, there is a chance of that happening.
Vive la révolution!
nothing worse than a mummy
Sat, 01/29/2011 - 01:32 — jacks Anonymous (not verified)nothing worse than a mummy with an austarity plan,how many paired sets does the big cheese got,besides a welfare police state at the zenith of economic miracles & tyrannies unleashed
I do not know this for a
Sat, 01/29/2011 - 02:42 — Anonarcmous (not verified)I do not know this for a fact,an acquaintance who had visited Egypt, told me that in Cairo "1/3 of the city population lives in cemeteries". I could not understand. He explained they camp out there homeless b/c they have no houses. I am not sure how this can be, or maybe it was a while ago. But he said that was true when he was there.
Somoza was not FDR's
Sat, 01/29/2011 - 04:58 — Anonymous (not verified)Somoza was not FDR's sonofabitch, and that is not the sort of language FDR used. You meant LBJ. It would be good to correct it in the text -- after fact-checking.
Actually, it was FDR.
Sat, 01/29/2011 - 08:53 — Anonymous (not verified)Actually, it was FDR.
America is one of the most
Sun, 01/30/2011 - 07:15 — Anonymous (not verified)America is one of the most hypocritical countries in the world! It preaches democracy and then supports the most corrupt and undemocratic governments!
They did that in Vietnam and the people in both countries paid the price! Don't Americans ever learn that by fearing a government that does not suit them, and propping up bad ones, they have messed up the world!
louis vuitton store online
Thu, 10/25/2012 - 01:56 — PaulkNug (not verified)order an authentic louis vuitton online for more detail qxzqQSld http://louisvuittononlineshop.metroblog.com/
hermes outlet
Sat, 10/27/2012 - 14:49 — jefeLedy (not verified)buy hermes outlet online shopping kqqlzFak http://www.hermes--outlet.net/
uggs outlet
Thu, 11/01/2012 - 23:23 — loossece (not verified)to buy uggs outlet and get big save UzxVTtRC http://www.uggs--outlet.net/
burberry raincoat
Tue, 11/06/2012 - 23:21 — Imatacok (not verified)sell burberry outlet for more detail KBPHGvyh http://www.burberry--outlet.org/
burberry purse
Fri, 11/09/2012 - 14:44 — Utinnire (not verified)cheap burberry outlet with confident cFlEkxhK http://www.burberry-outlet--online.com/
chanel outlet
Tue, 11/13/2012 - 18:24 — begeCeaf (not verified)purchase chanel outlet suprisely NuNLSCTR http://www.chaneloutlet-handbags.com/
chanel bags outlet
Fri, 11/16/2012 - 15:10 — WoowlCes (not verified)purchase chanel outlet with low price ScHcDRJz http://www.chaneloutlet-handbags.com/
amaccxs
Fri, 01/04/2013 - 09:27 — amaccxs (not verified)ftxagcsv
Ralph Lauren
Mon, 01/21/2013 - 12:50 — Ralph Lauren (not verified)http://luvloop.com/index.php/component/k2/item/244-maxwell/244-maxwell?start=320