What Is to Be Done?

by: Jules Siegel, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

What Is to Be Done?
(Image: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: DianthusMoon, konradfoerstner, lepiaf.geo (back mid February))

"History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme."

- Attributed to Mark Twain

I have never been a great fan of Rahm Emanuel. In his clips, he seems to relish his image as a foul-mouthed, vengeful pit viper. He looks like one, too. Don't get me wrong. At least he's a vertebrate. Karl Rove is one of those poisonous Australian jellyfish. He sleeps in a jar of seawater at night.

I know that even Democrats need people like that, but as Barack Obama morphed into Hopey McChange, I found myself surrendering my Buddhist principles of compassion for human folly. I devolved into reptilian animosity toward Rahm Emanuel, who came to represent for me all the failings of the Obama White House. I wrote letters to my influential media contacts, begging them to expose him. They didn't even respond to say no. This inflamed my anger even more.

When [Martha] Coakley conceded, I had a raving fit and told my wife that Rahm Emanuel was a creepy Israeli [unprintable string of utterly noxious ad hominem epithets that only a Jew like me can apply to another Jew] who should be exiled to his father's basement in Tel Aviv. Anita said, "Well, he may very well be an unsavory character, but I don't think you should say things like that. Are you sure his father lives in Tel Aviv?"

The Massachusetts result was foreordained when Rahm Emanuel drove Howard Dean out of the party power structure. Dean would have been on top of the situation long before the primary. He would have been in touch with the younger people and known why Coakley was so widely disliked by the Massachusetts party insiders. She might have been nominated anyway, but funds and resources would have been deployed much earlier.

Rahm purged the man who invented a new form of political campaign and in the process gave Democrats the massive victories of 2006 and 2008. He then substituted Beltway centralism for Dean's grassroots (and/or netroots, if you will) approach to operational politics. Instead of embracing Dean's followers as a counter balance to the corporate whoremasters, Rahm went out of his way to trash them.

"There are no liberals left to get," Rahm Emmanuel said during the health insurance reform scheme-athon. Yep. Well, you just changed that, Tough Guy.

Now what?

[1] President Obama is surrounded by enemies, a prisoner in the White House with various guns - literally and figuratively - pointed at his head. He needs a Chicago-style political gangster as a bodyguard who is 100 percent loyal to him and no one else. I doubt that he would be inclined to make any changes.

Recommendation: Rahm must make an accommodation with Dean. Otherwise, 2010 is going to be a repeat of Massachusetts, and Barack Hussein Obama will probably be a one-term president. The most troubling aspect of Massachusetts is that the GOP now has a viable presidential candidate, and his name is Scott Brown. This is not Sarah Palin. This is a very astute politician who looks like an action figure and can talk like a sane person when he wants to.

[2] Joe Biden was right about Afghanistan. He knows how things work, and he knows what it is to be a Democrat. He hasn't enriched himself in office. He has the best security credentials in Washington, if unfortunately on the side of repression. He's no Dennis Kucinich, but he can add and subtract, an uncommon skill among high-ranking politicians.

Recommendation: The president should use Biden as a counterweight to Rahm. The vice president can probably broker a deal with Dean and act as a political center to unify the party for 2010.

[3] I would speculate that if 51 votes ruled in the Senate, the Democratic Party would be able to give the nation a record of accomplishment that would merit its favor in 2010. Joe Biden has observed, "This is the first time every single solitary decision has required 60 senators. No democracy has survived needing a supermajority."

Recommendation: The filibuster has to go. Its modern use was established to protect the rights of the Dixiecrats, who have evolved into today's Republicans. The red states are an exact match for the slave states and territories. The results are exactly what you would expect. We are paralyzed by their venom. And we have begun not merely to rot, but to stink.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Jules Siegel is a writer and graphic designer whose work has appeared over the years in Playboy, Best American Short Stories, Library of America's "Writing Los Angeles," and many other publications. He administers newsroom-l, an email discussion list for journalists. You can learn more about him at http://www.cafecancun.com/bookarts/jsiegel.shtml


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Thank you. I'm sorry that no

Thank you. I'm sorry that no one in power is listening. I'm at best dumbfounded by the Dems and at worst enraged. I grieve for my country. How badly have they screwed up that Americans are now willing to give back the country to the very same monsters who nearly destroyed it and will finish the job when the regain power? It boggles the mind.



Right on, I feel very much

Right on, I feel very much the same way. I want to know WHO is in charge. Surely, the President of the United States has some clout, perhaps he could speak up, and GET THE DEMOCRATS WITH ANY BRAINS, to speak up to their fellow meek comrades and get them a little positive reinforcement so they will act like a member of the Democratic Party. If not I suggest those meek b......s join the Independent, Libertarian or republican Party. No offense to those parties. We have an agenda, to work for the working class...always have. The Americans are overwhelmingly behind the president. Did you not see the results from the election?

Mr. President...Please regain your confidence, listen to your heart not your group of people. Stay to your principles and get this government working for the people...like it should. What would our founding fathers be seeing if they could visit us for one day and update themselves on how their Constitution is working out.



Beautifully put, and yes it

Beautifully put, and yes it is sad.



Well, Cheney ran the White

Well, Cheney ran the White House for Bush, and Emmanuel runs it for Obama. People in the know always understood that, and that is why the first appointment Obama made was Emmanuel.

Its not about who Obama chooses, its about who Emmanuel chooses.



You sound like a petty,

You sound like a petty, small minded, racist, reactionary bs-er.

Since when do looks come into play in a serious political discussion?

The President is not some dummy led around by the evil Jew.



"[1] President Obama is

"[1] President Obama is surrounded by enemies, a prisoner in the White House with various guns - literally and figuratively - pointed at his head. He needs a Chicago-style political gangster as a bodyguard who is 100 percent loyal to him and no one else. I doubt that he would be inclined to make any changes."

Wrong, Sir. You don't know Obama's economic training, obviously. He's an ardent neoliberal. He'd lick the boot-straps of Milton Friedman, if the Devil Himself was still around conning economists. Obama is no liberal or left wing sympathizer. He's conservative through and through. You Buddhists have fertile imaginations and live in political fantasy land. Only a violent revolution or total world collapse can "help" us now. I am always amazed, after reading an article like this, at how many stupid liberals there are!



I agree that ;lberals are

I agree that ;lberals are "stupid," or at least spineless. The thing is there isn't going to be any revolution, at least by any left-leaning portion of the public.

first, it would be crushed. Where have you been? They can trace anything now, and certainly have the weapons and techniques, the power and the media. Any hint of revolution would be erased, stomped on, made to be unpopular and obliterated. The only violence would be against the instigators and participants.

I should correct what I am saying. If the anger gets too much in this country as economic times worsen, the revolution might come from the right. From the tea baggers and the lunatics who carry weapons to Obama town meetings. Aren't they the ones now organizing and massing last summer?

The question might be: where have you been?

A total world collapse would help you in exactly which way, turkey? Grow up.



I agree whole heartedly with

I agree whole heartedly with Mr. Siegel...we need to be very afraid of Rahm he is NOT to be trusted.

Dean has been kicked around plenty by the Republicans which is expected but this isn't the first time his own party has done this to him. They don't deserve him.

I seriously hope Howard Dean thumbs his nose to the Dems and starts a third political party that we so desperately need in this country!



Calling people names and

Calling people names and saying clever but mean-spirited things about them is one thing we dislike about hate radio. Why stoop to that level here?



Thanks for blasting Rahm.

Thanks for blasting Rahm. However, don't let Obama off the hook. He appointed Rahm, and I knew in that moment what Obama is: a corporatist. Don't look to either of them for anything like progressive change.



Osama bin Laden was right

Osama bin Laden was right when he said recently that there will be no peace while the US unequivocally supports Israel and its total disregard for International Law. How is there likely to be any change of policy when Emanuel is at the centre of things at The White House?

The ongoing tragedy of Israel/Palestine and the betrayal of the Palestinians by the international community is the biggest single cause of tension and Islamic extremism in the world today.

Obama could do something about it but will he, or perhaps more correctly, will he be allowed to?



Impeach Obama. Just the

Impeach Obama. Just the thrill of theater would help the financially ruined cheer up a bit.



I love the part about Karl

I love the part about Karl Rove sleeping in a jar of seawater at night...

But seriously, can't we think of change as would Gandhi? LIke the bus boycotts that led to massive social change, why can't all Americans simply refuse to do business with usurious banks and corporations? With businesses that destroy the environment? And indeed, what would happen to the death-grip of the insurance companies if everyone choose not to be insured and let the chips fall. Something big would have to happen. Banks that did not give the public a fair shake would fail. Corporations that destroy would die. Government would be forced to deal with medical care as a right of all people, not just the wealthy.

It would take a Gandhi to do this, but I'd line up right behind him.



Nice article, Mr. Siegel. I

Nice article, Mr. Siegel. I don't know why it has to be 60 votes in the Senate to pass anything, but looking at the way the dems achieved the 60 votes they needed for their sorry version of the health care bill doesn't comfort me very much. I wish the party show conviction and not be so willing to compromise what is good into something else.
As we all know, it's not how R. Emanuel looks, but what he has done that deserves our condemnation and you are right on the button. If a non-Jewish person had written this, there surely would have been more comments about it being an anti-Semitic commentary. Again, it's what Emanuel has done, not what he is or looks like.



Nice article, Mr. Siegel.

Nice article, Mr. Siegel. It's not what R. Emanuel looks like, but what he has done. Considering the way the dems achieved their 60 votes to get the health care bill through, morphing something with good possibilities into a total 'other' just for the sake of passing it, has made me wonder about the party as a whole. They need to take a definite stand and stick by it. Will doing away with the filibuster help?



The Michael Taylor

The Michael Taylor appointment is worse than Emanuel. If anything announces corruption to the world in the loudest possible voice, it is that appointment. Community organizers in India know it. Doctors in China know it. Physicians who have treated farm poisonings know it. While Taylor can pull down his fancy perks, even Republican garden ladies are getting the word about the suicides in India. These truths have been leaking out, and we probably still have enough cross-cutting cleavages that it is just now a matter of time for those who have badly used the taxes of working people to enable harm. Big ag, chem, and pharma are having a rough pr year already, corrupt politics notwithstanding.



Rahm desperately needs to

Rahm desperately needs to "spend more time with his family" (not including his brother Dr. Zeke); Rove needs to be tried in the Hague for crimes against humanity.