Weekly Mulch: Oil Spill Could Bring Mass Extinction to the Gulf Coast
Friday 04 June 2010
by: Sarah Laskow | The Media Consortium
A cap placed over a severed pipe is siphoning some oil from the broken BP well in the Gulf Coast, the company said today. The company's CEO said this morning on CBS that it was possible that this fix could capture up to 90% of the oil, but that it will take 24 to 48 hours to understand how well this solution is working. Adm. Thad Allen, the former Coast Guard chief and oil spill incident commander, called the cap "only a temporary and partial fix."
Despite the capping procedure, it became clear this week that the onrush of oil from the BP Deepwater Horizon rig will not cease any time soon. Even in the best case scenario, thousands of barrels of oil will still flow into the ocean. Destruction is already spreading along the Gulf Coast, and before the oil stops leaking, species might be extinct and industries destroyed.
In the coming months—it’s not clear how many—oil will continue to pollute the Gulf of Mexico. BP and the Obama administration are talking about August as the end of this crisis, but other experts have projected that the spill could last until Christmas.
As Justin Elliott reports for TPMMuckraker, BP told the government it could handle a spill much larger than this one. In the initial exploration plan for the well, BP claimed "it was prepared to respond to a blowout flowing at 300,000 barrels per day -- as much as 25 times the rate of the current spill," Elliott writes. BP cannot, it turns out, respond to a blowout flowing less than 20,000 barrels per day, and the consequences for the Gulf communities are only beginning to emerge. The first casualty will be Gulf ecosystem and its inhabitants. The second casualty will be the livelihood of Gulf communities that have depended on fish, shrimp, and oysters for survival.
How Long?
In 1979, another company released torrents of oil in the Gulf of Mexico, in much shallower waters than where BP was drilling. As Rachel Slajda writes for TPMMuckeraker, the clean-up methods the oil industry relied on three decades ago are similar to the technology BP is trying now. The Ixtoc spill was comparatively easy to address; yet it still took 10 months to stop.
During that spill, the nearest state, Texas, had two months to prepare for the oil to hit shore, and still “1,421 birds were found with oiled feathers and feet,” Slajda writes. The fishing industry escaped much damage, but the tourism industry lost 7-10% of its business.
Dead Fish
In Louisiana, Mississippi, Florida, and other states affected by this spill, fish, fowl, restaurateurs, and oystermen won't get off easy. As Care2 reports, the National Wildlife Federation has already documented the deaths of more than 150 threatened or endangered sea turtles and of 316 seabirds (“mostly brown pelicans and northern gannets”).
And BP is trying to keep images of the animal victims away from the public. Julia Whitty, reporting from Louisiana, writes for Mother Jones:
All up and down this shoreline angry and scared people told me some scary and infuriating stories in the past few days. I heard about the the dead and dying wildlife we're never going to see because the victims are being carted away to early responder ships and to inaccessible buildings onshore. I've seen some of those photographs which can't be shown (according to BP's new orders) of dolphins swimming through thick gunky oil, struggling sperm whales trailing wakes a mile long in thick gunky oil, dead jellyfish in gunky oil.
Extinction
The impact of the oil spill goes beyond those individual bodies, though. As Inter Press Service reports, environmentalists and scientists “are beginning to reckon with the reality of a massive annihilation of sea creatures and wildlife.”
“You could potentially lose whole species, have extinction events,” Michael Blum, a Tulane ecology professor told IPS. “Brown pelicans were just taken off the endangered species list. On this threshold, a big dieback and mortality event, they would be pushed back into a situation where they could be endangered.” Also at Care2, Jay Holcomb, Executive Director of the International Bird Rescue Research Center, demonstrates a brown pelican being de-oiled, her feathers shampooed with Dawn detergent, her head and pouch cleaned with Q-tips.
Livelihoods Destroyed
For generations, Gulf Coast residents made their living by fishing. Their fishing grounds are now off-limits. Some have found short-term work with BP fighting the oil. But those jobs come with new hazards.
Some clean-up workers have reported dizziness, nausea, and shortness of breath that they think comes from exposure to chemical dispersants. BP is not providing safety gear that would clean the air workers breathe and has threatened to fire clean-up workers who bring their own, Colorlines reports.
In the long-term, Gulf Coast fishermen may have no source of income and will have to abandon their homes and professions.
“It’s a way of life,” shrimper Dean Blachard told Democracy Now!’s Amy Goodman this week. “They destroyed a way of life, a way of life that if you take it away too long, you can’t learn this in a school. This is passed from generation to generation, so the daddy teaches the son, and the son teaches his son. And, you know, once the chain is broke, you’re never going to get it back.”
It’s understandable that the residents of the Gulf Coast might want BP to pay for the damage. At The Nation, Chris Hayes reveals that BP could be on the hook for mitigation, the cash value of injured property, and for punitive damages–all beyond the cost of cleanup itself. But, as Zygmunt J. B. Plater, a law professor who chaired a legal task force on the Exxon Valdez spill, explains:
“In Alaska, most of the damage was suffered by communities who had their quality of life destroyed, and there’s no way to put a dollar value on that.”
This post features links to the best independent, progressive reporting about the environment by members of The Media Consortium. It is free to reprint. Visit the Mulch for a complete list of articles on environmental issues, or follow us on Twitter. And for the best progressive reporting on critical economy, health care and immigration issues, check out The Audit, The Pulse, and The Diaspora. This is a project of The Media Consortium, a network of leading independent media outlets.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.



Comments
This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Leave the entire BP
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 12:54 — Anonymous (not verified)Leave the entire BP management team and BOD in New Orleans, unattended, no body guards. Let's get lord-0f-the-flies on those pigs. Sure, it won't bring backs livelihoods or wildlife, but what else do we have?
This is a nightmare of
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 13:34 — boomboomlaroux (not verified)This is a nightmare of monumental proportions. This is a nuclear type of catastrophe, and the US centric reporting is making me sick. This is going to destroy the livelihoods not only in the states, but Mexico and Cuba, the Bahamas and beyond. I want to see more honest reporting about the fact that if containment does NOT occur, how long will this poison be spewing into the ocean? Stop calling it a spill. I spill my coffee or my milk. Carcinogenic toxic sludge that is flooding out of a hole in the bottom of the sea deserves a more epic verb, like discharging, gushing, belching or ejecting. Give credit where credit is due, and let us get honest questions repeating, 'HOW LONG WILL THIS GEYSER BE GUSHING IF IT ISN'T STOPPED?'
BBlaroux is right, this is a
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 14:43 — Anonarcmous (not verified)BBlaroux is right, this is a greater than earthquake or volcanic event beyond any event occurring since 'the Flood'--worse than a volcano b/c these happen at the weakest point--but Mississippi canyon 252 may be a point witholding much more than the weakest pressures. No one knows. Someone mentioned 7 years... Of course now BP & the others donot show us their great satellite mapping of the earth they had to begin these--they will show the size/pressure & how these deposits are connected to each other below. All this wildlife life dying is a very slow ugly death for the larger species--probably severely blinded along with mucosa & internal damage...
It would be "truth-out" if
Fri, 06/04/2010 - 21:15 — Anonymous (not verified)It would be "truth-out" if the individuals that published this article published their names and academic qualifications to make such a bald statement. Electrons are cheap - virtually free - and the most "backward" country on Earth has a degree of ready access to the World Wide Web. However, how many of those that proselytize the future have read and comprehended the first edition of "On the Origin of Species by Means of natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favored Races in the Struggle for Life"?
with 80 to 100,000 psi
Sat, 06/05/2010 - 07:27 — Anonymous (not verified)with 80 to 100,000 psi gusher and a battered and bent riser to fit a device to its not gonna get capped or controlled , cut the top off a barge , invert it lower on top the junk ,send a flotilla with sand bags millions of pound of gravel will entomb this monster ,we gotta build a mountain on top of this mess,or lose the gulf ,east coast and all the way up to the arctic ,lets bite the bullet , nuke it we should get so lucky, i may be stretching it but i think we are messing with the survival of our species here,how many millions of pounds of gravel will it take to bury it ,simple math solution
Yes, bury it in tons of
Sat, 06/05/2010 - 08:07 — radline9 (not verified)Yes, bury it in tons of gravel and cement.
Burying the oil well won't
Sat, 06/05/2010 - 13:52 — Anonymous (not verified)Burying the oil well won't work. Neither will "blowing it up". Also, the big picture is that this mess may never get cleaned up. Imagine oil washing up every day for decades. That is likely what we will have. Imagine no sea life at all in the gulf and Atlantic seaboard. Oil does a pretty good job at killing everything. Plankton provide oxygen for us to breath. Most of the oxygen we breathe comes from the oceans. It will take hundreds or thousands of years for nature to erase this mess but the types of plants and animals will be far less complex than what we have now.
when MIT says we can't bury
Sat, 06/05/2010 - 16:25 — Anonymous (not verified)when MIT says we can't bury it , ill shut up ,until then ill wait for their opinion,let them do the math,I think they've stuck it right in mother earths heart,bp doesn't have a clue ,had they made the first cut to take the weight of the fallen riser out of the picture they probably wouldn't have stuck the saw,with their performance history of failure after stupidity they should be run off with a stick
We first need to make sure
Sun, 06/06/2010 - 00:50 — michael richmond (not verified)We first need to make sure that we refer to this as an untamed, pressurised oil/methane gusher, NOT A SPILL! The corporate media wants us to keep thinking of it as a "spill" that will just go away in time, which is not going to happen. Pass the word.
www.akprogressive.blogspot.com
Why gravel and cement? It's
Wed, 06/09/2010 - 08:13 — Anonymous (not verified)Why gravel and cement? It's easier to do but should be more effective to get a massive boulder and drop it on top of the fucking thing. If it just breaks the pipe than drop another one, and another and another until you have the thing buried completely, then fill with cement and gravel.
Would be much easier to bury I think if they could cut the damned pipe at the base. Then you'd only need one well placed boulder to do the job.
I grew up on the west coast
Sun, 06/13/2010 - 14:07 — Anonymous (not verified)I grew up on the west coast of Florida and lived there almost 40 years. I grew up watching developers come in and destroy the forests, kill the mangroves with little or no regard for what they were doing beyond increasing their bank accounts. That was bad enough, to see huge swaths of forest reduced to little lots, most of the animals gone. I cannot tell you how this makes me feel. Everyone who lives on the Gulf coast is intimately close to the gulf.To think of all the fishing, the oysters, the crabs wiped out. This is just a total disaster for humanity. We have wounded our mother. I wonder if this could indeed start a cascade effect on the whole biosphere, being that it is interconnected in ways we cant imagine. We are killing our planet. We made a huge area uninhabitable with Chernobyl, now we may have killed the gulf and part of the Atlantic. For what? GREED. I would like to know what planet the "drill baby drill" crowd is planning to move to after we destroy this one. And you know what, this is never going to stop until the people who arent sociopaths are in charge. The souless corporatists care only about money and power, the Earth is expendable to them. We may have finnaly gone too far and we will reap the whirlwind for it. All of us.
Having lived in Clearwater,
Mon, 06/14/2010 - 19:59 — Lou (not verified)Having lived in Clearwater, Fla. for a couple of years and enjoying the natural richness of the Gulf Coast I can not imagine the fear and panic that must going through the minds of those who presently live there.
I spent many weekends canoeing down the beautiful Suwannee river in to the Cedar Keys and was always awed by the abundance of fish and birds, fish and birds of all kinds which depend on the Gulf waters to sustain them, I see so many dead and dieing now and I cry.
I cry for the fishes, the Manatees, so much life being lost because of a company's greed and it's inability to safely maintain control of it's technology because of cutting corners on it_shame, shame on you greedy oil whores, it is you who are the KILLERS OF OUR EARTH.
coach handbags cheap
Wed, 09/19/2012 - 16:27 — rarpZome (not verified)get coach handbags for cheap suprisely SYwEAZoB http://www.cheap-coach-handbags.us/