The Self-Inflicted Wounds of 9/11
Saturday 11 September 2010
by: Melvin A. Goodman, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

(Image: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: Kim Erlandsen, The U.S. Army)
The attacks on Washington and New York City nine years ago extracted a terrible price in terms of blood and treasure. Unfortunately, the adverse US reaction to 9/11 has also extracted a terrible price with no end in sight. Although al-Qaeda is no longer a sophisticated terrorist organization capable of launching large-scale operations and is merely one of many jihadist groups based in Pakistan, the United States has thrown itself into the briar patch called Afghanistan.
Nearly twice as many Americans have died fighting wars in Iraq and Afghanistan than were lost in the 9/11 attacks. The total cost of these long wars will be in the trillions of dollars. When the United States invaded Iraq in 2003, the cost of oil was less than $25 a barrel; the price reached $140 a barrel in 2008 and, currently, the price is still three times the 2001 levels. The entire national security system has suffered as a result of the wrong-headed actions of the Bush administration in Iraq and the Obama administration in Afghanistan. The Iraq war marked the greatest travesty of all, based on a series of official lies that linked Saddam Hussein to Osama bin Laden and Iraq to weapons of mass destruction. As we knew seven years ago, there were no such links and no such weapons.
President Barack Obama declared last week that the US combat role in Iraq was over, but Americans continue to die in military action there, and 50,000 American servicemen and women will remain at least until the end of next year. President Obama inherited the war in Afghanistan, but last year he unwisely redefined and expanded it when he bowed to the demands of Secretary of Defense Robert Gates and the Pentagon to send more than 30,000 additional soldiers and Marines to Afghanistan. The president has defended this action as being part of the struggle against bin Laden and al-Qaeda, but we have been told authoritatively that there are only 50-100 al-Qaeda members in Afghanistan. In both wars, we have aligned ourselves with corrupt governments that are dysfunctional.
These wars have been used to dramatically increase the size of the defense and intelligence budgets, which find the United States now spending more than the rest of the world in both categories. The $708 billion defense budget for FY 2011 is higher than at any point in our post-World War II history. In constant dollars it is 16 percent higher than the 1952 Korean War budget peak and 36 percent higher than the 1968 Vietnam War budget peak. Secretary of Defense Gates argues that the budget plan "rebalances" spending by putting an emphasis on the near-term challenges of counterinsurgency, counterterrorism and stabilization operations, but the plan makes no effort to prioritize these near-term commitments against funding for long-term commitments. The Pentagon's role in so-called nation building assures continued high defense budgets, and already we hear demands for an increased military role in Yemen and Somalia.
Don’t miss a beat - get Truthout Daily Email Updates. Click here to sign up for free.
The defense budget is, in fact, out of control, increasing funding for both near-term and long-term programs and activities. Overall procurement spending would rise by nearly eight percent in the 2011 budget, buying virtually all of the equipment the services want. Historically, the costs to operate and maintain the US military tend to grow at about 2.5 percent a year. Not this year! The defense budget request for Operations and Maintenance is more than $200 billion, which represents an 8.5 percent increase. President Dwight David Eisenhower's warnings about the military-industrial complex and the need for commanders in chief who actually understand the Pentagon's clarion calls have never been more germane.
In addition to unprecedented military spending, the Pentagon has gained increased leverage over the $75 billion intelligence community as well as increased influence over the national security and foreign policies of the United States. As the State Department and the Central Intelligence Agency decline in influence, the Pentagon's role in intelligence, nation building and third world assistance grows significantly. The armed services committees of the Senate and House of Representatives have become sounding boards for the interests of the Pentagon, and the increased absence of military experience on the part of Congressional representatives contributes to an absence of oversight. No genuine Congressional oversight of the intelligence community has been conducted since 9/11, and the Obama administration has made sure that the only internal oversight process at the CIA, the Office of the Inspector General, cannot function in any meaningful way.
The unfortunate creation of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) in the wake of 9/11 has led to a more sclerotic policy process as well as the growth of contractors who have been a drain on the national treasury. DHS has weakened key government agencies.; it took Hurricane Katrina in 2005 to expose the bureaucratic mess at DHS. Spending on intelligence has tripled since 9/11, marking the rise of a national security state that finds all branches of government, even the judiciary, bowing to the demands of the military and intelligence communities. Like the Bush administration, the Obama administration used the state secrets privilege to block a lawsuit by former CIA prisoners who were tortured in overseas prisons.
We have had four directors of national intelligence in the past five years, and they have failed to correct the decline in strategic intelligence or strengthen the overall intelligence apparatus. The ability of the Nigerian "Christmas Day" bomber, who should have been a poster boy for the "No-Fly List," to board a commercial airline in December 2009 demonstrated the confused lines of authority in the intelligence community as well as the failure to learn lessons from 9/11. President Obama has so little confidence in the DNI and CIA that he did not even request a National Intelligence Estimate before making his wrong-headed decisions on Afghanistan. The intelligence community, moreover, has been unable to complete an estimate on Iran's nuclear program, which was promised nearly two years ago.
George Kennan wrote in his memoirs 60 years ago that it is the "shadows rather than the substance of things that move the hearts, and sway the deeds of statesmen." In his memoirs, Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara finally acknowledged that "wars generate their own momentum and follow the law of unanticipated consequences." Since 9/11, the national security process has been in a state of decline with a dearth of statesmen and an abundance of shadows on issues dealing with Iraq, Afghanistan, terrorism, insurgency and, now, cyber-war that are swaying the actions of American policymakers. President Eisenhower warned that the fears of the cold war were distorted and exploited for political advantage. Similar distortions have taken place in the wake of 9/11. As a result, we are on a glide path that has bankrupted US national security policy and threatens to bankrupt its treasury as well.

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
"...but we have been told
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 09:06 — Brien (not verified)"...but we have been told authoritatively that there are only 50-100 al-Qaeda members in Afghanistan." I was not aware of this. Source?
This is nonsense! It was an
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 10:56 — Anonymous (not verified)This is nonsense! It was an inside job pure and simple and what follows on has nothing whatsoever to do with fortune or al Qaeda- and everything to do with willful intent, murder, war of aggression - precisely what the Nazis were hanged for. The people are being taken for a ride.
Source for figure of 50-100
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 11:30 — kenneth Kinkade (not verified)Source for figure of 50-100 al Qaeda is CIA Director Leon Panetta
http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalpunch/2010/06/cia-at-most-50100-al-qaeda-in-afghanistan.html
This is what happens when
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 13:24 — Erich von Freemason (not verified)This is what happens when you elect Demublicans.
It is disturbing to hear
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 13:53 — Anonymous (not verified)It is disturbing to hear about the numbers of American deaths in the same breath as the price of gas. I'm beginning to hear this more often as the relentlessly repeated BIG LIE wears away at truth. There is generous evidence available showing that the "attacks" were in fact, self-inflicted, yet we still use that non-language generated by the criminals who now are in charge of not investigating themselves. Then it is boiled down to the most meaningless abstraction of : DOLLARS : having abstracted all real values from our awareness, we are presented with a bill...a dollar bill...a trillion dollar bill, which cannot repay anything, for it is no longer guaranteed or backed up by real values. A PRIVATELY OWNED Federal Reserve demands our real valuables (land, gold, silver,etc.) in exchange for these bad bills (I.O.U.s which are just non-refundable lottery tickets for the Great American Dream). But what has this to do with the TRADE towers? It's arigged game where the 1 % Winners-take-ALL.
Without the attacks of 9/11,
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 14:11 — Reg (not verified)Without the attacks of 9/11, there would have been no wars against Iraq or Afghanistan - the expressed goals of PNAC before 2001. The single issue NOT permitted as public discourse - even on the most progressive sites on the Internet - is the evidence that totally refutes the official account of the events of that fateful day. Not a single word is said about the collapse of Tower 7 (now rebuilt) - without the impact of any airplane. The truth has been totally suppressed, because the dialogue has been denied.
Has Truthout become a 9/11 myth hugger?
http://tvnewslies.org/tvnl/index.php/news/911-related/15871-911-myth-huggers-9-years-of-ignoring-the-evidence.html
I like the idea of the
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 14:42 — goobagooba (not verified)I like the idea of the "glide policy" introduced in this column. It rightfully and precisely defines the way our congress and presidencies have moved along nearly since the creation of the D.of I. Nobody up there is willing to take responsibility for their actions, their choices. Like kids with a gang mentality, assignment of actual responsibility is called "snitching," and whistle-blowers are rewarded with corporate penalties rather than the grateful thanks they deserve.
We are exhorted to toe a moral line by people who have no more sense of loyalty or higher purpose than the playground bully in order to be better exploited as citizens. We go along with this because it's inconvenient to fight back, or we're afraid of not being backed up by others who see things as we do.
This is not to say we don't feel the outrage. The trump cards against us are credit ratings, salaries, wages, taxes, and our willingness to allow others to define our limitations. Tearing down these walls is the only way out. That, and making sure those we entrust with decision-making know to whom they owe their position.
YES! But had the Bush scam
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 15:07 — Anonymous (not verified)YES! But had the Bush scam to pull off the invasion and thus be able to steal the Iraq oil as planned, we would have a tap on one of the largest sources of oil in the world. And all to ourselves! And the price of that oil would be under the control of our Petro-Greedheads! Now that's a thought. Now let's just guess what the current price of gasoline would be today.
Families In Denial Never
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 15:59 — Bill O'Rights (not verified)Families In Denial Never Heal until they admit that 'Uncle Bob really did molest little sister' and deal with that reality - and with Uncle Bob.
All three WTC Towers came down by controlled demolition - over 1200 Architects and Engineers of high repute have risked the scorn of the denying public to demand a new investigation due to this fact.
The above article is a farce to leave this out. Visit ae911truth dot org
Where did TO dig up the war machine paranoia apologist who wrote the above article? Hand wringing over military and intelligence inadequacies rather than calling out the whole thing as the fraud that it was and continues to be?
Very likely lower since
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 16:22 — Anonymous (not verified)Very likely lower since there wouldn't be any kind of war/economic disruption premium put on the cost by the pumpers, the shippers, the insurers. One thing we do know now is that gas is at least twice as much as before Bush* and at times three to four times as much depending on what Wall Street wants to speculate in at the moment.
911 was an inside job. check
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 18:40 — Anonymous (not verified)911 was an inside job. check out the videos. They are not passenger airplanes. Sheeple being programmed as usual.
"911 was an inside job.
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 21:11 — Rick Levy (not verified)"911 was an inside job. check out the videos. They are not passenger airplanes. Sheeple being programmed as usual."
So the people who died on those planes really didn't exist in the first place?
Exacerbating the tragedy,
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 21:14 — Vic Anderson (not verified)Exacerbating the tragedy, Obummer blunders on Furd-like in the Mayaguez "rescue" incident where more dupes were lost than the "victims" (who were safe all along). Manifest Insanity perpetuated into our Third MILLENIUM!
Yep, we should have just
Sat, 09/11/2010 - 23:45 — Anonymous (not verified)Yep, we should have just nuked the bastards and saved the money.
Whining about mistakes made
Sun, 09/12/2010 - 00:26 — Stalker (not verified)Whining about mistakes made nine years ago, while pointing fingers at the political demons of your choice solves nothing. We instead need to have a plan to go forward. Anyone who wastes our time trying to get elected by dinger pointing without offering solutions should be ignored. We need to get serious about who we elect instead of being side tracked by smoke and mirro campaign issues like abortion amd gun control. Untill we force our politicians to hold a conversation about their plans we will continue to scratch our heads an wonder how these guys got elected on the first place.
exactly, that was my problem
Sun, 09/12/2010 - 09:12 — Anonymous (not verified)exactly, that was my problem with McCain, he had nothing to say but his three cheat sheet full of what everybody else was doing. He still has nothing to say.
911 took a decade to plan so don't think for one second that Al-queda is not a live and well, they never were a sophisticated group and they don't need sophisticated people to blow themselves up. They achieved their goal by being very unsophisticated.
To Stalker: I couldn't
Sun, 09/12/2010 - 14:47 — elizabeth (not verified)To Stalker: I couldn't agree more about whining and the need instead to focus on solutions. However, I would argue that we cannot find appropriate solutions without learning from the lessons of the past. As Winston Churchill famously and correctly said: Americans will finally do the right thing after trying everything else several time over first. (My paraphrase.) Let's skip the reinventing the wheel part and figure out what worked, what didn't, and THEN move on to solutions. (Actually there are a lot of smart people who already know these things, but unfortunately TPTB and our Mockingbird-infected society tend to drown them out.)
9/11 was a vicious act of
Sun, 09/12/2010 - 21:16 — Alan8 (not verified)9/11 was a vicious act of right-wing DOMESTIC terrorism against American democracy by neocons, with a fascist agenda, which they've used this false-flag attack to achieve.
The 9/11 attacks were used to justify starting two wars, draining the Treasury for Bush's wealthy owners of the defense industries, murdering one million Iraqi civilians, and overturning the Constitution.
The evidence for controlled demolition of the three buildings on 9/11 is overwhelming.
A paper describing the military-grade nano-thermite found in the debris of all three buildings, used to demolish the three skyscrapers on 9/11, was published in a peer-reviewed physics journal:
Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe (http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM)
Molten steel found WEEKS after the collapses can only be explained by thermite charges used to demolish the buildings. (http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/moltensteel.html)
Over 1200 architects and engineers have pointed out the fact that the three skyscrapers collapsed like controlled demolitions, and NOT like from fires. (http://www.ae911truth.org/) ; These professionals are demanding a REAL investigation into the cause of the buildings' collapses on 9/11.
Exposing this big lie is the best way to wake the American people up to the corporate-fascist conspiracy to overturn American democracy for the benefit of the wealthy.
The corporate Democrats have joined the corporate Republicans in the coverup and the corporate media's fact-free ridicule of anyone who dares to question the Dick-Cheney version of what happened on 9/11. (Yet another reason to vote for the Green Party.)
We need to publicly call for a REAL investigation into this event.
Admiral Mullen declared that
Mon, 09/13/2010 - 10:53 — Anonymous (not verified)Admiral Mullen declared that the PENTAGON IS THREAT TO OUR NATIONAL SECURITY, because the Pentagons/spy agencies are funded with Treasury bond proceeds which fund the Federal deficit. Mullen declare that the national debt, which funds the Pentagon, is a threat to national security and it is the national debt which funds the Pentagon, thus making the Pentagon the threat to national security. This is shocking admission by Admiral Mullen who should know as he is head of the Pentagon. This staggering admission has not been rescinded by anyone, nor has it been reported.