No Dominion: The Lonely, Dangerous Fight Against Christian Supremacists Inside the Armed Forces

by: Matthew Harwood, t r u t h o u t | Report

The Lonely, Dangerous Fight Against Christian Supremacists Inside the Armed Forces
Mikey Weinstein. (Photo: Steve Most)

In his fight against British imperialism, Mahatma Gandhi described the life cycle of successful civil disobedience: "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win." Mikey Weinstein, the 55-year-old founder of the Albuquerque, New Mexico-based Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), likes to quote it, knowing full well he's crossed the line into a bloody-knuckle brawl. Over the past year, Weinstein and his organization have recorded a tremendous string of victories in the fight against Christian supremacists inside the armed forces.

In January, the MRFF broke the story on the Pentagon's Jesus Rifles, where rifle scopes used in Afghanistan and Iraq were embossed with New Testament verses. In April, he got the military to rescind its invitation to the Reverend Franklin Graham to speak at May's National Prayer Day because of Islamophobic remarks. Most shockingly, MRFF received its second nomination for the Nobel Peace Prize in late October. These high-profile victories have earned him the enmity of the hardcore Christian Right and the mentally unstable. And the crazies are getting crazier. Weinstein and his family are bombarded with hate mail, from the grammatically incorrect and easy to dismiss - "I hope all your kids turn out gay as hell, take it in the ass, and get aids and die!!!!" - to the kind of threats that immediately make you leap out of your chair and double-check that the doors and windows are locked. (MRFF has referred multiple death threats on Mikey, his family, and MRFF employees to the FBI.)

Unlike Gandhi, Mikey's no pacifist. Aggression rises up in his voice like a white shark's fin breaks the waves. In a recent conversation, Mikey bragged how a punk wouldn't shut up in a movie. When a confrontation ensued and the man took a wild swing, Mikey put him down. None of this is surprising. Weinstein boxed during his Air Force days, his face marked by a strong jawline sitting below a bald head on top of a stocky body - a cross between Rocky Marciano and Butter Bean. Simply put: Mikey Weinstein can be a brute and a zealot. He knows this and admits it freely. But he believes it's the only position a reasonable person can take when confronted with a faction dedicated to mutating the U.S. military into "a weaponized Gospel of Jesus Christ."

But for all of his rhetorical excesses and bravado, Weinstein's fight is simple and correct. The United States military cannot favor one religious sect over another, staying true to the Constitution's establishment clause that service members pledge to defend. More pragmatically, the military cannot favor one religious sect over another because it's destructive of good order and discipline, creating divisions between service members when they must rely on the guy next to them to survive in a firefight. Yet inside the U.S. military a small, determined, and fanatical clique wants to abuse its power and prosetlyze to service members below them in the chain of command. Through this captive market, they can inject their peculiar ideology into the most powerful institution on earth. As Weinstein likes to say, this isn't just a civil rights issue, it's a national security threat of the gravest magnitude. The description sounds hyberbolic, but according to Weinstein there's a pervasive Christian supremacist milieu inside the U.S. military that's a danger not only to constitutional order, but to the American wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. What's ironic about Mikey's fight is that he never thought about becoming "a civil rights activist." He discovered his calling by rising up like a grizzly bear for his son.

Mikey Weinstein's family.

Top row, left to right - Casey Weinstein (Mikey's son), Bonnie Weinstein (married to Mikey), Mikey Weinstein, Curtis Weinstein (Mikey's son)
Bottom row, left to right - Amanda Weinstein (married to Casey), Jerry Weinstein (Mikey's father), Alice Weinstein (Mikey's mother), Amber Weinstein (Mikey's daughter). (Photo: Steve Most)

The Academy

The Weinstein family is an Air Force family. After graduating from the Naval Academy in 1953, Mikey's father switched to the Air Force to pursue new opportunities in a new service. Mikey followed in his footsteps, as did his two sons, Casey and Curtis. Casey, the oldest, even met his wife Amanda at the Air Force Academy while they were cadets there. Mikey's daughter Amber dates an Academy graduate - 2nd Lt. Mack Delgado, a Christian with a cross tattooed on his chest, a detail Mikey points out every time his name's brought up. It's a family whose life orbits around the Academy, although that gravitational pull has slipped.

Can you help? If you can afford to contribute, please keep Truthout free for everyone with a donation.

As recounted in his 2006 book, With God on Our Side, Weinstein's confrontation with Christian supremacism began during his youngest son Curtis's freshman year at the Academy in Colorado Springs. Sitting at the base of Pike's Peak, Colorado Springs has been called the Christian Mecca. More than any city in America, evangelical Christianity saturates its streets. For instance, James Dobson's Focus on the Family sits just across the interstate from the Air Force Academy's airfield. Before he was outed for allegedly doing meth and banging a male prostitute, the Rev. Ted Haggard ran the 14,000-strong New Life Church in Colorado Springs. That extreme conservative religiosity has long permeated the Academy. Unsurprisingly, it doesn't like or respect diversity of any kind, as two generations of Weinstein's would discover.

Entering the Cadet Area at the Academy as a "doolie" in 2003, Curtis was asked from both naive and intolerant Christian cadets why the Jews killed their savior. During an intramural game, an upperclassmen asked him, "How it felt to kill Jesus." The religious discrimination got so unrelenting that Curtis complained to his father in June 2004. "The next person that calls me a fucking Jew or accuses me of killing Jesus, I'm going beat the fucking shit out of them," Mikey recounted to CNN in 2005. His older son, who graduated in 2004, confirmed the evangelical sea all Academy cadets swam in during their tenure there. "Dad, this is just the way it is," Casey said. "Senior cadets would sit down and say, 'How do you feel about the fact that your family is going to burn in hell?'"

Bad memories flooded back from Mikey's own time at the Academy, which he never told anyone about except for his wife, Bonnie. During his freshman year at the Academy, Mikey first faced anti-Semitic notes taped to his door that quickly escalated into two violent ambushes. The first time Mikey says he was attacked from behind inside an Academy academic building and thrown down the stairs, waking up in a pool of his own blood. The second time came while he was in the john. His attacker kicked in the stall and tore him up. "I was a victim, and having to admit that, even now, fucking pisses me off and makes me feel ashamed," he told the co-author of With God on Our Side, David Seay. Mikey was reduced to an Auschwitz Jew rather than the Warsaw Ghetto Jew he idolizes.

"I remember as an 18-year-old the overwhelming sense of helplessness of being abused, of utter degradation and humiliation," Mikey says. And the anti-Semitism then directed at Curtis gave him another chance to redeem himself and be that Warsaw Ghetto Jew. And he did. A former Judge Advocate General (JAG), a Reagan White House lawyer during the Iran-Contra scandal, and a former general counsel to billionaire and former presidential candidate Ross Perot, Mikey couldn't be dismissed as a Che Guevara T-shirt- wearing armchair revolutionary. And as a lawyer, he made it hard to ignore him. In October 2005, he sued the Air Force Academy, seeking a ban on religious proselytizing or evangelizing by superior officers after finding evidence of systematic evangelical coercion festering inside the Academy's walls. While the lawsuit was later dismissed in October 2006, the precedent was set. The initial lawsuit that Mikey leveled at the Air Force Academy morphed into MRFF as the winter of 2005 slid into 2006. Mikey left his lucrative job as an executive of business development at Perot Systems to continue agitating religious reform inside the military.

"Who will guard the guards," he asks. "We will, the Military Religious Freedom Foundation will." In the process, he has systematically exposed himself and his family to terroristic threats, virulent anti-Semitism, and financial ruin.

Neo-Crusaders

Quickly, Mikey realized that the infection wasn't isolated; the virulence was military-wide. He likens it to nuclear contamination. "If you had a geiger counter, there wouldn't be a place you couldn't find it," he says.

For decades, he discovered, evangelical para-church organizations had cropped up with the sole purpose of evangelizing service members. One group, Campus Crusade for Christ's Military Ministry, described the service members that come under its sway as "government-paid missionaries for Christ." At Fort Jackson in South Carolina, Military Ministry snapped pictures of soldiers posing with their rifles and their Bibles, an image eerily similar to jihadist propaganda videos. The same soldiers participated in Bible studies where one outline asked "Can a Christian Soldier Kill?" "NO to murder, YES to killing," the outline declared, because the soldier was god's "angel of wrath," punishing evil.

Other examples MRFF uncovered were no less disturbing. Inside the Military Police building at Fort Riley, a printout slapped on an office door carried conservative columnist Ann Coulter's sunken face and this quote: "We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity." A more subtle evangelical hubris also appeared inside the Pentagon. In 2007, MRFF's discovery of nine Pentagon officials appearing in a promotional video for Campus Crusade's Christian Embassy caused the Department of Defense's inspector general to rebuke seven military officers. For one officer, United States Air Force Maj. Gen Peter J. Sutton, that appearance proved embarrassing when he was assigned to Turkey as chief of defense cooperation. According to Sutton's own testimony to the inspector general, his Turkish driver approached him with an article from the Turkish newspaper Sabah, which carried a picture of his appearance in the video and described him as a member of "a radical fundamentalist sect."

But the Christian supremacist rot inside the military wasn't confined to home or overseas posts. It had spread to the worst possible battlefields: Afghanistan and Iraq. Tipped off by service members, MRFF has discovered chaplains handing out Bibles in Arabic, Dari, and Pashtun in theatre. In another instance, a lieutenant colonel and 15 to 20 armed troops cordoned off a city block in Iraq and told a missionary he knew from home that he would protect him and his missionaries while they evangelized Iraqis. These are all serious violations of military regulations. United States Central Command's General Order 1A, issued in December 2000, couldn't have been clearer for service members fighting overseas: "Proseltyzing of any religion, faith or practice" was prohibited.

According to MRFF's senior researcher, Chris Rodda, the organization has adopted a crude categorization scheme for incoming complaints such as these: "holy crap," "holy shit," "holy fuck," and "holy fucking shit." One "holy fucking shit" tip MRFF received described an incident in Samarra in 2004, when a National Guard unit painted an Arabic phrase on their armored pickup truck. It read: Jesus Killed Mohammad. Examples like these continue to accumulate with untold damage to U.S. military operations, Mikey says, despite the emphasis on winning hearts and minds in Afghanistan and Iraq, the focus of Gen. David Petraeus' counterinsurgency manual. In these environments, fanatical Christian soldiers become self-tripped IEDs. When news broke out in May 2008 that a soldier shot up a Koran at a Baghdad shooting range, a violent riot broke out among 1,000 Afghanis in which three people died.

Mikey talks about Christian supremacists like they're vampires, demons determined to drain secularism and pluralism out of the military. That realization turned what was once a personal fight against anti-Semitism into a more lofty principle. "Wherever I see unconstitutional religious predators in the U.S. military, of any stripe, I don't care if I live or die. Someone's gonna get a beating and we're going to do it," he says. "The two ways to administer the beating is to go into the media or into court," he explains, a strategy distilled from his fight at the Academy. Lance Benzel, a journalist for Colorado Spring's The Gazette, recently summarized Mikey's civil rights agitation aptly: "Condemn in the strongest language possible. Publicly embarrass. Sue if necessary. Each new step raises the pressure on his publicity-averse targets." What the U.S. military has realized over the years is that the mosquito they swatted at didn't only have bite, it had malaria.

Some Christians, out of ignorance or sincere apocalyptic belief, believe Mikey is the anti-Christ. (He's actually a reluctant agnostic.) Google "Mikey Weinstein" and you'll see descriptions like "Jesus-basher," "AntiChrist," and "anti-Christian Jewish supremacist." One "Concerned American" on the website "Powered by Christ" argued Weinstein's "doing all he can to create an anti-Jewish backlash and help bring about the predicted endtime Holocaust of Jews that'll be worse than Hitler's."

There's one problem with this assumption. Ninety-six percent of MRFF's 18,300 military clients are Christians - many Roman Catholics and mainline Protestant - that have been treated by their more spirit-filled comrades and commanders as not Christian enough. "This is not a Christian-Jewish issue," Mikey argues, "it's a constitutional right and wrong issue, and Christian fundamentalism does not recognize the supremacy of the Constitution over its sectarian theocratic dictates."

Elizabeth Sholes, the public policy director of the California Council of Churches/IMPACT, which represents 1.5 million progressive Protestant members, denied Weinstein and MRFF are anti-Christian. She says he simply fights for religious freedom.

Sholes is a good person to describe Mikey's enemies, as she sits on the left side of the great schism in American Protestantism. While Sholes supports an evangelical's right to witness to whomever they please, she, like Mikey, believes they cannot do so when they are representatives of the government. "Our Constitution was established to give everyone the right to conscience, the right to free expression of religion" she says, "but not to commandeer the institutions of government to make that happen." Yet Sholes says aggressive evangelicals within the military get it upside down, believing the government violates their religious freedom when government regulations forbid its public servants to proseltyze the saving grace of their savior.

Sholes, a believer in the Protestant social gospel tradition, argues Mikey's enemies represent the very worst of Christianity - the apocalyptic rapturites confident of their own salvation and most everyone else's belly flop into the lake of fire. These types of Christians go by many names, she says: fundamentalists, dominionists, the Christian Right, Christian nationalists. I asked Sholes if Christian supremacists is an accurate description. She says yes. But Shole's assessment goes even further, comparing Christian supremacists to Nazis. Asked if they represent Christian fascism, she doesn't hesitate: "Yes."

"We hate a small subset of Christianity that goes by this term, dominionist fundamentalist Christianity," Mikey says.

Hate on the Homefront

Case in point: On May 25, the 5th floor of the Dallas County Courthouse was cleared so Mikey's lawyer, Randy Mathis, could take the deposition of Rev. Jim Ammerman while six deputy sheriffs stood guard, rotating in and out of the jury room. In his 30 years of practicing law, Mathis never saw this type of security for a deposition unless the person being deposed was already a prisoner of the state. Spokeswoman Kim Leach for the Dallas County Sheriff's Department confirmed extra security was provided, but could not provide details except to say the judge had requested it because of a "security issue." One possible reason for the extra security is that Ammerman is batshit crazy, a man who holds so many wild and dangerous beliefs he can be seen as the grandfather of the craziest fringes of the Tea Party movement. To be clear, Ammerman, who will turn 85 in late July, is not the threat. It's those who listen to his conspiratorial screeds, according to Mikey and Bonnie.

A former Navy pilot, Green Beret, and Army chaplain who rose to the rank of full colonel, Ammerman is an early purveyor of the One World Government ideology that believes foreign troops are knowingly stationed in U.S. national parks, and that former President Bill Clinton and current Secretary of State Hillary Clinton are members of the Illuminati - a secret society determined to install a one-world government. As he stated in his deposition, he also believes there are 125 FEMA-built concentration camps inside the United States with more in construction right now.

What's striking about all this is that Ammerman's organization is currently one of the U.S. military's largest ecclesiastical endorsing agencies for chaplains. As President and Director of the Chaplaincy of the Full Gospel Churches, he currently endorses 270 Pentecostal chaplains across all branches of the military. Ammerman's tinfoil-hat beliefs, however, have brought scrutiny before - from the Pentagon, itself. In September 1997, Lt. Gen. Normand G. Lezy of the USAF ordered an investigation of Ammerman and his endorsing organization for using military chaplains "as agents to collect and convey military intelligence information for Mr. Ammerman's political purposes." The two other reasons Lezy gave for opening an investigation were no less inflammatory: Rev. Ammerman's encouragement of groups with "supremacist viewpoints" and his repeated suggestions that a military coup of the United States was imminent.

Mikey and his wife Bonnie are currently suing Rev. Ammerman because of the actions of Gordon Kingenschmitt, a former Navy chaplain and self-styled "traveling evangelist" he endorses. Klingenschmitt became a hero of the Christian Right in 2006 when he was court-martialed by the Navy for insubordination after he attended a Religious Right protest outside the White House in uniform. When the evangelical Episcopal Church pulled his chaplain endorsement after his reprimand, Ammerman's Chaplaincy of the Full Gospel Churches picked him up.

An avowed enemy of MRFF, which applauded the Navy's decision, Klingenschmitt began channeling the Old Testament's King David in his fight against godless secularism. Last year, Klingenschmitt issued multiple imprecatory prayers, basically a curse, calling for Weinstein and his family's destruction. During his first curse, Klingenschmitt quoted the Bible's most violent imprecatory prayer:

Almighty God, today we pray imprecatory prayers from Psalm 109 against the enemies of religious liberty, including Barry Lynn and Mikey Weinstein, who issued press releases this week attacking me personally. God, do not remain silent, for wicked men surround us and tell lies about us. We bless them, but they curse us. Therefore find them guilty, not me. Let their days be few, and replace them with Godly people. Plunder their fields, and seize their assets. Cut off their descendants, and remember their sins, in Jesus' name. Amen."

In a revealing exchange during the deposition, Klingenschmitt told Mathis that he and Mikey were both anti-Christians for suing him. Then, without prompting, Klingenschmitt added, "And it's a little bit anti-Semitic because King David was Jewish, and King David prayed that Psalm to God as a member of the Jewish faith."

His absurd Biblical exegesis aside, Randy Mathis says Klingenschmitt's prayers are coded directives to other Christian supremacists to harm Mikey, Bonnie, and their children, done on behalf of Ammerman. "They're trolling for assassins," he says. If a conspiracy exists and that was indeed its intent, there's evidence it worked. Kingenschmitt's curses have ratcheted up the hate directed at Mikey and MRFF to extreme levels. "Since these fatwahs were issued, the threats and hate mail have increased exponentially," the lawsuit filed last September states. "Plaintiffs justifiably live in fear of imminent violence against their person and their family."

Things have deteriorated more rapidly since the New Year. In January, MRFF discovered that the Pentagon had a $660 million multi-year contract with Michigan-based Trijicon, which supplies rifle scopes to the U.S. military that had New Testament citations inscribed on them. One scope read "2COR4:6," a reference to Second Corinthians 4:6 which states: "For God, who commanded the light to shine out of darkness, hath shined in our hearts, to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ." The Pentagon, along with countries like Canada, Great Britain, Israel, New Zealand, and Australia, have all since either raised concerns about the scopes or demanded Trijicon wipe the scopes of their New Testament citations purchased by their respective militaries. Then the news broke that MRFF successfully had Rev. Franklin Graham's speaking invitation at the Pentagon's National Day of Prayer event revoked. The son of legendary presidential sycophant Rev. Billy Graham, the younger cleric didn't have his father's discretion in public and had assailed Islam repeatedly, once calling it "A very evil and wicked religion" after 9-11.

"We moved to another level," Bonnie says of getting Graham booted from the event.

Then on April 15 at 11:18 p.m., an e-mail popped into Mikey's box. It's subject read: "Bad Leo Frank," and displayed a picture of a young bookish man, hair parted to the side, with glasses framing a skinny face. A minute later, another e-mail appeared in Mikey's MRFF account. It read: "Good Leo Frank" and showed the lynched corpse of the same man dangling like strange fruit from a tree. Considered a textbook case of Southern prejudice and cruelty, Leo Frank was a Jewish pencil factory manager in Atlanta, Georgia who was murdered by vigilantes for the murder of a 13-year-old girl many believe he didn't commit.

A little more than 12 hours later, the final e-mail dropped into Mikey's inbox. The subject read "Re: Good Leo Frank." The e-mailer knew a version of Leo Frank's murder too. "He was guilty as sin, just like you," it read. "Tried, convicted, sentenced, appealed, denied. When jew money bought him a Clinton style pardon, white justice stepped in. Are you ready?"

Since Mikey's very public fight began half a decade ago, the family has had to take increasingly extreme security precautions, as people left dead animals on their lawn, shot projectiles into their home, and drew crucifixes and swastikas on the side of their house. The family has two attack-trained German Shepherds, referred to as "the girls," that patrol their property with a third one on the way. The house is equipped with floodlights, surveillance cameras, and when things get really bad, Curtis tells me, a team of security professionals camp out and watches over the property. But that e-mail, among other threats, made him embrace the Bill of Rights even more: he and Bonnie got concealed firearms permits.

Bonnie, who suffers from multiple sclerosis, now carries a gun in her purse. She and Mikey now regularly go shooting to keep their skills sharp. "I have to have my gun as my friend," Bonnie said. "It reminds me on a daily basis, if not hourly basis, that there are really crazy people out there and at any moment they can shoot." To remain comfortable with the weapon, Bonnie aims the unloaded gun at the TV and pulls the trigger.

The hatred takes a toll on her. "When I talk about this my chest tightens up; I get full of stress," she says. She is very, very afraid, she tells me.

Extended Family

Zachari Klawonn is an unfortunate young soldier. Not only is he a Moroccan-born U.S. Army Specialist and a Muslim-American, the twenty-year-old is stationed at Fort Hood, where Maj. Malik Nadal Hassan went jihadi postal on his comrades, butchering 12 soldiers and a civilian in November.

"I am just an American soldier who happens to be Muslim," he says. Not everyone at Fort Hood sees it that way, and his faith has not endeared him to some soldiers. In February, someone on base wanted him to know it - badly, at 2:00 a.m. on a Monday morning. That night, someone repeatedly kicked the door to his barracks room, making him leap from bed. When he opened the door, he found an empty hallway and a note, folded twice and wedged into the doorframe. It read: "FUCK YOU RAGHEAD BURN IN HELL." It was an incident reminiscent to what happened to Mikey during his Academy days. The nighttime visit, shoveled on top of a pervasive base culture that associated Islam with terrorism and repeatedly used the ethnic slur haji, made Klawonn decide to stand up for himself. It also didn't hurt that Klawonn's own comrades would hurl the most offensive slur imaginable after the Fort Hood Massacre; they called him "Zachari Hasan."

"Enough was enough," Klawonn says, and he filed a complaint with his unit's equal opportunity officer to force the Army "to take a good hard look at that moral compass and start using it."

But that arrow didn't move. Instead, Klawonn was forced off-base because Fort Hood could not assure his security. Too compound his problems, Fort Hood also did not pay out his housing stipend, and Klawonn had to survive on loans and pawning belongings. "I was running out of hope quite frankly," he said. "I lost hope in the system." With nowhere to turn, Klawonn did research online and found Mikey and MRFF. Within 24 hours, MRFF reached out to Klawonn's chain of command. "I felt the urgency in the matter just completely take a 180," he said. He was told immediately that his living expenses would be reimbursed. In another act of kindness, MRFF extended him a loan to carry him until Fort Hood reimbursed him. Within the next pay cycle, Klawonn was collecting his Army paycheck again. "It's clear and it's evident, MRFF definitely has some big push," Klawonn.

"He's the Jackie Robinson of the U.S. military," Weinstein says.

Klawonn's story isn't an aberration. MRFF receives multitudes of thank you's from veterans and service members serving across the globe. One thank you came from a U.S. Navy veteran, a self described "religious Jew," who described extreme religious coercion during hospital stays at the Iowa City Veterans Affairs Medical Center in 2007. "During two hospitalizations, despite my written and verbal instructions to the contrary, the hospital staff was not content to just refuse to contact my rabbi," wrote Akiva David Miller, now the director veterans affairs for MRFF, "they sent a proselytizing Protestant chaplain in to see me - while I was bedridden and wired to a heart monitor - to tell me that Jesus was the Messiah of the Jews too, and that my only hope was salvation through Jesus Christ." Miller and his rabbi protested and the medical center retaliated by discontinuing Miller's care. When they cut of his pain medication, Miller asked his doctor why. His response: "You're a religious Jew. Why don't you try prayer or meditation?" Miller contacted MRFF. Mikey flew out to Des Moines and held a press conference that launched a full investigation that confirmed Miller's discrimination. And with the help of his old boss Ross Perot, Mikey got Miller care at the Dallas V.A. Medical Center.

While Mikey considers his approximately 18,300 clients new members of his family, his fight has naturally eviscerated other family relationships. Bonnie Weinstein tells of many friends and family who have left their sides when Mikey began trying to reconstruct the wall between church and state in the military, but she didn't provide details.

She didn't have to. On June 25, Colorado Spring's Gazette printed letters to the editor on Benzel's piece on Mikey. The comments took an even more absurd turn than usual, considering the type of e-mails and comments Weinstein and MRFF generate. Paul Baranek, the father of Mikey's daughter-in-law Amanda, wrote a letter to the editor calling Mikey an anti-Christian bigot and chastised the paper for giving him more press. "This man's motives are anything but noble, and the more publicity you give him, the more you encourage his crusade against Christianity," Baranek wrote. Mikey responded in typical Mikey fashion: "I want to fucking strangle him," he told me. But a more constructive and devastating response came from Baranek's own daughter, Mikey's daughter-in-law Amanda, published in the Gazette:

I was raised with the idea instilled in me that only a person with unstable and unsound beliefs tries to silence those with beliefs different from his or her own. Ironically, it is Paul R. Baranek who instilled this belief in me, the same man now wishing to silence Mikey Weinstein. Technically speaking, Paul Baranek is my father, but it is more accurate to describe Mikey Weinstein as my father. It is not by blood but by heart and choice that makes Mikey my father. He is the one who believes in me. He is the one who protects me. He is the one who defends me. He is the one who stands and speaks for me when no one will listen. He is the one who knows me. And he, Mikey Weinstein, is the one that I call father, that I call Dad.

But she wasn't finished, echoing a sentiment seen in countless e-mails to MRFF: "But Mikey is much more than just MY father. Every military member seeking help from MRFF, whether they are Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Atheist, or Christian (and most of them, like me, are Christian) is treated the same way he treats his own children," she wrote. "Mikey is the only person willing to protect our military members and stand up for them when no one else will listen, ensuring they have the same constitutional right of religious freedom guaranteed by our country's forefathers, the same rights that he himself fought to protect during his service in the Air Force."

The letter, with all its awkward airing of family hatreds, proved one thing: Mikey Weinstein can be an incredible asshole sometimes, but to those that know him, he's an indefatigable protector of the weak when they have nowhere else to turn.

"The care with which he handles each and every person who has decided to appeal to him for help...is what matters to us," says Sholes. "His personal style is just not the issue."

"My family is my life," he declares repeatedly to me over multiple conversations.

No Dominion

The fight has changed Mikey. He has a darker view of American history now, acknowledging the genocidal underbelly of the American Christian conception of "manifest destiny." He also feels like he's beset by enemies from every conceivable angle - fearful an imbalanced Christian fanatic could step out of the darkness and end it all, as well as resentful he can't rely on even liberal Democrats for support. In May, the Pacific Pasilades Club awarded Mikey its Anne Froehlich Political Courage Award but then quickly yanked it back, the club's president justifying it by saying they weren't aware Mikey defended the Reagan administration during Iran-Contra. (The Air Force assigned him the task.) In disgust, former Ambassador Joe Wilson and his wife Valerie Plame, the CIA agent outed by the Bush administration during the run-up to the Iraqi War, gave back the same award they won years before. The club flip-flopped again and returned the award with apologies. Mikey will receive it in Los Angeles this fall.

Sholes compares the last five years of Mikey's life to the famous Vietnam battle of Khe Sanh: "He's been under fire relentlessly and he's just exhausted emotionally." Bonnie says their struggle, and she believes it's their struggle, has taken a lot from them, especially their wealth. "Our security is completely gone," she said. At times there's an air of fatigue in her voice, that the stress of all this has ground her and her husband down. Yet she says service members would have no one to turn to if MRFF closed shop.

And the e-mails seeking counsel and help just keep coming. In May, 43 members of the U.S. Army - 29 of which were Catholic and mainline Protestant - reached out to Mikey complaining about the emblem at of Evans Army Community Hospital at Fort Carson. The emblem shows a cross with a stake at the end accompanied by the Latin phrase "Pro Deo et humanitate," meaning "For God and humanity." The official Army Heraldry Manual says the symbol dates back to the Crusades when Christian pilgrims would stake a cross in the ground to mark their camp, and he wants it retired. Mikey says it shouldn't be ignored that the Fort Carson cross looks eerily like the cross emblazoned on the Web site of the Hutaree militia, the apocalyptic militia the FBI raided in March. He compares the casual Christian supremacy at Fort Carson to the casual racism of the "Sambo's" restaurant chain that died out after the Civil Rights movement took hold in America. And just a few weeks ago, Mikey received complaints about a new commander at Dobbins Air Reserve Base in Georgia. During the change of command ceremony, the new head of the 94th Airlift Wing, USAF Col. Timothy E. Tarchick, declared, "My personal priorities are first, my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, second, my family, and third, everything else." Imagine Tarchick said this, argues Mikey: "My personal priorities are first, Allah and Savior Mohammed, second, my family, and third, everything else."

According to Mikey, these recent incidents mean the fight will continue on. Sometimes he says he feels like he's "screaming into the abyss each morning." In essence, he's a civil rights Sisyphus. He shoulders the boulder up the hill, only to watch it come crashing down again.

"I worry about him," Amber says, knowing full well her father won't stop "unless someone shot him dead."

Looking back on the 20th century, one of the morbid realizations of any civil rights activist is that their wick doesn't last long. There's no reason to think the 21st century will be any different. That doesn't deter Weinstein. Neither does poverty. He says he'll sell everything to continue his fight. He is a man on fire, but he's hoping his wick will burn out naturally.

Mikey Weinstein is a member of Truthout's board of advisers.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



 Matthew Harwood is a journalist in Washington, DC, and a frequent contributor to the Guardian's Comment is Free. His writing has appeared in The Washington Monthly, Progress Magazine (U.K.) as well as online at Columbia Journalism Review, CommonDreams, and Alternet. He is currently working on a book about evangelical Christian rhetoric and aggressive US foreign policy. You can follow Matt on Twitter @mharwood31.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



A very informative article

A very informative article here. However, I think we need to see that what's happening in the military is but a natural extension of the insidious proliferation of religious extremism in this country. As a non-religious person, I find it just slightly strange that members of the armed forces, who in every respect, are tools in a global dominance scheme, are so concerned about THEIR religious freedom. The military mentality is patently inconsistent with the core beliefs of all of the major religions, so it seems that the truly religious would simply avoid the military and practice their religion in a non-institutional setting. No need to go into the ultimate absurdity of all of these belief systems, but we need to be aware that the extremists efforts in this country are far more sinister than we might think--as this article points out.



It'd be rapturous if these

It'd be rapturous if these sky pilots would just(ly) be off into the wild blue yonder, instead.



Christians??!! There is NO

Christians??!! There is NO WAY that Jesus would accept and condone those who partake in the acts of genocidal mass murder, torture, war crimes and crimes against humanity that are an integral feature of the current wars of occupation in Iraq and Afghanistan, and those who support them, including the "Clergy" of Christendom who support and condone these wars. And in doing so prove that their religions are a "False Christianity". And considering the fact that the wars are not wars of self-defense, but acts of illegal, immoral, unprovoked and totally unjustifiable imperial aggression, Jesus most assuredly has nothing but CONDEMNATION for these wars and their participants and supporters!!!



Amazing but NOT

Amazing but NOT unexpected.... Mike, as millions have over the millennium, run into the stone wall of "My way or I'll kill you" mentality that has been rampant in this country's military but has spread everywhere as an alleged religious freedom squawk.. There are people even within out own boarders (millions) that believe that ANYONE that doesn't fall into line must go - permanently. It will take millennium to change this back into balance of the 'right' and 'wrong'... Personally, in the US, I don't think the non-compliant meat sacks have a chance.... Me and Mikey included.

A good friend of mine lives in the outskirts of Colorado Springs. He WILL NOT venture into Colorado Springs because everything he sees, touches, hears, smells is rank with this bigotry that is palpable.. The loons have truly taken over Colorado Springs based on the very data that Mikey is finding all over the world - fanatics are loose!

The press in Colorado Springs is appalling - at best..Because the religious issue of the day takes precedence over everything or it doesn't get printed..

Since the religious nut-bags have invaded every strand of life in the Springs, some of the basic city services are now being shut down because more and more of the 'church money' is going to folks like James Dobson and his gangs and NOW, Ted Haggard has started again.. got his church back up and running again after spending some time at 'restoration camp', W T F ?????

They can't raise taxes or fees on anything in the Springs because the republican/military/church controls everything... and taxes just to keep the city functioning are out of the question... They would probably come looking for you with a gang of hooligans in the back of their pickup..

Dying city... they brought it on themselves... AND, if it doesn't die, then it will be transformed into the first/second/or third US concentration camp by the Military. The locals won't know this because there are not very many smart, independent minded folks left.



Hats off to Mikey Weinstein

Hats off to Mikey Weinstein and the brave Weinstein family They are the kind of citizens that make me proud to be an American and give me hope for our country.



If you boss is one of those

If you boss is one of those Christan nut officers, your career may be over unless you join his church, attend prayer breakfasts, and stop drinking beer. Of course none of this is required, but failure to do so will result in a poor eval.



Scary, and highly

Scary, and highly disappointing. I hope this is a passing phase, and that this country wakes up to what is going on inside it. Otherwise, I'm afraid there isn't much hope for us.

Great report. Thanks.



Another reason IMO they

Another reason IMO they should reform policies towards gay Americans in the military, actively recruit more talented women, and pass the Dream Act.

They would thus attract a more intelligent population into the armed forces that has informed experience with discrimination and bigotry.

To this day, too, there is a lot of ignorance in our nation about the role of American Jewish soldiers during the Second World War. The sons of immigrants who fought in the biggest battles, and were on the beaches of Normandy. I have communicated with teachers who are terribly uninformed on these matters. even overtly anti-Semitic.

Perhaps they should require coursework for military people in this subject, if they don't learn about it in our high schools.



No questions raised about

No questions raised about whether the military itself is some kind of cult, some manifestation of failure in the USA. Yes, let's make sure we get rid of the actual Brownshirts. In fact, if a draft were to return, start spouting off racial hatreds, bizarre interpretations of Leviticus - so you can get away from potentially being killed.



A Christian army? Did any of

A Christian army?

Did any of those assholes understand the New Testament at all?



That's a very upbeat final

That's a very upbeat final graph, what with basically predicting Weinstein's assassination. Nice.
Thank god for Mikey Weinstein--people like him are what give me hope for humanity.
As for the christian fascists--Jesus would weep if he knew what these people did in his name.



I am so glad Mikey and

I am so glad Mikey and company have taken up this very important fight against the uber-christians, who if they succeed, will bring chaos to this country and it's democracy.

Mikey you have the brains, the heart, and the power.

I am so glad I give money to Truthout and that you are on it's board of advisors.

Thanks Mikey, and thanks also to those around you.

Karen in KC



So much for Christ being the

So much for Christ being the "Prince of Peace."

So much for "Thou shalt not kill."

WABOFM

The last word of the acronym is Morons.



Mikey, I found my military

Mikey, I found my military experience of over 20 years to be very much like yours. The exception for me was that I am an Atheist and not religious at all. I do not care about anyone's beliefs or reasons for those beliefs. My major gripe is that the real problems are with those who for what ever reasons, must force their beliefs on those who do not believe as they do. Whether this is a problem of having a persecution complex or just being a knucklehead who likes to bully others is of no matter. These kinds of people need to be shown the errors of their ways by removing the means of communication of these obnoxious beliefs. If it means fines and jail time for those involved, so be it.

I never cared for the Chaplain Corps when I was in the military. I felt they were about equal to "tits on a boar" window dressing only. In 1974 just before I retired, I had the displeasure of meeting an junior officer (a line officer) who claimed that he was part of the "New Army of God" and they were out to proselytize all branches of the Military.. And as an Atheist I was going to be placed on their "shit list" and they would see that I was "taken care of". At the time I was a Navy Chief and I could see the writing on the wall.... I still see it, even more so today. I have visited several ships that have passed through my little area of paradise, and see prayer meetings happening in places that I would never have expected religion to be a public act.

I for one, am damn glad that I am no longer a member of the armed forces, no would I join today if I were young and eligible. I have a real bad feeling that the United States has slipped into the abyss, and there is no return.. I probably will never return to the country of my birth, as I feel that it isn't the place I would want to live or raise a family in. Too much ignorance and superstition in the government today and religion is very much a part of all this.

Just this old Chief's 2 cents



This was a superb article

This was a superb article about a terrifying situation that has not come about overnight. One of the problems is that the military is still terribly lacking in social services. Once you enter the military, you are pretty much on your own, and when something bad happens—you can't pay your bills, your kids are dropping out of school, you're freaking out from stress—there is no one there but Christian fundamentalist churches and their pastors. This has been going on for decades—the church is now the greatest social force in the military, and fundamentalist churches are totally aggressive at getting to the men and women in it.



Mr. Weinstein, keep up the

Mr. Weinstein, keep up the good work.

Dave in Columbia, MO



As a military family member

As a military family member whose husband is retired, I am grateful for Mikey Weinstein's fight to keep the military sane and protect the powerless. Those who threaten him and his family members and commit acts of violence against them are cowards. If these cowards do succeed in silencing him, America is doomed. Therefore, I wish health and long life to him and his family.



I say, let all the

I say, let all the extremists fight it to the death: Christians, Muslims, Jews. We should supply them FREE weapons and help them fight one another, keeping our fingers crossed. As they kill each other, we will have a world dominated by the THINKING people and hopefully the manufacturers of bigotry, rationality and humanity vanish from the face of the power structure, if not the earth..... Kudos to Mr. Weinstein.

If we do not demilitarize exterminate the extremist from the power structure, we are going to self-destruct very quickly, especially as we keep blundering politically, militarily, educationally and financially.



Good idea Matt putting up a

Good idea Matt putting up a picture of all of Mikey's family. That way all those space cases will know who to kill. I'm guessing that you did that on purpose?



A fruitful area for Mikey &

A fruitful area for Mikey & MRFF to explore is the nexus of this Christian-fascist politics and the rampant network marketing at service posts. In my two years at Hood I lost count of the number of times I was invited into an Amway scheme by someone who also held these right-wing views. The overlap was total -- and the history of Amway is riddled with fundamentalist causes. Jay Van Andel and Rich DeVos are like Fred Koch and Robert Welch. The pressure for religious conformity is one of the reasons I eventually left active duty; I was tired of getting it from my First Sergeant.



Mickey Weinstein is on

Mickey Weinstein is on Truthout's board of directors?! Yeshua! With an attitude such as his, it's no great wonder that Truthout is as weebly rightwingy as it is, cuz Truthout ain't no lefty place, this is for sure.

"NO to murder, YES to killing," the outline declared, because the soldier was god's "angel of wrath," punishing evil.

And this is what? a revelation? an epiphany? Militaries have always laid claim to God as 'angels of wrath' and 'punishing evil.' No greater Lie & Scam has existed, except maybe the divine right of kings, and that capitalism is a good thing.



Check this out

Check this out



A hero with most of his

A hero with most of his family standing strong right with him. An enviable place to be. As a person who regularly attends non programmed Quaker services,, articles such as this are rare jewels of inspirational medicine,, giving me hope for the future of our country.
The Native American had an expression;
"Measure a man by the strength of his enemy."
Mr. Weistein has chosen an ignorant but powerful opponent,, and I wish him wellness and safety in his worthy struggle. Bravo. Were just an eighth of our nation as wise as Mr.Weinstein, there might be an America to believe in once again.



Excellent. I am reminded of

Excellent. I am reminded of the anti-Semitism in my undergraduate school in 1959. A roommate of a Jewish friend of mine asked to feel his head, swearing he must have had his horns surgically removed. My friend was from Brooklyn, the roommate was from some town in Pennsylvania...not Georgia or Alabama. Have we advanced much further?



OSG~~~~(Oh somebody's god.)

OSG~~~~(Oh somebody's god.)



a hero. a real, all-American

a hero. a real, all-American hero.



It is a high degree of alarm

It is a high degree of alarm that such retromingently thinking fools, who obviously have not a lick of knowledge about what and how empty what they so fiercely 'believe', are in positions that could eventually create catastrophic disaster of unimaginable proportions that will make all life suffer for their insanity. This just has to be a part of extinction that is hardwired to bring an end to humans as it is definitely NOT a healthy way of faith, thinking, ideology or life in general. Also absolute proof that the 'organized' religious idea of a god is WRONG.

Note: retromingent is defined as an animal that pisses backwards.



I'm a recovering

I'm a recovering Christian. The hypocrisy amongst religious zealots no longer astounds me.



I really wish these nuts

I really wish these nuts would read their own Bibles, and without the study guide.

Every Biblical description of the origin and nature of the Anti-Christ state that he will come from the extremist right-wing of Christianity. The meaning of the term, Anti-Christ, is not that he would be a mirror opposite of Christ, but one who appears to be what the extremists imagine Christ to be, but is not with God and Christ.

The Anti-Christ would be a Billy Graham type, not a Mikey or a Hitler (not to compare Mikey with Hitler).

Christ is named The Way, The Truth, and the Light. The extreme right is not the way, it is against the truth, and it brings only darkness in the soul and the world.

All of this is not to say that I follow either left or right Christianity, I not guided by man this way, but I believe that there should be more direct Biblical confrontation of the hypocrisies of the false prophets and their minions, who are known as the "Christian Right."



Dobson, Campus Crusade et

Dobson, Campus Crusade et al: Fuck You. America is not your personal religion. it is the land of the free, not the land of the evangelical. GTFO.



I like the idea of a

I like the idea of a religious fanatic cage match. Give them melee weapons and put them in an arena together. Include anyone who is willing to die for the belief that their god is good and makes them righteous and superior to anyone who disagrees with them. The rest of us can watch in horror as they act out their primitive urges and desires. Include all the chickenhawk propagandists who whip the weak-minded into a xenophobic frenzy.



May his efforts be in

May his efforts be in vain.

I would see Western society return to the set of values that drove it to establish itself as the dominant force in the world. This Mikey fellow, and those who applaud his efforts, stand in the way. It is my fond hope that the pipe-dream ideals of the modern "progressive" crowd are swept away. I would see them stymied at every turn and their most strenuous endeavors come to naught.

The West will not survive the coming collision with other more dynamic cultures armed with the sort of cultural cohesion that Islam and China possess. Once upon a time, we could boast of the collective willpower, emotional fortitude, and societal unity of purpose to successfully oppose the enemies of our culture, but I believe the "Enlightenment" killed all that, and I would turn back the clock if I could find the means.

A common religion is a necessary part of the set of shared values and cultural touchstones essential to a strong societal identity. I don't care to see it--or any traditional Western cultural institution--actively torn down and cast aside in the name of a nebulous equaltiy by pseudointellectual, anti-religious zealots, however well-intentioned.

I believe that they are, in the long run, only cutting their own throats, deepening division and sowing intracultural conflict, ultimately weakening Western culture so that it will wither all the faster in the face of the eventual onslaught of Islam or the East. And so our culture will die, and our daughters be consigned to to the burqa or footbinding.

May the left side of the culture war come to rue the day they, blinded by their short-sighted, selfish, and ignorant zeal, destroyed the Faith of the West.



Thank you Mr. Weinstein for

Thank you Mr. Weinstein for all the work you do. This country needs more people like you.



These morons are preaching

These morons are preaching hieresy they don't know what their religion is about. So, maybe we should ask them Who would JESUS HATE! The only time in the new testament he showed outright anger was to go after the religious leaders that should have enough sense to know better. They with a preconceived political opinion. Then try to twist scripture beyond recognition to fit it.



Instead of bearing spiritual

Instead of bearing spiritual fruit christians are becoming religious nuts



Thanks Mikey, I am a Black

Thanks Mikey,

I am a Black Man who spent 24 years both active and reserves in the U.S. Navy. Believe me when I say that the U.S. Army and the U.S. Air Force do not have a monopoly on the religious & social neanderthals that you so aptly describe in your article. I was never so disappointed as I was when I arrived in Vietnam to discover the truths that you espouse in your article and it was not until I adopted and internalized the creed that I live my life by today that I found and got respect from the sick bastards who profess so loudly to be "proud ameriKKKans" and that creed is "You respect my shit, I'll respect your shit and there will be detante-if you don't then we will move to the next level!"

A Retired Combat Action Navy Veteran



do christians ever stop to

do christians ever stop to read most that all the testimony of the resurrections is by women, or only 1st-named persons--like that doesn't go to court? & they don't give women any rights, but try to enslave them??



Dear Mr Weinstein, you may

Dear Mr Weinstein, you may (as the article suggests) be an asshole, but you are OUR asshole and I am deeply grateful you are there and doing the vital work you do. Keep shining the light of truth on the batshit crazy religious fascists.

As soon as I can afford it, I'll be donating to MRFF. Regularly. I urge others congratulating you to speak with their dollars as well as with their keyboards.



The suggestion that society

The suggestion that society requires a self-destructive ideology to grow and sustain does clearly contradict itself.



To charles and maheanuu, I

To charles and maheanuu,
I just retired after 25 years in the military. As an atheist the entire time and as I requested, my ceremony specifically did not have a Chaplain and my beliefs were respected by very religious senior members of my command (who I consider friends) . So there is hope for us and for the military.

The nutjobs that Mikey fights are not all pervasive, but just as wacko as Fred Phelps and the Westboro Baptist Church. Evil exists, you just have to recognize it, and expose it in the light of day if you discover it, then squash it like a cockroach. I have seen examples of the kinds of things described, but fortunately for me, I haven't had to personally fight like Mikey. Throughout my career, I have been vocal on my belief that the military is secular, with all peoples belief systems respected, even ones you didn't personally agree with, unless they themselves didn't play well with others, then the gloves COME OFF! I fully support MRFF.



Thank you Mikey Weinstein, a

Thank you Mikey Weinstein, a real hero, hopefully never to become a martyr. I won't even bother listing all the disturbing shit I heard from the mouths of chaplains and religious soldiers when I served... and it seemed like the Air Force, the whitest and most elite branch, had far more of a Xtian supremacist culture than the relatively diverse Army wherein I served. A lot of soldiers were told and some actually believed that the "anti-christ" would be a muslim leader from the middle east around the year 2000. A fellow soldier said it best: "chaplains' job is to tell us what we are doing is the right thing when we all know killing for oil is wrong." It is not hyperbole to say that the mainstream Iraqi clerics I met in 2003 are religious moderates compared to pro-war US christian leaders. CNN will never tell you there are Iraqi clerics preaching peace because it would spoil their whole war-rationale narrative.



I am in awe of brave people

I am in awe of brave people like Mr. Weinstein who sacrifices so much for the principles that shouldn't even be in question. Maybe we need to amend the Constitution and clarify once and for all that: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof" means SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE. Anyone working in government, no matter what position, should be fired if religion is EVER mentioned. I don't even know why they even have chaplains, why not just secular advisors?



I might add, the Navigators

I might add, the Navigators helped start the Crusade, and print the majority of its manuals and does a lot of training for this, too.

It's even more destructive, they have had suicides and military oppose orders sine the 1970's, too.

We were told we were military too, God's Army to take back the US using the military and campus to do it, eventually by force.



The American Public doesn't

The American Public doesn't have any clue how incredibly dangerous and violent this faction is. And, it's very large, and they're very bloodthirsty. They want a civil war - and they'll stop at nothing to make it happen.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkKEBsr1Yho

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fc8XS-PxFFA



MRFF is a brave and

MRFF is a brave and necessary organization, but should take it to the ultimate solution, which is to oppose the entire US military as it is currently configured and used. Why? Because the US military is an organization committing war crimes of occupation and invasion, torture and murder, worldwide, and long has been. I would content that almost everyone in the military is attracted to violence and believes in US imperialism.



Nineveh better watch it's

Nineveh better watch it's back.



Seems to me that Obama and

Seems to me that Obama and the Demorcats need to put basic moral and constitutional education in the military top on their urgent list. It might well balance the pressure placed on unwilling soldiers who haven't the necessary arguments to stop the evangelists.
Thank you for this article.



This is an excellent article

This is an excellent article -- with one exception. The comparison of right-wing Christians to mosquitoes undermines the piece. Dehumanizing language -- comparing human beings to vermin or disease -- is unacceptable regardless of speaker, audience or context.

I direct this observation also to a couple of other commenters above.



Wow. I read this hoping that

Wow. I read this hoping that Mikey Weinstein isn't complicit in treason for his involvement in the IranContra crime. This article that praises the man's moral victory should have also examined the man's past moral failures. While I feel that the MRFF's efforts are all too praiseworthy, history has already shown us that Regan and the rest of his criminal administration (many future neocons) escaping justice for their treasonous acts was the nail in the american coffin. When Nixon was caught red handed, he resigned. When Regan was caught committing a far greater crime, they just stuck to the lie and they won and proved that the american people would never again have a say in their country.

So, how about it Mikey Weinstein? Did you think up the "I don't recall" defense? Maybe not. Maybe you navigated the mess as morally as possible. One would like to hope so based on your actions now, but as I contemplate sending you money to help with your noble cause, I can't help but wonder your complicity in one of the most serious crimes against the american people in modern times. Maybe the next interview?



To the anonymous person

To the anonymous person expressed the hope that efforts of people like Mikey would fail: I and other progressives are NOT devoid of a unifying belief system, and are in no need of adopting a system of belief that excludes so many. We progressives of sincere heart are ready to unite and take up arms for our country, too. We have, in our favor, no aversion to people who may have been raised up in a religious tradition different from ours, yet who acknowledge our common humanity, common decency, and common imperfect knowledge of ultimate destiny. In this there is strength.



This guy is an ass. He

This guy is an ass. He should be worried about Muslims and Islam. Not Jesus and Christians. Jesus is about peace and came to offer himself for mankind. Why is everyone so afraid of that??? Islam on the other hand is a hateful religion, bent on destroying those who don't become Muslim.

He's picking a fight with God not Christians. In the end he forfeits his soul.



Thanks for your good work,

Thanks for your good work, Mr. Weinstein, and the selfless sacrifices you and your family are making to fight these fundamentalist tyrants. Those right-wing "Christians" are the scourge of our country and will do all they can to enforce their beliefs on the rest of us.



Those of you who think Mr.

Those of you who think Mr. Weinstein is doing good work may want to consider making a financial contribution to his organization.

Putting my money where Mikey's mouth is makes me feel as if I'm helping, in a small way, combat stupidity and intolerance.



Who is any man to tell

Who is any man to tell others what their god is, when the nature of any god is to be greater than any man? Let the fools think there is a god in the sky and below thier feet: Logic, reason, and war will sort them out later.

But, by all means, if one attacks you..... attack him back twice as deftly. If he attacks your family, kill his. Let no score go unsettled.



Checked with my brother, a

Checked with my brother, a retired Air Force officer and a consultant at the Academy, as well as other military installations. His take is that this guy is a loon and a lone troublemaker who sees boojums where there are none.

My brother is about as far from a Christian nut as possible, and has no sympathy for any religious movement that would seek to disenfranchise anyone or to "take over" the military that he has served in for decades and still serves. BTW, he is a practicing attorney and has defended the civil rights of enlisted military personnel.

As a practicing journalist, I find this article to be inflammatory and unprofessional propaganda. Those of you reading this might want to get a second, and probably a third opinion, so you can get closer to the truth. Don't rely on Mr. Harwood to tell you what to think, or how to think it. Think for yourself.



Re: Checked with my brother,

Re: Checked with my brother, a

As a so-called journalist you offer no facts or proof of events, just opinion.

I think it is very obvious you are not a journalist and represent only a single view, or maybe you are just a Jesus-nut.

Just because your brother thinks something, does not make it so.



Thanks for publishing this

Thanks for publishing this great article. I didn't know this struggle actually had someone with clout fighting the good fight.

For anyone like me wanting to donate, I found the Paypal button here: http://www.militaryreligiousfreedom.org/support-mrff/make-a-donation/



It is not just religion that

It is not just religion that is the problem it is also politics. The military gives democrats a really hard time. My son is a democrat and he has exactly ONE COMMANDING OFFICER that is a democrat. The rest are anti Obama, anti liberal and give democrats hell. They are suppose to be an army of ONE but this is not true at all.
Republicans are not only dividing our country they have taken over our military and use it to pick on anyone that does not beleive as they do.



Kudos to Mikey Weinstein; we

Kudos to Mikey Weinstein; we need more men like this standing up for what is right, even in the face of danger.



Eh... yawn.. "Jesus Rifles"?

Eh... yawn.. "Jesus Rifles"? You do know that not everyone who shot ACOGs even knew they were on there and the military didn't even know that either? Hell, Trijicon salesmaen didn't even know it when I asked them about it.

Again... yawn. You're "victories" have come because of Obama's in office and nothing else. Sorry but this is still a Christian nation. The military is predominately right wing and yet... apolitical. Don't take preference as bashing... sorry if we don't all agree its what makes us a great place to live.



I truly have respect for

I truly have respect for Mickey. I don't think I have the courage or patience to do what he's doing. Personally I refuse to treat people that are racist, bigots, and generally ignorant people as proper human beings. It makes me sad that these people have a right to vote. That's why I like living in the Northeast, especially in a diverse city like New York City. Where any and everyone is excepted. That sort of openness makes me all tingly inside. I sincerely hope that Mickey prevails in his battle, and gets some decent security. Death threats and the like are just ridiculous.



Continue to shine the light

Continue to shine the light into these crevasses and cracks in which this stuff hides. Continue to use The Constitution and the Rule of Law to insure the separation of church and state.

These supremacists are anything but.

They claim to know Jesus, but what is it that they really know? Not much...



While I completely disagree

While I completely disagree with Mr. Weinstein (and the attitude of this article towards Christians), I do sincerely apologize for the horrible statements and threats that have been made against him. I am deeply troubled that anyone would say such things, regardless of how deeply they disagree with another person. Offensive comments and threats are not Christian in any way, shape, or form and do not accurately reflect true Christianity.



Go Mikey. I'm a USMC combat

Go Mikey. I'm a USMC combat vet of OIF, who is one of the ones who joined the military with a fervent gung-ho kill everything, hate the enemy attitude, on top of being raised very religious. And it was by experience alone that I was shocked into realizing the deeply woven fabric of lies and horror that is our military and the christian religion. The shock of realizing your entire moral fabric is torn beneath you and rebuilding from the ground up has been difficult, but also quite enlightening. When you have an open mind not closed off by bigotry and hate, you can see the world in a different way. Religion to me is the anti-thesis of logic and reason. I think it can be summed up well by the title of Christopher Hitchen's book: God is not great: How religion poisons everything. The problem I run into is that there are so many who blindly follow religion and flail out in anger at the slightest hint of reproach, that I often despair at there ever being a possibility for us to claw our way out of what I still consider the dark ages. People like Mikey are the ones who give others hope in America, but more importantly humanity.



Thank God for people like

Thank God for people like Mickey who are not afraid to take a stand. As a person who grew up in Right Wing Central, i.e. Colorado Springs, I believe that there is a Christian Fundamentalist Fascist extreme that threatens our freedom of religion. I chose to move away from Colorado to escape this lunatic fringe. We need to all support MRFF and others who are fighting to protect separation of Church and State. Freedom to believe as we choose is a fundamental human right. The comparison to Nazis is very apropos. The danger with Nazism and Fascism is that they eventually gained control of Germany and Italy by means of fear and intimidation. The same fear and intimidation tactics are being experienced today in our military and we need to fight back.



Very well said, Marine

Very well said, Marine Oorah! Oorah!



If we had only 10,000 more

If we had only 10,000 more guys like Mikey, the Christian right would be buried. Most of the right wing cowards resort to email threats because that's the sort of folks they are -- piss faced cowards to the core. Thanks to Mikey for all his great work.



ALL FUNDALISM IS BAD!!! The

ALL FUNDALISM IS BAD!!!

The solemn collects of Good Friday include prayers for “those who in the name of Christ have persecuted others” that “God will open their hearts to the truth, and lead them to faith and obedience.” We like to tell ourselves that Christians killing in Christ’s name is a relic of the Middle Ages. Sadly, this continues right up to today, to the tune of $660 million in US military contracts. http://www.sevenwholedays.org/2010/01/18/killing-in-the-name-of-jesus/

How American Evangelicals are Killing Gay People in Africa - http://gayrights.change.org/blog/view/how_american_evangelicals_are_killing_gay_people_in_africa

"The United States of America should have a foundation free from the influence of clergy."
~ George Washington

"Millions of innocent men, women and children, since the introduction of Christianity, have been burnt, tortured, fined, imprisoned; yet we have not advanced one inch towards uniformity. What has been the effect of coercion? To make half the world fools, and the other half hypocrites."
~ Thomas Jefferson

Imagine If All Atheists Left America - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mbef07aQtB8



It was my rare privilege to

It was my rare privilege to interview Mikey Weinstein for an article in Subversify Magazine a few months back. As much as I didn't want to believe the research I'd done prior to the interview, it became apparent to me that the MRFF was not only necessary, but vital to turning the tide against militant Christianity in America.

That there are several sites (christianfighterpilot.com; others) which are almost-completely devoted to 'debunking' Mikey's research and trashing his reputation only reaffirms to me that he's doing the right thing.

When the final history of this era is written, Mikey will be owed a debt of gratitude by all Americans - who, by then, will hopefully be living in a genuine social democracy where genuine freedom - including the freedom from religion - is once again guaranteed.

"Who Teacheth My Hands To War" - Christian Fundamentalism in the American Military" - Subversify Magazine; February - 2010

(Podcast of Weinstein interview - Subversify Radio; February - 2010)



This is all true. A great

This is all true. A great deal of this information came out several years ago. And I write to servicemen and women monthly. And off and on I get a letter about this same subject.

Some of the units in Iraq and all over the middle east have christian flags. And there havebeen interviews with CO's that have said outright that they"expect all of their men to be right with god." And from what has been written to me, if you don't go to a religious service, or don't pray, pressure is put upon you. And there is no way to avoid it when it comes down from the top.

In the part of the world where they remember the crusades where Christians slaughtered Muslims the sight of a Christian flag flown by soldiers occupying their countries is an insult and a red flag.

This is not what we are supposed to be doing. It is no more correct then the wars or the occupation of country's. And no more fitting then forcing our own brand of government on people that not only do not want us there, but do not want our interference in their lives. So called nation building by bullets.

We owe this man all the support we can give him. All the support that our own corrupt government will not give. All the support that our constitution gives. Separation of church and state. The reason is plain.

When you see all the country's around the world that place their own religion as the base of everything, you find fundamentalism. Look around at the punishing fundamentalism of the middle east. We have been able to avoid that problem because of our constitution. Now there are forces working in the government and the military that are trying to tear down the very fabric of this law.

We are a religious country. But we are not a christian country. There are too many different religions here to place one ahead of all the others. It is a matter of privacy for each one of us. And not something to be forced on any of us. And the military is the last place to turn loose upon the unwary soldier by his superior officers the pressure and dogma of religion.

Let's hope this man and this organization survive.



I am a Christian and a

I am a Christian and a republican. How am I any less entitled to my beliefs than you agnostics are to yours? I am deeply offended that you readers would seek to "bury the Christian right." I would never seek to bury anyone, rather, I would hope and have pray that people of all religions can peacefully co-exist without attacking one another. There is nothing wrong with Christianity. Mind you, this country would never have existed without it. How dare you judge any person who stands and fights for our country just because of their religion? Do you have the same contempt for Muslims extremists? Oh wait, that's right, they are untouchable.



Christianity and all

Christianity and all religions will be the death o this planet eventually. What people do in the name (fill in the blank) is not God's plan at all but leave it to man to twist it into a shape or verse that was never meant or written. I've lived for 49 years, I've been Christian, Wiccan, Shaman and I have to say, I will NEVER go back to being a Christian. It's a cancer on this earth and I hope that one day it's extinguished by God himself and admits that he made a mistake making it happen.

Say what you want about me.. I really could care less. I find this article just one more for the mount to bring up in the end of days. These are tyrannical, fucked up people with their souls owned more by Satan than God. I mean really. They will Kill but not Murder.. for fucks sake, it's the same god damned thing any way you look at it. In the name of God?? Uh.. OK... what ever ... my God does not kill, does not hate and does not pick this group over the other to reside in "heaven" We are all his children, pure and simple. We are all perfect in our ways regardless of our religious beliefs, our skin color, our sexual orientation or anything else that might come up.... folks need to get their ego and their self righteous attitude out of the equation and really look at this mess in our military and this needs to be put down like an old mare that can't walk any more....



I am proud that Mikey

I am proud that Mikey Weinstein and his family call me "friend" and "Brother"[despite the "blue zoomie connection" ... for about a week a year only his Father and I are friends] ... I have followed Mikey and MRFF almost from it's inception, having had somewhat similar experiences at Canoe U., although only on a very limited personal level and never on an organizational level, and somewhat more on an organizational level after commissioning in the USAF. Mikey and the MRFF are the only ones to whom members of our military can appeal and have ANY expectation of support. I would hope that all who understand this fight is not against Christianity, but against religious bigotry and the radical evangelical "amerikan taliban" dominionists who desire nothing less than a U.S. theocracy of a rabid, fundamental, evangelical christianity, will not only support them vocally, but financially ! PUT YOUR MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS AND REALLY SUPPORT THE TROOPS AND THE CONSTITUTION !



Support MRFF, but don't

Support MRFF, but don't support the troops or the US war machine!! It is troubling to see so many pro-military people posting on a progressive website, and so few progressives stating the obvious fact that anyone who volunteers to serve in the US military is attracted to death, imperialism, blood money, bullying, dominance and also directly or indirectly commits war crimes. Christian nutcases or not, people in the US military illegally invade and occupy small countries to further the goals of corporations, hegemony and the empire. This is a volunteer military, and the soldiers are complicit in torture and other atrocities. All you "proud" soldiers...you really ought to obtain a conscience!



Take it to the

Take it to the Christo-fascists, Mickey!

Christianity is the most Janus-faced religion in the world. It sanctimoniously pretends to be all about "peace" and "loving your neighbor". But look at the true historical record of this religion: Crusades, Inquisitions, "witch" burnings, the conquest of the New World and genocide against its peoples, justification of slavery, today's Right Wing, etc. etc. This was the religion of the Roman Empire, starting with Constantine, and it's now the religion of the would-be contemporary equivalent, the U.S.

Christianity is based on myths and absolutism much more than it is on ethical principles--that's why it always is corrupted. All you have to do in the end is "buh-leeve"--it doesn't really matter whether you've supported an evil status quo, acted selfishly your whole life, and voted Republican. You're still "saved" if you just "buh-leeve" in the fairy tales, the evidence for which is so shockingly absent that it amounts to the greatest hoax ever perpetrated upon humanity. No one would "buh-leeve" this stuff based on the evidence alone; it's all about cultural momentum, brainwashing, delusion, conformity, and fear of death/"damnation". Islam depends upon precisely the same BS strategies. The very presence of these delusional religions can't but lower your opinion of humanity.

As Dostoesvky noted long ago, what makes Christianity work is the *absence* of Christ, creating a vacuum that evil charlatans from the Catholic Church to Ted Haggard and beyond have been only too willing to fill.

Again: Take it to 'em, Mickey!



I found the article very

I found the article very interesting and alarming, but I'm concerned that the author's tone is not objective. I can't imagine sending this article to someone who didn't already agree with the stance presented. Harwood makes it too easy for others to disregard his work because, even though he's written a compelling, well-researched piece, his prose is editorial. When the facts speak for themselves, it's better to just let them.



This is a great article and

This is a great article and excellently highlights just how insane the Christian fundamentalists have become.

As an ex-serviceman who fought in the first Gulf war I can say that we need more Mikey's out there to fight these loons.

What the christians do not realize is that they are viewed "exactly" by the rest of the world as we view "islamic fundamentalists", issuing their fatwahs and filling late night televisions and the airwaves with constant hate-speech and apocalyptic proclamations where they and they alone are swept up to some heaven full of earth gold while relishing in their ideas that the rest of humanity will be writhing in fire as they are having a party. It is somewhat sick and degenerate to think that these people honestly believe this.

In the service I did notice some of this but luckily my unit didn't have hardcore nutjobs in it, it would not have gone over well with me if there had been.

Cheers and keep up the good work!



Re: The reference to Leo

Re: The reference to Leo Frank ... "murdered by vigilantes for the murder of a 13-year-old girl many believe he didn't commit." I lived in Atlanta during the 1980s when a black janitor who worked in the factory confessed to murdering the girl. Leo Frank was lynched and was an innocent man.



"May his efforts be in

"May his efforts be in vain."

Oh STFU!! I love the way you put your message in the form of a prayer. What a joke you are. Take yourself and your little god and go live on an island in the Bermuda Triangle. I hope you get to heaven soon.



Can someone smart out there

Can someone smart out there write a story correlating these crazies with the folk that the Christian Zionists that the Rolex Republican Jews all think are their best friends?

Are these the same people?



I CHECKED WITH MY MOTHER...

I CHECKED WITH MY MOTHER... and she told me you're a religious nut.

"Checked with my brother, a retired Air Force officer and a consultant at the Academy, as well as other military installations. His take is that this guy is a loon and a lone troublemaker who sees boojums where there are none."



Religion has been used to

Religion has been used to motivate and inspire armies throughout history. As a veteran, I did not see any of what this articles speaks of but I served back in the seventies. Things were very different then. I was very different then. I am a lifetime member of Freedom From Religion Foundation and wish you the best in this endeavor.



We don't like your dirty

We don't like your dirty atheists, who try to force their evil, devoid of love, compassion, common sense, logic, hate filled, paranoid atheists.

I support Christian Crusaders and their attempts to balance world peace against other extremists groups. The Christian World has always been there for everyone to render assistance and support. The Old Christians had a sense of duty and honor, not like the dirty atheists, who think they can kill a theology and kill an ideology.
King David's Tribe still rules! Jesus Christs' kin are NOT the Church, but we are there for world peace and mutual aid for those in need.
There is more in the spiritual teachings, the gnostics know of to save life and propagate wisdom. The atheists, Muslims, and Jews, and even the Celtic Wiccans were ignorant about many fine details. King David Rules.
-A Member of King David's Tribe



Wow, some of you nutty

Wow, some of you nutty Christian fundamentalist wackjobs are so backwards it's embarrassing.



I grew up a fundy baptist

I grew up a fundy baptist and all I can say is God Bless Mikey Weinstein and the MRFF. The current attitude among christian conservatives of refusing to accept or respect the beliefs of others, even those of us who believe in Christ as savior and lord, terrifies me. We are NOT a conservative christian nation, we are populated by every creed and belief and have been from the beginning.
And to those members of the Radical Religious Right who think they are so superior to the rest of us; I'd like to send you all on a little time warp to the 15th century. I'm sure you and Tourquemada would get along just fine.



Thank you "Mikey" and family

Thank you "Mikey" and family for your perseverance to expose the "evil" sect(s) of Christianity which wish to establish a "new world order" using the United States Military for their nefarious vision.

As an Air Force officer, I fully support your efforts to eradicate this infection from our ranks.



And some of us thought Islam

And some of us thought Islam was the only threat to our country .... If those fundamentalists take over, we will be a western hemisphere version of Iran.



I am an

I am an atheist/agnostic/philosopher living in Seattle, Washington writing to say two things.

First, thank you for publishing this article. We need to pay attention to the spread of Christian supremacism, those who want to kill in Jesus' name and who dream of a coup d'etat, those who have openly proclaimed their intentions to launch a civil war as soon as they think they can succeed. This is something most peaceful, compassionate people - including many Christians - simply cannot believe unless articles like this shine a light on this horrible truth.

Second, to some of my fellow posters I urge you to avoid doing exactly what you're afraid of. I urge you to avoid behaving like bigots yourselves.

Christianity, like most religions, encompasses a wide range of behaviors. To attack Christianity itself, to lump all Christians in together as dangerous and violent, is an act of indefensible bigotry.

Likewise, Christian fundamentalism also includes a wide range of behaviors. I personally know over a dozen Christian fundamentalists who are very good people, gentle, ethical, compassionate, intelligent, creative, and open-minded. I also know Christian fundamentalists who are pro-military, who serve in the military, but who would neither violate the separation of church and state nor tolerate it happening around them.

If that seems impossible - if you can't imagine how a Christian fundamentalist can be open-minded, if you believe it's a contradiction in terms - that's because you are prejudging individual people based on the faulty categories you're trying to lump them into. The certainty you feel that you know what all Christians or Christian fundamentalists are like, the disbelief and irritation you feel at what I am saying is precisely the same feeling bigots feel when you try to tell them that black people are just as good as white people, that women are just as good as men, that atheists can be just as moral as theists. That rage and resentment toward Christian fundamentalists is also bigotry. You are trying to reason your way to the truth rather than let actual, living, breathing people speak for themselves and demonstrate their worth as individuals.

It is important that those who engage in criminal behavior be held accountable for it, but it is even more important that those who do not engage in criminal behavior not be blamed for behavior they did not engage in and do not condone. That is a requirement for any person who claims to be civilized, to be just. To lump all Christians together or all Christian fundamentalists together and to blame all of them for the actions of a few is an act of intellectual barbarism. It must not be tolerated any more than we tolerate prejudice against Jews, Muslims, gays, or anyone else.

Again, I write these things not as a Christian - I'm not and never have been - but as a philosopher who respects people of every religion when they behave ethically, humanely, and will not stand by and see them slandered as a group, no matter how well-meaning or otherwise good the people are who do the slandering.

At a time when we are looking at a serious threat to the fundamental political and religious architecture of our nation, the last thing in the world we should be doing is fighting amongst ourselves out of reflexive unconscious prejudice. If we stand for anything, it's for doing better than that.



1. The United States

1. The United States Constitution is the highest law of this nation. God and Christianity have no official role in it, including its founding. The Enlightenment, which managed to escape religion's failings, is most responsible for giving birth to our form of government and the nation.

2. For those of you so afraid of modernity and so petrified by the miraculous cross-section of Americans of all kinds and creeds, your religion is yours but it is not the nation's or world's and never will be, nor should be. Religion doesn't bind a nation together, it ultimately sets people against each other.

3. Mikey Weinstein and his family, and organization, are doing sacred work that the biblical Jesus would be proud of, defending people from self-righteous phony religionists who bully and abuse innocent people in the name of real religion. The military's Christian Supremacists are just intoxicated with their weaponry and special status within society. They are taking advantage of the nation more than they are defending it.



From the wife of a Muslim

From the wife of a Muslim soldier--thank you.



As a hot-blooded,

As a hot-blooded, peace-freak, die-hard, excessively-hyphenating Unitarian Universalist, I must be the OPPOSITE politically of Mikey (I am a democrat, anti-war, "Che T-shirt wearing armchair revolutionary"?), yet I have more in common with him than with any creature (it's hard to think of them as people) who would order underlings to kill for Jesus. Thanks, needful things, for sending me to Wiktkonary to look up retromingent! Secondary meaning is "cowardly". Mikey needs the support of good Americans (i.e., those who don't hide behind phony religion); he has put his life on the line. Do check out the Military Religious Freedom Foundation. Kudos to TruthOut, once again coming down on the side of the good guys!



@Rick: "I personally know

@Rick: "I personally know over a dozen Christian fundamentalists who are very good people, gentle, ethical, compassionate, intelligent, creative, and open-minded."

Rick, if they're Christian fundamentalists, they think you're going to hell. They are neither gentle nor compassionate. Chatting amiably with you doesn't make them so.



Mikey no longer goes this

Mikey no longer goes this alone, since everyone who has been victimized by the Dominionist Christian extremism has stories to tell. He has led the charge in the most public of ways, but we are all coming together to stand against this force that wants to rule the world, save all the world's resources unto themselves, and rid the world of "sinner" meaning anyone who does not believe their way. They assert we stand betwen them and Jesus' return - which, if you believe that, shows scant faith in God or Jesus. Whether it is our troops, Muslims (the BIG target worldwide), mainline faith people, GLBT people, women exercising conscience on their own reproductive care, or any other "unacceptable" thing, we need to support one another. And that means secular progressives MUST include faith progressives and stop fearing that we are just "Pat Robertson Lite" because we are not. The solidarity of the Civil Rights and anti-war movements rested on this coalition. It must be reorganized and be respectful or, indeed, Mikey will go it alone. And that is not good.



Many TX Mike! As the only

Many TX Mike! As the only Jew in my Navy boot camp company back in Orlando, FL in 1980 I remember that s**t very well. I NEVER changed my religious preference on my dog tags and spent my full time in fending off the enemies who called me a Christ Killer. I got out and realized I spent my entire time in service to my country under "friendly fire."



And the Multinational

And the Multinational oligarch said to his pet politician; "Make the next war a very holy war!" The military is FILLED with self-deluded, muddled but useful idiots.



Why doesn't the author learn

Why doesn't the author learn something about the Illuminati before labeling EVERYTHING Ammerman believes in as "batshit crazy"?

As one other person wrote, Harwood's polemics detract from the strength of this piece.