True Colors

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

True Colors
(Image: Jared Rodriguez / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: Christian Haugen, Micah Taylor, *TomCool*)

There was an awful lot of stupid flying around Washington, DC, in the run-up to Sunday night's historic House vote on President Obama's health care reform initiative, and it didn't stop with the dawn. A New York Times news analysis on Monday morning carried the following tidbit:

Now, armed with a specific piece of legislation that offers concrete benefits to millions of people - and that promises to guarantee insurance for many who found it unaffordable or unattainable - the White House and Democrats believe they may have gained the upper hand.

But there is no doubt that in the course of this debate, Mr. Obama has lost something - and lost it for good. Gone is the promise on which he rode to victory less than a year and a half ago - the promise of a "postpartisan" Washington in which rationality and calm discourse replaced partisan bickering.

Never in modern memory has a major piece of legislation passed without a single Republican vote.

The direct message intended by this passage is that Obama failed to follow through on a campaign and administration promise to end the madness of political partisanship and work together to get things done. Got that? It's Obama's fault that not one Republican voted in favor of this very Republican bill.

That, right there, is some magical stupidity. The reason this process has been so drawn out and berserk is because Obama did everything but give Congressional Republicans the shirt off his back to try and garner even a few of their votes on his health care legislation, and in every instance, he was rebuffed. There are any number of reasons for this, not one of them involving presidential fault

Press play to listen to author William Rivers Pitt read his column, "True Colors":

Press play to listen to author William Rivers Pitt read his column, "True Colors":

For one thing, the rhetoric aimed at him and at Congressional Democrats by the right-wing punditocracy was so feverishly deranged that GOP Congress people had no choice but to vote against it, lest they be shredded by wild mobs of Tea Partiers who were roaming the halls of Congress shouting "Nigger! and "Faggot" at Democratic lawmakers. It was the right-wing media who got these people all ginned up for a riot, and no Republicans wanted a piece of that action.

The stupid didn't stop with the shouted slurs, either. Republican Rep. Randy Neugbauer of Texas shouted "Baby killer!" at Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Michigan), arguably the most anti-choice Democrat currently alive on the planet, after he switched his vote to "Yes" upon reaching a deal on abortion language in the legislation. Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli vowed to sue over the passage of the legislation, citing it as unconstitutional, and rumblings suggest several such nuisance suits will be brought by like-minded state officials around the country.

And then, of course, there is the moment when stupid tips over into crazy and dangerous. A conservative blogger named Solomon "Solly" Forell posted a pair of threatening messages on Twitter in the run-up to the House vote. The first read, "ASSASSINATION! America, we survived the assassinations of Lincoln and Kennedy. We'll surely get over a bullet 2 Barack Obama's head!" His next Twitter message read, "The next American with a Clear Shot should drop Obama like a bad habit. 4get Blacks or his claim 2 b Black. Turn on Barack Obama!" This message ended with the Twitter tag, "#TCOT."

"TCOT" stands for "Top Conservatives on Twitter."

Mr. Forell's Twitter account has since been deleted, and at last report, the Secret Service is actively investigating him for making threats against the president's life. Taken in combination with the slurs and general ugliness displayed by the GOP base, however, what we have here is a pretty clear picture of the mind and soul of today's Republican Party ... but, yeah, it's Obama's fault he couldn't get these people to work with him.

Right.

Former Bush administration adviser David Frum had some pointed observations about this particular tribe of maniacs, and about the "entertainers" who egged them on:

There were leaders who knew better, who would have liked to deal. But they were trapped. Conservative talkers on Fox and talk radio had whipped the Republican voting base into such a frenzy that deal-making was rendered impossible. How do you negotiate with somebody who wants to murder your grandmother? Or - more exactly - with somebody whom your voters have been persuaded to believe wants to murder their grandmother?

I've been on a soapbox for months now about the harm that our overheated talk is doing to us. Yes it mobilizes supporters - but by mobilizing them with hysterical accusations and pseudo-information, overheated talk has made it impossible for representatives to represent and elected leaders to lead. The real leaders are on TV and radio, and they have very different imperatives from people in government. Talk radio thrives on confrontation and recrimination. When Rush Limbaugh said that he wanted President Obama to fail, he was intelligently explaining his own interests. What he omitted to say - but what is equally true - is that he also wants Republicans to fail. If Republicans succeed - if they govern successfully in office and negotiate attractive compromises out of office - Rush's listeners get less angry. And if they are less angry, they listen to the radio less, and hear fewer ads for Sleepnumber beds.

So today's defeat for free-market economics and Republican values is a huge win for the conservative entertainment industry. Their listeners and viewers will now be even more enraged, even more frustrated, even more disappointed in everybody except the responsibility-free talkers on television and radio. For them, it's mission accomplished. For the cause they purport to represent, it's Waterloo all right: ours.

There it is in a nutshell.

In the end, this could have and should have been a far better bill. Those who wanted more, who heard Obama's campaign pledges and public option rhetoric and then watched as he dealt them away in a sad attempt to corral conservative support, are rightfully upset today. It falls to these lawmakers to do what they said and make improvements on America's still-pitiable health care system, to take this "first step" and make it count with a second step, and a third, and a fourth, until health care becomes the right it should be and not the privilege it is.

This reality, however, cannot justify or explain away the insanity displayed by the Republicans, both in and out of Congress, throughout this grueling process. The GOP thinks the passage of this bill will help them in November, or at least that's what they're saying. That remains to be seen, but in the meantime, they have a bigger problem on their hands. They and the right-wing media mouthpieces who support them have kicked over a very large, very angry and very active hornet's nest by embracing the Tea Party fringe. Now they're stuck with them. 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



William Rivers Pitt is a Truthout editor and columnist.  He is also a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



The reason Republican

The reason Republican lawmakers were lock step against everything and anything Obama has had to say or do up to now is because they felt they had nothing to lose and everything to gain by it. They were witnessing an energized conservative base whipped into a frenzy like never before, watched Obama's popularity slide as months dragged and he failed to get things accomplished, and felt they had no blame to shoulder because without them he would never get anything done.
I am interested to see where we go from here. Short term, we will no doubt see those elements I mentioned above go into an even greater frenzy of anger and venom. But are they perhaps draining themselves out? It is not entirely out of the realm of possibility that many Tea Partiers and conservative protesters will grow discouraged by their failure to derail the healthcare bill and stop coming out to events. It is not entirely out of the realm of possibility that just a few Republican lawmakers will start to shift gears, seeking out a different political strategy after seeing their opposition tactics fail. Its also not out of the question that the relief of this development could energize Democratic lawmakers and unite the party in a way that has been sorely lacking in the last several months.
But realistically, that won't happen for the time being. The right will go even crazier, Republican lawmakers will frame this as a huge win because it passed without a single Republican vote, and there will be more feet stomping and chest beating than ever. But again, with this new development, it is possible that the anger and venom will wear itself out and taper off.



hmm, the True Colors of the

hmm, the True Colors of the 4th estate must be to focus on stupid/crazy and to completely ignore how this bill failed to address a major problem with US health - the for profit insurance companies. Make no mistake about it, a stooge like Max Baucus would prefer his constituents like big Pharm to write the entire bill. Instead, the Ministry of Information focused on "historic victory" which dovetails nicely with the "final four" which most people are probably more concerned with in our Dead Democracy.



Frum is still an idiot. He

Frum is still an idiot. He offers a slightly weaker flavor of cool aid, but he's still so hooked on his own talking points he forgets how stupid they are. Or, he knows he's talking trash and does it anyway.

I'd like to know how:
1) Providing the insurance company with 30 million new customers, with no real competition and minimal cost-control is a a defeat for the free market?
2) How the nanny state provisions that tell a woman what she cannot do because a bunch of pointy-hatted pederasts think its a no-no, is a defeat for Republican values?

Ball in your court, Frum.



Sooo, when is Limbaugh

Sooo, when is Limbaugh leaving anyway :)



I'm with ya. You rightly

I'm with ya. You rightly spotlight the derangement of the right wing infotainment complex. By feeding the fear and loathing of the right, these nutcase entertainers create the environment for lunacy in this country.

Did the world come to an end after health care passed? I noticed that the sun came up this morning.

This bill will save 30,000 to 40,000 lives each year after it is fully implemented -- and quite a few of those lives will be the lives of right wing nut jobs.

It just doesn't get more ironic than that.



Regrettably, insanity

Regrettably, insanity through this process has not been limited to Republicans, or else we would have a public option in the bill.

I agree with the jist of the article, that this a victory for the entertainment industry. It will feed the selective outrage that passes for political discussion in this country.

My question is: Does an article like this represent the equivalent left wing response? Is this article and so many more that disparage Rush, Glen, Sarah, et al, just another piece of selective outrage, albeit from the left?



As the ever shifting

As the ever shifting justifications of the opposition indicate, dissent was based solely on the desire to agitate the electorate. And as Frum aptly points out, there is a market for agitation, and, boy, does it have handsome margins.



They have only bigotry fumes

They have only bigotry fumes left to run on.
Bigotry of black people,
bigotry of hispanic people
bigotry of arab people
bigotry of Indian people,
bigotry of women,
bigotry of gay people,
bigotry of poor people,
bigotry, bigotry, bigotry, a big bag of bigotry is all they have to offer. Prejudice and Bigotry.



"Never in modern memory has

"Never in modern memory has a major piece of legislation passed without a single Republican vote."

How about BIll Clinton's 1993 Economic Recovery legislation where Gore had to break the 50-50 tie vote?



You know when you push too

You know when you push too far, backlash can happen both ways.
If the name calling and threats keep up, some folks may vote for Dems. in spite.
I too wished for a better bill but I do think this at least helps many and some in my own family.
So thanks Dems.



Dear Solly, When the feds

Dear Solly,

When the feds bust your door down, they should send your dumb ass to Guantanamo and deny you council! Then a little waterboarding ought to do the trick!

Threatening the President! Solly, I hope you get what's coming to you! If you stop by later, you will get YOURS, tonight!



http://gretawire.blogs.foxnew

http://gretawire.blogs.foxnews.com/bad-timing-or-sneaky-or-neither/

Bad timing? or Sneaky? or Neither?

I am sure you have heard about this....here is the Congressman's press release. Do you think this is why the Congressman changed his vote on health care? or a coincidence?

http://gretawire.blogs.foxnews.com/files/2010/03/
--



Love listening to you read

Love listening to you read your work Mr. Pitt

Keep up the great work



Here's some actual sorcery:

Here's some actual sorcery: Obama took His PROMISE to US of single-payer in exchange for Congressional majorities and (HIS) presidency (and rather dan effecting a VETO of anything less until achieving it); instead turned it into a pile of abject Democrap to be molded into coprolite by Big PhRMA for the foreseeable future! What a lying DEM reneger!!



you know, when this happened

you know, when this happened in britain they sent the tea party to america. i say we make these people the welcoming committee to mars.



Too bad. Chicken Little fail.

Too bad. Chicken Little fail.



Despite the partisan b.s.

Despite the partisan b.s. The healthcare bill without a public option is no more than a win for the insurance industry. One cannot, and should not expect them to regulate themselves. AIG proved that. Get real with the American people, and stop this nonsense...........



does they (you know who/

does they (you know who/ whom i refer to on bipartisan ship . like good citizen ship ) the republics of us cans ) forget the "every child for himself and the royal screwing they gave KENNEDY . does they ,BROWN , BUSH , CHERTOFF ,REMEMBER THE" ROYAL" SCREWING THEY GAVE NEW ORLEANS AND KATRINA VICTIMS ... JOHN FARMER , A DIE HARD REPUBLICAN FRIEND OF TOM KEAN AND CHRISTINE WHITMAN (SEE GROUND TRUTH ) TELLS OF THE LIES ; NOT ONLY ABOUT THE HURRICANE ,THE LIES STARTED WITH FLIGHT 93 ,ASK BROWN (FEMA;S BEST MAN ) ON THE GROUND IN LOUISIANA . ACCORDING TO BUREAU OF TRANSPORTATION : DETAILED STATISTICS ; DEPARTURES (KNOWN AS RITA) SHOWS THAT FLIGHT 93 NEVER EXISTED . IT ALSO SHOWS THAT THE OTHER 3 FLIGHTS 11,77,175; ALL FLEW ON 9/10/2001 ( SOME ARE LISTED ON 9/11/2001 ALSO , BUT NOT WITH DEPARTURE TIMES ... SON OF A GUN.. THE 911 COMMISSION NEVER TRIED TO IDENTIFY THE PLANES THAT CRASHED .. I WILL BE A SON OF A GUN AA (AMERICAN AIRLINES , UNITED AIRLINES ARE COVERING UP .. 9/11/2001 // BIG F**** TIME



Obama and the Democrats are

Obama and the Democrats are just as resistant to meaningful social change as the bigot Republicans are. Obama broke his promise to give Americans justice, he is a liar who has a talent to pretend, through sloganeering and classic politrick con artistry, that he supports change. This was an attempt to woo Americans into supporting the government and remaining passive in the face of a bill that does very little for anyone. It supports the current system of for-profit insurance and health care, forcing people to pay the companies or die.

Kudos to Mr. Pitt for this intelligent, pointed commentary.



Alternative Medicine Lost

Alternative Medicine Lost with this bill. The corrupt FDA, with all of it's former (and future) Monsanto and Pharma employees, now has a monopoly on what gets prescribed because we are all now forced into their lousy paradigm. Like lambs to slaughter... and in the name of being charitable - what a bunch of dumb suckers we have been.



Best thing to happen in a

Best thing to happen in a long time is the FOXpublican Tea Party - finally, the R-nut lunacy, hypocrisy and anti-Americanism is on display loud and proud for all to see and cringe.

Of course, said FOXpublican Tea Party will now quickly dissolve away... until such time as FOX tells them where to show up ranting confused nonsense again...



Keep focusing on the "how"

Keep focusing on the "how" and "when" of this legislation. How Obama excluded progressives and used the bipartisan bystander act to abandon real reform from the first--when he and Rahm gave up the public option to the drug and hospital lobbies. His populist rhetoric when he swung into campaign mode--late and lame--distorted the bill almost as much as the Republicans'.

Progressives should maintain a healthy distrust of this charlatan.



Rapture now, please! Oh,

Rapture now, please! Oh, Lord, please beam all the bastards up off of the planet right away. Give them their Rapture ASAP so they can let the rest of us putter along and make the best of what's left behind.

If You need a list, Lord, Mr. Pitt can provide it. But do it quickly. The rest of us need relief from this pain.



says Frum, an observation

says Frum, an observation that becomes inescapable if you think about Italy's Berlusconi, arguably the most successful politician since Hitler. Read the piece in the current Atlantic about this lying, thieving pervert, whose grip on the Italian voting public gets stronger with every new scandal.



Just spoke to a fellow who

Just spoke to a fellow who feels that this bill will cause a great deal of harm to America. Strangely, he felt that businesses would be hurt and had not one whit of concern for the tens of thousands who will continue to die for lack of access to medical treatment. He said there is no right in the Constitution to food, water, or medical treatment.
This, then, is the soul of the conservative--Nuts to you, I've got mine!



The Republicans have yet

The Republicans have yet again demonstrated that they hate Democrats more than they love the good of our country.



Give me a break! Max Baucus

Give me a break! Max Baucus had people arrested, D for Detention!



Has the New York Times been

Has the New York Times been bought by the "Reverend" Moon or Rupert Murdoch? What a piece of right-wing Nazi propaganda to blame the lack of Republican votes on Obama and the Democrats after they gave the Republican concession after concession. Now liberals feel like Obama and the Democrats sold out (which they did), but Republicans and the press still pretend they refused to cooperate with the Republicans instead of the other way around.

That's why I keep saying it's stupid for the Democrats to compromise. They should simply ignore the Republicans completely and pass what they really want to pass. I'm already almost sure that they aren't as stupid as they appear and they really are as conservative and pro-corporation as the bills they pass indicate. This is their last chance to prove otherwise, and if they do, then maybe I'll be able to support them again.



For supposed Christians, the

For supposed Christians, the GOP conservative owners certainly do not understand the repercussions from chumming for the fanatics and violent to support them in their quest for power. Time to pay the piper! Sow the wind, reap the whirlwind.



The Right in this country

The Right in this country has going off the rail and plunged headlong into the depths of paranoia.

The Republicans talk about a "government takeover" of health care. The only takeover that's taken place is the takeover of the GOP by these paranoid right-wing fearmongerers.

They've signed the GOP's political death warrant, as far as I'm concerned. Those who fail to learn from history are condemned to repeat it. The Republicans have apparently forgotten about what happened the last time their party was taken over by right-wing extremists.

That happened in 1964. Yet Barry Goldwater -- the "Godfather of the Conservative Movement" -- would be denounced as a liberal by today's generation of right-wingers.