Worse Than 1789?

by: James Howard Kunstler, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

Worse Than 1789?
US Sen. Carl Levin. (Photo: Matt Hampel / flickr)

Sen. Carl Levin pretty much had Goldman Sach's (GS) Lloyd Blankfein dead in a casket with that now-notorious email from GS's head of sales and trading, Tom Montag, describing one of their billion-dollar investment "products" as "one shitty deal." Levin seemed to delight in crossing the boundary into the realm of the unspeakable, knowing that even the so-called "family" newspapers and cable TV networks would have to report it. And just to make sure nobody missed the point, the senator repeated that phrase at least 20 times before the day was over. It was like the climactic scene in that old Hammer Films classic, "The Horror of Dracula," where Professor Van Helsing moves from coffin to coffin pounding stakes through the hearts of Drac and all his fellow bloodsuckers.

It's hardly the climax of our story, though. Ours has barely started. It seems to me, lately, that the crack up we've entered is liable to play out more gruesomely for our privileged elites than the orgy of bloodletting that attended the French Revolution. That historical moment was a sharp transition between old, settled, social relations and the new political realities of imminent industrialization and a rising middle class. The elites in charge of things to that moment, an ossified aristocracy, responded to rising discontent with utter feckless stupidity. To make matters worse, a great many of them were hunkered down in the fantasy-land royal palace of Versailles, enjoying what was for practical purposes a nonstop, mega house party. They must have thought they were safe 12 miles outside Paris.

The French Revolution actually got off to a better start than the way for which it is remembered. A progressive opposition put together a new legislature, the National Assembly. They undertook the writing of a constitution. But it all fell apart rather quickly, since the dim-witted king and his cohorts didn't really get into that old changing-times spirit and their lack of cooperation - not to mention their decadence - provoked the more violent factions of the common people to form that kraken of politics, the mob. What a goddamned mess it turned into - a revolving cast of mob masters, each worse than the last, whipping up the crowds to ever more horrible enormities of human vivisection - a political process that had gone hopelessly out of control. Despite the agile precedent of their friend, the new USA, quickly resolving its own rebellion into a functioning government of law, France opted for a bloody cluster fuck - which went on for eight more years.

The France of 1789 and the USA of today have a few important elements in common: a striking inability to sort out any national problems, an arrogant, depraved, ruling elite resistant to reform and an intellectual underclass motivated by blind fury. Some signal differences: most of our even theoretically best-intentioned "leaders" - e.g., elected officials, business, education and media figures - are unable to articulate the problems we face, which go way beyond the mere distribution of political power or even wealth. (In fact much of the so-called Left, especially the faculty intellectuals, are preoccupied with esoteric sideshows around wealth, power and the ridiculous "politics" of gender.) Paul Krugman and David Brooks have no more of a clue about the implications of peak oil than Rush Limbaugh and Sarah Palin.

The resounding message of Senator Levin's hearings on GS last week is that Wall Street is a shitty deal for America. O.K., now everybody knows it. Nobody has an excuse for not knowing it. The machinations ongoing over a financial reform bill seem to be leading to a rather feeble outcome. The only people who are excited by it are - surprise! - a bunch of economists, who will soon be relegated to the dumpster of discredited professions along with necromancers, alchemists and magnetic mesmerists. My guess is that something lame will pass, it will be instantly denounced as yet another fraud, and then the next move is probably the stock market's. A return of volume will signal a return of cratering equities as all the indexes give up their hallucinated gains of the past year, and all the pension funds, college endowments and banks, which flocked there in the desperate search for yield, will find that they were hosed.

By August, it's possible that the entire country except for the editorial board of The New York Times will be members in good standing of the Tea Party, and it will have split into a dozen warring factions. By then, too many other destabilizing events will be in motion. The hangover of the British election will reveal the fatal insolvency of the UK, torpedoing the pound - a huge event that would certainly trigger a cascading fiasco of credit default swap obligations. I don't see how the global financial system emerges from that in any form recognizable to someone watching the scene in the first week of May 2010.

In the background of all this, something wicked this way comes in the matter of oil prices and availability. The eco-disaster underway from the Deepwater Horizon oil spill is looking every hour more like an event horizon that will rock the whole industry and, with it, the developed world. At the moment, oil is over $86 a barrel (and gasoline over $3 for regular at the pumps).

I continue to wonder how it will all go down this summer in the Hamptons where, like Versailles in 1789, the elite mega-wealthy of today cavort shamelessly in a semi-private fantasy land of status vamping for the Vanity Fair shutterbugs. The Hamptons are not defensible - unless you count private hedge as an effective fortification. Any bloody-minded gang of unemployed, grievance-maddened mudlarks can creepy crawl down the Sunrise Highway to Gin Lane with firearms bought at the Walmart (and modified to full automatic in the garage). What if hundreds - thousands! - of them get the same idea? Louis XVI and his homeys probably never thought the mobs would scale the ha-has of his fabulous estate, either.

This article was previously published on James Howard Kunstler's blog. 

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.





     

»



 James Howard Kunstler is the author of "The Long Emergency," the novel "World Made By Hand," and the sequel, "The Witch of Hebron," coming out in September from The Atlantic Monthly Press.


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.



Article on fire, this really

Article on fire, this really smokes:

'The France of 1789 and the USA of today have a few important elements in common: a striking inability to sort out any national problems, an arrogant, depraved, ruling elite resistant to reform and an intellectual underclass motivated by blind fury. Some signal differences: most of our even theoretically best-intentioned "leaders" - e.g., elected officials, business, education and media figures - are unable to articulate the problems we face, which go way beyond the mere distribution of political power or even wealth. (In fact much of the so-called Left, especially the faculty intellectuals, are preoccupied with esoteric sideshows around wealth, power and the ridiculous "politics" of gender.) Paul Krugman and David Brooks have no more of a clue about the implications of peak oil than Rush Limbaugh and Sarah Palin.'



This is amusing, but scary,

This is amusing, but scary, There were times people were being openly shot, we don't need that shit, but people are furious.



wow.. this is the same James

wow.. this is the same James Kunstler from "the long emergency!" Can i mention that book changed my life forever!?! What an eye opener. I no longer "sleep walk" but I'm quite depressed now. Catch 22.



I said many years ago that

I said many years ago that the resource wars were only going to get worse.

Let's see... Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran next. Then we'll start making more noise about South America... all those leftists and such... and we'll start talking about "helping" Africa.

And don't forget the nice little war we can have over the opening Arctic Circle.

The absolute best way to stop this is to: Let Wall St. and every "too big to fail" company fail.



Thanks, Mr. Kunstsler: my

Thanks, Mr. Kunstsler: my thoughts, as well. Jim Hightower and the Iowa CCI were featured on Bill Moyers final Journal on PBS Friday night. It can still be watched at the PBS web site. Good sense rebellion -- the "government" is supposed to be US, and we do NEED us as a fair and just government; so shall we reclaim it? Together we can. Divided over stupid issues like "abortion," etc., we will fail. TAKE BACK OUR GOVERNMENT -- not to boss around all who are "not like me," but so we can have a democracy, as our founders did, indeed, dream. They must be SO frustrated with us now.

I suspect that the French model is the one that will prevail, however. It is scary.



An interesting hypothesis,

An interesting hypothesis, and certainly, given the venality of the ruling class, some kind of significant overturn in existing power and class relations will happen sooner or later.

Why I write, though, is because you perpetuate the myth of the mindless French Reign of Terror.

I suggest you read the excellent recent history, "The Terror: The Merciless War for Freedom in Revolutionary France by David Andress.

From the Booklist review:

"In retrospect, the foiled royal escape was the turning point, convincing revolutionaries and the Parisian crowd of two things: the Revolution was incomplete, and counter-revolution was a genuine conspiracy, not fantasy.... Andress meticulously recounts the progressive eclipse of moderate factions in the midst of foreign invasion and internal revolt throughout France. It was to master this crisis that the National Convention instituted the Terror, succeeding ruthlessly but undergoing a series of lethal political crises over revolutionary purity."

-- Hence, you are not wrong that excesses took place, mob violence, etc., but the historical truth is more complicated, and the myth of the horrific Terror is usually used to convince people that any radical change is dangerous. Such a myth undermines the point I believe you are trying to make.



With the kind of sell-out

With the kind of sell-out corruption at every level of our government from the White House, the Congress, the FEds, the SEC and last but not least, the Supreme Court who never met a Corporate ruling it didn't love to overturn in favor of the bad guys, voters must now wear boots and carry umbrellas . Thanks to all of our leaders, we are on the oil slopes of 3 rd world demise.



Another key difference that

Another key difference that Mr. Kunstler leaves out is that the French didn't have the sordid and complex history of domestic slavery and Jim Crow with which to contend. There was no insanely layered history of racism and no Right Wing Noise Machine to exploit it in service of driving the angry white middle and lower class mobs against their own interests. JHK is right that the angry mobs will grow to encompass the vast majority of the U.S. population, and they will quickly turn on each other. He's most likely wrong to suggest that the most well-armed and organized among the mobs will ever turn on the rich (mostly) white elites. They'll most likely turn on more vulnerable, convenient, easily segregated, and familiar targets.



Since the second term of

Since the second term of Bush the lesser, I have wanted a bumper sticker that says
IMPORT GUILLOTINES

Unfortunately, taking heads doesn't help without a full scale revolution. I can tell you from the feeble fight in my state to hold on to due process for teachers that no one has the stomach for it. The anger is far too sedated, and the spin machine too well oiled for any lasting or productive outrage. The middle class has to be completely decimated first, and have nothing left to lose.



The work required to keep

The work required to keep human institutions honest and healthful is intense and constant. Just trying to get the library to carry on-line contract information to prevent no-bids and sweethearts is convoluted. There are those who believe it is perp walks that ended the Great Depression. We are sorely in need of fines and perp walks. In the U.S., street demos don't even get you 15 minutes for your cracked head--not worth it. People will watch perp walks on TV still, and the perps almost always get out to offend again, but at least maybe some of their fraudulent gains can be clawed back.



The French Revolution

The French Revolution happened because the generals who supported the American Revolution went back and.....started a revolution. A French General planned the last battle of our Revolutionary War and won. Maybe our returning forces will start their own revolution here. Doubtful, but you never can tell nowadays.



This article sounds like a

This article sounds like a call to action. Be careful the fervor you whip up!



People who are angry about

People who are angry about the behavior of the elites need to realize that its our own fault for continuing to throw money in their direction. Spend at ma and pop stores, buy health foods, microbrews etc. (i.e. non corporate products and services). This is how we as individuals can help spread the wealth more equitably.



The Left in this country has

The Left in this country has been doornail-dead since Reagan--and outfits like Truthout basically want to keep it that way.

This scare piece, directed at the prosperous lesser bourgeoisie, is an example of the way that works.



special interest would

special interest would probably be the 1rst logistic ,spuralious and concealed such as they arc array,whair else might the handle be,oo,China,peak oil thats' Kergyezee(?),French and Greek for pollutions' aka corruption mis-managed(to say the least),oo is decay a blight,oo,watershed event, entropy (mildly) civily enzymned, aka structured,hows the song go and satan" cried fair game,trouble comin every day,oo,can't happen HERE,@evolutions design live demise and clearing house or aftermath conglomed liquidation and distribution "center,alpha numeric indoctranation retraining camp,,,,wait i got another,tax pollution outta existence,hence the taxed labor werx achieves final resoulution,every thing must go,fission,big petro/pharma/chemo,textile synthetics right across the board , pollution,etc,etc,,,



Far fetched. the TV toads

Far fetched. the TV toads will never turn on the Hamptonites. Most of them couldn't find LI on the map.

Also, I'd like to remind everyone here of Mr. Kunstler's bigotry regarding Palestinians. I like to give everyone the benefit of the doubt, but Kunstler has tarred himself good. He doesn't really belong on a left/progressive site despite his consciousness raising re murkans regard for the sacred mother.



"Why then, one might ask,

"Why then, one might ask, have the expropriators not yet become the expropriated, and why does capitalism still survive in the highly industrialized countries?... The growth of the proletariat, of its exploitation, and of organized revolt against that exploitation, are the main levers for the overthrow of capitalism... But they do not automatically produce such a society on some universal day of victory... The social catastrophes which mankind witnessed since Auschwitz and Hiroshima indicate that there was nothing 'romantic' in such a prognosis...classical Marxists...formulated their prognosis in the form of a dilemma: socialism or barbarism." From Ernest Mandel's Introduction of Karl Marx's Capital Vol. 1