Too Little Too Late for Haiti? Six Sobering Points
Saturday 16 January 2010
by: Bill Quigley, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

(Photo: United Nations Development Programme / Flickr)
Point One. $100 Million - Are You Kidding Me?
President Obama promised $100 million in aid to Haiti on January 14, 2010. A Kentucky couple won $128 million in a Powerball lottery on December 24, 2010. The richest nation in the history of the world is giving Powerball money to a neighbor already suffering tens of thousands of deaths?
Point Two. Have You Ever Been Without Water?
Hundreds of thousands of people in Haiti have had no access to clean water since the quake hit. Have you ever been in a place that has no water? Have you ever felt the raw fear in the gut when you are not sure where your next drink of water is going to come from? People can live without food for a long time. Without water? A very short time. In hot conditions people can become dehydrated in an hour. Lack of water puts you into shock and starts breaking down the body right away. People can die within hours if they are exposed to heat without water.
Point Three. Half the People in Haiti Are Kids, and They Were Hungry Before the Quake
Over half the population of Haiti is 15 years old or younger - and they were hungry before the quake hit. A great friend, Pere Jean-Juste, explained to me that most of the people of Haiti wake every day not knowing how they will eat dinner. So, for most, there were no reserves, no soup kitchens, no pantries, nothing. Hunger started immediately.
Point Four. A Toxic Stew of Death Is Brewing
Take hundreds of thousands of people. Shock them with a major earthquake and dozens of aftershocks. Take away their homes and put them out in the open. Take away all water and food and medical care. Sit them out in the open for days with scorching temperatures. Surround them with tens of thousands of decaying bodies. People have to drink. So they are drinking bad water. They are getting sick. There is no place to go. What happens next?
Point Five. Aid Is Sitting at the Airport
While millions suffer, humanitarian aid is sitting at the Port au Prince airport. Why? People are afraid to give it out for fear of provoking riots. Which is worse?
Point Six. Haiti Is Facing a Crisis Beyond Our Worst Nightmares
"I think it is going to be worse than anyone still understands," Richard Dubin, vice president of Haiti shipping lines, told The New York Times.
He is so right. Unless there is a major, urgent change in the global response, the world may look back and envy those tens of thousands who died in the quake.
Wake up world!

This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
How about redeeming ones
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 13:39 — Anonymous (not verified)How about redeeming ones self by giving some of the HUGE bonus money to Haiti?
$700 Billion last month, $33
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 14:17 — Anonymous (not verified)$700 Billion last month, $33 Billion more this month? Are you f$%king kidding me?
Upon announcing the $100
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 14:35 — marcywrite (not verified)Upon announcing the $100 million in support to Haiti, President Obama was instantly criticized from the left for doing too little, and from the right for doing too much. He's doing far more than the Bush Admin. did during its eight years -- despite the fact that humanitarian aid is a powerful tool in building international alliances (something Dubya didn't care about in the least). I'm just waiting to hear what Rush and Bill and Newt and their ilk will have to say on Monday morning, now that the President has enlisted former presidents Clinton and Bush to head up the Clinton Bush Haiti Fund. Stop carping, everyone, and start behaving compassionately -- THAT is what Americans are supposed to do!
No, Bill, the first and last
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 15:31 — Anonymous (not verified)No, Bill, the first and last infuriating point is that AID IS SITTING ON THE GROUND AT THE AIRPORT and has been for days. USAID is said to be in charge, but the timidity of the response is all too reminiscent of that we saw following Katrina. Who is the "heckofa-job-Brownie" responsible for the outrage in this case?
TV pictures have shown the national palace grounds still empty of survivors. It has a defensible perimeter with a high fence through which survival supplies could be issued. A Doctors Without Borders unit had to be abandoned last night for security reasons, but the palace is a central location where they and other medical units could be secured with the 220 airborne troops sitting at the airport for 3 days now.
As I write this, Joe Biden is stating on TV why immediate help has not been possible but touting the wondrous help that's yet to come. The Air Force 4-star general in Washington was still calling for Haitians to be patient Friday night. And why are Haitians not allowed in the UN medical treatment facility?
Where is the innovative thinking that could have started aid flowing from the airport as it arrived?? Why not parallel bucket brigades passing aid hand-to-hand for miles? So what if a truck full of supplies causes a riot if the aid does in fact get distributed?
As with the Katrina aftermath, I am seething with anger that there is not one kickass, damn-the-torpedoes leader making things happen in Haiti. As much as I supported Obama early on, he should have made sure there was someone like that in charge.
$100 million, chump change,
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 16:13 — Hempwinch (not verified)$100 million, chump change, then send in the military to enforce martial law because there is not enough relief to go around? What a chump!
Could this have anything to do with Haiti, walking out of the Copenhagen talks? We all know that Copenhagen wasn't about "saving the earth" or arresting climate change, moreover "Empirical Design"
What a chump indeed!
We are not the richest
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 16:14 — Anonymous (not verified)We are not the richest nation in the world. We are rapidly becoming a Third World country. I spent all of December and this much of January attempting to purchase anything . . . yes, anything . . . not made in China. Usually I come home empty handed.
If the political and business leaders of this country think that we can continue to produce nothing and import everything without our economy sinking deeper and deeper into debt and the American people becoming poorer by the day, then those leaders need to have their heads examined. Or rather their bank accounts to see where the bribes are coming from.
First and foremost all my
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 16:29 — windskull (not verified)First and foremost all my prayers to the people of Haiti, now Mr Quigley, as you can see from www.xe.com the currency exchange rate is 1 Haiti Gourdes = 0.0251572 US (for those whose abacus does not register that`s 2&1/2 cents American equalling 1 Hatian Gourdes)Which means corruption not withstanding one US Dollar goes a long LONG way in the hands of a Haitian citizen and though you choose not to see this President Obama fully understands $100 Million US Dollars translates to 1/4 Billion infusion to Haitian infrastructure
a Powerball lottery on
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 16:39 — Nori Muster (not verified)a Powerball lottery on December 24, 2010.
Sorry, but it's only January.
Please stop dis'ing the president. Your editorial is so one-sided, it sounds like something I would write. You're the professionals! Don't use your position of power to pull our president down, okay? I am a left left lefty and I still support him. What can he do by himself? We have to pave the way for him. We are the People and if we want power, we should start to act powerful.
The $100 million is on top
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 17:04 — Mishma (not verified)The $100 million is on top of at least a half a billion dollars and more spent in mobilizing the US armed services which are on the ground and rendering aid as I type. This type of editorializing gives the left a bad name and is as slanted as any diatribe that the right can come up with. Truth out purports to tell the whole truth when in fact the writers leave out an awful lot of the story.
Slight error in Microsoft`s
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 17:16 — windskull (not verified)Slight error in Microsoft`s calculator there Mr Quigley that translates to 1/4 TRILLION,(250 Billion)Haitian Gourdes
Half the people of Haiti are
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 17:45 — Anonymous (not verified)Half the people of Haiti are children? Then, taking ten years as the average age of a child, the population of Haiti has doubled in the last ten years. I do not dispute this, I merely wish for this fact to sink in.
Population control can be a matter of rational human action delivered by family planning and medical services, or it can be effected by Mother Nature. Mother Nature is ruthless, but ultimately it is going to be done her way. At bottom, the massive wholesale destruction of this planet is driven by overpopulation of humans. Haiti, desperately overpopulated, is a vision of the future for all the rest of us.
The earthquake only served to deliver this news in an emphatic way. And, no, Mother Nature does not need to be fair. If the population of Haiti was limited to a number which could be sustained by that small island, there would have been merely thousands of people affected, not millions. They would have had resources and space and a margin for survival of this or any other disaster. Who is standing in the way of family planning? How dare they wish this future on anyone?
what kills me about this
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 17:47 — Anonymous (not verified)what kills me about this 'what can the president do by himself?' crap is that when bush was in office all we heard was 'what can we do he's the president he can do whatever he wants' and he DID do whatever he wanted for the most part. now its obama and we get this 'he can't do it all alone, WE have to empower him' and everyone acts like: oh poor obama is trying but he's only one guy...yeah...one guy who CHOSE to surround himself with suspiciously 'disempowering' people. why is it that we can't help people in dire need as well as we can bomb the sh*t out of them when ever it suits us?! somebody with some play in this situation needs to take the bull by the horns and get the supplies to those who need it!!
We are not the richest, only
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 17:49 — Hempwinch (not verified)We are not the richest, only the most incarcerated.
We have more people in prison, than any other industrial Nation. The real dark side of this? More American goods are made in U.S. prisons than any time else in our history. Want American made? Buy prison goods!
As for the exchange rate between Haiti and the U.S. was the $100 million in cash, or goods and service's? Big difference.
No Port, half a airport and
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 19:31 — Bill (not verified)No Port, half a airport and no roads what would you like then to do. When things get as bad as they are in Haiti nothing can work fast enough. The UN gave 10 mil wow. More money will come but first you have clear the roads to move whats there. Sadly there are no easy ways.
Wrong. If every Haitian
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 19:44 — Anonymous (not verified)Wrong. If every Haitian Gourde is worth 2-1/2 US cents, then 100,000,000 USD = 4 billion HG.
Thank you for the article,
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 19:55 — SOA watcher and fan of bill Q (not verified)Thank you for the article, Bill. As usual, you try to spur our leaders on to do the right thing.
To put the cost in perspective of sending $100 million to Haiti, compare that it costs $100 million to keep 100 soldiers in Afghanistan for a year. The US spends $3.6 billion per month in Afghanistan, according to Congressional Research Service, and that price tag will go up after the 68,000 troop infusion. In other words, the US goes through $100 million in only a few days in Afghanistan.
The US gives Israel $2.5 BILLION per month.
$100 million is the cost of ten 2 BR 2.5 bath townhouses in Boston.
$100 Million is a mere pittance.
It is nonsense like this
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 20:13 — Anonymous (not verified)It is nonsense like this that makes me despair for Truthout (this is opinion rather than truth) and for liberals in general. Haiti was the poorest Nation in the Northern Hemisphere before the quake. They are a predominantly Catholic French-speaking country founded by former slaves and through most of their history they have been ruled by corrupt dictators. To work in Haiti one has to tread carefully because this is a country where corruption and death squads operate openly. This essay is like something from a left-wing Glenn Beck. Surely you can do better than this.
The richest country in the
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 21:06 — Rodrian Roadeye (not verified)The richest country in the world has no money to give. It will not give it's own poor needed high quality healthcare. Yet it is amazing that it can create suffering by allowing it's armed forces to continually add crippled enemy combatant and US veterans to an overtaxed humanitarian aid healtcare sytem as well as destroy families and brilliant minds with Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome. The cost to maintain the affluence of the global privileged few comes unfortunately with a very high price tag for the rest of the world. And the band played on.
If you really want to aid
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 21:19 — Anonymous (not verified)If you really want to aid the Haitians, the best way is NOT to buy a product that will contribute a dollar to the relief effort unless you really need it. Forgo the purchase altogether and donate that purchase money instead. That is where true giving lies.
I donated to Partners In
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 21:28 — Mark E. Smith (not verified)I donated to Partners In Health/Zanmi Lasante http://www.pih.org/where/Haiti/Haiti.html
PIH has been working in Haiti for 20 years and were among the first responders because they were already on the ground. Today their team was designated by WHO to coordinate the public health hospital services.
The US also has a history in Haiti, but one of oppression, not of helping.
What an incredible gift from
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 21:49 — chuck38 (not verified)What an incredible gift from the heart!!! Blessings to you both!!! What a win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win-win!!!!
Most of the "aid" "given" to
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 22:04 — 74oldman (not verified)Most of the "aid" "given" to Haiti, in whatever form it takes, will be squandered on the unnecessary and wasted on those that have while those who need and have not sontinue to die. Read your history, man. Any actual money that is offered will be at least 50% grafted away from the pile before it leaves this country. Preds. VP, Congress, Red Cross, UN, etc. etc. All talk no action. Just ike the "aid" to New Orleans IN OUR OWN COUNTRY just sat and rotted. The buildings unused and wasted, the monies disappearing as fast as it materialized, and those in need are continuing to be in need today, YEARS after the fact. Read your history. Over one million will die in Haiti. There is no solution because nobody really cares about haiti but Haitians and they are either filthy rich and out of the country or the poorest, most pitiable people in the western hemisphere and living in haiti where they will surely die. Thqt is the true horro of it. There is really nothing we can do on a gradn scale except grieve.
PRF
. . . as far as Bush, he was
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 22:04 — Nori Muster (not verified). . . as far as Bush, he was a demagogue and our country was under a dictatorship during the Bush/Cheney administration. President Obama is not a dictator, so he needs popular support to get things done.
Also, my apologies to Bill Quigley, sometimes blogging gets a little rough & tumble. You raise a lot of good points. But again, we are the liberals. If we devolve into a little snit fit because we are not getting everything we want from Obama, our fighting amongst ourselves drags down our momentum.
Searchers and recovery
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 22:15 — dtroutma (not verified)Searchers and recovery people were in pretty quickly. Food and water deliveries, with NO roads essentially left open, finally got going when rotary wing aircraft arrived. It is STILL difficult to distribute materials.
The simple fact that we still are providing aid and comfort to Haiti, in less time than "Bush administration" folks managed after Katrina- shows improvement. And Obama isn't pulling SEABEES out of the disaster area (like in Mississippi) where they were helping; to send them to Iraq.
I'm outrage at the
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 23:18 — Anonymous (not verified)I'm outrage at the excruciating morbid response from the US led coalition.
Unbelievable that they deliberately would not air drop food/water for the starving Haitians. This is the least that could have been done to prevent more death. I'm appalled at our leaders who are great at promising stuff but I'm outrage at our mainstream media for re-regurgitating this "US-AID" propaganda.
I'm sure in the end Haiti will as it as done for the last 200 yrs is to pay back it's foreign masters
Prior to the earthquake,
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 00:36 — iopakerbeth (not verified)Prior to the earthquake, there were, according to US military sources, some 60 US military personnel in Haiti. From one day to the next, an outright military surge has occurred: 10,000 troops, marines, special forces, intelligence operatives, etc., not to mention private mercenary forces on contract to the Pentagon.
A growing number of folks
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 07:55 — Skip Londos (not verified)A growing number of folks are expressing their solidarity and concern for our Haitian friends by fasting and donating the money saved to one or more of the credible charitable organizations working in Haiti.
I think it's a wonderful idea -- practically, economically, and spiritually. More information about the Fast for Haiti to Raise $ for Aid can be found at http://culturechange.org/go.html?592. It's is a "new" way for the average person to be able to afford to donate to an urgent, essential cause.
One of the important points
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 08:51 — Curt (not verified)One of the important points to remember for those that blame Haiti for its poverty is that the cause of the poverty is not Haiti, and one of the important points to remember for those that describe the violence and death squads is that Haitians did not suddenly create these squads. Once Haiti freed itself from France the international community imposed impossible debts on the country, and then the US stepped in with their neoliberal methods to plunder the population for cheap factory laborers and to destroy Haiti's agricultural base. When Haiti finally overthrew its dictator and elected a democratic government things started to get better, the US deposed the president by force and installed a new dictator, because the factory workers started to expect a $2 a day wage from those US owned businesses. Haiti (in fact the entire island of Hispanola) has been plundered from day 1 and it is the West and the elites there installed and supported by the West that are doing the plunder, and not only is this plunder responsible for the poverty of Haitians, it is indirectly responsible for the huge death toll. WE destroyed Haiti's agricultural base and forced all those people off farms and into the capital where they were forced to build houses on top of each other to have shelter. The US has proven it can use it's military to instill martial law in 8 hours in Haiti by it's past actions, and now we've sent a measly $100M and we're whining that we can't get aid in? I'll buy that when I see a flock of pigs fly over. If you're really interested in the truth, read http://www.truthout.org/article/noam-chomsky-the-tragedy-haiti
Bill Quigley is
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 11:06 — Nick Mottern (not verified)Bill Quigley is knowledgeable, fair-minded and absolutely on point. He deserves thanks for pointing out what is really happening in a situation in which all of us will be judged by what we do.
1/2 haitians are kids->
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 11:22 — Anonymous (not verified)1/2 haitians are kids-> where is the catholic & others whose churches are so wealthy w/ 'fake concern'while their white bosses rule w/ economic slavery--the two are of the same coin.
Try selling all your fantastic Vatican treasures & jewels & returning the funds to the people you steal from & brainwash to being slaves...
Wake up you pathetically
Sun, 01/17/2010 - 13:50 — Arminius Aurelius (not verified)Wake up you pathetically stupid white honkies !
Why is it that a country like Japan that was bombed for years on end and their cities and infrastructure were leveled and then to add insult to injury , 2 Atom Bombs were dropped on 2 large cities , Hiroshima and Nagasaki and reduced to dust and yet within less than 20 years the country was once again prosperous . Why is it that Germany that was relentlessly bombed on a daily basis by THOUSANDS of bombers , their cities and infrastructure totally destroyed were once again able to recover within less than 20 years and become one of the most prosperous nations on earth ? Many cities such as Dresden , Nurnberg , Hamburg were 80 % to 90 % destroyed . If they can survive and prosper , what is the problem with countries such as Haiti and most countries in Africa ? Could it be a genetic problem , corruption , no leadership , lack of ambition or what ? I am more than willing to help the downtrodden , the sick , the infirm , the elderly but they should also put in the effort to succeed in life . I may be my brothers keeper BUT I am NOT their sugar daddy . Enough is enough ! 50 % or more are under 15 years old , they might consider trying birth control . I have no sympathy for irresponsible people.
18:50 - Your statements are
Tue, 01/19/2010 - 20:08 — Anonymous (not verified)18:50 - Your statements are so outrageous, and yet, the world is filled with such bigotry, I don't know if you're being hyper satirical or serious. The countries you reference received enormous amounts of U.S. aide to recover, and, their populations were relatively prosperous and well educated. Also, if 50% or more of Haiti's population are under 15, doesn't that inform you analysis even further?
I would like more
Tue, 01/19/2010 - 20:18 — Anonymous (not verified)I would like more information as to why it is so challenging, logistically, for aide to be distributed, after it arrives at the airport. Another article I read quoted a military person (I forget who) saying it was kind of like a tunnel getting supplies into the country. There was another article about a cruise ship 60-80 miles north of Port Au Prince that stopped for its passengers to "relax and enjoy" this private beach cove area -- and also dropped off some supplies -- to whom, I wasn't clear from the reading. (Though that story was surreal unto itself.) But it made me wonder about the use of water transportation in all of this -- which seems to be short-shrifted as an option. For example, just these cruise ships -- with the amount of donations going in could be appropriated for humanitarian use. Use the donations to "rent" them, I guess. 1 million from this actor, another million from that actress, etc. However much in texting dollars from the U.S. But the challenge with aide so often appears to be how it's used -- the strategy -- even more than the amount. As for the U.S. pledge, I think Obama indicated that was initial aide. I certainly think aide to Haiti and use of our troops in this kind of humanitarian endeavor is much better than what we've doing, and at what costs, both financial and human, in places like Iraq and Afghanistan.