Moving Beyond the Failed Consultancy Class
Thursday 21 January 2010
by: Joe Brewer, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

Scott Brown. (Photo: Dan Kennedy's Pix / Flickr)
Are you one of the millions of progressives grieving about the catastrophic fiasco that happened in Massachusetts yesterday? Wondering why it is that a Republican took the Senate seat in one of our most beloved - and deeply blue - states? This event is a tremendous learning opportunity for us.
Now is the time for bold vision and action. While the corporate minions of our party's past continue to call for us to act like Ronald Reagan if we want to win (see this disgusting diatribe by Mark Penn who recommends kissing up to Wall Street and ignoring main street as a strategy for success. Leaves one wondering just what the hell "success" means to him), we know what we really need to do:
Fire all those political consultants who couldn't find a progressive victory if it hit them on the head!
We saw what happened when John Kerry refused to fight for what he believed in during the 2004 election, instead opting to follow the latest poll conducted by an "approved" consultant on the insider list of the party leadership. We observed the tactics of the status quo in Hillary Clinton's campaign, including the adoption of Rovian attacks in the infamous "3 AM ad" that used fear to discourage voters from caring about Barack Obama as a way to undermine his electability (and throw the entire progressive agenda under the bus at the same time). Most recently, we've stood by as a "super majority" which has more representational leadership in the federal government than any party in our lifetimes, waffled and caved in to a nonexistent opposition in the debacle called health care reform throughout the last year.
These are clear indicators of failure. Yet there is no accountability for the liberal consultancy class. Indeed, they remain deeply embedded in the Democratic Party apparatus through requirements from central funding organizations like the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC), Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC), and Democratic Senate Campaign Committee (DSCC) as "people who must be hired" if candidates want to get a dime from the party establishment.
This is a recipe for continued disaster. We don't need more triangulation or "moving to the center" (a code phrase for ignoring our popular roots and pretending to be neoconservatives). What we do need is a strong moral vision and the will to stand by our principles. This isn't about messaging. Nor is it about following the polls. Such small-mindedness begets incremental progress combined with monumental setbacks.
Now is the time to begin building on success. Barack Obama didn't win the White House by presenting a seven-point plan or playing the cold-shouldered wonk. He won by articulating a clear vision of progress and calling us all to rise with him to become the country we know in our hearts that we can be.
Our current political system is taking us to the brink of collapse. It brought us the financial meltdown and massive bail outs to the super rich, while leaving the economy in tatters. It denies the urgency of our faltering global ecological commons, putting all of humanity at risk of extinction. And it is poisoned by the moneyed interests of health insurance companies, oil and coal companies, financial institutions and bloated defense contractors. These entities are part of the problem. They will go down when the structure topples, like a neglected bridge in rush hour traffic or the unmaintained levies of a coastal city in the eye of a hurricane. It is clear to anyone who cares about the environment, universal health care, livable wages and fair taxation that our current political infrastructure is broken. It's time for an upgrade.
Our job is to be sure that new and better systems arise to take its place.
There are many of us working day and night to build the new models for politics based on civic engagement, social technologies, the needs of real people and an earnest desire to solve problems instead of catering to bullies from decades past. We're applying microcredit lending strategies to help those in need to help themselves, starting social businesses that earn a profit while doing good, organizing communities of empowerment to meet each other and share ideas, starting our own media centers to bypass the corporate filtered "mainstream media" (the one that manipulated the populace into a war in Iraq) and so much more.
The political establishment isn't going to know what hit them. They didn't recognize our tactics when Howard Dean asserted that we'll only win if we engage as many people as possible (through his 50 State Strategy). The conservative "wisdom" of Democratic leadership was that the only way to win is to turn off as many people as possible while still securing 50-plus-1 percent of the vote. This may be the case if winning means preserving the status quo. But 50-plus-1 doesn't stave off the climate crisis. It doesn't remove entrenched interests either.
We've entered the second decade of the new millennium. The digital natives among us, those who cut their teeth in an internet world, are wired for collaboration and thinking in terms of systems. And they are starting to come of age. The politics of tomorrow is upon us. Let's go about the work of creating it.
This will require a retooling, just like any system replacement. During the 20th century, most of the standard tools came from the fields of law, economics, marketing and accounting. In the 21st century, our tool set will include computer programmers who design "civic software," adaptive management experts who can navigate through ongoing periods of significant change by creating learning organizations that nurture people, eco-design architects who shape public spaces that encourage meaningful interactions in our built environment, and much more.
The time for the politics of tomorrow is today. But first we need to get the failed consultancy class out of our way. And we need to employ new and better tools that promote civic engagement and build trust with everyday people. The people in charge right now don't seem to realize this. So let's replace them with people who do.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Why anyone would listen to
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 13:55 — TadS (not verified)Why anyone would listen to Mark Penn is a mystery to me. The man is one of the most beloved lobbyist/spin doctors of the tobacco industry. It's a shame that Democrats have gotten in bed with him.
Bravo. It is so refreshing
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 14:59 — Blue Collar (not verified)Bravo. It is so refreshing to think outside the box. Keep up the good work of breaking it down. With any great good wind "the consultancy class" is dust and the sooner the better. So the Brown win is a slap in the face across the board and especially to the Republican leadership if Brown's current positions are to be at all believed. It almost brings some legitimacy back to the "democratic" process. Wow, what a strange feeling.
We've known for years that
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 16:32 — Curt (not verified)We've known for years that the DLC was the representation of the far right in the Democratic party (further right than your average Republican), I gave up on the other two some years ago... they always need my money to support their agenda of more war, more bailouts, etc. as if the only way I can get a government for me and my fellow Americans is to buy it? And even if I try, how is my $20 going to stack up against the $200,000 my representative got from Wall Street and real estate firms? Or against the tens of thousands of dollars he got from the medical insurance industry? There is something TERRIBLY wrong here...
When will Democrats finally
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 16:44 — Jody (not verified)When will Democrats finally question why it is that in "Democratic" states, with the Democratic candidate leading in the polls immediately prior to the election, there is this sudden change in the electorate.
The vast majority of Americans' elections are based upon electronic voting and counting methods, corporate controlled, hidden from sight, and insecure from manipulation on multiple levels. The votes in Massachusetts were counted electronically, not by humans. The programming controlling the counting and tabulation is all hidden from view, done by one private company that does it for several New England states, and the system itself has been shown by multiple private and governmental studies to be easy to hack and virtually impossible to prove.
The American people, Democrats in particular, are not suddenly choosing to vote for a party that has basically been destroying our government, trashing our Constitution and Bill of Rights, and making corporations the primary power in this country and the world.
I am disgusted with a Democratic Party that does not stand up for the American people, and the principles it espouses. Instead it capitulates and compromises away the ideals and promises our country was founded on. If my vote for a Democrat is wasted, then I would do no worse by voting Green Party. At least they stand by their principles, and their platform reflects more closely what is needed for this planet.
How is it possible for "you
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 18:52 — eval (not verified)How is it possible for "you people" to continue to vote for either party; it being so painfully obvious that our interests are their last concern?
Organize locally, regardless
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 20:13 — Anonymous (not verified)Organize locally, regardless of party labels. Get like-minded people and elect the school board, the city council, the zoning board, and the local library board. Take back our country at the grassroots where real people live and can work on the real problems that affect them daily. Then when a movement is built, move to the statehouse and on to Washington. We'll be irresistible.
Get rid of the consultants,
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 20:40 — greg Gerritt (not verified)Get rid of the consultants, none of them understand the role of the planet in al this, and we ignore the ecology at our peril. When they remember you can not end poverty without healing ecosystems, you can not heal ecosystems without ending poverty, and the military industrial complex just gets us in trouble, we may have a chance.
ProsperityForRI.org
Come on, can't you see that
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 20:42 — Anonymous (not verified)Come on, can't you see that it's time to give up? The corporations already have control over most of government, and because of today's Supreme Court decision, they will soon be in total control. The time to fight was when the rabid-right-wing activist judges were being appointed to the courts, especially the Supreme Court. But Democrats were too wimpy to stand up for us, as always in recent years, and they let them through. The people have no chance any more. The only way out is revolution.
Obama should not bother
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 20:52 — Wilfred Candler (not verified)Obama should not bother passing anything in the next 11 months. He should focus on forcing the Republicans to physically filibuster good legislation. Insist on a public option. Surely he has 51 Democrats who will support this?
Get the Republicans to filibuster a sensible global warming bill with tax and dividend.
Introduce a green jobs revitalization bill to get America to work building the fast trains, intelligent grid and home insulation that will be needed to dispense with fossil fuels. An let the Republicans filibuster that.
Get the Republicans to filibuster a return of Glass-Stegal, it worked for 50 years.
Launch a wholesale legislative attack on company financing of lobbyists and candidates. Introduce “matching public funds” for every special interest dollar given to the other candidate. And let the Republicans physically filibuster against that.
Put up a bill for withdrawal from Afghanistan, and force the Republicans to filibuster against that!
The go to the Country on a platform of “I need more Democrats!” Indeed, it would do no harm to pull the rug from the last hold-outs on the Democratic side against the public option.
Yes.. It is indeed a
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 22:48 — Anonymous (not verified)Yes.. It is indeed a learning opportunity. Its an opportunity for all American Parents to sit down with their children and tell them that there is no Santa Claus and There is no Republic. There is only the Global-Corporate Empire and We are its Consumers...
I'm with Wilfred. Put up the
Thu, 01/21/2010 - 23:11 — Herbert Browne (not verified)I'm with Wilfred. Put up the Good legislation, and let them read the Bible & the phone books & the encyclopedia Americana aloud for months. To hell with "doing business." I'll happily eat tree bark & drink roasted dandelion root 'coffee' if that's what it takes. I see no victory in domestic compromise. Let them do their damnedest. ^..^
Amen to Wilfred. Dems,
Fri, 01/22/2010 - 11:19 — Anonymous (not verified)Amen to Wilfred. Dems, instead of caving time and again, make the gop explain why tens of thousands dying yearly for want of medical treatment is a good thing so long as profits are up. Make them state their case for maintaining the occupations in the Middle East. Make them justify the fact that anti-corporate power candidates now have no chance whatsoever of winning elected office. A year ago there was a popular President and a large majority of his party. After a year of cowardly capitulation, we've got nothing. Now as for me, there is no way I will ever vote for any major party candidate again. Throwing my vote away, you say? Even if we discount the very real possibility of voter-machine driven fraud, of what use is my vote if corporate funded candidates ignore the wishes of their constituencies?
For those still advocating
Fri, 01/22/2010 - 11:26 — Duke (not verified)For those still advocating legislation that satisfies the public's needs; where do these noble advocates (legislators) come from? Other than a few such as Dennis Kucinich and Bernie Sanders name the representatives that are not bought and paid for by corporations. Past the level of City Council or mayor of small towns the level of fund-raising required means going to the Chamber of Commerce, corporations, big oil/pharma/banks, etc. who represent the elite ruling class. The Supreme Corporate Court now has made it even more difficult to run populist candidates. In CA an action-figure conservative on steroids (Arnold) was elected governor and made a bigger mess. The corporate media still loves him despite his low popularity. I understand that 91% of talk radio is conservative (Rush Limbaugh recently signed a contact for $400 million) and except for portions of MSNBC the TV is controlled by Rupert-type conservatives.
I think we need a new party (Green Party or other) to break through the obstacles to true representative democracy.
BOTH parties are rotten to
Sat, 01/23/2010 - 13:27 — Anonymous (not verified)BOTH parties are rotten to the core.
Voters are taking aim on all incumbents and their voting records.
Anyone who thinks that dems or repubs are opposite parties and is drawn down party lines only, is either a criminal themselves or a complete IDIOT.
There are no exceptions to this FACT.
Yes, a lot of 'educated' people are especially included.
Watch REAL people like Ron Paul (R) and Alan Grayson (D) working together to save America.
WE the people had a good reason to be democrats for a day to elect Obama in hopes of breaking down the scourge of the bush crime family. That party 'unity' is no longer needed.
Now the objective is to remove every lying pig in congress with NO concern over party lines.
Then as demonstrated yesterday, 5 supreme court judges need to come under massive criminal investigation in hopes of removing them too.