Our Fault, Too
Friday 11 June 2010
by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

(Image: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: Dadmandu, NASA)
There were hearings on Capitol Hill this week regarding the Gulf oil disaster, and virtually everyone involved - from witnesses to experts to government officials - had a grand old time throwing rocks at British Petroleum. The Obama administration and various government agencies have also been taking it in the teeth over their failure to quell the oil boiling up from the bottom of the sea. Beaches are closing, animals are dying, livelihoods are being destroyed, and unbelievable as it may seem, the worst is yet to come. New reports indicate the well may have been releasing oil equivalent to the Exxon Valdez spill every eight to ten days since this whole thing started.
BP is taking the lion's share of the beatings, and justly so. They ran a shoddy operation out there on the Deepwater Horizon, and knew even ten years ago that such operations were incredibly risky. They lied and lied again about the scope of the disaster. They have been attempting to limit press access to the disaster zone to keep people from finding out what is actually going on. Their corporate officers have denied the existence of oil plumes beneath the surface, and have held pity-parties for themselves on television over how trying this whole situation is for them.
This mess is their fault, and the world knows it. Their stock value has cratered, and even the BP shareholders are beginning to revolt. They are going to be sued for God only knows how much money, and will be saddled with the cost of the clean-up, which may take years.
But here is something to remember: it's our fault, too. Yours and mine.
If you own a car, it's your fault. I own a car, so I own a share of the blame. If you own more than one car, or own some gargantuan gas-guzzling SUV, it's your fault. If you ever thought a Humvee was cool, or ever owned one, it's your fault.
If you ever voted in an election based on the high price of gasoline, it's your fault.
If you ever voted for a politician who went on to deregulate the oil industry from their seat in a committee, it's your fault. If you didn't vote to remove that person from office after they voted to deregulate such a dangerous and polluting industry, it's your fault.
If you eat food that is not grown locally, it's your fault, because your food had to be brought to you on the backs of trucks that need gasoline to travel. If you eat food grown on an industrialized farm, it's your fault, because the machines used to cultivate that food need gasoline, too. Even if you eat food that is grown organically and locally, they still use gasoline and oil, so basically nobody is safe from judgment.
If you fly on airplanes, this is your fault.
If your home has oil heat, this is your fault.
If you eat fast food, this is your fault.
For a hundred other reasons, in a hundred other ways, it's your fault. And my fault. This is our fault, too, and that's all there is to it.
These judgments don't sit very comfortably. People need to get to work, need to get their kids to school, so they drive. People need to eat, and don't necessarily have the money to eat food that is safe for the planet; spend any time in one of those high-end planet-conscious stores, and you learn pretty quickly that only rich people can afford to eat both healthy and responsibly. The rest of us have to get by on Wonder Bread.
It's all too easy to declare that anyone who has voted Republican should take the blame for this disaster, because it is the Republicans in Washington who have championed the deregulation push that has been ongoing since the Reagan administration. But there are plenty of Democrats who are just as deep into deregulation as their GOP comrades, so voting Democratic is no safe haven.
We are learning a savage lesson in the Gulf. We are witnessing the end of a way of life we have become all too deeply accustomed to. We drive, we eat, we fly, we vote, and in doing so, we share the blame for what is happening, and what is to come. We have gone to sleep each night deliberately oblivious to the deadly nature of the fossil fuels that power the way we live, because it is too hard to even think about living a different way.
The Deepwater Horizon is the period at the end of a very long, bleak sentence that has been rolling along for a hundred years. We are killing ourselves with the way we live, with our complacency, and we can no longer ignore this wretched truth. The oil that is killing beaches and fisheries and animals of every kind is our lifeblood, the spigot on the sea floor is our femoral artery, and we are bleeding to death right there on television.
If it wasn't BP, it would have been something else. So long as we lay back and live this oily lifestyle, there will always be some company ready to provide it, and there will always be some way that lifestyle will be killing us. The water is fouled, the clouds stink of gasoline, the ground is seeded with poison, and now the sea is dying before our eyes, and all because this is the way we live, and we just can't seem to realize how mortally dangerous it all is.
This must change. Until it does, it's our fault, too.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Amen!
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 14:54 — Kirsten (not verified)Amen!
I'd substitute the word
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 14:59 — Brooklyn Girl (not verified)I'd substitute the word "responsibility" for "fault" ... I don't own a car, for example, and don't want one. But, when I did own one, if electric cars had been available, I would have gladly bought one.
I never voted for a politician based on the price of gas and would have welcomed higher gas prices, if for no other reason than it might have made people think twice before getting in the car to go a few blocks. And it literally drives me nuts to see so many people driving around in large cars by themselves. It also surprises me how many people leave lights and air conditioners on in unoccupied rooms.
Realistically, people can't be expected to give up their lives, to stop traveling, to not be able to eat what they want, and so on. But it's time for all of us to take responsibility for the choices we make. We should also be given reasonable, practical options so that we can have real choices in the first place, and should be informed as to the implications of those decisions. Making those options available is something, sadly, that often rests in the hands of others.
All of this is true, but
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:07 — Syl Jones (not verified)All of this is true, but more than anyone else, be they politicians, corporations, governments, whatever, TO ALLOW THE DRILLING TO BEGIN, BY FOREIGN ORGANIZATIONS, WITHOUT PROPER ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES IN ORDER TO RUN THE MACHINE YOU DESCRIBED ABOVE, can only be considered GREED.
Indeed, this is very true
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:13 — Anonymous (not verified)Indeed, this is very true
OUCH That hurts. Worst of
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:15 — Anonymous (not verified)OUCH That hurts. Worst of all, b/c you are correct.
This is not what I wanted to
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:23 — Slim (not verified)This is not what I wanted to hear. But seriously, WRP is, as usual, right as rain.
BP still needs to be excoriated over it, bankrupted even, even though that will be yet another nail in our economic coffin.
The repuglicans need to be ran out of office, too - along with the too-moderate, business-centered democrats. But neither of those will fix the problem that only we can fix.
If the Federal Reserve can print money to bail out Wall Street and AIG - why can't they print money to fund development of alternative energy? If we applied the same fervor and CASH to the problem, like we did to get to the moon 40 years ago - what couldn't we accomplish??
We are to blame ourselves
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:43 — J.G (not verified)We are to blame ourselves entirely for engaging the culture we raised in..entirely? I think not. We what should blame ourselves for is abdicating our responsibility as citizens of a democratic republic and electing officials, with no accountability on our part that handed over the safety and security to corrupt politicians that chose serve the minions of greed and power and not the interests of the nation at large. Yes, for that we as a a nation, are to blame,
This is exactly on point. If
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:47 — Anonymous (not verified)This is exactly on point. If your born into this system you have no choice but to live in it. I drive an old small pick up that gets better mileage than any new pick up, I also have an old diesel suv that runs on bio and gets better mileage than any new suv. You have to do the best you can in the system you live in and you have to pay the bills.
This spill is the fault of the rich,the greedy, deregulation, and corporations searching for max profit( which is also the fault of the rich).
Its not my fault that cars are being made that get 16 mpg around town and it's not possible to get affordable electricity. In my town if you go solar you can only sell back to the utility company the amount of electricity you use, excess is given to non-profits. That limits the size system you'll do, a system that could power much more that my house could go on my property but I can't afford a $20,000 system if the power cand be sold back. Again the rich set up the system.
Its a mistake to blame the masses who can basically only consume what industry decides to sell to them.
QUIT BLAMINGTHE WORKING MASSES!
". . We are learning a
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 15:49 — Anonymous (not verified)". . We are learning a savage lesson in the Gulf. ."
Yeah, you wish. Forty Earth Days and dozens of similar teaching moments have not shifted the entrenched economic model toward something even a tad less ruinous.
Had Deepwater Horizon lit up a month before Earth Day, we might have been subjected to a remake of that 1971 public service spot, you know, the one where the fake indian paddles up a polluted creek, then climbs out onto a litter-strewn highway only to have a bag of half eaten fast food tossed at his feet? We were supposed to be moved by the glycerine tear rolling down his cheek but empathy, genuine or contrived, has gotten us nowhere.
At least Chief Rusty Eye's message got through to Jimmy Carter, though, eh? His intended path to fossil-fuel-free energy independence was met with almost universal derision. Reagan couldn't wait to make a public spectacle of those pinko-commie solar panels being demounted from the White House roof.
What more savage lessons are there to be learned than the recent misadventures in the Middle East? Hell, even Vietnam was, at a deeper level, about securing control over Indonesian oil and gas reserves and other assets.
Now that we've all been implicated, keep us posted, Mr. Pitt, on the lifestyle changes you make as a result of this latest lesson learned. I will follow your lead.
I don't quite agree with
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 16:04 — Linda (not verified)I don't quite agree with your statements. Many of us do "realize how mortally dangerous it all is." And have been yelling and screaming about it for years....and have cast our votes accordingly....to no avail. All one has to do is look at the saga of the electric car. It did exist in the mid '90's. It was viable, efficient, affordable. AND IT WAS CRUSHED AND SHREDDED by the very company that marketed it.....GM. And whom did we, the tax payer, have to bail out just recently? Why none other than GM....inventor of The Hummer! No, sir, many of us have warned of the dangers over the years. We have made the necessary suggestion. We have individually tried to conserve, try to institute environmental changes. We have tried to buy locally and live greenly. But, alas, only the rich can afford to do so. No, sir, I do not accept responsibility for the disaster unfolding in the Gulf. American ingenuity could have saved us from such disasters years ago. It was American greed that prevented such saving!
Yes William, you are mostly
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 16:05 — radline9 (not verified)Yes William, you are mostly right, I don't live without the use of oil and gasoline, but if everybody was as conservation minded as I am (and a small circle of friends) they probably wouldnt have to drill in the gulf. I never asked for cheap dangerous oil and gasoline. For the last 40 years, I have been a proponant of conservation, living a trimmed down lifestyle and using clean safe energy like windmills and solar. Big industry has fought me for all its worth. Remember Bush telling us that our contribution to the war should be to go out and shop. What I am saying is that some people are more reponsible than others. Some people are more forward thinking. I wrote to my senators last year saying now is the time to add a $dollar a gallon gas tax so we wouldn't have to fight wars in the middle east. Consumption would go down and we would be less dependant on foreign oil. It's that easy. Not everbody is to blame. Some more than others. I drive a small car with a small efficient 4 and get 40 mpg by driving slow. Also, I don't use it unless I have to. I can make a tank last 6 weeks. It's the conspicuous consumption that is causing the problem.
We can start by encouraging
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 16:35 — Anonymous (not verified)We can start by encouraging our local governments to improve public transportation. More buses, subways, trains. The reason we are dependent on the automobile is that too often that is the only mode of transportation. New York City has the best transportation system in the country. In Europe, the Paris Metro is superb. Train travel in Europe is fast and efficient. Why has that bypassed most of the U.S.? My husband and I have driven a hybrid since 2002. It's roomy, handles beautifully, and saves on gas. We encourage others to do the same.
Get a horse. And wagon. No
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 16:48 — Adoregon (not verified)Get a horse.
And wagon.
No oil, no pollution.
Just hay, grain, and manure.
Otherwise, STFU.
This victim's not taking any
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 16:59 — Vic Anderson (not verified)This victim's not taking any more of this Pitt! We've been trying to buy ELECTRIC CARS since upping a $Billion or so In 1995, are waiting to buy solar/ electric roof film to power them, our homes and our economy (JOBS! JOBS! JOBS!) and though recently we've OWNED the banks and car companies; can't get 'em, or even PROMISED single-payer health care for the sociopathies inflicted upon US ALL by these Corporate CRIMINALS and their (s)elected gummint BAGMEN! It is their fault and their fault alone; We, the People must change their NAPPYS (No Account President(s) and Parties of Yoo're Screwed)!! Take NO incumbents!!!
Our red state southern tier
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 17:03 — Anonymous (not verified)Our red state southern tier (Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama) voted Bush/Cheney in 2000 and 2004. George Bush and Dick Cheney are oil men and friends of big oil. The Bush/Cheney administration was deliberately lax when regulating the oil industry. With the spill, those red states now reap what they have sown.
Mostly I agree w/this
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 17:19 — Eliot (not verified)Mostly I agree w/this article too, yet I'm reminded of a paper I wrote 20 yrs ago for an ecology class predicting GREED would lead to an unrecoverable ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER. There is no way to comprehend the scope or spread of long-term damage from the toxins released by BP into the fragile underwater environment of the Gulf. The technology for electric cars was available over 30 yrs ago, this is just one example of how big oil and govt greed have given Americans no choice but to "add to the blame" as Mr. Pitt describes it. Pitt may right that we are also to blame, just for the wrong reasons...
this writer was so right me
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 17:33 — Anonymous (not verified)this writer was so right me included being truthful i love to be driven(i dont drive everywhere) when love to blame others some more then others im sorry i just felt the more obama tries to do and yes he's a politician and you wont like everything he does he doesn't walk on water but he gets blame blame blame funny i didn't hear it so often with the other guy big oil guys you no
For my money, changing our
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 17:57 — Starko (not verified)For my money, changing our lifestyle is the answer; beating our heads against the wall trying to convince the government to regulate the marketplace to clean up their methods and stop selling destructive stuff is a noble cause, and I wouldn’t let up on it for a second, but an even better strategy would be to just stop BUYING IT ALL! As long as people are making money, the status quo has too much invested it itself to change much; real change is going to take place when enough people change their buying patterns, hopefully in time to have some healthy resources left on the planet to work with. Just redeeming your own little carbon footprint a tad, recycling your own trash, using less gas, water, and such, is great, but everyone knows it’s not enough. Everyone’s feeling guilty and frustrated to make bigger strides, but where do you start to rewrite your lifestyle, when you’re still in the busy throes of trying to maintain it?
I read an inspirational article recently that I want to share, about a guy known as the Ultimate Cheapskate, who rode his bike across the country interviewing people who have dropped out of their rat races, and found the joys of a simpler lifestyle. I’m jealous. I don’t know if I’ll ever have the courage to be as drastic a vanguard as any of them, but I’ve found their words echoing in my head at the mall and market the last few days, and I’m excited about the change, I want to foster it, encourage to grow. In some ways I think I’m wanting to (re)discover the hippie ethos I was born just too late to feel full-on, toward a much simpler, greener, shopping list, for me and for the planet.
The story was in the AARP magazine I get in the mail, a publication that comes with a discount card I get for the post-middle-aged, for coupons and such.
http://www.aarp.org/money/budgeting-saving/info-05-2010/leap-to-cheap.html
The article's author, Jeff Yeager, has a number of books on the subject of frugal living that I haven’t had a chance to check out yet, but I plan to read more, see if any of the ideas fit. His website is http://ultimatecheapskate.com/index.cgi
The only way to change is
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 18:10 — Anonymous (not verified)The only way to change is this:
Raise the price of gasoline via taxation. Double or perhaps triple the price. Only when people begin to pay the *real* cost of gas will we change our habits and seriously develop new types of cars, invest in public transport, and start living more locally.
No - I refuse to take any of
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 18:11 — Anonymous (not verified)No - I refuse to take any of the responsibility for BP running shoddy and irresponsible operation. That is in no way my fault. It is theirs and theirs only.
We need more than the
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 18:33 — Anonymous (not verified)We need more than the placement of blame. We need positive steps to take to make this better. If this bleeding into the ocean is a sign for change, the one obvious step that would make an immediate difference would be to add a $1/gal tax on all petroleum based products ... maybe $2. Then use the tax to fund alternative energy research, to build high-speed bullet trains systems and to repair our decaying infrastructure. But, no one who hopes to have a political future will ever propose this ... meaning there is no hope for our future.
What a load of bulls**t!!
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 18:45 — Anonymous (not verified)What a load of bulls**t!! It's not our fault that BP
chose to be negligent in their operation. It is a corrupt corporation that cares for nothing except its profits.
Also had a hand in the overthrow of a legally elected government in Iran in 1953.
Yes, of course we are all at
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 19:20 — herbr (not verified)Yes, of course we are all at fault in many ways and in different degrees. Bu that assessment MUST lead to concrete SOLUTIONS or, at least, to effective,practical countermeasures. One can enumerate many of these even now: feasible public transportation, increased density of human settlements to reduce transportation distances, solar and wind energy, etc. etc.
But most of all we are in need of devising and/or adopting a public philosophy based on communal valuation, rather than on the individualistic premises now tearing us apart with so-called "economic" modes of reasoning. And that, I vow, will be the most difficult part of achieving a more reasonable way of living and being.
How much hope for achieving that are we entitled to ?
We may never know the answer to that question, but if we fail to see and develop it, we are surely doomed.
And who will be left behind to write the history of the species that was ?
I don't accept the blame for
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 19:28 — Anonymous (not verified)I don't accept the blame for this disaster in any way shape or form. The 'A' holes who reversed Jimmy Carter's conservation ideas, down-sized federal regulatory agencies, stocked the agencies responsible for oversight with toadies and cronies and laughed all the way to the bank profiting off all that are the ones responsible. And if anyone cares to notice they are the same people who today own the media and are preventing the average American from realizing who is to blame by blaming everything possible on Obama.
Wake up Sheeple!
Obama just continued with
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 20:22 — Anonymous (not verified)Obama just continued with the oil guys Bush/Cheney rules: Drill baby drill. No rules, no regulators, no collection of royalties, no brains and no guts to stop deep water drilling. Over a million plus acres of leasing rights to drill for oil and gas on land here but they don't want to use that....afraid Mexico or Brazil is stealing their oil. Note Mexico and Brazil have not destroyed the Gulf, but then they don't have the high degree of technical knowledge we do or Halliburton's junk for equipment.
The Republicans still think it's OK to continue, cap the BP damage at $75million, seriously,and keep drilling. Mitch McConnell needs to talk to Bobby in LA. and see what he thinks. All these Republicans down there are yelling for government help. Must not be the tea party gang on the oily beaches of their shores.
It's alsol YOUR fault it you
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 21:03 — Rick Levy (not verified)It's alsol YOUR fault it you support auto racing in any way, shape, or form.
A very simple solution to
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 21:10 — Anonymous (not verified)A very simple solution to bring the oil companies to heel. Let's pick one particular company and boycott it! Run with the alphabet for order of the companies, but don't start with BP. Keep those bastards funded until every available cent of their capital has been extracted for the clean-up in the gulf. Starting point on the list then is Caltex. Simply drive past their station and fill up at the competition. Announce it far and wide and watch the share price drop even before the boycott really bites in. It might take 12 months, and then move onto the next company ... oh yes Exon-mobile -now there's an outfit whose ethics we can admire -not!! Your power as a consumer is the only real power you have left when dealing with these multi-national bastards -use it!!!
We have , all of us,
Fri, 06/11/2010 - 23:59 — DaveW. (not verified)We have , all of us, essentially been placed in a maze from the moment of our birth in this country. Like trained ,obedient rats we have run the gauntlet buying and consuming every new gadget and machine, no matter the environmental implications because that's what we were told by our mass marketed culture to do. In the early days of WWll this country was able to mobilize almost overnight to produce vast amounts of the materials we needed to win that conflict. That type of mobilization, enforced by a up to now worthless corrupt government, is needed badly. Both political parties are to blame with the GOP edging out their Dem counterparts in the open acceptance of big business crafted legislation, but with the Dems perhaps more to blame because we, as working people, expected them to be on our side. Either way, we've been had. Sacrifice should not be reserved for a few Soldiers and Marines, and sticking a support the troops sticker on your SUV is a poor excuse for quite literally pumping blood into your tank. America, collectively, should be hanging her head. Good article WRP!
Obama has from the start
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 00:29 — Anonymous (not verified)Obama has from the start been trying to change and alter this. His stimulus bailout, whatever you want to call it, opposed by so many who now threaten to remove the Democrats from power, was based largely on the proposition of changing and reducing fossil fuel dependency.
The problem seems to be that "the people" are a bit too stupid and selfish to govern themselves. The fallacy of democracy.
And of course the "American interests"that excuse our invasions over in the ME are oil interests as well.
"The people" are just shallow and stupid and I'm not sure that Obama or anybody can change that.
To "Anonymous" above @ "Fri,
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 00:44 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)To "Anonymous" above @ "Fri, 06/11/2010 - 23:10", did that, or is that, working in Europe? They pay, including in the United Kingdom, three or four or more times higher gas prices than we do. Has that caused most of them to stop driving; or produce, buy and drive nothing but 100% electric cars, or even mostly hybrid cars? Yes, they have efficient mass transportation in the cities, and trains from town to town or city to city if you can afford them (fortunately for them, especially in Germany, their wages are much higher, with much more benefits, than we get), but that doesn't stop them, as here in the U.S. it doesn't stop us either, from continuing to drive relatively-gas-guzzling cars just to drive across town or the city.
The problem is, most people just don't care. They don't care about the environment. They don't care about what's happening in the Gulf of Mexico. They don't care about or for recycling, and won't bother, especially in the U.S. even though it's been around for, what, at least thirty years? They don't care about the fact that they should walk down the street, or a few blocks, to the grocery store, instead of driving there. All of this is a worldwide phenomena. Perhaps we Americans, per capita, are (much?) worse, but I don't think we're much worse...
...I think, rather than the
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 00:44 — S. Wolf Britain (not verified)...I think, rather than the "answer" of driving less and making tankfuls of gas "last six weeks", more and more of us should stop driving motor vehicles AT ALL, as I did fourteen years ago. I ride my bicycle EVERYWHERE, to do EVERYTHING, run all of my errands, and to do all of my food shopping, etc. And most of us shouldn't own motor vehicles AT ALL either, as I haven't owned ANY, also for fourteen years. Sure, because most people are ignorant, self-centered idiots, especially in "America", they think I'm a "nutcase" for running all of my errands on my bike, and never driving; but that's there stupidity, isn't it? If it's supposedly idiotic for a fifty-four year old man not to own a car, and not drive anywhere, then what are they (much more?) idiotic about? A lot, I'd reckon.
This world is completely ass-backwards and mass-insane, that' all there is to it; and, for that reason, its only hope is the Lord Jesus, the Christ, returning very soon and bringing a total end to all of this mass- insanity and madness. Therefore, "(e)ven so (return very quickly), Lord Jesus (just as you have promised and I know you will; and bring an end to all of this greed, selfishness and narcissism, take us home to heaven for a thousand years, and then remake this earth back into the Eden it was originally created to be)"! [Revelation 22:20; etc.; emphasis and/or clarification(s) added by me.]
I disagree. Simply owning or
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 00:45 — Anonymous (not verified)I disagree. Simply owning or using anything that uses the oil does not make us responsible for the spill in the gulf. We as a society have created a system that extracts fossil fuels from the earth. Only certain people who failed to keep that system in check can be held responsible for what has happened in the gulf. Yes, we as humans understand that there are limited recourses in the world that we are using. That being said they are key to certain technologies which have revolutionized the way we live. I buy gas from companies assuming they will get their gas in an environmentally safe way, when they fail to do so they have let their customers (all of us) down. Yes I have allowed gas prices to influence the way I vote if you didn't you aren't considering the political views of who you are voting for nor are you considering the standard of living. Simply because we use a service we cannot be blamed because the service has failed us.
Less time for this, more for
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 01:18 — Scott (not verified)Less time for this, more for solutions. Electric cars are being built. More electricity can be generated green ways: river turbines, generating buoys, thermal solar with sterling engines, more. Busses and trucks can use natural gas. We can work toward a national grid of electrical trains for freight.
It can be done. It would provide a wealth of jobs. No time for pity. Write your congressman. If we all did it, they do want to get re-elected.
The corporations want you to despair, buy some chocolate, go to the big and tall store. Don't give them the satisfaction.
Lets start by taking
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 01:25 — Dave (not verified)Lets start by taking responsibility right now.
Obama has put a moritorium on new drilling in the gulf. There is pressure from the four states to open up the drilling. lets support Obama in permanently stopping the drilling in the gulf.
In just about everything I
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 01:26 — hbro (not verified)In just about everything I read or hear about the problem of limited resources, I look in vain for a mention of the two greatest threats, continued population growth and the industrialization of the third world with its automatic force for rising expectations and demand for energy.
I have come to believe that the self censorship of those two subjects indicates that all the talk about saving the planet is just talk. That we have given up, but we feel we must pretend that we are doing something.
"Many of us do 'realize how
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 06:24 — jahf (not verified)"Many of us do 'realize how mortally dangerous it all is.' And have been yelling and screaming about it for years....and have cast our votes accordingly....to no avail. All one has to do is look at the saga of the electric car."
The point is that those who act for monetary profit at the expense of all other things are an effective majority in the world. If the effort to mass produce the electric car was crushed, it was because the forces at play to kill it was greater than the forces at play to bring it to life.
Any such movement or result is the sum of all forces. Consider the failed effort to privatize Social Security. It has failed (so far) because there are large forces arrayed against it, namely, the great numbers of those who fear immediate detriment to their financial situations should the current structure of Social Security be changed.
If there is no net movement *as a society* toward the more sustainable practices and safeguarding of our environment, it can only be because those of us who are not interested enough in such things to effect change, number more than those of us who are.
"We have tried to buy locally and live greenly. But, alas, only the rich can afford to do so."
This statement is true only if one counts cost or judges value only in terms of that social fiction and much abused tool called money. We are a society that, given the choice of taking a container of money or a container of water for a trip through a desert, has so mistaken something meant only as a very crude measure of value for something of true worth, that we have taken the money for our journey, while leaving behind the water.
The reasons we are in this
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 07:50 — Frank (not verified)The reasons we are in this mess given thus far are valid to a point. We must step back and look from a larger perspective. If we were ALLOWED to have access to the technologies that the TRUE RULERS of this planet have it would be a different picture altogether. You may scoff at this but there have been enough whistle blowers from the secret side of history to show we could have been free of the internal combustion engine and all the attendant fuel issues 70 years ago but those technologies were suppressed and remain in the hands of a select few. The inventors were either silenced or bought out. Remember One of the Elite had a sign carved into the head of his bed. "Competition is a sin" That says much as to why we are in this situation. Yes, we are partly at fault but IF we had had all the choices available would we have made the same decisions? I think not.
I fully support higher taxes
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 09:13 — Anonymous (not verified)I fully support higher taxes on gasoline and other petroleum-based products in order to fund alternative energy research and better public transportation systems. The problem is that this country, in its current political climate, is so geared against taxes really of any sort, and is brainwashed that raising taxes at all is advancing socialism that the chances of tax legislation ever being so much as written for consideration is a long shot.
The basic premise is wrong.
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 09:32 — Anonymous (not verified)The basic premise is wrong. Moderate use of fossil fuels, with due attention to conservation and transitioning to renewables should be the aim. That would still have people driving cars, flying in planes etc.
The "we're all to blame"
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 10:03 — Anonymous (not verified)The "we're all to blame" position well serves the interests of the ruling class when it causes a disaster of biblical proportions whether environmental, political, social, financial or otherwise. It makes it seem as though we are all on the same side or that "mistakes were made". We are not on the same side. They control the levers of power. We do not. Next thing you know, I'll be hearing about bringing change through my support of either the right hand or the far right hand of the status quo.
Everyone involved with
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 10:14 — ted stanuga (not verified)Everyone involved with allowing deep ocean drilling on a wink and a prayer should be prosecuted for fraud at the very least. Everything else is BS. I think that the secret meeting on oil headed by Cheney is where this disaster began...start with those people.
Someone was omitted from the
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 12:56 — Chari Kolp (not verified)Someone was omitted from the list of the guilty: those who bought houses in suburbs where it is impossible to walk to a store. Trouble is, we have painted ourselves into a corner as far as housing and energy use are concerned. Next time you visit a suburban mall, take a good look around at the size of the parking lot, the number of cars and the paucity of safe places to walk to get there. It will atke massive investment to get out of this mess. Entire neighborhoods, roads, shops and all the appurtenances of life will have to be redesigned .
William's right. And you
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 13:37 — Dana (not verified)William's right. And you don't get off the hook with a special dispensation just because you're part of "the working masses." And you are not off the hook just because you drive. You're on a computer. It requires petroleum inputs. You probably eat vegan. That requires petroleum inputs because you won't let animals be used to make your food in any way, shape or form. (By the way, your other option is human slave labor. Feeling virtuous yet?) Any time you go into the hospital you've contributed to an oil spill. Any time you buy anything made of plastic or packaged in anything you've contributed to an oil spill. Are you getting it yet? YOU ARE NOT OFF THE HOOK. If you're alive in a petroleum-based economy IT IS YOUR FAULT.
And mine too. I know. But see, I can admit it. I'm not trying to soften the blow. I'm not a goddamn *coward* afraid to face the truth.
Are you awake now? Will you ever be?
And no, you don't "have" to take whatever industry throws at you. Take a good hard look at the stuff around your house. Ask yourself if there was ever a time in which you could live without it. If you've older than, like, TEN, the answer is Yes.
I remember living without computers. I remember living without cell phones. I remember when you could still find lots of toys made of wood and metal and didn't have to settle for plastic. I was only born in 1974. This was not all that long ago.
The Amish live without a lot more than that. Do you notice them starving and having shitty lives? Me neither.
I'll say it again... IT'S YOUR FAULT. And MINE. Wake up.
That may be, but there are
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 14:40 — Anonymous (not verified)That may be, but there are many out there who's hands are stained with far more oil than others. 1st: Vote OUT the Drill, Baby, Drill crowd, for they are undeniably the puppets of the oil companies. 2. Make a list of life-style choices to train yourself to do without TODAY. 3. Repeat until we have renewable energy resources and a government that is not run by Big Oil, Big Banks and Big Insurance.
On point, Mr. Pitt. Now
Sat, 06/12/2010 - 23:57 — Anonymous (not verified)On point, Mr. Pitt. Now what do we do? I hope we vote more progressively. We need a government that can make and enforce environmental regulations and officials not in any way beholden to the fossil fuel industries.
Change is difficult for many, but more modest lives do not mean lives less full of joy or meaning. We all need to live more simply. Right now we all must begin taking small steps to train for bigger ones to follow.
I too hope for higher gasoline taxes/prices. BP should pay, but we all know they won't pay and pay until everything is back to the way it should be. Revenues from these taxes can both pay down debt and pay for long-term cleanup costs of this nightmare.
No, it's NOT my fault.
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 00:27 — Susan (not verified)No, it's NOT my fault.
Excuse me, but I don't drive an automobile. I take public transportation.
I unplug my appliances when I'm done with them.
I put on extra layers of clothing during the winter instead of turning up the heat.
I do not use air conditioning in the summertime.
If you do these four things, then your oil consumption dramatically reduces.
Oh, and by the way, just because we use oil does not let BP off the hook. BP should be eviscerated for what it's done to its employees, to the environment, and to the people of the Gulf Coast. Remember that, Mr. Pitt.
I'd love to create change
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 07:37 — Anonymous (not verified)I'd love to create change here. Unfortunately, with the powers that be at the helm I don't see that happening. Too much money involved. So, I'll do what I can to ease the pain as I watch it slip away. What is most disturbing is to watch the faces of intelligent twenty somethings know with great certainity that they are left with a cess pool of nothing to look forward to.
Peace
FAULT REQUIRES CHOICE Show
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 07:44 — Gwalihir Windreaper (not verified)FAULT REQUIRES CHOICE
Show me the list of jobs that will pay a living wage which I can reach on a bike, which will accept me coming in drenched and muddy on rainy days, stinking and sweaty on hot ones, and an hour late when it snows. Show me the dealers who sell all-electric or air-powered cars: the repair shops which will service them: the apartments with recharge stations in their parking spaces. Show me the markets which provide only locally produced foods (and how to get my perishables home in my backpack, on my bike, without my milk going sour or my eggs getting broken. Show me how I can be regarded by the majority as a sane member of society and not a "tree-hugging leftover hippy" when I attempt anything but the most basic environmentally sound changes in my life.
Corporate greed, mass production and a system of commerce founded on forcing us back to the pump once a week has created a social structure which traps us into the cycle of self-destructive consumption. Did I vote for it? Do I want it? Do I have a choice that will change it?
Show me the choices I could have made with allow me to be accepted by my peers as a rational member of society, and I will accept that this is my fault. Until then, place the blame where it belongs: oil companies, auto companies and the politicians they buy and sell.
Give me a lever long enough and a place to stand, and I may move the world. Take away the social influence of everything but the dollar, and you have America. The love of money truly is the root of all evil.
Gwalihir... right
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 16:14 — Tony (not verified)Gwalihir... right on.
Everybody knows we support this is in concept, but the reality is that the entire chain of accountability has been dismantled from the inside. Our actual choice options are almost nonexistent and the appearance of a market or democracy a charade.
This is why they will get away with it, that regulatory reform will be too little too late, and it will take something far worse, that actually kills thousands or millions of people to wake people up to the fact that money runs this system, not choice, and that people with SOME money need to band together with those without and end corporate rule.
Big Government or big
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 22:23 — Don D. Brock (not verified)Big Government or big business
Who do you trust giving the recent problems Of America?
Should we go on deregulating and fearing the Government that was set up for we the people?
Big business or corporations cannot have us trusting or being involved with our Government and so they teach us to fear it while behind our backs, They go make deals with our once honest politicians and turn them to the dark side.
Deregulation was our biggest mistake All it did was give big business and corporations a free license to raise prices and keep the little guy in debt, They even control us with drugs we do not need if we would exorcise and not take a chance at all the side effects we will get from there controlling drugs.
http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/charters/declaration.html
Auto racing If it is done
Mon, 06/14/2010 - 10:55 — Don D. Brock (not verified)Auto racing If it is done with every day cars is important to check out the vehicles abilities and of course see how it can handle a crash in real life. Of course normal cars do not have harnesses and most people do not wear helmets but a good engineer can still gather important information. However when we get more electric cars on the race track or have hybrid only races then we will be doing a better job of filling the needs of America.
We need a solar panel on every roof of new houses and as fast as we can on all other houses So we can stop buying oil from those who use it to annoy us and someday go to war with us.
I've been thinking about
Tue, 06/15/2010 - 15:27 — Kym (not verified)I've been thinking about this one since I first read it, I thought about it all weekend. And as a little experiment I started a personal boycott of plastic. Such a little thing except it is literally impossible to boycott plastics 100%.
I agree with you that this is our fault, too. But people, at least some people, will do the right thing if they have the chance. Look at how popular the electric car was, until it was killed (and not by we the people). So to some extent we are trapped in the maze we've allowed to be created around us. Not only do we have to break out, but the maze needs to be breakable. And we are so OWNED by big businesses that the maze is nearly unbreakable.
Won't stop me from trying tho!
The fault lies with the
Wed, 06/16/2010 - 17:27 — Anonymous (not verified)The fault lies with the one-party (Demopublican) system in the US and those who support it. There are now NO independent voices in the US government. The Obama administration, the Democratic Party, the Republican Party and the U Congress are completely in the pocket of the corporate military-industrial-medical-insurance-fascist cabal that runs the show--without exception. Those who fail to oppose this completely corrupt system AND work to build a new independent political party in the US are at fault.
When will YOU wake up and begin the work of building a new independent political party in the US? Stop complaining and begin organizing for 2012!
ugg gloves canada
Tue, 10/23/2012 - 08:50 — jetEmita (not verified)you definitely love [URL=http://www.uggs--canada.com/ - ugg gloves canada[/URL - for more tMVPqLZG [URL=http://www.uggs--canada.com/ - http://www.uggs--canada.com/ [/URL -