Remarks in Support of Whistleblower Private Manning

by: Ray McGovern, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

Ray McGovern presented these remarks at Sunday's rally for Pfc. Bradley Manning, the soldier who allegedly leaked classified material to WikiLeaks. The rally took place in Quantico, where Manning is imprisoned. Although the Marines denied the protesters permission to hold the rally, they were overruled by Quantico Mayor Iris Tharp, who issued a permit for the event.

Lancing the Boil

We are living in a liminal time, that is to say, we live on the threshold. So much that we have taken for granted is passing.

In times like this, we must be careful to keep our bearings, lest we come to love the chaos that passes for reality.

This is why we need to honor our brother Bradley Manning. He was not afraid to face the unknown; not afraid to resist the seduction of conformity; not afraid to follow his conscience; AND not afraid to give us the wherewithal to distinguish truth from lies so that we, too, can follow our conscience.

The principalities and the powers, including the Fawning Corporate Media, have no hold on citizens like Private Manning, who refuse to live in a moral vacuum.

Bradley Manning dared to mock the falsity parading as reality after our country had a nervous breakdown as a result of 9/11 and the efforts of those who would use 9/11 to stoke our fear.

THAT false "reality" has lost its power because it cannot live in the light of truth.

"You shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free." THAT is the rock-solid truth.

I noticed that this Bible verse was chiseled into the marble wall of CIA Headquarters when I began working as an analyst there in April 1963. That was the same month that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. penned a "Letter From the Birmingham City Jail," including graphic, earthy words in describing our duty to expose deceit and injustice:

"Like a boil that can never be cured as long as it is covered up, but must be opened with all its pus-flowing ugliness to the natural medicines of air and light, injustice must likewise be exposed, with all of the tension its exposing creates, to the light of human conscience and the air of national opinion before it can be cured."

What Private Manning is alleged to have done with the help of WikiLeaks is to puncture that boil of injustice and deceit.

Our defense secretary and joint chiefs' chairman do not mind the blood on their hands - yes, on THEIR hands - not the hands of Manning or WikiLeaks. The Pentagon chiefs are but cogs in an imperial system; large-diameter cogs, but cogs nonetheless.

They have made their peace with the crimson red on their hands. What they do mind is the pus. Pus stinks - it stinks to high heaven and is more quickly smelled and pungent than blood.

We have no problem with Marines and soldiers who are taught to believe they must surrender their conscience to some kind of noble enterprise. We do have a BIG PROBLEM with those who send them off on missions that make the Charge of the Light Brigade look like a model of military planning.

Worse still, the gun-barrel video that WikiLeaks posted and titled "Collateral Murder" shows the degree to which our own soldiers have been brutalized by so-called Rules of Engagement that authorize them to brutalize others. Our secretary of defense had not one word of regret about the dozen human beings, including two employees of Reuters, murdered on that fateful day in July 2007 - or about the now-fatherless children who were seriously wounded.

It is THAT kind of thing that needs to be exposed. And it is that video that Private Manning is accused of giving to WikiLeaks.

The more recent WikiLeaks disclosures expose much more. Did most Americans know, for example, that Washington is giving one billion dollars a year of our tax money to Pakistan; and that Pakistan turns around and uses some of that money to train, equip and lead those who are killing our Marines and soldiers in Afghanistan? Do Americans understand that, as far as our supposed "ally" Pakistan is concerned, the main game is about keeping the Taliban strong, in order to ensure that India does not regain predominant influence in Afghanistan?

What WikiLeaks has released is documentary evidence of what is really going on - otherwise known as the truth. Pentagon and press protest the "granularity" of the documentary evidence. The appropriate word here is not "granularity" - the appropriate words are blood, fecklessness and the absence of any common sense, including moral sense, in the Pentagon and, sadly, in the White House.

We are here today to help Private Manning lance the boil and to do what we can to help the pus flow freely. We are here to give him encouragement to keep living humanly, as we are trying to do, among the fallen powers. We are here to say thank you and to tell Bradley Manning, loud and clear, "You are not alone. You are not alone."

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Ray McGovern works for Tell the Word, the publishing arm of the ecumenical Church of the Saviour in Washington, DC. He was an analyst at the CIA for 27 years, and is on the Steering Group of VIPS.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Manning is a hero. My brave

Manning is a hero.
My brave heroes are Bradley Manning, Suzanne Swift and Ehren Watada.



Amen! May others be

Amen! May others be encouraged by his example and do likewise if they have the capacity.



absolutely damn right. This

absolutely damn right.
This young man has given face and honor to the thousands of un- recognized civilian dead kept secret by this odious and secretive war machine . His courage allows for their 'collateral' deaths to be recorded, shines a light into the depth of the failure of imagination we now call american capitalism. Although really it should be called corporate fascism.



My dear Ray. Don't delude

My dear Ray. Don't delude yourself. Pfc. Bradley Manning, if he really did leak the data, was scared out of his young heroic mind. He probably was terrified because he knew he would be imprisoned if discovered or even possibly hanged.
I am very proud of his supporters and those who speak out for him but don't delude yourselves, his punishment will be severe and secret if possible.
Our responsibility is to not let him become yesterday's news and to not let the warmongers and profiteers make this sacrifice a waste. Expose the secrets and propaganda to sunlight.
Acknowledge Pfc. Bradley Manning was very afraid and engaged the real enemy anyway.
That is heroism.



And the New York Times ought

And the New York Times ought to be thoroughly ashamed of itself.



Thanks Ray. I can't say

Thanks Ray. I can't say anything to improve your article to show the WISE heroism that Brad stands for.

The weapons and the personnel of Uncle Sam are too massive, I doubt, to be thoroughly repelled by any country, but I honestly believe that Brad's action might cause a shift in the World's paradigm.

So many are the people all over the World that are so hungry for TRUTH, that if it began to flow from other sources of FACTS, it could possibly become a gusher' literally forcing governments to change for the better...not being able to repel its force of honesty.



Pfc. Bradley Manning is a

Pfc. Bradley Manning is a genuine hero, if he is the one who released the helicopter gun-camera video and/or the documents from the military and the State Department. The military will make an example of him to intimidate any others from emulating him, whether or not he actually re;eased the material.

The military wants to keep this material secret because it reveals that their soldiers are not the noble warriors fighting for a noble against an treacherous enemy, but are cowardly, bloodthirsty murderers killing people from the safety of their helicopter, that the war in a Iraq is a string of atrocities committed by Americans against unarmed people.

I await the revelations of State Department communications.

The only purpose of military and diplomatic secrecy is to keep from the American people and from friendly nations the vicious, corrupt and brutal nature of the US government and its military.



Will someone create a

Will someone create a blog-space where we could send our support to Mr.Manning? HE deserves to know that WE, all around the world, feel for him!



I must add my voice to

I must add my voice to support and praise for Bradley Manning and for Wikileaks and for all who continue to actively and vocally directly confront the US imperialist war machine which commits war crimes and genocide in the name of capitalist profits and the US way of life. It is important that people realize that Obama is as much the enemy as was Bush and that the time to put ourselves clearly on the side of the peoples in struggle around the world is well upon us. Further delay in hopes that the 'real Obama' will present himself and transform this country and world is a self-evident fantasy. A confrontation is brewing in this world between the forces of plundering capitalist imperialist and peoples seeking justice and self-determination for themselves and their nations. Bradley Manning and Wikileaks have taken their stand. They may pay dearly. The US government (in tbe form of the Obama regime) has issued its orders to allow the assassination of US citizens as well as all manner of spying and pre-emptive police actions against activists. Yes, we love life dearly but at what point is the kind of sacrifice Bradly has made -- perhaps a life sentence or a death sentence -- the cost of freedom, the cost of solidarity, the cost of human dignity? The Bradley Mannings and the Muntadhar al-Zaidis, i.e., those who believe and then act as if enough is enough (enough dead Iraqi babies, enough dead Afghan children, enough US interventions, occupations, and killing fields), are indeed heroes. May we all be likewise inspired to overcome our fear and to act. Solidarity NOW!



"The first casualty in war

"The first casualty in war is the truth."



Over the years I have always

Over the years I have always hoped that there would eventually be some honest retired politician who would write an expose on what goes on behind the scenes , the waste, corruption, the incompetence , the indifference in Washington , D.C. This country was founded by Patriots such as George Washington, Thomas Jefferson , Samuel Adams , Benjamin Franklin , Paul Revere , John Hancock ,John Adams , Alexander Hamilton , Nathan Hale , Thomas Paine , Patrick Henry , etc.who were willing to lay down their lives and personal fortunes in order to free us from British domination . They were true heroes as compared to our present groveling , self serving , greedy Traitors whose loyalties lie with and do the bidding of a near Eastern power rather than the American peoples.
How can any objective , intelligent , civilized human being turn his back on a 21 st century Holocaust that has been ongoing for the past 60 years .......NON STOP . The Palestinians have had 90 % of their lands and treasures stolen thru TERRORISM . They only have small arms and inaccurate short distance rockets compared to Israels WEAPONS of MASS DESTRUCTION supplied by the U.S. Taxpayer.

Duplicity , Treason and Murder
check out :
WWW.USSLIBERTY.ORG

Support our troops , what a joke !



P.S. forgot to add , yes

P.S. forgot to add , yes Bradly Manning is a true Patriot , who is concerned about the direction that this country is headed in compared to our bought and paid for political Ho's in Washington.



Definitely one of what

Definitely one of what appears to be quite a few true American heroes of this putrid decade. I salute you, Private Manning! He is in my list of what I consider to be true heroes. See if you agree/disagree:

Todd Beamer: passenger aboard United Airlines Flight 93 during the 9/11 terrorist attacks. After the plane hijacking, Beamer and some other passengers reportedly jumped the hijackers, leading to the premature crashing of the plane in a field in Shanksville, Penn. The plane is believed to have targeted either the Capitol Building or the White House. His last words were “Are you guys ready? Let’s roll.”

Capt. Chesley Sullenberger: After both engines of US Airways Flight 1549 were compromised by a flock of birds soon after takeoff on January 15, 2009 in New York City, “Sully” safely piloted the plane down in the Hudson River. All passengers and crew members survived.

Capt. Richard Phillips: After his MV Maersk Alabama was hijacked by four Somali pirates on April 8, 2009, Phillips was taken hostage by the pirates after a botched trade between his crew and the pirates, trading his safety to save his crew. Phillips was held in a lifeboat by the hostages and a standoff ensued between the Somalis and the US. Phillips was rescued a few days later. Three of the pirates were killed by Navy SEAL Team Six, and the fourth was captured.

Katharine Gun: former translator for the UK’s GCHQ who blew the whistle on illegal activities by the US leading up to the War in Iraq in ’03, saying that she acted to prevent imminent loss of life in a war she considered illegal. She was charged with an offence under section 1 of the Official Secrets Act 1989, but due to her cause célèbre status the prosecution dropped the case in ‘04. It is unclear why the case was dropped.

Sherron Watkins: VP of Corporate Development for Enron who inadvertently blew the whistle on her company’s fraudulent activities in August ‘01. This set off the first of many corporate scandals in America. (NOTE: Her e-mail, which began the scandal, was believed to be an internal e-mail to CEO Kenneth Lay warning him about whistleblowers inside Enron. Her e-mail was eventually discovered and Watkins was hailed as a whistleblowing hero.) Enron no longer exists.

Cynthia Cooper: VP of Internal Audit at WorldCom who, with her team, blew the whistle upon discovering $3.8 billion worth of fraud at her company in ‘02. At that time, this was the largest incident of accounting fraud in U.S. history. WorldCom no longer exists.

Dr. David Benke: Deer Creek Middle School math teacher who tackled gunman Bruco Eastwood during a school shooting in February 2010. Although two were wounded, no one was killed.

Rick Rescorla: former Vietnam veteran and security chief for Morgan Stanley who is credited with saving 2,700+ lives during the 9/11 WTC attacks, specifically Tower 1. Rescorla perished in the process.

Pfc. Bradley Manning: U.S. soldier who allegedly leaked classified material to WikiLeaks (see below). Manning is currently imprisoned at Quantico.

Julian Assange: Wikileaks founder, whose site blew the whistle on more than 90,000 records of incidents in July ‘10 on the US’ War in Afghanistan, including but not limited to far more civilian casualties (many involving children) than reported. In defending his site’s stance against a critical White house, Assange said his files showed that "thousands" of war crimes may have been committed in Afghanistan. At the time of this writing, Assange says he expects a huge increase in submissions by whistleblowers. This scandal is considered one of the largest leaks in US military history.

In light of these people, perhaps there may be a ray of hope for America after all.



Repeat after me: Bradley

Repeat after me: Bradley Manning, American Hero. Bradley Manning, American Hero. Bradley Manning, American Hero.



Dear Marble Rye: Please add

Dear Marble Rye: Please add to your list: Sibel Edmunds, FBI translator; Valerie Plame-Wilson, covert agent working to forestall proliferation of WMDs; Daniel Ellsberg, the guy who reminded us all why we Do the Right Thing.



Dear Anonymous on 8/10 at

Dear Anonymous on 8/10 at 5:36 - there is a place to help Bradley Manning; it's Courage to Resist.



Dear Anonymous on 8/10at

Dear Anonymous on 8/10at 2:50 - The New York Times? Ashamed? 'Remember Judith Miller?