Thousands Rally in DC in a More Diverse Counterpoint to Beck, Tea Party
Saturday 02 October 2010
by: Margaret Talev | McClatchy Newspapers | Report

The view from the Lincoln Memorial steps during the One Nation Working Together rally in Washington, DC. (Photo: ep_jhu)
Washington - Thousands of liberal and labor activists rallied in the nation’s capital on Saturday and in other U.S. cities, calling for young or disillusioned Democrats to vote in the November elections.
If conservative Fox commentator Glenn Beck’s late August rally invigorated tea party enthusiasts to vote for Republicans, many of those who turned out for the “One Nation Working Together” event saw it as their chance to shout back.
Rally participants were determined but appeared fewer in number than at Beck’s “Restoring Honor” event. Enrique Alvarado, 29, a student from Boston College, charged that tea party activists are “intolerant and racist,” and said, “This crowd is a much more diverse and representative crowd of people.”
MSNBC anchor Ed Schultz whipped up the midday crowd, from the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.
“The conservative voices of America, they’re holding you down!” Schultz shouted, calling them “forces of evil.” He said conservatives “talk about the Constitution but they don’t want to live by it. They talk about our forefathers but they want discrimination. They want to change this country.”
Schultz said progressive activists haven’t gotten all the policies they wanted in the first two years of the Obama administration, they were obliged to stand by the Democratic leadership. “This is no time to back down! We cannot give up on Nov. 2!”
“We can maintain the momentum, that is our challenge,” said civil rights activist Rev. Al Sharpton.
More than 400 organizations endorsed Saturday’s event, from gay rights groups to a DC voting rights coalition to the AFL-CIO and the SEIU. They promoted a grab-bag of causes from job creation and higher pay to universal health care, more public school funding, ending the war in Afghanistan, supporting Palestinians, giving illegal immigrants a path to citizenship and promoting civil rights protections for gays and Muslim-Americans and vegetarianism.
Soraya Gardner of Yardley, Pa., a union member, said she’s sick of “the racism, the tea party stuff.” She, her husband and her daughters stood with signs reading: “The Coffee Party: Wake up America!” and “Hey Glenn, We’re here. You’re not. Honor restored. You’re welcome.”
Peggy Brown, who lives in the Washington suburbs, said “Fox News, that’s about as bad as you can get” and that conservative personalities Beck, Sean Hannity and Rush Limbaugh “preach and spew out hate” and have “brainwashed” Americans.
“Are you smarter than a half-term governor?” read the poster Cornelius Boss of Columbus, Ohio, was carrying, taped to a toilet seat along with a photo of ex-Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin.
Matthew Leber, a member of the University of Massachusetts teachers' association, said he was rallying out of concern for his four granddaughters’ future. Their father lost his job nearly two years ago.
“The government needs to give incentives, tax breaks and whatever it takes for people to get back to work and stop giving tax breaks to the rich,” Leber said.
Ellen Zablow, who travelled with her husband, Len, from New York, said: “We’re here because we want peace. We want the soldiers brought back from the war. We have children and grandchildren, and we fear that fascism is coming back.”
Harold Beatty of Wilmington, N.C., president of his local NAACP chapter led a group of 52 demonstrators. “We are here to support the change that the president asked for during his campaign,” he said.
Elizabeth Gutierrez, 18, of Charlotte, N.C., was among an immigrant rights group marching, blowing whistles and chanting, “Yes to education.” One man in the group carried a sign that declared, “We are America’s Future,” and declined an interview request, saying, “I don’t speak English.”
Some rally participants including Makayla Reed, 16, of Ellsworth, Maine, are considering returning at month’s end for the satirical “Rally to Restore Sanity” and “March to Keep Fear Alive,” event being staged by Comedy Central hosts Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert. Others saw the Stewart-Colbert rally as more of a publicity stunt that could distract for turnout efforts the weekend before the election.
(Yewon Connie Kang and Catherine Ngai of the Medill News Service contributed to this report. The news service is a Washington program of the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University. Kang and Ngai are graduate students at Medill.)
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Diminish Obamanible
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 09:27 — Vic Anderson (not verified)Diminish Obamanible INSANITY, indeed!
MSNBC, that ol'progressive
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 10:50 — Hemp Schwarzenegger (not verified)MSNBC, that ol'progressive news outlet. Good lord, is anyone vomiting yet? Progressives have received almost nothing from this Republican Administration. Voters have a few good choices on November 2, very few. Some votes will go to incumbent hacks who will be in office until they die. And a rare good guy may lose office - Feingold
That's Democracy in Am'urica! War forever!
The importance of the
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 13:09 — Rod Random (not verified)The importance of the Saturday rally can't be exaggerated. It represents the beginning (I hope not also the end) of a consensus social-democratic movement with the goals of which everyone on the Left should be able to agree. It also represents the hope of a continuing progressive movement during the dark night of the coming Republican dictatorship.
Sadly, the reporting has been all about the numbers. These, while impressive, were less than they might have been because of a) the contempt felt by the petty-bourgeois "netroots" for working people and b) the insularity of the labor unions (the major force in guaranteeing the turnout), which resulted in their making little or no attempt to reach out to potential sympathizers among the Netroots.
If you were there for even an hour during the five hours of speeches many of which were electrifying, or if you spoke in depth as I did with rank-and-file attendees and event organizers, you know how special this rally was and what potential it holds for a new-model Left movement in this country. It just dissolved boundaries that everyone has assumed for years were permanent.
The thing that will BURY the
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 13:58 — billnbillieskid (not verified)The thing that will BURY the Democrats in November is APATHY! Get OUT and VOTE for SANITY and REASON. Do NOT let the regressives win. Your children will live to regret it. Do you REALLY want to extend the retirement age to 70 or 75? Vote Republican! Do you want to see the END of Social Security? Vote Republican! Do you want to see Tax Breaks for the filthiest of the RICH? Vote Republican! Are you CRAZY? Vote Republican!
Take me for granted,
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 14:46 — Anonymous (not verified)Take me for granted, Democrats, and I'll make you pay. While I have utter disdain for much of the GOP's current platform, I have no interest in rewarding inert , ineffectual Democrats. The last 2 years has felt like a clusterfuck, and I'm starting to think that it makes more sense to sit this election out and let the GOP back in. The Democrats who oppose the GOP in 2012 and beyond will hopefully be a fresh band of upstarts who won't be afraid of their own shadows. Hopefully. In the meantime, I have little interest in rewarding this current group of do-nothings with continued "public service." Thanks for nothing. Don't let the door hit you on the way out.
It is unfortunate that we
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 15:07 — Marc Shapiro (not verified)It is unfortunate that we are being balckmailed by the Democratic party. " Caught between the rock and the hard place" The democrats want our support in spite of the fact that in the last two years they took our mandate and dumped in in the garbage. They don't even have the courage now to tell us categorically that they will make good on
any of their promises from two years ago, if we should return them to power. The only reason they give us to support them is to ward off
what the republicans would do if we don not.
The "health care bill", though it has many needed required changes in the way insurance companies do business, is, in the final analysis just more of the same. Instead of providing for health and health care, it gives
us insurance that is inadequate at prices that we will not be able to afford. In the time since it's enactment five million more Americans have lost access to health care.
The banks should have been allowed to fail
The money provided to them would have gone a long way toward putting the society back together.
We continue the failed policies of Greenspan.
We exclude much of the real cost of living, like government an d war and health care from calculations of inflation, and then we say we have none. The banks hold and lend a trillion dollars of our money an pay virtually nothing for it, while making record profits from its use.
Since those who run the FED are beholden only to the banking industry, you can count on it[s actions to enrich the banks while the rest of the society goes to hell.
The republicans presented how they would continue to destroy our society if we should be foolish enough to, again, give them control.
It is unfortunate that the democrats don't have the guts to tell us ANYTHING GOOD that they will do if we return them to power!
Perhaps, it is their intention to continue the
BUSH policies as they have done 'till now, if we give them our votes,
Representative democracy can only work if informed voters are given a choice. We are, unfortunately a long way from there!
EVERY AMERICAN VOTER NEEDS
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 15:07 — photojack53 (not verified)EVERY AMERICAN VOTER NEEDS TO SEE THESE TWO WEBSITES BEFORE THE ELECTION!
http://politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/rulings/promise-kept
This vital site and the facts it posts won the 2009 Pulitzer Prize, so the information is indisputable. 6 pages with about 20 promises kept on each one, and of such diversity and foresight, you know Obama's accomplishments in less than 2 years far outweigh what little Bush accomplished in 8! Bush, Cheney and Rove actually DAMAGED our country and its relations abroad! WAKE UP AMERICA and VOTE OUT THESE EVIL REPUBLICANS!
http://dccc.org/page/content/accomplishments
This crucial website shows how much all the Democrats accomplished to get our nation out of the quagmire the Republicans left us in:
http://dccc.org/page/content/accomplishments
And most of those crucial issues were won over the blocking, filibustering and negativity of REPUGNICANS!
REMEMBER, THE REPUGNICANS NEARLY CAUSED THE RUINATION OF OUR NATION!
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 18:09 —
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 15:10 — Erich Von Freemason (not verified)Sun, 10/03/2010 - 18:09 — Rod Random (not verified)
"It also represents the hope of a continuing progressive movement during the dark night of the coming Republican dictatorship."
As opposed to the dark night of a Democratic dictatorship? Those are our only two real choices until the US wakes up to the fact that our two parties' only fight is over who gets to control us. And, even if the progressives somehow manage to get enough votes to fill the elected seats, we'll end up with the dark night of a progressive dictatorship, as the progressive movement is all about more laws controlling what we can and can't do. The only real alternative was the Libertarian party, but then it was marginalized by the influx of Republicans.
You're just dead wrong. My
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 15:51 — @Ehrich von Arschloch (not verified)You're just dead wrong.
My whole premise is that independent, broad-based social democratic movement with strong ties to labor must form and flourish within a progressive framework, but with a power base outside the control of either political party. Hence my joy at the potential revealed by Saturday's rally.
As a matter of fact, Obama is not now actually (or not yet) a dictator, and he is not going to become one if he wins re-election in two years. This doesn't mean we aren't under the thumb of an oligarchy or that the powers of the president aren't getting scarier. On the contrary, that's why an independent social-democratic movement is so important.
The Tea Party, on the other hand, represents the final stage in a takeover of the Republican party by a totalitarian element that came close to establishing an overt, literal dictatorship under Bush II. They will certainly go the remaining distance if placed in a position of power comparable to that occupied by Bush II.
These people are the literal heirs of the degenerate Jacksonian tradition once embodied in the Ku Klux Klan. They will stop at nothing.
If you don't understand the strategic difference between the two, then God help you.
Nope, don't really see any
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 18:27 — Mount Weathermen (not verified)Nope, don't really see any difference between Max Baucus and John Boehner when it comes down to key votes. They'll vote for and against anything simply for posterity, once they've determined what the status quo wants to pass or fail.
Barely one or two people in the entire Senate will ever actually threaten Defense Spending.
We're still at war in two countries while many in the former middle class bleed debt ans have a seriously threatened financial future. Enjoy the illusion of Democracy if you must.
I was told that
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 18:42 — lilmytmax (not verified)I was told that several"Americans for Communism"groups attended this rally.Can anyone straighten this out for me?
Democrats and Republicans
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 19:18 — Anonymous (not verified)Democrats and Republicans are both unpatriotic if we evaluate by results of what they have done to this country. They have wrapped themselves in flags while hijacking the constitution, government responsibility, amassing $millions for themselves and burying us in $trillions of debt due to wars and swindles. WAKE UP AMERICA AND SHOO THE BANDITS.... Find and support someone like Ralph Nader who can stand to CEOs, board members and lying, cheating politicos...
Absolutely, even right wing
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 19:32 — Jimmy Crickets (not verified)Absolutely, even right wing idiots realize a Communist country is completely outproducing us and beating us at Capitalism, we insist they don't do what we've done forvere with currency. What a joke, teabaggers heads will explode when they realize the US is in 2nd or 3rd place. Meanwhile, better ideas need to see the light of day.
Communism, did I hear right?
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 20:02 — Dave (not verified)Communism, did I hear right? That old scare back again? Please, you must be a hundred years old, and part of the old Republican party.
The people who attended this
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 21:05 — LisaX (not verified)The people who attended this rally--union members, environmental activists, peace advocates, NAACP members, etc.--are the true heirs to MLK's dream of diversity and social justice.
By contrast, Beck's stunt represented nothing but self-aggrandizement and monochromatic backwardness.
Obama is Corporate lackey
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 23:03 — Tom martin (not verified)Obama is Corporate lackey like never seen in the history of the human race.
The Democrats lead by Obama sell this amazing story that they hate corporations - yet they gave the largest bail outs in human history. Hey the Dems won Congress in 2006 so EVERY bail out bill is theirs, fact is democrats are totally the responsib. They also worked hard to crush any honest look into the FEderal reserve so they can keep printing money and giving it to their low friends in high places with zero accountability -- nice job.
Here is a link to the
Mon, 10/04/2010 - 08:29 — Anonymous (not verified)Here is a link to the official website of One Nation Working Together listing the endorsing organizations. It looks like a good, diverse group of people including The General Board of Church and Society-The United Methodist Church. So overall not revolutionary. No armed militias or anything like that. Link:
http://action.onenationworkingtogether.org/index.php/partners/
Nice try, 04:03, but why is
Mon, 10/04/2010 - 08:49 — Anonymous (not verified)Nice try, 04:03, but why is it the Republican-appointed members of the Supreme Court decided in favor of unlimited corporate spending in the Citizens United case? Why is it that the Dems are seeking disclosure of campaign donations while the Thugs are blocking it? Why is it that Big Oil gives far more to GOP candidates? Why is it that the GOP wants to retain tax cuts for Fat Cats but the Dems want to go back to Clinton-era levels? Why is it that economists on both sides supported the bailouts? I suppose you would have enjoyed a Second Great Depression? Your "theories" are more than flawed; they're full of it.
If that's the best you can
Mon, 10/04/2010 - 09:53 — Anonymous (not verified)If that's the best you can offer, 13:49, Democrats are indeed doomed - go back to Clinton and his bombing of Iraq and sanctions, his destruction of Glass-Steagall, through the gutless abdication of leadership by Democrats in attacking Iraq and Afghanistan, the complete treason of not bringing the Bush Administration to trial for war crimes, through the Obama lies and failures on health care, the economy, putting people back to work and in school, and the continuation of endless war, and the Democrats have little to nothing to offer. You ask a lot of questions, but have no answers, just like a typical Democrat.
And what do you have to
Mon, 10/04/2010 - 12:44 — Anonymous (not verified)And what do you have to offer, 14:53? A Republican government owned by billionaires and serving the interests of billionaires? Or perhaps the mirage of a non-viable third party? Or just bile and simplistic, armchair-QB accusations? Regardless, it's nothing that will help anyone in the real world.
Sun, 10/03/2010 - 20:51 —
Mon, 10/04/2010 - 17:56 — Erich von Freemason (not verified)Sun, 10/03/2010 - 20:51 — @Ehrich von Arschloch (not verified)
"My whole premise is that independent, broad-based social democratic movement with strong ties to labor must form and flourish within a progressive framework, but with a power base outside the control of either political party."
What does that even mean? Does it mean that you will have fewer restrictions on what you can legally do? No, it means more laws restricting your freedom. Does it mean that the right to own that which you produce will be restored? No, it means that other people will decide who owns that which you produce. Does it mean that you will decide what to do with your property? No, it means that self-serving politicians and
bureaucrats will make those decisions. Look at any country that has a ruling party with the word "social" or "progressive" in its name... people are no more than ants in an anthill, living merely to serve the state. The more positive rights that people have, the more people must be forced to provide those things that everybody has a right to.
People are gullible and will vote for anybody who promises a free lunch. Nobody realizes that they will not be GETTING the free lunch, they will be PROVIDING it, at gunpoint if necessary.
Read, "The Gulag Archipelago," by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (this should be required reading in all high schools). Read, "The Road to Serfdom," by Friedrich von Hayek. Think about the fact that, after reading "The Road to Serfdom,"Solzhenitsyn praised Hayek for his incredibly accurate portrayal of what it's like to live in a socialist country, and, most importantly, his logical demonstration that socialist countries must end in dictatorships. If people have mandatory health care, you will be forced to provide it. If people have a mandatory "living wage," you will give up your income to
provide it. You will be forced to provide whatever it is that people have a right to have, and the list of things that are rights will grow without end.
The "freedom" glorified by
Tue, 10/05/2010 - 08:41 — Anonymous (not verified)The "freedom" glorified by Ayn Rand types is that of billionaires to pollute the planet and to buy governments that write the legislation they want. As de Tocqueville warned us, a new aristocracy will arise in America through industry. And so it has. The result of plutocratic right-wing ideology is impoverishment of the masses and concentration of wealth in the hands of a tiny minority--exactly what we've seen in America. And that's why people in Western Europe, where the Right is much weaker, enjoy a higher standard of living than do those in the U.S.
Yes, standards of living are
Tue, 10/05/2010 - 09:05 — LisaX (not verified)Yes, standards of living are higher in Western Europe and also in Canada, Australia, and Japan. It's not like it's a choice between pure capitalism or the Soviet Union! (Well, duh.) There are infinite shades of gray--and many nations have found a better balance between free enterprise and social democracy than we have. The important thing is to prioritize how we want to use our resources. For instance: Instead of spending so much on the military and funding utterly misguided invasions based on lies, as with Iraq, we should invest in universal healthcare like so many other countries have--including the ones with higher standards of living than our own.
Tue, 10/05/2010 - 13:41 —
Tue, 10/05/2010 - 16:49 — Erich Von Freemason (not verified)Tue, 10/05/2010 - 13:41 — Anonymous (not verified)
You totally misunderstand Rand (tho I'm not a fan... more of a libertarian). Respecting property rights means that, in order to pollute your land, a company would FIRST have to get your permission and negotiate compensation. There would be no point in buying the government because the government would have no power to rig the game in their favor. What you are describing is the current Democrat/Republican system, where money can get you the legislation you want and the people dying in Cancer Alley (google it) have no recourse against companies that are killing them, as the companies all have EPA permits.