Ordinary Workers Would Be Fired in a Second If They Screwed Up Anywhere Nearly as Bad as the Bankers Have

by: Dean Baker  |  AlterNet

There has been little change in personnel and no acknowledgment of error at the central banks whose incompetence was responsible for the crisis.

The world is suffering from the worst downturn since the Great Depression. The crisis has left tens of millions unemployed in the U.S., Europe, and elsewhere. The huge baby boomer generation in the United States, now on the edge of retirement, has seen much of its wealth destroyed with the collapse of the housing bubble.

It would be difficult to imagine a worse economic disaster. Prior periods of bad performance, like the inflation ridden seventies, look like mild flurries compared to the blizzard of bad economic news in which we are now enmeshed.

None of this is new. People don't need economists to tell them that times are bad. However, what the public may not recognize is that the same people who caused this disaster are still calling the shots. Specifically, there has been little change in personnel and no acknowledgment of error at the central banks whose incompetence was responsible for the crisis.

Remarkably, this crew of incompetents is still claiming papal infallibility, warning governments and the general public that bad things will happen if they are subjected to more oversight. Instead, the central bankers and their accomplices at the IMF are dictating policies to democratically elected governments. Their agenda seems to be the same everywhere, cut back retirement benefits, reduce public support for health care, weaken unions and make ordinary workers take pay cuts.

Given how much they have messed up, it is amazing that these central bankers have the gall to even show their face in public. They are lucky that they still have jobs -- and very good paying ones at that. (Many of the boys and girls at the IMF can retire with six figure pensions at the age of 50.) Ordinary workers, like teachers, autoworkers, or custodians, would be fired in a second if they performed as badly as the world's central bankers.

What was going through their heads when they saw house prices in the United States, the UK, Spain and elsewhere spiral upward with no basis in any of the fundamentals of the housing market? How did they think this bubble would end; did they think that trillions of dollars of housing bubble wealth could just disappear without any impact on the economy. Or, did they think the bubble would never end and that house prices would just continue to go skyward forever?

How about the central bankers who allowed the euro to be imposed on a mix of economies with very little in common and no controlling governmental organization? Did they think that wages and prices would follow the same pattern in Greece and Germany? If not, what adjustment mechanism did they envision once these widely different economies were tied to together in a single currency?

Yes, many of the central bankers are now saying that they knew the euro was a bad idea back when it was established. Some of them even muttered quietly to this effect. But the central bankers and the IMF in 1998 were not making the same bold pronouncements and issuing the same directives to elected governments about structuring the euro zone that they are now doing in telling them to dismantle their welfare states. In other words, these central bankers failed disastrously -- why do they still have jobs and why on earth is anyone listening to them?

At the top of the list of villains in this story is the IMF. Its ineptitude managed to reverse the fundamental flows of capital in the world economy. In normal times capital is supposed to flow from wealthy countries with large amounts of capital, like the United States and the European countries, to the developing countries who need capital to fuel their development. Due to the failure of the IMF to establish a workable system of international finance, the flows went in the opposite direction in a huge way. The world's poor were sending their capital to the United States because the IMF gave them little choice.

It is important to be clear about the responsibility of the central bankers and the IMF for this totally preventable disaster. The first reason is accountability, something that is very important to economists who believe in economics. Economic theory teaches us that if workers are not held accountable for poor work, then they have no incentive to do their jobs well. If the central banker and IMF crew can mess up disastrously and continue to draw their paychecks as though everything is fine, what is their incentive to do better next time?

The other reason why it is important to recognize the responsibility of the central bankers and the IMF for this disaster is so that we don't continue to take advice from people who apparently don't have a clue. Before anyone listens to Ben Bernanke, European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet, or IMF Managing Director Dominique Strauss-Kahn, they should first be forced to tell us when they stopped being wrong about the economy. We cannot afford to let these subprime central bankers control economic policy any longer.

Dean Baker is co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research and author of the new book, False Profits: Recovering from the Bubble Economy (PoliPointPress, 2010). 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Dean Baker's column hit the

Dean Baker's column hit the nail on the head.
My home has lost 60% of its value. A lifetime of savings is gone.
I am 52 and still employed for now, but probably not for long. I see the job market like a game of musical chairs, with fewer and fewer chairs on which to sit.
Mr. Baker asks why are these guys are still in charge if they failed so badly? Yeah, they failed the country, their fellow citizens, the world, but they made tons of money for themselves and their friends in the short run. That sounds like success to me.
So now they can retire at 50.
Of course, me, you and the rest of us working and unemployed stiffs are paying for it.
Had Democrats voted for real financial reform they would sweep the polls come Novemver. But they really don't work for us do they. The bankers are their true bosses.
Damn them all.



Yep, definitely agree. Why

Yep, definitely agree. Why do they still have their jobs? And what can we do to get them fired & lose their pensions?

I'm still hoping for a move to impeach Bush & Cheney. Why should I & anyone else who pays taxes pay for their pensions & health care?

Ditto for those members of Congress and the members of the Obama administration who, you can be sure, will soon be saying and working towards privatizing Social Security, getting rid of Medicare & Medicaid, Headstart, and any program that doesn't benefit the banksters and other ultra wealthy people.



I CAN BUT DEPRESSEDLY CONCUR

I CAN BUT DEPRESSEDLY CONCUR AS I AM OBLIGED TO LEAVE A CAREhOME AT AGE 85 and attempt to become self reliant, tho most of day abed or in wheelchair. all this the result of Bank ofAmerica's BancoInvest(now Merrilly Lynch 'em) doing nothing to save my meager savings from a 54% loss in one year = $104,000.



I don't understand. The

I don't understand. The banksters are wildly successful and profitable. Haven't they have cornered the "money market?" Who would fire them and why? We might lynch them given the opportunity, but their stockholders have no incentive to fire them. Hell, they even own the government now.



If you don't understand that

If you don't understand that the IMF activities are intentional, designed to rape and pillage, you need to look deeper. Ditto the banks in general. This is NOT incompetence. It is consolidation of power and control of the money stream to accumulate wealth in the hands of the few.

Now they have even more power. Too much to fight. The only solution is alternative systems that don't need the banking system. They are around and in operation and growing.



It's not only the Banks that

It's not only the Banks that have screwed up without taking responsibility. Wake up America, NO ONE takes responsibility for their failures any more. "Teflon" now attaches itself to any and everyone who screws up, yet all the talking heads do is point fingers and place blame. We will never be able to repair some of the damage that has been done to us financially, ecologically, or morally but what I'd like to see is SOMEONE, ANYONE, besides President Obama, take some responsibility for the failures that were set in motion long before HE took office. The previous Administration took no responsibility for it's MONUMENTAL "screw ups", the consequences of which we will be dealing with for generations. Why can't we fix things anymore? I think it's because people are paralyzed by the fear of responsibility itself. I, personally, don't trust people who don't make mistakes. If you don't make mistakes you can't learn to develop alternative methods for dealing with your poor decisions. BP should have SERIOUSLY considered the consequences of "screwing up" when drilling for Oil a mile down in the Gulf of Mexico. Do you think they did? I wonder if they've tried drilling in the English Channel or off the Coast of England or France? No matter, I suppose, but hopefully, they WILL in the future. The arrogance and overconfidence they assumed far out=distanced their abilities and WE will be paying for decades to come.



I knew a long time ago they

I knew a long time ago they were going to pull the plug on baby boomer retirement. Bush was all but screaming it from the rooftop. So I retired early and that has been good for me.



Ordinary Workers Would Be

Ordinary Workers Would Be Fired in a Second If They Screwed Up Anywhere Nearly as Bad as the Bankers Have

Or BP has.... It seems that hiring and firing are class bound. If you belong to the Zeus class, you are safe and other gods you bought will protect you, if you are one of the mortals or seem to given knowledge to the mortals, you become food for the lions or vultures as Prometheus.

Zeus argument: Who said life will be fair. I would say, 95% who are bought and sold as serfs by the corporations are the ones who say it SHOULD BE FAIR....



When will BP (Banker's Pig)

When will BP (Banker's Pig) Obamanible come clean and STOP the LIPSTICK-UP of US all? Probably when the crude-oiled baby heron flies from its BPed nursery marsh. You BET!



The greatest re-distribution

The greatest re-distribution of wealth out of the hands of the middle and lower working classes into the hands of the passive income and investor class, in the history of nations. Dean's got one big thing wrong. It was no mistake. And it's not over yet.



no sh$t! It isn't over,

no sh$t! It isn't over, foreclosures look like they are going to really take off - people are still out of work ---
Can we get the FBI to go after these guys? Look here:
http://www.counterpunch.org/mokhiber03052010.html



Dugan , Summers, Bernanke,

Dugan , Summers, Bernanke, Geithner, etc - fire every one of them. Criminal investigation of GS.....



Baker writes: "What was

Baker writes:

"What was going through their heads when they saw house prices in the United States, the UK, Spain and elsewhere spiral upward with no basis in any of the fundamentals of the housing market? How did they think this bubble would end; did they think that trillions of dollars of housing bubble wealth could just disappear without any impact on the economy. Or, did they think the bubble would never end and that house prices would just continue to go skyward forever?"

We haven't really asked them this yet.



"How did they think this

"How did they think this bubble would end...?" How does any bubble end? The point is they didn't care. They didn't have to. Future damage to their company or country was somebody else's problem, and it still is.



Concurrent with our illegal

Concurrent with our illegal wars, investment banks was engaged in selling shit worldwide - the Fed, has a key role in our war machine, as does Wall Street. That same consuming pariah, less sanitized for millions domestically. Their financial ruin helps the effort and was understood from the beggining.



In a way, one needs to see

In a way, one needs to see the humor in Baker's writing, Do you think the elite in Brazil see themselves as some kind of failure? I mean they are in their fortified castles while millions live in squalor. Big Money has no soul. Housing vanished along with jobs and Obama chides people for "getting in over their heads". He has people like Larry Summers in his adminstration! People should be taking to the streets.



Americans are STILL being

Americans are STILL being ripped off by our government, FEDS giving Goldman and the gang our money at o% and allowing them to give whatever rates they can get....3-4 % is a nice profit on the billions and trillions they are using free. The FEDS give us the same rate0% and then tell us we need to invest in the markets and the Wall Street sharks want us to jump into the pool so they can get the last dime from the tax payer. Both the Congress and the White House KNOW exactly what they are doing...selling us out to become a slave/worker state . The GREED is the most disgusting part of all this HOPE and CHANGE crap.



Fired by who?

Fired by who?



crisis capitalism,, isn't

crisis capitalism,, isn't it great.. we get to rip off everyone, it's free enterprise, we're free to rip off as many of you dummies as we can. you stupid suckers
are great, we can set up a phony monetary system
that makes us rich and you poor, destroy your health, environment and society for profit and you idiots
wonder what's next on the TV.. and if any of you dumb asses get any ideas, we'll just melt your brain from space with micro waves through your cell phone....
go ahead feed my greed..



The situation is very

The situation is very critical. Unfortunately, people are living in a moment that unemployment is high and foreclosures are happening. What's gonna be the solution?

Regards
Tony
http://www.foreclosurelistings.com/



Repent and be saved! The

Repent and be saved! The world is ending day by day because we continue to offend the Lord .