Racist Elements in the Tea Party Movement?

by: Dr. Wilmer J. Leon III, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

Racist Elements in the Tea Party Movement?
(Photo: asterix611 / Flickr)

On Wednesday, October 20, the Institute for Research and Education on Human Rights in conjunction with the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) released the report "Tea Party Nationalism: A Critical Examination of the Tea Party Movement and the Size, Scope and Function of Its National Factions." According to the report, it examines histories and the "... corporate structure and leadership, finances and membership concentrations ..." of "... six of the national organizational networks at the core of the Tea Party Movement." The six Tea Party organizational elements examined are the Freedom Works Tea Party, 1776 Tea Party, Tea Party Nation, Tea Party Patriots, ResistNet and Tea Party Express (the "Movement").

The report is very clear from the outset: " ... the majority of Movement supporters are people of good will." But integrated into their calls for a reduction of the budget deficit, greater focus on the national debt and smaller government are concerns about race, sexual orientation, national identity, national birth rights and who qualifies to be an American. As the Tea Party Movement has taken shape amid calls for less government, lower taxes and less government spending; racist, white nationalist, anti-immigrant, homophobic and anti-Semitic elements have found their way into the Movement.

The authors of the report use different methodologies to gather their data such as national opinion polls; Tea Party published literature and books; blog posts; tweets from Tea Partiers; hours of video from Tea Party events; and first-hand accounts from attending Tea Party meetings, conventions and rally's across the country. They also conducted interviews with Tea Party members.

The report presents some very interesting findings. It estimates the size of the Tea Party movement to be between 16 to 18 percent of the adult population, putting the number of sympathizers in the tens of millions. This is considered the outer ring of support. The next level is a less defined group of a couple of million activists who go to meetings, buy literature and attend national events. At the core, is a group of 250,000 individuals who have signed on to the web sites of the six core groups in all 50 states.

The Movement is a vast array of loose affiliations of organizations, many listed above. It's a "multimillion dollar complex that includes for-profit corporations, non-party non-profit organizations and political action committees." The 1776 Tea Party, a.k.a TeaParty.org, grew out of the anti-immigrant Minuteman Project. Tea Party Nation has grown from the "birther's" and Christian nationalist and nativist organizations. Many members of the Tea Party Patriots are calling to repeal the 17th Amendment of the Constitution that allows for the direct election of US senators. Groups such as the Tea Party Express have made such vile racist pronouncements that other Movement elements have distanced themselves from it.

One would think that based upon the Tea Party's expressed concerns about the economy, national debt and deficit spending that there would be a correlation between a rise in unemployment and an increase in Movement membership. The report found no statistical link between Movement membership and rising unemployment. A nationalist sense runs through many of these organizations that is focused on "Take it Back - Take Your Country Back."

The idea of Tea Party Nationalism ties directly to Dr. Ronald Walters' discussion of white nationalism, black interests, and how many white conservatives perceive themselves as being under threat and are pursuing politics and policies that direct resources toward their own interests (against social programs, too much government etc.). The report states, "... their storied opposition to political and social elites turns out to be predicated upon an antagonism to federal assistance to those deemed the 'undeserving poor.'" At the heart of a lot of their ire is the redistribution of wealth in America.

The language they use is very subtle, "We want our country back - Take it Back - Take Your Country Back." As the dominant ethnic group, whites can speak in the context of "national interests" as code language for their own group interests. They can reward, punish and so structure policy outcomes as to protect and enhance their own race-based interests. According to Walters, "Given a condition where one race is dominant in all political institutions, most policy actions appear to take on an objective quality, where policy makers argue that they are acting on the basis of 'national interests' rather than racial ones." Even though many in the Movement are outside of the system, the analysis holds true, the rhetoric is consistent.

There is a historical correlation between the Dixicrats in 1948, Southern Democrats who left the Democratic Party over new civil rights planks that had been proposed for addition to the party platform, and the modern day Tea Party. Will this Movement result in a new party being formed as the Dixicrats formed the State Rights Party in 1948 or will their politics translate or be absorbed into the politics of the Republican Party moving it further to the right?

Many in the Republican Party such as Rep. Michele Bachman (R-Minnesota) and Rep. Brian Bilbray (R-California), former House Majority Leader Gingrich, former Congressmen Tancredo and Dick Armey and Republican spokesman Rush Limbaugh, play to the sentiments of the Movement and court their voters. Others such as Sens. Lindsay Graham (R-South Carolina) and Mitch McConnell (R-Kentucky) try to keep their distance and not align themselves with the extreme and fringe elements of this movement. While Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele describes the Tea Party and Republican Party as "locked hand-in-hand."

The report provides a clear historical presentation of the development of the Tea Party movement and the ideological struggles that are being waged within it. "The Tea Party movement has unleashed a still inchoate political movement who are in their numerical majority, angry middle-class white people who believe their country, their nation has been taken from them."

Some such as the conservative web site Daily Caller and Brendan Steinhauser, director of federal and state campaigns for Freedomworks, which support many Tea Party groups, are questioning organizations like the NAACP, Think Progress, Media Matters for America and New Left Media for launching their web site TeaPartyTracker.org and the Institute for Research and Education on Human Rights for publishing this report. Conservatives call this discussion of race and the Tea Party frustrating, divisive, unbalanced and a distraction. Nothing could be further from the truth.

These issues are frustrating and divisive. In 2010, Americans still have to deal with Tea Party-backed candidates such as Sharon Angle, a US Senate candidate in Nevada who thinks it's appropriate to tell Hispanic students who questioned her campaign's anti-illegal immigrant message, "You know, I don't know that all of you are Latino. Some of you look a little more Asian to me. I don't know that ... What we know, what we know about ourselves is that we are a melting pot in this country. My grandchildren are evidence of that. I'm evidence of that. I've been called the first Asian legislator in our Nevada State Assembly."

If there are links between the Tea Party and racist hate groups as the report indicates, then, as NAACP CEO and President Benjamin Jealous states, "These links should give all patriotic Americans pause." The members and leadership of the Tea Party should "distance themselves from those Tea Party leaders who espouse racist ideas, advocate violence, or are affiliated with white supremacist organizations." They have no place in our "one Nation under God"; they have no place in our politics.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Dr. Wilmer Leon is the producer/host of the nationally broadcast call-in talk radio program "On With Leon" and a Teaching Associate in the Department of Political Science at Howard University in Washington, DC. Go to www.wilmerleon.com or email wjl3us@yahoo.com.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



"Racist Elements in the Tea

"Racist Elements in the Tea Party Movement?"

BIG TIME



Tea Parties = Modern

Tea Parties = Modern resurgence of the KKK



Oh yeah. Those Tea Party

Oh yeah. Those Tea Party types...those racists...those wipers of peoples bottoms. I'm with you.

Oh wait...I forgot...wasn't there this thing that happened recently...that's right...the Obama Justice Department decided not to pursue a Civil Rights Voting violation against the New Black Panther Party. Didn't they intimidate white voters? Wasn't that caught on video? I wonder why that case was dropped?

*cough* hypocrite.



2:18- The case was not

2:18- The case was not "dropped". It was narrowed to focus on a winnable case. NOT that I am conservative, or agree with Ms. Thernstrom, but read below for a right-wing perspective based on the facts/merits of the case:

Washington Post:
Abigail Thernstrom, a commission member and a senior fellow at the conservative Manhattan Institute, called it "small potatoes" and said conservatives should pursue more important issues against the Obama administration. The case, she pointed out, invokes a narrow and rarely used provision of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, which has been used successfully to prosecute only three times since its passage.

"If you want to criticize [Attorney General] Eric Holder, there are lots of grounds on which to criticize him," she said. "Why waste your breath on this one?"

Thernstrom said that she did not find Adams's testimony convincing and that the facts of the case raised doubts in her mind, noting that the Black Panthers were standing in front of a majority-black precinct that had voted overwhelmingly for Democrats in previous elections -- not a prime spot for intimidating white voters.



Tea Party Truth-Out-er: "the

Tea Party Truth-Out-er: "the Obama Justice Department decided not to pursue a Civil Rights Voting violation against the New Black Panther Party. Didn't they intimidate white voters? Wasn't that caught on video? I wonder why that case was dropped?"

In order: 1) No, they counter-intimidated whites who they believed had come to intimidate black voters. 2) Something was caught on video, but I don't think it was what Fox News, Rush Limbaugh, the Republican Party and other wholly-owned subsidiaries of the right-wing noise machine have told you it was. 3) Because of what Gertrude Stein said on returning to her childhood home: "There's no there there."

"Tea Party Truth-Out-er (not verified)". Truer words were never written.



Tea Party, racist; surely

Tea Party, racist; surely you jest. These whack jobs are to the right of the Republicans. I think I remember a figure quoted of 35 black people at the last Republican convention. Now that's racism, but hey, for a group that's 13% of the population to have ONE US Senator; now that's real racism. As Malcolm X said when he referred to the south "I mean south of Canada, the whole US is the south". Sadly, although some things are better & some worse, the country has a long way to go. The country still has not ratified the ERA to this day & the female participation on the Supreme Court was down to 1 of 9 & now it's 1/3, a record; when you consider the population is greater than half female; that's sexist. Still have not adopted the international system of measurements to this day, the last country on earth. Conservative & resistant to change; you are that!



Patriotism is the last

Patriotism is the last refuge of scoundrels.



A good chunk of the

A good chunk of the republican party is KKK. If Obama asks congress to declare the KKK as an illegal terrorist organization, the republicans would block it. They also want it to be legal to fire everyone that is gay or rejects "Christ" or "GOD", the latter being against The Civil Rights Act of 1964 which the republican tried to filibuster. If the Republicans have their way, they'll let the Civil Rights Act expire and not renew it like they tried in 2005. FUCK the right wing



My, aren't we all a bunch of

My, aren't we all a bunch of hate mongers of all those tea party types. They have a different viewpoint from us...burn them! Isn't hate at the root of racism? Where are all the anti-racist, anti-hate speech zealots now? Could we all be a bunch of progressive, left-wing hypocrites? It seems that we've stereotyped all right-wingers as racists. Isn't stereotyping the little brother of racism? Let's see...yep, here's a pretty good definition: "a standardized mental picture that is held in common by members of a group and that represents an oversimplified opinion, prejudiced attitude, or uncritical judgment". Looks like we're a bunch of prejudiced truth-out-ers.

New Black Panther Party incident didn't have enough there there? Dare I say that you hair-splitters would be singing a different tune if the race of those haters were white?

And the Reverend White? Did you look the other way then? Don't give me that Obama apologized stuff...just search your own site for the text of his speech on that one. Chock full of hair-splitting.

No, the left-wing isn't racist, not a prejudiced bone in the body. Clean as a whistle.

*cough* hypocrites.



The right wing tries to mask

The right wing tries to mask its own racism by trumping up alleged minority racism. Remember the Shirley Sherrod incident?!? What a lying sack of sh!t that Andrew Breitbart turned out to be.

The Right Wing has pursued its anti-Civil Rights agenda, its Southern Strategy, its anti-Obama lies, and so on, on a MASSIVE scale. Yet it wants to pretend that all that's "excused" because of a tiny thing like the New Black Panthers--which has no influence whatsoever on the larger picture. Remind us again how many members the New Black Panthers have by comparison with the Tea Party? Care to turn that into a ratio?

The true hypocrites are disingenuous fools like 00:49. Keep marching to your Orwellian tunes, fascists.