Rachel Maddow Interview With Elizabeth Warren: Can America's Middle Class Be Saved?

by: Rachel Maddow  |  The Rachel Maddow Show | Video Interview

Elizabeth Warren, the representative to the President and special advisor to the Secretary of the Treasury, tasked with setting up the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, talks with Rachel Maddow about what it will take to restore the middle class in America:

Partial Transcript:

Rachel Maddow: ... democrats can take advantage of this political gift republicans are handing them if the electorate believes democrats aren't just being more fiscally conservative on this issue, they're doing it because they have the interest of the middle class at heart. the white house really does have a promiddle class agenda. they're not waging war on the rich, theyen sad for the middle class, and standing for the middle class in a responsible way. joining us now in many ways, the face of those efforts for this white house, elizabeth warren. professor warren, thank you for being here.

Elizabeth Warren: it's good to be here.

Rachel Maddow: Republicans coming to washington have their sights on you, several saying they want the agency you're setting up dismantled before it larges. how does the mission of consumer financial protection fit into this idea of an agenda for the middle class?

Elizabeth Warren: I have to say, i'm really surprised by this move. following the great depression it took 50 years before anyone started chipping seriously away at the new reforms that had been put in place to protect us. now we're coming out of -- we hope coming out of another great recession, we've passed serious reform, and it's just a matter of months until people are talking about how to undercut this new consumer financial protection agency. you know, this new agency has not yet drawn breath and yet there are those who are saying, let's do what we can to weaken it to make sure that it's never able to have any effect to be an effective voice on behalf of middle class families.

Rachel Maddow: In terms of the middle class agenda of this white house, the middle class agenda that democrats hope to present to regain their majority in the hou house. consumer financial protection is one of these things that's been defined by its enemies as an extra layer of regulation that will hand string businesses and hand string job growth. what's your take on that argument?

Elizabeth Warren: Well, so let's just be clear, that argument didn't win. the consumer financial protection agency became law, not because there was some special interest group pushing for it, or some lobbyists. remember the wall street lobbyists said they would kill it before it was ever born. they lost. and they lost because this is an agency that really is there for middle class families. let me gish you an example of that. this agency is about being able to tell in advance what the price of a credit product is, how much risk is associated with it, and being able to make comparisons, so you could look at a credit card, tell what it costs, how risky it is. and compare four credit cards and tell which one is the cheapest. american families think that's a pretty good deal. recent poll says 96% of american families say we need to get rid of the fine print in these financial contracts. 96%, that's democrats, republicans, independents, libertarians, vegetarians. everybody. this is not a partisan issue. this is a core middle class issue. american families have been hit hard, flat wages, rising core expenses. they've turned to debt. debt has turned out to be very dangerous. it has really torn a hole in the bottom of the economic boat for millions of middle class families. what this agency is about is about repairing that boat. and families are with us on this.

Rachel Maddow: You have been studying the economics of the middle class of american middle earners for the last 30 years. what is -- what's going to make the biggest difference on the return of the middle class? you talk about stagnating wages, you talk about the par sittic effect of predatory debt and predatory debt marketers. and these other issues. in the big picture, what is going to make a middle class? is it ultimately going to be something that happens through the tax structures? what can be done?

Elizabeth Warren: I and as a result, it's going to take a lot of things to start fixing it. we're going to have to work on the wage side. we can't live with stagnant wages for the next 30 years for american workers. rising core expenses is what pushed the middle class into debt. those have been really tough on american middle class. but here's one we can fix and start fixing right now. and that is that families turn to debt. they turn to debt to deal with medical bills. they turn to debt to pay for college. they turn to debt to make it from here to the end of the month. and that debt turned out to be really dangerous. and it has put lots of middle class families. millions of middle class families over the edge financially. this is an agency that can say, that problem we can fix and we can start fixing now. and it doesn't take tax money to do that. what it takes is leveling the playing field and saying, look, we just want some basic fairness here. the pricing has to be clear up front. the risk has to be clear up front. and it has to be easy up front to make comparisons amorning products. that means getting rid of fine print. that means no more tricks and traps in the game. when that happens, more money stays in the pockets of american families. and less of it drains out to the financial institutions that have become so powerful.

Rachel Maddow: Elizabeth warren, assistant the to the president, and special adviser to the secretary of the treasury demonstrating tonight why she is both of those things. and one of our nation's most eloquent voices on these very central issues. thanks for being here, good luck, ma'am.

Elizabeth Warren: Thank you. 

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.





     

»




Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



not saved until ceo's are

not saved until ceo's are shipped off to gulags



While the Consumer

While the Consumer Protection Agency would have some good effects, the entire economy and political system has to be reformed to save the middle class. It's more than I can go into in a short post like like this, but financialization and rent-seeking have to be replaced with production, and productivity gains have to be passed on to workers. The US economy is out of balance, and workers do not have enough bargaining power.

Business will argue that worker compensation has remained the same even though wages have been stagnant for 30 years, because of rising benefits, mostly health care. This is true and it is why health care needs to be decoupled from work. The only viable way forward is single-payer, because health care is a public utility that cannot be run profitably chiefly by the private sector and still cover everyone adequately.

Moreover, people have to come to understand that deficits don't matter if they are good deficits. That is to say, when consumers desire to save as now, if there is trade deficit, then there will not be enough demand to purchase available supply, so unemployment will rise. The only options are to make up the difference with exports, not likely in the case of the US, or have the government make up the difference in a budgetary deficit. This is simple accounting, not economic theory.



whoever did the

whoever did the transcription --it's ham-string, not hand string...



The proper question to ask

The proper question to ask is should we allow the uber-wealthy 1% to threaten every one else? While making contracts clearer to understand is good - but criminalizing loan sharking with tough legislation is more effective, Many folks have long since abandoned plastic, and survive quite nicely with cash, Before some of the new financial reforms it could be said that credit cards were helpful for wealthier folks, but a vicious tool of debt slavery for the not so rich, by design.



Warren is very smart, but

Warren is very smart, but she cannot challenge her authority. Apparently, this would be uncouth or is somehow prohibited in her newly assigned (captive) role. When people are bleeding debt right now, why is it that we need to ignore them, and focus on just making sure this predatory behavior doesn't happen in the future? It's like Obummer telling us to look forward, and ignore the war criminality of the previous administration, (probably because the some of guilty are still employed in his admin) Other authors, former regulators, and activists are calling for the firing of Tim Geithner, for foreclosure moratoriums, for receivership of TBTFs, for cramdown, for the firing of Ben Bernanke. She's way too polite when she sits down for tea, and this should piss the middle class off.



This would have been a lot

This would have been a lot more effective (and easier to read) with a modicum of proofreading. Shame on Truthout.org for letting an insightful interview go out in such a deplorable condition.



Nothing like boosting

Nothing like boosting unemployment - and reforming bankruptcy law to make it much easier to walk away from parasitical violence. The rightward creep since 1980 by the entire political system culmintaed in relentless attacks on societies most vulnerable, irrevocably proving we can be just as nasty and draconian as any other 3rd world nation we used to look down. The Questions that must be asked: Why is that our entire Government is doing very little for such a horrible employment situation?



@Mio Latte: Why isn't our

@Mio Latte: Why isn't our entire government doing much for a horrible employment situation? In short, The GOP can't stand to have Obama get credit for anything, so they attempt -- often with success -- to block his every positive move.



I like Elizabeth, she says

I like Elizabeth, she says all the right things Progressives like to hear. I wish her well in her uphill battle against the entrenched uber-wealthy/powerful in Washington. She could and should take the place of Timmy Geithner where she could be very effective at saving the Middle Class. We will see if Obama allows her any real authority or whether he is just throwing some crumbs for the "Professional Left".



This President must realize

This President must realize that there has not been nearly enough crumb-throwing to the "professional left' to make any difference. In fact, almost None. Does he not understand that all he is doing is acting like an Uncle Tom, kissing up to the Republicans as he has done, while calling it ' reaching across the aisle.' Come on, man, enough already.