WikiLeaks: "Demystifying Diplomacy"

by: Norman Solomon, t r u t h o u t | News Analysis

Norman Solomon | WikiLeaks: "Demystifying Diplomacy"
(Photo: Pfc. Sarah De Boise / U.S. Army)

Compared to the kind of secret cables that WikiLeaks has just shared with the world, everyday public statements from government officials are exercises in make-believe.

In a democracy, people have a right to know what their government is actually doing. In a pseudo-democracy, a bunch of fairy tales from high places will do the trick.

Diplomatic facades routinely masquerade as realities. But sometimes the mask slips - for all the world to see - and that's what just happened with the humongous leak of State Department cables.

"Every government is run by liars," independent journalist I.F. Stone observed, "and nothing they say should be believed." The extent and gravity of the lying varies from one government to another, but no pronouncements from world capitals should be taken on faith.

By its own account, the US government has been at war for more than nine years now, and there’s no end in sight. Like the Pentagon, the State Department is serving the overall priorities of the warfare state. The nation's military and diplomacy are different moving parts of the same vast war machinery.

Such a contraption requires a muscular bodyguard of partial truths, deceptions and outright lies. With the U.S.'s ongoing war efforts at full throttle, the contradictions between public rationales and hidden goals - or between lofty rhetoric and grisly human consequences - cannot stand the light of day.

Details of Washington's transactional alliances with murderous dictators, corrupt tyrants, warlords and drug traffickers are among its most closely guarded quasi-secrets. Most media accounts can be blown off by officialdom, but smoking-gun diplomatic cables are harder to ignore.

With its massive and unending reliance on military force – resulting in more and more carnage that leaves behind immense grief and rage in Afghanistan, Pakistan and elsewhere - the US government has colossal gaps to bridge between its public-relations storylines and its war-making realities.

The same government that devotes tremendous resources to inflicting military violence abroad must tout its humane bona fides and laudable priorities to the folks back home. But that essential PR task becomes more difficult when official documents to the contrary keep leaking.

Stay informed with free Truthout updates delivered straight to your email inbox. Click here to sign up.

No government wants to face documentation of actual policies, goals and priorities that directly contradict its public claims of virtue. In societies with democratic freedoms, the governments that have the most to fear from such disclosures are the ones that have been doing the most lying to their own people.

The recent mega-leaks are especially jarring because of the extreme contrasts between the US government’s public pretenses and its real-life actions. But the standard official response is to blame the leaking messengers.

"We condemn in the strongest terms the unauthorized disclosure of classified documents and sensitive national security information," the White House said on Sunday.

Meanwhile, Senator Joseph Lieberman (I-Connecticut) denounced "an outrageous, reckless and despicable action that will undermine the ability of our government and our partners to keep our people safe and to work together to defend our vital interests." For good measure, he twittered: "WikiLeaks' deliberate disclosure of these diplomatic cables is nothing less than an attack on our national security."

But what kind of "national security" can be built on duplicity from a government that is discredited and refuted by its own documents?

 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



Norman Solomon is co-chair of the national Healthcare NOT Warfare campaign, launched by Progressive Democrats of America. He is the author of a dozen books including "War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death." For more information, go to: www.normansolomon.com.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Hmm ... outrageous, reckless

Hmm ... outrageous, reckless and despicable LIEbermen (Holy Joe, Obameh, Billary et al) ATTACKS on their Promised TRANPARENCY-providing leakers? In these former blank spaces on the map, They're Be the HEROES!



While the politicians howl

While the politicians howl about the "traitors" who leaked this damning information we ought to be preparing jail cells for the real traitors.



Here is the transparency

Here is the transparency Obama promised us... and not only didn't deliver on, but condemns. As an Obama supporter, I am disappointed... but little in these documents comes as a surprise.



It is outrageous not that

It is outrageous not that any source like Wikileaks could bring us information about our government and where our tax dollars are going, but that our bungling government has deceived us, squandered our resources and imposed a brutish militarism on our nation.



Americans now have the

Americans now have the documentation that clearly distinguishes the myths from reality in the Wikileaks release of diplomatic correspondence. We can reasonably assume that every government lies in order to gather support for their hidden agenda. Unfortunately, the people suffer as our tax dollars are squandered on wars and bankster bailouts.



wasn't there a 60 Minutes

wasn't there a 60 Minutes documentary about the heavy hand & deception of the U.S.? Frontline has had much to show us about the deception of our government. This is not surprising - marshall law will probably be imposed now.



I'm sorry -- exactly which

I'm sorry -- exactly which lies did the recent leaks uncover? Your story doesn't say. I'm all for whistleblowing when it reveals actual wrongdoing, but this set of leaks doesn't seem to have done that. I don't go in for the traitor talk, and haven't seen where lives will be endangered by the leaks, either. What I am afraid of us that our diplomats will no longer be able to have frank discussions with leaders of other countries, and that they won't feel comfortable giving us important information that we need to PREVENT wars. It's utterly unrealistic and naive to think every diplomatic discussion should be aired on national tv. While secrecy often covers up wrongdoing, there is also a legitimate need for privacy when handling delicate international situations. If we want to promote diplomacy as an alternative to war, we shouldn't support actions that undermine it.



How clever we conceal

How clever we conceal secrets electronically since no one understands electricity and we don't invest any monies to maintain our electric grid's infrastructure.

It is delightful someone out there wishes we will, by exposure; turn our questionable representative democracy into a real democracy. It is up to us to accept truth and fact instead of living in a brainwashed Plutocracy.



The pursuit of an aggressive

The pursuit of an aggressive war based foreign policy furthers the interests of a business community that is waging financial war on Americans with government domestic policy.



RTFO, Norman.

RTFO, Norman.



so, America, Britain, etc

so, America, Britain, etc etc... now you know. Question is, what are you going to do about these criminals at the heart of your 'governments'? Are you going to continue playing dead? It is not an earth shatteringly big surprise that politicians lie every day. What should surprise you is that YOU pay their wages while THEY wreak havoc in your name and YOU don't do anythjing about it.



Please stop. Secrecy has

Please stop. Secrecy has always been part of American democracy. The constitution was written under a pledge of secrecy. The executive branch is allowed to conduct foreign diplomacy in private. No country in the world would enter into a treaty agreement if the negotiations were public information. No American president could succeed at foreign affairs with the advice and consent of congress. In the end, executive branch secrecy is constitutionally legal and necessary. The wicki-leaks are unconstitutional, illegal and are probably treason.



One of the things Obama said

One of the things Obama said in his pre-election speeches was the U.S.'s urgent need to "get Latin America back." Now you know what he meant. Obama plays right out of the Milton Friedman book of NeoLiberal Mafioso "Hit Man" economic "principles." Have no doubt, friends, you've got a full blooded Republican sitting in the White House.



From infancy we are

From infancy we are conditioned to accept lies and deception. Religions, being built by faith could not exist without them. However, governments could and should.

Government should never be dependent on faith in order to govern; only on truth.



the authoritarians hate

the authoritarians hate WikiLeaks because it calls their authority into question

The plutocrats of the oligarchy cannot believe the unmitigated gall of one of the sheeple exposing their secrets and undermining their power

The carrier diplo-mats are facing extreme difficulties trying to keep up a professional facade in the presence of their own words, that they mistakenly hoped would be kept secret

The MSM scurries to cover-up their glaring omissions on the behalf of their Corp Masters

The Peoples News is WIKILEAKS
The Peoples EMPOWERMENT is WIKILEAKS
WIKILEAKS is the PEOPLES way forward



Democracy without

Democracy without transparency is a misnomer.

Citizenry must be informed of the truth lest "of the people, for the people, and by the people" can not be rational.

Any fascist government knows that. That is why they lie, deceive, classify, and live in their dark and secret world, afraid of judgment; if not by God, by humanity.